character: and you have wonder'd, perhaps, why that air of enthusiasm, which fits
so gracefully with an Antient, shou'd be so spiritless and aukard in a Modern.
SHAFTESBURY A Letter Concerning Enthusiasm edited by Laurent JAFFRO
This edition is based on Characteristicks of Men, Manners, Opinions, Times, vol. I, treatise I, London, 1711, p. 3-55. Shaftesbury’s spelling, punctuation and use of italics have not been modernized. Capitalization has been eliminated. Shaftesbury’s footnotes have been turned into endnotes and are referenced with letters. refers to the original page number. Shaftesbury’s corrigenda from the 1711 edition (vol. III) are included and are indicated thus: {...}. The editor’s additions are in brackets [...].
Send comments to Laurent.Jaffro[at]normalesup.org www.jaffro.net
!" #$%$
& ' ( ( ) ( ' , + ' . (, . *( 0 * ((. (
*
"+ +( ,, (" * ) ' . / . +( + 0 (+ " ( ., . ' ( * , 0 , (+ 0
1 * *. ) "( + / " ' 2 + .0 + 3 / "" , ) +(" /( ( ' .+ " . + " *( " '0 + ' " / "( .' 4( ,+ +( + + 0 ("2 . .' ( /-' () 5+ ,* * " ++ 6 (+( " . 0 * 0) (/ ( + 2 *. " ' *.,) (+ " " 3 ( 0 ' ) / / ' ' " , " (.. ' () * / . (2 7( (* ( /' () 0 .0) ( .3 " () . 0 * , 8" ( ." ' " ( 0 + + "" * " 0 " . +( * , 0 ) * " . /. * +*. " // " . " + 2 / , *. / 3 * *. + 0 ' +( * + 0) ( 8 .0 . + * (/ + / * *. , ( & ' ' / *. ' 9 2 ' 0 0 ' /) / .. ' ) (" () / ( ( / 0 + 0 (* ,) : . ., ( ;7( ) 2 ' 0) * ., /. + ' ( . +( 0 // ) *( / " .. / + + . /( 0 "2 '. ,) / ' " "; / +, ' / * *. , 5 .. . 3 (// , 0 * + " ' () . 2 ' 0 .2 + , ( . " () . /. , 7( /
/ + ' ( + " ( /2 ' ' (.. // "(. "0 , + .0 ' 0 . *( 3 0 + .. ( / ' .. 0 ( . " ' ..*( 0 ' 2 (8 .0 * ( ' " ( * .. " .0 8 + ' ./ + " 0. * , 0 + + * ( , ' 0 ( ." 5" +* . , + . *. , ( ' // * < . . /=() + * +/ 0 , + *"+ 0 ( 0 , 0 , ' ' () * 0 8, 2 " 0 *. 0 (, + * + .. ". ' .. +/ 0) 5 . ,. " +/ . .. " /( . .+ ". *( . + .8' 0 > (. " () /( ( / + + . ) (. / . ( " 2 ' ' " () 0 ,0 ( (.. "" ( *. + 2 + 0 + 2 // ' / ) + , / *. 0 * ) , ' + , 7( ' / )+ * . 0 0 * "
'
0 (" +/. ( 8 .0 ' .. ..' , +( * . 0 > ' .. ..' +(" ' ., -' " ' " *( * * + 0(., 7( 0
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
2 ' ,' .. ' 5/ + ( " "( 0 ( ' " " + , ' * / (+) .0 F& 0 '
0" ' *( ' 5" .. , ( +
2 ' ' .. 5 0, " 0 2 ' + /. /" + ' . "(.) +, / . + , +/ + ( , ' ". , - "' 0 ( +/ ' ' .. " ( + * * , . (. /0 / * 2 + + ) . + /(*."2 ( / ) ? ' 4 .( ...0 , / /. "( / ' (. (, / " * ' . " * + ' / "(. "( + ./ / . 5 +/ + " " + *( 0 . ) ' , ) . (" ( +/ ( / 0., - #% " "( /' *. ' (. " (" " ,0 / " +* , ,) 0 / // " ) ( .* + + ( > + / / * + 2 ..( 0 ' .. ' + . (" ) / . 5 + ) 7( ' ..* 4( , + * . 5+ ) + ;" .* + * ( )+ ;> + ..' / " * , .; * * + .* . ' " " +/. ) ; + 0" ( / (. *( 0 - + , + " " +3*( ..) ..+( " )+ * A( (, . + + , * , /. 0 2 " "+ . + . 5/ " ' * *( " , . , + ( 0 ,' .. * ( > 0 (+ ( , * ( ( . " .../.") ' .." . .. . ' 0 0 // " + ( '" /.") ;& ' ..'
'
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
+/ , ' " (. '" * ( . * //. , * ;7( ' //. (. 0 , +/ ( + . .0 * / /. ..
(
' "
"(.( ; ' ' .. ,' "( " ' , ;> 0 ..') ( 8 + + . + (. (
) 0 / ' "/ " 4( , , > +( * 4( , ( ' +/ "" ,. , ' " ..( ( 4( ,+ 7( ' +( 0 + / 4( , , ( ' +/ 4( , , + ' ' 0 ,0 (/ ( / .+ , 4( ,+ ( / (+/ , 0 0 ..') ( .0 * + "(.( + / ( . + "(.( , ( . (, ' 2 ' ? 0 , .0) 0 ' " 0 * ( # $
% #%
&
+ + . 0 ( 8 . ' ..2 ' ( * "( , , " * * 0 +/ ( .) ' .. * 0 + " + , *. 0 + (" ) 0 , . ' 2 '0 ' .. + 0 "(.( 2 / (/* .+ 3 + . ' " , ' (// * *. ..+ 0 * " " 0) * 0 * + 0) *( * 2 " (. * + /. ' (, ' " "" +/ .. ( + 7 H ( + * I , " /( / , ' ,+ " .. + . " . * + 0) + .* ' " * , "(.( 5 + ' ' ' + + ' . / /. * . +(" /. ) 0 /( (. ' 0) . * .(, ) #1 ' ..* "( ) * " + " (+ ( + 2 ' " " +( 0 0 (+ + * * )+ ( .. (*4" " ++ 3 , + *. ' " + * "" 5 " ,, ( / ". ' " +( * ' * + () / " 0 ( * .( . .. + * 2 (+ ( ' " "0 + .0 (" (/ +, + 2 , "( * / / /.,( ( / ,8 ,( ((+ 8 ( / + " .+ ., 0 " . ../ " ' ! ' ' () * +/ ,' + . (/ - ( /" ( / " ., " (/ 0 , (. + " , ( + () .. ( (/ ( ' " " *( ". .++ + ., ,
> 5/ + ,
HI
& ' "" +/ ) 7 J ( ( + 2 #9 * ./ + .." +/ ' ".+ ( + ,) 0 , + , "" , "2 "0 ' 0. * ..' , "0 4 ) ( /" (" /." ) (" + + , ./) )+ 0 " (*. + ' + (+ 3' . (" ' )+ , / * +/." . 2 " () " 0 ' ' 8 + + " ..) ! ,0 , ( / ' " " .* ' ( + + 5( ( + (/ (2
2
> + ' , " .. 0 / !' " ) +(. ( " 0 ) * /" ' * " " +/ ( / /(. ( + * " ..) !' , / /. ' 0 + + 2 ' /( + * + .0 - / " .. ' ., 0 . 2 " ( ( . + " "3 " (, ' * ( #< + 0 +(. ( ( /' / 0 ' ) ' "( " + + ,+ , . *. + 5/ ) + / "" (" " " .. ' .. , / 3 +(" , " * ,
( +
+ ! + 2 * + . ( ., . !-' ( + 2 , (/+ . " . "" ' .. ? 0 / ( .. * + / " .. ' / + .' /(*."2 " .+ ( , (' . + ' " 0(. // ( + =( 2 + : , / , 3 !+( ( , + , " ,0 ' ? //. ( + * , ' "( +( + 2 " + + . " . " 0 "( +/ * + ( . 0( 0 /' , +* +( * + ( ( .+ + , * () 0 , . " ( "2 #$ " +/( () * ( , * .+ - ' 2 +/ , " " / /. 2 , ' / (/ + () ' ) ) 0( * " (.' 0 . ' / ." 3 "H *. ( ( 5/ I " / /. () 0 H*I ! ., ? + , ' / 2 ' . " (" + ( + ' " (// "( ? ' () * /(*."2' .2 ' .. / 0 , ;> /(*."2.* ' .. / 0 (" + 8 ( ;7( / "* *( " / "(. ,(. + //
., ( * . ( + * , ( * " " .0 #D )
(// "
0( + " ' "+
* 0 . " (" ( * ".
( ./ /" 0 .2 / 4"
&
. 0 ( ..2 ' . ( /2 ' * 3*( / . / "( ' / + * .. " , (/ ' . + " (" * . * !4 ) ' (/ ( + + - + , ! ' ..') ( .. " ' .. , (+ ' //. * .. ") /. . , " " .( ) > (.' + +/ ' " + .. " ( (/ ( + ' + .. - * ,. . 0 ,) , "" *. ' / "( 0 ' . 7( ' / ." ' " 5 . ' . " (( .0 // + / + ( . / *( ( . (+ ( (/ ( ." (, ( ' /.,( , + 0 (. ) / ' " +/ . " () 0 .) (/ ( +( #E ( . .. ' H / (. / 4"FI . 2) . 5/ , 0. 0 , (. ' "2/ 5. / *"+ + " " + , 0 ,0 + 8 . + , " () 0 (" / ( +(" " " + ' () 0 * .,"2 * + + "2 0 2 * / . / ' 0 0 "( ' / " 5 . * .' ) + ,0 + .' *( 2 /( * ) .2 . ' .. 0 +(" *. ( / (. ( +/ . 3 " *( * ( ' .. 0 ' (, 0 ( 8 .0 ' / 4( " . ' 7( ' * ( " 0 ,' 2 ) 0 + , + .' 3 " * 0 0 (( ' + * + 2 + + ( .' 0 + / 0 ' .. ' . ,0 .* ' & '' " 0 0 .* ' 2 ' 3 , ( 5 0 G% , " /. "2 (+ ( + *( >
0
(../ ' 0 .. + " /. > + + ' /. > + "(. .0 , .. 2 , 8 (+ - ' . ' (+ ( 2 ' " ' " / 0. / ' .. ". ) "( "( , .. (" 0 ( , .. . =( + .3*( + , +. ., + , (.8 "( , / 8 / 0 . (
..' (
' +/
' ' " ' .+ + '/ / ( . ' , * ( "(
'
+
" . * " , ' *( =( + + ." ( 4( " ( ' , 0 " 4( , " / " .." " , . (// " (+ ( 0 " -*( / "(. + 5 0, / .0 (* / &J ) J )3 / ,. " ' ( , 0( / . * G# " / /. * 0 + ,/ /. ' ( / / *. / . * 2 (" " + . .0 8 . +(" /. 0. * .. -' + , / / ', , ( 0 / "( 3 . / /. ( ,' () * :) ' 0 , / 3' () 0 .8" 0 ". .0 / 3 ' () * ..) ' + "2 / / 3 "2 ( ' "" + / ) /' .0 > + , 0 " " * + ,+ * , * "2 ' . , ( ". . *( ,' + . &J @ @ ' + . . ' + # ".+
7( + (+ ( (*4"
0 ,* ' (" . ,0 ' +( ) + . " " // ) ." +(" 2 (*4" +(" GG . ' ' ( 0 ( , /( + . , (+ ( / *. /. ' " ( + . +/ *( .. (+ ( 2 ' . . (* "(/. ., + ++ .( " /' " =( + .* (, (. / "" 5 . +/ , ' * ( .7( * * ' ' ..- * .0 ) " " + ' ' () 0 ' * + . .. 0 ( ' ., 0( , (, * 0 .. " 2 3 , + .8' ' 2 , ' .. 0( + K
(+ (
/
.
/' () '
*
, + (+ (
"( , *( ( 0 , (, ' // (/ + * , ( + . .. ( ' -) + / * *. ' .. 0 + " / " *( .. (+ ( . & ,*( .. (+ ( ( ") " * , + 2 (. G ' . ,0 * 0. + ." ( / ' 0 +(" =( ' ,* .. (+ ( " * "( + ?
* / . ) +
,(+ 2 . (
/ ( + (+ ( + .. , ' .. / ) ' () 2 +/ *. + * " " ' + , .. 0 ( 0 *. ' " " ) + , '0 +/ ( ,*( .. (+ ( " ,0 ( (. .. (, (/ + + , & , " / ( ( (.. ( (" * , *( 8 ., + ' 2 ' ( 8 .0 3 ' * , ,, (+ ( ., 2 ,' + /. (" (*4" K@ -) * " ( ' " " 0 (*4" .2 ( 8 .0 " . 0 1 ' ( "" +/ , '0
' " ' ' * + ' ' + , /' + ,( / (. + . ( G1 ' .. * /. ) ' (*. , * , ? + ") + . . 5+ ) + ' // "0 " +) ' ("" + .0 + 0 ' / 0) .* ( (/ ." " ( , 5/ ") 6 ( /2 ' + / / + ' . () ( 0 * * .0) /' ( /' ..+ * .0) ; 2
4( '
0
" " + + ' .*
0 F 0 ( ' , + (" 5 +/. , 0 * + (" > 0 2 ' +, / " 0 +/ ' . ' " () * ( " " . . " ( " *( + / (. / " " .(+ 0 " + / /+ ' 0 * (" 5 +/. ( 3*( + / " .. "" 0 * ,0 * )' + + ( + 2 , . / "(. + . +/ ' (" + *, / "( . G9 , ( + + . *( ..' ' (/ " ' 0 ( > " () 0 * , ( 0 , * / "( * & @;7( * / " ' "+ ' / ( + 0 "( ) ( + , + , / *. 0 * ( / :) ' ' ' " +, / / / . " / ' *( + ..+ / +/ ( + ) ' ) " / "(. + ' / ' " * + . + ( ( .. )+ " +/ *. " *. .. + ' 0 (" ' ' + + ("" , + , / "( ' +(" * 0 H"I / " ' ' +) , + " ' + . * (" ' , / "( ' () ..' ,( (+/ " ( " 8. /(*."2 " . ' ( +/ , / 0 ' * 8 ., + + , /(*."2 ' / +
G< ) ' ..' 0 ( " ( ( ., ( ( / *0 @ ' +, * .. " .:) / / + (/+ 0 " + 0 "" , ( ' "" ( . ' ' . , H * + 2 , I' (// , .0) .' ( / " 2 ! ' () 2 , " ,0 (* " & 8' / , + ( ' () " " 2 +* B" + . .* C 2 ( ' ( + . () + , + H' + / /' * .' *. ) I (/ / ' ".+ ( .. (. + , ."2 + + (, * $ . . " + + ,( ' +, . 2 ' /+ 0 ' 0 8 / + + ' ' "( . , * , ' ' ..,0 )+ . 0 )+ "" 3 ' ' .. . )+ G$ 0( , +/ )+- ' ' .. . * *., , * 2 * )+ "( *.' (/ : . 8 " . / "( 7( (" , " " * ( 8 ' ' , ' + * ' .. , * ' 2 *.' (/ )+ . )+ ' / / ' ' () ,. . ,0 )+ ) "/. ., / * )+-' + + ' + ( ' "( ' .. ( ( * ( ( ) & " ' * (// ) " ( 0 * 3' " ' " + ( .+ ' () ' .. ,. , ' * ' " (" * + + / /, . ' ' (. * 7( +
' * * ( .. + . "( . ' . , + F? " / / , ( ( / "( ' 0 .0 ) )+ 0 "( .. " +/ ' . + . " 0 HI + (*4 " GD " " .. /(// 8 ' 4 5 ? (*. , 0 " 0 .( , + *. ' .. " * + ' / // ? * / / / / " * , ' / ' *( H + .0 I+ / 0 , "( * 5 " 0 , ( . +*. , .. ( + 3 ' (2 . 0 /(// 8 ' + + " +( / / . ' . 4 5 ? / / 0., "( ( ." ( " " ( '0 / / " + ". .. 0 , /( (*. , , ' + " // ' () + . .*
( ' / / ," .' ( 3 K
, / ( 2 ' '
+
) ' +
' ) ' 2
"
*.
./ ( ' , / (. / ( ( ./ ) .0 *. .. / +, + ' / / 0 0 , GE " ( + ,/ 0 ' ' .. 0 ) ../( / (// , ., + 2 ( + 4 5 ? + 7( +/ ( ( K / .* ' ( + ( *. ' () 0 * +(" . " , " BC * , ( / + 0 ( (/ , /. ' * 82 / " 8* . 6 ' ( .. 0 HI".( / /. .. ,-+(" . ' * . ,) / ., ' . 2) (/ ' (.. . + " () / " * ,' (/ ' 0. 0 , ,(+ ' .. + ." 0 " ( 0 ( *( 2 " " (" /(// 8 ' ( / / " , (- + / +, / *. 0 ( ., + + ' 0
' () ( .. ., ( " , ,' " . 2) .2 , 7( ' / . + " +/ 2 % * ..
*.0 ( , . ) / . ( . HI 0 , + + , , + (. "( / + / "( , 6 " + . +/ 0 + " ( " 0. 4( , : . , ,( 0 + " ./ ' " / . // , * ' , * " ( 4( " ( / " , + . ' + . "" ++ + . // +/ /. / /. ". ' -*( ' ( ( /" " ( ' .. , , (. " ++ / , / "(. ' " + , * ) 7( ,
6 ' 0 /. ) ' + ." ' # ( 0 ( / . ., ( / ) . ,* , * " * " " + 0 + , + & / 0 4( *( " , 0 , 0 " " " ' " 0 , / ' ( . 4( 0 + ' 0 // ) ' . ' , ' + * ' .. / + * + *. "(.) ' . " + ' " /( / 7( ' + 2 , /( (// , / . / * " ) + // . , ' * + 0 " ' . " * "(.) -*( +, ./ / +(" / *. / + . / . . ,( H' " ' 0 , ( I+ , * " +/ ) ' ' " ' / * (, / 0 , (" ' & " () * ' . , + 0 " *. , + , + '
+/ ( ( " ( "2 2 ' . 2 /.
& "" " / 0 * , 0 *
"
"
/ +
("
+ + , + // , . (" ' ., 5+ ( " , + " 3 " 5/ )
? G
'
,
. " . '
, ., ' " ," . "" + . , ' . + ' , + ' " 0 ( +(" ' +(" ? ' .. . / *( 0 , * /( ( +5' +/ ( ' ..
+ . " . ' ' " ' 0 * (, ., 2 , (+ ( ) 0 " . ." (* " + " +/ ( +/ " ( . ' 0 ( 2 0 2 ( > " 0 * " +/. ( ' ' " . 2 ( 8 .0 5+ +/ ( ' + / ? ' ( 0 , 6-' (* " 0 * ( " +(" ( . " .+ ( +/ > +(
,
() . + *
(+ ( *( * (+ ( ( .0 ( ' .. ' +/. ' " ' " * ' (" //. ( ( 6 > .. * *. * ' + 4( " , /( + +/ + + ( " , ' " ' 0(., . (// K@ ( *. , . ' " + 0 * , ( ( + +/. ( ' " ' +( " . / (// ,0 +/ ( 2 + "( , .. (/ 3 + +* , K@ *( ' !7( ' ' ( ( 1 . 0 0 =( ' .. -' " ( .. / (+ + . . " " / " " , , -' . ' " 0 + ( +/ , + " &LJ 6 '
. * 2 '
+ 2 ( ( / .. . ( ' 0 (" , *0 " .+. ' ' (.. 5 .
> 0 *. / A@7 ' K@ 2 /. ' + *4"
,
/
" * (
( " ( * ) *( + 2 *. (, ( . 2 .. ,(+ , ' , / " (/ / 0 " (/ =( . + 2
"
+
, .. + +
, =(
"
* K@ 5 ' + " * (/ ' 2, ( ;> " // " , + * , ; 5" .. " () * ( 0 , ( 9 , +(" ( 0 , * . 0) 0 ( , , . ' . 0 " " F K@ ? ' 0. (
K@ 7(
0 " A *) / 0 ! * . 0 , K@ 0 ( (+ , / .0 , ,' " " K@ F ( ) /( . (/ ( . - * )' ( ( ' +, 0 * , ' " () * , /
+/ *. * ..8 ( ) + " ' , * , K@ 3 ' , , /(*. "2 0 , )/ 0 , , . ( 7( + (" ..8' .. . *. +( 0 ( . ( // / K@ *. 0 + , * 2 ' * + , +/ . ( + / "(. ' 0 " + 2 + ( 2 + / ( , " . + 0( ' . * , ., + 0 ) ( , K@ " * ,, ( ' , =( . 0" + , )+ + " . " + ( / / ' 7 77( ' . , + ' + + " " ) .' 7 < 7 7? () * .. " ' () * ( H I ' ,0 , . -*( / () * ' () * " - ' () * .. 2 ( ., > , . " " ) ' 2 .. / (/ , + 2 , + * ,, . (, + , *. ' " +, . " , + 5+ ' + *. + -M () *. 0 ( + 3* " ( .. * + ' .. * + * , ( " 0) -*( , ' .. * . + 0 * . 0) + 2 ' . 0 (, ) " 0 *. 0 " // 0 , " ++ ? * ' " 2 ' " ' .. 0 (, . * + *( ( ( 8 ( ' " *( " ( .. , ' ( ., / .. 6 $ ' . ( *. 4( ( (, + . 0 /(*. "2 ( ( 0 ' . ' . . ' , + 2 +/ ' H ( . ( () 2 ' () / 2 ' ( * *
) ) (/ 0 ,
0
* (.. N7( " ' . ' ( ) (" (* / /. 5 (
., / + ( /' ( . , " ' " .. +/ + ' ..I ) ( . ( ' , " 0 ") " (
5 +/. ) ( . ( ' * ( ( 0 0) / " " ( + 2 ( ( " 7( * + , . * , ( + " /(::.) ' " 2 ' ' 2' (" / ( 8 . 3 () ' " ; () ' (+ ( ) , D ( "2 , " .. 4( ,+ ' ; ' *( 0 , '"
.. ' ;
; ,, 0 ' ' '
, (. +
() + ,
; +*. ( + .
( +
() * 2 ' -/ "(. . , + + 0 ) // " *. / // ) (+* () + / 0 " 0 . ( , )+ () * . (/ ' " " ,( ' .. ' . , ( * "(. ( 2 / 5 0, . + ..8 + ' () 2 ,/ ' ( " (. " + (
.. 0 / ) 2 0 + * (, ,. ' .. *. ( () "" , 6 ' 2' + +/ 0 ;
*
( " " ) ,;@ ( 0 , " 0; . " " / ( / ( (
@ ' () 2+ ' . , 2 ' ( ' ' 2 , ,( ( (+ . ' ' " ' ' .. "=( @ ' () 2 ' ( / 0" " , 0 , 4. ( / ( /' . 0 + ,. . 2 *. , . .+ * E , " . 5".( O +P * , ' " / " ( 0 . 7( ' 0 0 .) ' ( 8 .0 ' 3 ' " ( ' " .. ( , *( " 0 /. " 6-' " ( , . + + . 0 . ( > +( * )* 8 " " 0 ( > ( " * . ., ( " " & ' * .. + ,/ 0 ( 0. + " + ( ( K@ ' . " 0 ( + ' ' .. ( ' .. + ( K@ 5" 0 * ( + ' " 0 ( /" ( ( 3 . " + 2 (
' 0 , *( ' // -
'
, *( " +/ " //. 3M " // ) ( 0 .* ," 0 " 0 + ." N *
+ *
0 + ."
1% ' . "
"
0 ' /0 ,*
3*( ,
+( + 0 .
, "
.,
,
*
+ * / 0 2) ," ' " ' * .. (" , ? ( //. * ' + " + ( .0 '0 ( 3 * .. & ' + ) ' 5 . " ' () + , () * + " + *. . , (. ., + , ( + , / /. ' ' () 0 . * , ( 5/ ) - ' () * / / + ' () . + ( ? * +*. 2 () * # -*( 5 ' 0 ' () * ' ' (, 2 . ' " () * / ( *. 0 .. ' K@ +( " *. , + ' ( 1# " / + +/ " ' " ' H,I "2 '. , (" ( 8 .0 ' " , + ' 0 ( .. ' " * (/ ' " ' ' 0 " =( ' , ' * ,*
2 + ' () * ' .. ( * , , ' ' () 0 (" * ' + / (, (/ /. " . 2) ( .0 ,( ) ' ' " ' () / * *. * 4( , " " " * ' " ' ( > +, ( ' "=( ) + " ' ' @ ' ' +, " " K@ . . ( + ? ) + , ' ( " + / " ( ' ( *. " 3 ' 2
' "
" . .
' '
> ..
(
*.
'
(
( ( *. ' ' '
'
+ 6 1G '
+( " ' " ) (/ 2 * " / /. ' +( "2 ' () ( . * /( *.( " () . ' , " ( " "" / * 0. " ( .. "=( ) + " +/ // + " () * ( + , ' .. , / + " .. ' * (, * ( ' () * . . " +( " 0 0 ' () 0 . . * " ' +/ 0 * ,/ " /
" / + * 2 " //. ( 2 ' ' " + *( ' , + . () * (, ) . 0 . * (// ) , (/ . ' , 5
) (
*
.
0 ! 1
'
+ ' ' ' .. / ' ( * , *. /
(
=( . ' " ' + > + 0 5" .. + 2 > + 4( , ' ..
' "
' 0
( * ,/ . *.
/
' * ,* , ' *. + ' .. ' +( "
0 () + +, . , "
2 . + . + ( ( ' .
,
.
/ "20 3*( ( * , . *. / ' /' , . ' ? / . + 2 ,
@ . 2 ,
+ ' /. + 8 /( / . / ( 8 .0 + ( ' )( 0" " , ( ., ? ( + " ' + , . " ++ + .0 / / , !' " * ' " )+ / .. * + * +/ ) . " (. ( . *. + . + ". * + + 2 )+ 0 *. 0 " * " ) ' ' 0 ' " " 0 (/ " (/ 7( 11 2 '. , ( / 0 + ( , ' .. , ' / , ( + 4( , , , . ( . " ' " ++ 0 ( 0 + " ( // + ("" (.. .( ' " " + +) ' /" ( / 5 + . "
'/ / , " + + *0 / + + ,+ + ". 0 + , . " / + . ' ' , * + ( / /. ' " ( .. , 0 + ( 7( ' () . 2' ' / + , ( / ' 0 , 0 * " ' .. , 0 + + ' +; +( * " 2' (" * ' .. / "(. ( +;*( ' * + ' +) ( 4( ,+ ". * ' .. .. . 2 . " / *. .. ( + * ;? ' !+ 0 * " (, 0 " . ++ , . +) + + 0 *( (/ 0 19 / ". 4( ,+ " +*( *. + . / / )' 2 / 2-*( " . +(. ( :) ' + / & ' *. : ( -' (+ *. ,. ' ' / 0 ,* . *( ,' / 3' /" . *( 0 * 5 . + " ( / , +/ 8 . * *. / + 0 , (, .0 ' ' ' " / 0) " " , + , / / 0 / 2 * 7( . HI J ' + . " /( ' HI ' .. / / " * / 5/ " ' .. * .. " / / 0 ' + * . ,
K & &' ' . . " 00) / / " " .. + . !3 .. ( M / / / K@ (/ + 3 ' 0 , , ( 1< * + , ++ + H ( I // 0 . " 7 J Q R & !" N / " 4( * / . "2 + * ' " / . + . //. + ,. ,(. =( H ( ( / I /+ 0 " (" / , 7( . 0 + + 2 +*. " ' .. " * ' ' / . "2' . 2 ' +/ + " * ' " + . H/ , . + FI. * ( ( " / *. / + * ' ' +. . ( H " .. I( ,/ / " / +/ ( . ' " ( 5 + ' .. " / *. - * (, + + / ) " / 67 ' , ' / ". .2 8 9
9/ / 1&
+ 0
1$ &
6 , S
*
" ( ,
0 / *
.
,
5/
+
& @
") ( M? / * =( , ' * N
/ 2 , + *. ( ,* " * / ; 1 ; *. , .. ' ' () ' .. ,. " )+ . " 5 " *. " " ) + " ) ( / * ' , ' + 3( & H !" 1D & % % / 0 9 / & & @
.
" / .
( '
.
(
3
/
'
,0 ' * ' .
"
+/ / .
/
/)H
I
+' " * 2 / / " 0 E * 3*( / ,-* , (" I 9 < &
,
0 (/
&
// . ., ( *. 0 9
0 . + 0 " ( + ? + , J J () 0 0(., "" ( + " . 6 .. ' +2 . . 2 ,8,. 2 ' ' / '0 * ( (..
0 ". ' . . " (. (" 0 .0 )+ * ( 3' " ..
& 2 :
-
&9
=
1
1E &
&
%
&
& 0
: * * ("
& ;& 9 & 9 1
/ &
)'
, / . / * . 0) ' , "2 , .. (+ ( ' ) + ' ". ) 0 () , ' ( " + 2 )+ & ' , ' () ..' / " /. ., * ' ") " . ..' ' ' ( / + 2 ' 1 ' 0 ' + (" + ' .. * " () .* + 0 ? +' " " " 0 + 2 +, , ,(+ , + ' .. K @& 7( 3 9% ' + // * ( . +/ + + / =( . " / ' 0 8 ("2 ' # ! ' / 0 + /" 0 + ( . ' " ' + (" / 0 " + 5 5/ ) + .0 ( ' . =( 2 , +*. , , .+* H " .. +I " 0(. 5 +/ / / / " , , .2 .. 0 ! + 2 .." ( " H ' .. I 0 " +/. , @
' () ' " ' .2 / 0.
2 + , ) + . " ..) > ! * , " ++( " , +/ " ) + 7( " "2 0 * " + ' 0 + / / ( "(. " ++( " , // ? " // / , (/ ., .. " 0 * , - 9# 0 * /. ) ' , ' ( + "
/ 2
("2* ., + ( @ " 0
4 > ? * ,& + A7 * & 4 HI ? * ,2B & ,
" 2 //
" + 5 ..' .' * ? ( , + . 7 J
. "
' +/ , "2 ' '
! +
@
3: #E
G
H
0 () ( /I" , ' ' ' ( + , (// ' " + + + , / 9G ' / 2 , 0 " . J J + 2 ( / ' ' , ") // 0 + + " (" + 0 ' 2 , , ( / ., .. + ,' + 0 ,
&J
9
9 -
& 9 @
9& +3 2
& &
& 9
&
&
&
0
; S ("
. ,+ ' () + .. & J ' (.. / ' (. 5 0+ " 4( ,+ , ' . 2 ' (.. " .- " 0 H4I 5 +/ + ? + 0 ' .. + 2) 0 * & " 0 9 / * (' + 2 * . ,( ) + ? / ., 0 / " ( + 7( / +(" .2 ? ' + 2 (/ 0 5 0 ' . *4" + /" 0 -' 2 ,/ , ( + (+ ( ., " ( + ' 0 / *. , (// + "" ' .. 0 + ,0 H / I ' , 0 "" + ' ()* , . / , +
+ , " 0)
' ..* 5 0, " ( ' + , *, ' (+ 0 . " + * 4( . " ..) & J 3 ' . , ' + ( * / . / ' + . ? " ..) 5/ ' 0 ' (*.+ (+ / H2I 91 ' / .. 0 + .0 & " ' ( ' "" * " * , *. ( + ' 0 , ./ +) * .+ .. ( 2 ' + , / " /. 7( 2 ' ' () " 0 .2 * ( 8 .0 , ' 2 * + . ' " / 0 .( ? 1 # ' +( " .1 -' * -' * 1 ..* * , " . +/ .0 * ,/ 0 , 0/ ( + . " . (+ 2 '. , / 0 ( 4( ,+ 3 ( ' 2 ' ' ' + 4( , " ' / . + 99 / 0 0. + * . * 7 + ' + / / ( 8 .0 ' + , ( + ' 0 ) + * / +) * 2 / , K@@ J @J ? ' + .+ (
' + J
0 , .. + + ( 4( ) & ' ) ' // 5 0, , ( + 0 ( +( ..' + /. 6 ( +( (// + H ' ( ( + I+ / . ( ' 2 ' " ( . ( "" ( +( . ( ! ' 5" / , . " 0 8 ' C " 0 *( // ' , /" : . 5 %
HI .T H*I
, .*
G
,
H"I
0.
HI : , HI@( 6
( "
HI> '
"
G
+ , .
#$%$ 0 ,* " ( ) ) ' . 0 , 0 '
+ /. '
( *
+
. .' ,/
,
'/ " . . " " ' .. "=(
'
"
"
"
, + / .
0 " +
,
. +
. * 0
H,I? + J * HI "
' / 0 ' (
J , *.
+ N . / 0 2 *.
()
+ M () M ' 0 , (. !" N
(/ D
"
GG 0
HI
, 9 / /. # 6 9 , . .' , H4I
* (" "
"
G% !"
G-
"
E$ #
3 !
! G
#D 0 #E !"
( & J
0.
3' @ ' . * . 0 , + ". / @ & J =(
!" *,
,
H2I"# $ %& $' ( ! ) +++ & , & -. * . 0 . !" T 1 9$ 3 & ! 4 5 * 78 9 9 / ) 4 0 ! & - -) & 6 - = /& >? * / . / "(. " +/. + ( . ' ( , ' !' / . / . / , +* 78 ? ) / 4 (! $ -? ) & ) & &
* * 2 %
& !
)
& & +
& 6 '
& ! *;
/ 2 -) *:
