1 Introduction - David Wetherall - University of Washington

6 downloads 1752 Views 342KB Size Report
Feb 2, 2002 - out-degree, different points in this tradeoff can be selected. ..... We used the Georgia Tech "Transit-Stub" model (GT-ITM [19]) to generate the ...

                                           

     !    " #$%#&'()&* +  '  *('*('*(

                                        

                         



                  

                  !"  #"   $      %   &                 '      ()*+,  -             '       '     &                                                     

 

                        

              

    

       

                         

 

                Æ  

                         !    "  #!                      $   %                    & "!        ' ( ) * +!           %                   Æ  ,    -                                                   .                       ,     '

                    Æ      /         !    0                         $     .               

                               1 2 '3! 2 &!   14 ''!                                    52 '! 5  (! .  *!   6  +!                             .        

    Æ                      

     .       , 0        7      8    2                     7                 2                

     

     Æ                                     

   9          7  52   5            Æ        

 

 :        ;              7            8    52   5          /        7                         52   5  <  8                   = 

           7  =  #         

            =  &     8       1   8      =  "   =  ) /         =  +      = 

'3

(

Fully Connected

Bad Overlay

Good Overlay

13 A

A

C

10 r1

r2

2

1

B

2

A

B

D

12

D B

r1

(a)

C

2

3 12

D

12

B

D

(c1)

(b1)

C

A

13

3

13

1

1

C 12

12

r2

(d1)

r1

r1

r2

Physical Topology

r2

A A B

C (b2)

D

A

D B

C (c2)

D B

C (d2)

> ',                                                       

    !     

        

                    Æ  

                                                     %         %         $   8  '33

 

    

/               ?   Æ      =              8         & '( " ' !                 

              1    0                                  

 [email protected]                                          0  [email protected]          8  

             8               

   =       8                      .          0        

    Æ 

   2                      , -

                      >  Æ            -        

      ':;      8                      > ': ';    

          [email protected]      '           A               , > ': (;                       5   @                         

             

 8                          > ': '; <     

        1'1(          [email protected]      

    : )B'   :5; (#B(   :;   (&B(   :5@;; <      

     52 5    C        5          :   2;                           > ':'; .       [email protected]  

                 

   

.            2          ,   Æ   

                    

                            ,             

              Æ                   

#



       

.                

             %                 7             

           ?   

       



          < 7         :> (;                                              



               <  7   

     8           

 :       8       ; .      ,                               $   %           A                   Æ     

  %   

            

> (,  "   #                             

.                       ,                  

     

     <                

      

          



    :      ; 5                                           

 E        &

          

      :  8  ''!; /     

      

         

  

.         

 

 

     < 7                              /  2 &!        < 2     

        E       8         & '#!                .             8       

                      

             

                      8                             

       

 

   >     2   &! 



.    E     , 0        

   

        8                F

         8   $      5                 :       ;        

 .      

      

      



          

 /   E            

              :                         ; .                                 

     0                    E       .            

 E     :     E      





               

      

       

"

       ;  

  

              0      

   ? 

    

      

     A           >  8        

    

      (      D                  <  8                &3G 

             '! 

      <     

 :     ;        0     

       E                   /  

              

          E          

         

         

 ,              

 $       .            

                   

                   .       

 $        

         ? 

           

 >      

 

        

   %        /                       

            

        

                                  

                .      

                    

 

     . 

                      A                        

                  )

 

        $   

     

   5                        %   

         %         .                     

   %           

            9

                  

.        7         

     

   0        52 '!   5  (!                          -     

                C   '& '"! 

    ! "#

< 52

          5 

     

  (                

     = 

       5         

           /            52 ,   .                '!               5          

       

   28                                        %   8    

           '!                        

8    8                       =      52          

  %        

       !      <                                       .           

        /                        *



 

< 5  

        0 >      8      H (       

    

     :  H : ;   

           $;       ( (  (    (  .   

   

    I ( I (     I (  /               5   ,   /         



                         ?  >  8 

 3   

 )  8    # .                .             8    : ;     

   .                       ')! <            

   8         

      

       !      .               

                 

$  %

<         

 

        

     

     .                

  0     '*!                  

             

                            , " >

                     

   !      .               

    

            

+

!

"  #  $  

.   7       Æ                      .                 

          ?   /        0

                                        

            $                     

 E        8                                      D           /   C  .  J.  =  K   :C.                  

 "  

 '

$(

>    +3     [email protected]    7    2   %  $ /

   %   [email protected]   2   7    :  (3G;    $  '333

  0   [email protected]   '3(#

 7    &   [email protected]   '3(#

 2   '  

  [email protected]          $    7    2   7  [email protected]     (+ &    $     '(*

 '3(#

 /    %          (3G %   [email protected]      0      2    %             



                

    %   

  

                       

 

                      Æ               

''

6

Kudos 90th percentile Narada 90th percentile Kudos 50th percentile Narada 50th percentile

5

RDP

4 3 2 1 0 100

1000 Overlay size

> ,    $%     &!' ( )   *  (     +  30

Kudos Narada

Worst Link Stress

25 20 15 10 5 0 100

1000 Overlay size

> #, ,-    .     ( *    )   (   +  '

%! 

< > #                  $    2   7  . %               8                    0        :    

    ; /                       $   7        '( '*    $     '(*

 '3(#

 

    

            !"#       $   

       

'(

N 

   7  2 # '3 '(3 * '& ('# '" () (+& ( 3 #( "# ' )#& '(* ''*( .  ', .    8             7   2    $     $        '

  ) (   * +  +

.                              

   7    2                               < .  '                    (&"

          

         J  K  0   

       



 E      %     .  '"

     '"

      '" %

 E    .      ,      7     8    ? 

    

       2        

 .       7    

      <   

  2           '

 (      )*  )  +  , 

.      %     52   5           [email protected]        . J  K :    ;                 [email protected]            [email protected]        A                 %   

'

CAN Best CAN Smart CAN Naive

14

90th percentile RDP

12 10 8 6 4 2 0

100

1000 Overlay size

> &,   (   (    *           &!'   /"     (   +  140

Worst Link Stress

120

CAN Best CAN Smart CAN Naive

100 80 60 40 20 0 100

1000 Overlay size

> ",   (   ( *                ,



< > &     [email protected]      52     52  

   "     7   .     %   $ [email protected]            8   J  K        0      J K   J K      %            .        52

        $                8     .                               '#

14

90th percentile RDP

12

Chord Best Chord Smart Chord Naive

10 8 6 4 2 0 100

1000 Overlay size

> ),   (   (              &!'    (   +  < > "                $      52       >  52                                                            ,

 

> )    +3     [email protected]     5        = 52 

            > *             

 $   %    =                        /      J K 5        %                    52          A           52             5  -

)#        

<             7  52 5           <  8   

     7  52             " >  52   5     J K                     -

      

'&

140

Worst Link Stress

120

Chord Best Chord Smart Chord Naive

100 80 60 40 20 0 100

1000 Overlay size

> *,   (   (                  14

90th percentile RDP

12

Kudos Chord Smart CAN Smart Brite Flooding

10 8 6 4 2 0 100

1000 Overlay size

> +,  $%     &!' (          (   (   + -

$(

> +    +3     [email protected]     %         $ 

         >  7       [email protected]                          =     5        52      5           $ -



< > '3            $      %     /       7         >       7              $                  '"

Worst Link Stress

200

150

Kudos Chord Smart CAN Smart Brite Flooding

100

50

0 100

1000 Overlay size

> '3, -      (   (   + (          

90th percentile RDP

20

Kudos CAN Brite

15

10

5

0 0

2

4

6 8 Average Degree

10

12

14

> '',   (        $%     &!' 7 D            

          1         0                 -

            -

./ 0 (

28   8   %         

      <  

     [email protected]           >              '3(#

 52 7             / 

  5     

      5 

 > ''       8     8      [email protected]   52   

      # "                 ')

Worst Access Link Stress

14

Kudos CAN Brite

12 10 8 6 4 2 0 0

5

10

15

20

90th percentile RDP

> '(,     &!'          "     (                 .         7             7    8  [email protected]                   < > '(   '   8        [email protected]            



  > '(               :                    ;  > '               :         ;           %   [email protected]                                        A                 %     

    0                  

  ,  7              -

   

               ?   

         2              

   8           >               '*

Worst Backbone link stress

70

Kudos CAN Brite

60 50 40 30 20 10 0

5

10 90th percentile RDP

15

20

> ' ,     &!'           "     (                     Æ               

 :    52     ; < 2        

    

           

 8   : ;  < (               $         : ;  5            

           : ; >  52   5           

     

 A    52     8   :(  ;     5    :: ;; >           -

                      

 .  ( $            5    

      52 5                          2   7     7          2 .

+   /0

/              :  8  & ' ( " * + (3 '(!;                   L   

    

&'

%                              

'+

6 

    :   ;

2  7  52 :  ; ( 5  : ; 1   6  L  :  ; .  (,                

        %      

 /         0       

    <                   = %       ('!   ((!              ('!                             

     7                 

   $    /          7                      ('! < ((!                  $     <         0   0                A    

               7        

           

      

      1

)   2 /0

.        , 0        7      8  

 2            9           7          2                           7          2           ?                

      = 0    7  52 5          

    /                     %         :[email protected];             

   % (3

      %     /        7   0          

         

                       <       8             

                        /    8       7                        Æ   +    

'! = 1  6 >   A  1  7   = =  J =   5    2  K  )*+ ,-*.++  (33' (! < =   1    @ 7 >  7    A    J5 ,    

           K  )*+ ,-*.++  (33'  ! A   J , .      K  *    )  &#O"3



  '++#

 )*+

#! J"  / 6K  ,BB"   B &! P  5 = E 1    A Q  J 5     =     K  )*+ ,*  R  (333

,-+/

"! P  5  =  5

     J       <   5  @   

  <    = K >  (333 )! JC  K  ,BB    *!  P Q  R  @ 7   $      @ R  J. ,  <      >   / L     1   K .  1 95mail protected]3'''#' 95  (33' +!    1     6  @  J6 , =   @    E L     1      L=  6 6 = K  ,",0)*+ ,     *          +  2   (33' ('

'3! @ C    A     >  7    1    J. 5   1  2  K  1 . 2,,,  (33' ''! P  5  =   5

      J14, 1       A     2  K  ,".*.+ 3 (333  )+&O*3# '(! R  R

 @ 7 C%  7 L R     >  7    R / D.

 J   , 1           2  K  . , (333 ' ! @   6  . JL