November 25, 1997, was part of the APEC Summit taking place that same .....
Incidents at UBC During APEC 1997 – RCMP Documents Volume 1 of 4, A-H. 7-
9.
APEC Inquiry Collection (various collectors) Compiled by Jennifer Pecho (2008)
University of British Columbia Archives
Table of Contents
Collection Description o Title / Dates of Creation / Physical Description o Background o Scope and Content o Notes Memorial note – Sheri Ash
Additional Notes o Guide to Acronyms o A Brief Chronology of Events
Jonathan Oppenheim Sub-Collection Description o Title/Dates of Creation/ Physical Description o Biographical Sketch o Scope and Content o Series Descriptions APEC Exhibits and Related Documents series Legal Documents for APEC PCC and related Federal Court Litigation series RCMP PCC / Federal Trial Correspondence series APEC Alert and Jonathan Oppenheim Documents series General APEC Documents and Correspondence series Videotapes Photographs
Annette Muttray Sub-Collection Description o Title/Dates of Creation/ Physical Description o Biographical Sketch o Scope and Content o Series Descriptions APEC RCMP PCC Exhibits series RCMP PCC Transcripts series
File List
Catalogue entry (UBC Library)
Collection Description APEC Inquiry Collection (various collectors). – 1997-2001. 6.45 m of textual records and other materials.. Background In 1997, outgoing UBC President David Strangway invited the Asia Pacific Economic Co-operation (APEC) Leaders to meet to UBC. The meeting, which would take place on November 25, 1997, was part of the APEC Summit taking place that same month in Vancouver and would see the, often controversial, leaders of numerous nations, including China, Indonesia and the US descend on UBC. A number of groups, many of them student lead, criticized UBC's decision to host the event, and the months leading up to the summit saw increasing action on the UBC campus against the coming APEC summit. These actions, including those organized by the student-led APEC Alert, were geared toward raising awareness of APEC among students, staff and faculty, and encouraging political action and active resistance against APEC. Many of these groups and protestors considered APEC to be undemocratic, complicit in the erosion of human rights and in fostering a society of consumption, and promoters of environmental destruction. Following a series of peaceful demonstrations on the morning of November 25 1997, protesters, including members of APEC Alert, and police began to clash in the afternoon. At one of the roadblocks on N.W. Marine Drive (Gate 6), RCMP officers moved into the crowd with pepper spray, an incident captured by a CBC News crew. A number of protesters, including 48 students, were arrested. A variety of legal actions were initiated in the days after the protests and arrests. Serious charges were leveled at the RCMP for their handling of the event, and for their alleged role in the suppression of free speech and other civil rights. Allegations of political interference by the Prime Minister's Office (PMO) into the actions of the RCMP were also made. An official inquiry into the events at UBC was launched by the RCMP's Public Complaints Commission (PCC) on February 20, 1998, and formal hearings commenced October 5, 1998. Following allegations of further political interference, the hearings ended abruptly with the resignation of the Inquiry's Chief Commissioner, Gerald Morin, on December 4, 1998. A second round of hearings under the direction of Ted Hughes began on March 23, 1999, and concluded on June 30, 2000. The PCC's interim report was released on July 31, 2001, and its final report appeared on March 25, 2002.
Scope and Content The collection consists of exhibits, videotapes and documents collected for the PCC, correspondence and legal documents related to both the PCC and related legal actions, APEC Alert posters, information, pamphlets and ephemera, other material collected and created by Oppenheim with regard to the events surrounding APEC and the RCMP PCC, transcripts of the PCC proceedings, and a number of photographs. Notes Includes: 79 video tapes, 22 photographs, 2 diskettes. The collection was acquired by the UBC Archives in separate donations by Jonathan Oppenheim and Annette Muttray in 2008. File/item list available. In memory of Sheri Ash, who compiled, organized and looked after parts of this collection from 1998 until her death. She was intimately involved with the legal team for the students for the court challenges and for the RCMP Public Complaints Commission's inquiry into APEC – without her, much of this collection would not have survived to be donated to the University Archives.
Additional Notes Guide to Acronyms and Abbreviations
APEC = Asia-Pacific Economic Co-operation AELM = APEC Economic Leaders' Meeting CSIS = Canadian Security and Intelligence Agency DFAIT = Department of Foreign Affairs and International Trade DND = Department of National Defence RCMP PCC = Royal Canadian Mounted Police Public Complaints Commission PCO = Privy Council's Office PMO = Prime Minister's Office MOA = UBC Museum of Anthropology VPD = Vancouver Police Department
A Brief Chronology of Events November 22-24, 1997 A variety of non-violent arrests occur prior to the AELM. November 25, 1997 AELM takes place at the UBC MOA; additional arrests occur and violence breaks out. December 8, 1997 BCCLA President Kay Stockholder files a complaint with the RCMP PCC and becomes the first to call for public hearings into events at the APEC summit. February 20 1998 Shirley Heafey, Chair of the RCMP PCC appoints a three-person panel (Gerald Morin, Vina Starr, John Wright) to oversee the preliminary hearings into complaints arising out of the APEC summit. October 5, 1998 Formal hearings commence. November 23, 1998 Following severe criticisms of political interference into the affairs of the PCC panel, Solicitor General Andy Scott resigns and is replaced by Lawrence MacAulay. December 4, 10, 1998 PCC Commissioner Gerald Morin resigns, alleging additional political interference. This is followed six days later by the resignations of Vina Starr and John Wright.
December 21, 1998 Shirley Heafey, Chair of the RCMP PCC appoints Ted Hughes as sole commissioner to oversee a new (second) round of hearings. March 23, 1999 Formal hearings commence for a second time. June 30, 2000 Formal hearings end. July 31, 2001 The PCC's interim report ("The Hughes Report") is released. March 25, 2002 The PCC's final report is released. Further information about the APEC events at UBC and the APEC Inquiry see the BC Civil Liberties Association – APEC Inquiry fonds.
Sub-Collection and Series Descriptions Jonathan Oppenheim Sub-Collection. – 1997-2001. 4.79 m of textual records. 79 VHS Tapes. 22 Photographs. 2 computer diskettes. In 1997, Jonathan Oppenheim was a graduate student in the Physics Department at the University of British Columbia and a member of APEC Alert, a grassroots group formed at UBC of students, former students, faculty, staff and others who were opposed to APEC (the Asia Pacific Economic Summit) on the UBC campus and to the entire APEC agenda. Oppenheim was involved in organizing and carrying out APEC Alert's three phases of resistance to APEC. “Refuse APEC” ran to November 17. “Summit Under Siege” began November 17 with the erection of a tent city on the lawn to the west of the SUB. “Crash the Summit,” began November 25, the day that UBC would welcome APEC. In the early afternoon of November 25th, protesters and police began to clash in the afternoon. Among the various actions taking place on the UBC campus that day, protesters, including Jonathan Oppenheim, broke through a police barricade at Gate 3 near the School of Theology. He was subsequently arrested. Jonathan Oppenheim was party to the legal actions launched in the days and weeks following the APEC Leader's meeting at UBC alleging that he had been wrongfully arrested and that unnecessary force was used by police during his arrest. Oppenheim chose to represent himself at the PCC hearings and was a vocal critic of the process insisting that it could have no lasting effect due to its inability to call then Prime Minister Jean Chretien to account for decisions made in and around the protests at UBC. In the end, frustrated by what he saw as the corruption of process, Oppenheim “resigned” from the PCC proceedings on February 25, 2000. The sub-collection consists of exhibits, videotapes, photographs and documents collected for the PCC, correspondence and legal documents related to both the PCC and related legal actions, APEC Alert posters, information, pamphlets and ephemera, and other material collected and created by Oppenheim with regard to the events surrounding APEC and the RCMP PCC. APEC Exhibits and Related Documents series. – 1997-2001. 3.36 m of textual records. The series consists of documents compiled by a variety of government agencies and civilian witnesses for exhibit during the RCMP Public Complaints Commission. The exhibits consist of correspondence, witness statements, police
statements, photographs and videotapes and other materials considered pertinent for inclusion in the PCC. The series also includes the Commission's Interim Report published in July 2001. The exhibits are arranged in alphanumeric order where applicable and then by creating agency or individual. See the Annette Muttray Sub-Collection for additional APEC exhibits not included in the Oppenheim Fonds. Legal Documents for APEC PCC and related Federal Court Litigation series. – 1998-2000. 55 cm of textual records. The series consists of submissions by counsel representing a variety of individuals and organizations including the Attorney General of Canada, the Vancouver Police Department, the RCMP and various civilian participants in the RCMP PCC. It includes Affidavits, Books of Authority, Motion Records, Arguments, and Submissions. RCMP PCC / Federal Trial Correspondence series. – 1997-2000. 28 cm of textual records. The series consists of correspondence regarding the RCMP PCC and related legal action that took place around the PCC. It consists primarily of correspondence to Jonathan Oppenheim, but includes correspondence written by Oppenheim and other civilian participants in the RCMP PCC. It includes Oppenheim's “resignation letter” to PCC Commissioner Ted Hughes. The majority of the correspondence is arranged in rough chronological order. APEC Alert and Jonathan Oppenheim Documents series. – 1997-2000. 9 cm of textual records. 1 diskette. The series consists of materials created and disseminated by APEC Alert both before the APEC summit and in its aftermath and materials collected and created by Jonathan Oppenheim. It consists of posters, pamphlets, and ephemera produced by APEC Alert, information about APEC and the leaders of the APEC countries, News Releases about the PCC and a letter written to UBC faculty. In addition, it includes documents composed by Oppenheim and other APEC Alert members in their attempts to subpoena then Prime Minister Jean Chretien to appear at the RCMP PCC.
General APEC Documents and Correspondence. – 1997-2001. 43 cm of textual records. 1 diskette. The series consists of various documents related to the APEC PCC. It includes a variety of APEC related correspondence, exhibits, submissions and notes much of it related to both the perceived lack of cooperation of the Prime Minister's Office in providing access to necessary documents or access to the Prime Minister himself as well as including Procter's note which led to Andy Scott's resignation and the end of the first phase of the RCMP PCC. Videotapes. – 1997-1999. 79 VHS Tapes. The series consists of videotaped exhibits compiled for the APEC PCC and other amateur and news video of actions at UBC and in Downtown Vancouver with regard to APEC. The videos include helicopter and nightvision footage of downtown and UBC, news coverage of APEC and the protests at UBC, and RCMP video footage of the event at UBC. Photographs. – 1997. 22 b&w and colour prints. The series consists of photographs of the APEC demonstration and other related events. Annette Muttray Sub-Collection. – 1997-2001. 1.66 m of textual records. In 1997, Annette Muttray was a graduate student in the Biology Department at the University of British Columbia. Muttray was a vocal opponent to what she viewed as UBC's preoccupation with money before education and was involved in various actions on campus directed at showing discontent with this preoccupation. On November 25, 1997, during the clash at UBC between RCMP, Vancouver Police and student and other protesters, Muttray was arrested while searching for fellow protester and friend Jamie Doucette who had, himself, been arrested some time earlier. Muttray was taken to the Richmond Police Detention Facility alongside many other APEC protesters, and, like the other female protestors, subjected to a strip search by police. Muttray, like many of the other student complainants at the APEC PCC, was a vocal critic of the process insisting that it could have no real effect as long as the respondents (in this case, the RCMP among other government ministries) were responsible for vetting their own
documents and evidence. In the end, Muttray's allegations that her arrest had been inappropriate, and that her bicycle and backpack had been left unattended by police were rejected by the PCC Commissioner. In addition, while the strip search of female prisoners was, in general, deemed inappropriate by the Commissioner, he agreed that Muttray had been legally and rightfully arrested and that her strip search was, therefore, not unlawful. The sub-collection consists of exhibits collected for the PCC and transcripts of the RCMP PCC Hearing from August 1999 to June 2000. APEC RCMP PCC Exhibits series. – 1997-2001. 1.29 m of textual records. The series consists of documents compiled by a variety of government agencies and civilian witnesses for exhibit during the RCMP Public Complaints Commission. The exhibits consist of correspondence, witness statements, police statements, photographs and videotapes and other materials considered pertinent for inclusion. The exhibits are arranged in alpha-numeric order where applicable and then as maintained by the donor. See the Jonathan Oppenheim Sub-Collection for additional APEC exhibits not included in the Annette Muttray Sub-Collection. RCMP PCC Transcripts series. – 1999-2000. 37 cm of textual records. The series consists of transcripts of the RCMP PCC Hearings from August 1999 to June 2000. The transcripts are arranged chronologically.
File List JONATHAN OPPENHEIM SUB-COLLECTION APEC Exhibits And Related Documents series Box 1 1-1
1-2 1-3 1-4 1-5 1-6 1-7 1-8 1-9 1-10 1-11 1-12 1-13 1-14 1-15 1-16 1-17 1-18 1-19 1-20 1-21 1-22
Royal Canadian Mounted Police, Department of National Defence (DND), Department of Foreign Affairs and International Trade (DFAIT), Privy Council Office (PCO)/Prime Minister's Office (PMO) and Canadian Security Intelligence Service (CSIS) Documents: RCMP PCC Exhibits Table of Contents, March 12, 1999. Exhibit C-001 to C-011 Note: C-004, C-008, 009, 010, 011 removed Exhibit C-001 to C-011 Note: C-004, C-008, 009, 010, 011 Exhibit C-004, c-009-009.10, C-010, C-011, G-36.16 Exhibit C-007, P-003.2, H-019.1, H-087, C-009.8 Exhibit G-001 to G-036.20 Exhibit G-001 to G-036.20 Exhibit G-001 to G-036.20 Exhibit G-036 RCMP Audio Tapes/Video Tapes/Photographs Volume 1 of 2 Exhibit G-036 RCMP Audio Tapes/Video Tapes/Photographs Volume 1 of 2 Exhibit G-036 RCMP Audio Tapes/Video Tapes/Photographs Volume 1 of 2 Exhibit G-036.21 to G-036.39 Exhibit G-036.21 to G-036.39 Exhibit G-036.21 to G-036.39 Exhibit G-036.68, G-036.69, G-036.70 Exhibit G-037 to G-043.6 Exhibit P-003.1, N-003.31, P-002.1 Exhibit P-007, AA-001, AA-004 Exhibit T-001 to T-002.16L Exhibit T-001 to T-002.16L Exhibit T-001 to T-002.16L Exhibit T-001 to T-002.16L
Box 2 2-1
Exhibit T-003 to T-007.5
2-2 2-3 2-4 2-5 2-6 2-7 2-8 2-9 2-10 2-11 2-12 2-13 2-14 2-15 2-16 2-17 2-18 2-19 2-20 2-21 2-22 2-23 2-24 2-25
Exhibit V-013.8, 023.14, 013.15, 013.16 Department of Defense Documents [V-022] Exhibit V-022 to V-023.1411. Exhibit CC 001 to EE 007 Exhibit V-022 to V-023.1411. Exhibit CC 001 to EE 007 Exhibit V-024 to V-031.14 Note: V-029 missing Exhibit CC-001 to EE-007 Exhibit JJ-001 to JJ-008.1 Exhibit KK-001 to KK-004 and KK-006 and KK-009 Note: KK-006 and 009 removed Exhibit KK-007 PCO/PMO Documents PCO/PMO Documents Exhibit KK-008 Privy Council Office Documents Binder 1 of 3 KK-010 Privy Council Office Documents Binder 1 of 3 KK-010 Privy Council Office Documents Binder 1 of 3 KK-010 Privy Council Office Documents Binder 3 of 3 KK-010 Privy Council Office Documents Binder 3 of 3 KK-010 Privy Council Office Documents Binder 3 of 3 KK-010 Exhibit LL-001 to MM-002 and NN-001 Exhibit PP-001 to PP-004.12 Exhibit PP-001 to PP-004.12 Exhibit PP-005 to PP 014.3 Exhibit PP-005 to PP 014.3 Exhibit PP-005 to PP 014.3 Exhibit TT-001 to UU-001 Exhibit VV-002 to VV-002.14
Box 3 3-1 3-2 3-3 3-4 3-5 3-6 3-7 3-8 3-9 3-10
Additional Documents from Commission Counsel since March 12, 1999 Additional Documents from Commission Counsel since March 12, 1999 Additional Documents from Commission Counsel April 15, 1999 and April 20, 1999 Additional Documents from Commission Counsel since May 27, 1999 Additional Documents from Commission Counsel since May 27, 1999 Additional Documents from Commission Counsel since August 18, 1999 Additional Documents from Commission Counsel since August 18, 1999 Additional Documents from Commission Counsel since September 3, 1999 Additional Documents from Commission Counsel since September 3, 1999 Additional Documents from Commission Counsel October 29, 1999
3-11 3-12 3-13 3-14 3-15 3-16 3-17 3-18
Additional Documents from Commission Counsel October 25, 1999 Additional Documents from Commission Counsel October 21, 1999 Additional Documents from Commission Counsel October 18, 1999 Additional Documents from Commission Counsel since November 8, 1999 Additional Documents from Commission Counsel since November 8, 1999 Additional Documents from Commission Counsel since November 8, 1999 Additional Documents from Commission Counsel since November 8, 1999 Additional Documents from Commission Counsel since January 13, 2000
Box 4 4-1 4-2 4-3 4-4 4-5 4-6 4-7 4-8 4-9 4-10 4-11 4-12 4-13 4-14
City of Vancouver and Vancouver Police Department Documents for APEC Hearings Volume I City of Vancouver and Vancouver Police Department Documents for APEC Hearings Volume I City of Vancouver and Vancouver Police Department Documents for APEC Hearings Volume I City of Vancouver and Vancouver Police Department Documents for APEC Hearings Volume I City of Vancouver and Vancouver Police Department Documents for APEC Hearings Volume II City of Vancouver and Vancouver Police Department Documents for APEC Hearings Volume II City of Vancouver and Vancouver Police Department Documents for APEC Hearings Volume II City of Vancouver and Vancouver Police Department Documents for APEC Hearings Volume III City of Vancouver and Vancouver Police Department Documents for APEC Hearings Volume IV City of Vancouver and Vancouver Police Department Documents for APEC Hearings Volume IV City of Vancouver and Vancouver Police Department Documents for APEC Hearings Volume IV City of Vancouver and Vancouver Police Department Documents for APEC Hearings Volume V City of Vancouver and Vancouver Police Department Documents for APEC Hearings Volume V City of Vancouver and Vancouver Police Department Documents for APEC Hearings Volume V
4-15 4-16 4-17
City of Vancouver and Vancouver Police Department Documents for APEC Hearings Volume V City of Vancouver and Vancouver Police Department Documents for APEC Hearings Volume VI City of Vancouver and Vancouver Police Department Documents for APEC Hearings Volume VI
Box 5 5-1 5-2 5-3 5-4 5-5 5-6 5-7
5-8
5-9 5-10 5-11 5-12 5-13 5-14 5-15 5-16 5-17
City of Vancouver and Vancouver Police Department Documents for APEC Hearings Volume VI City of Vancouver and Vancouver Police Department Documents for APEC Hearings Volume VII City of Vancouver and Vancouver Police Department Documents for APEC Hearings Volume VII City of Vancouver and Vancouver Police Department Documents for APEC Hearings Volume VII City of Vancouver and Vancouver Police Department Documents for APEC Hearings Volume VIII Canadian Security and Intelligence Service (CSIS) Documents APEC Litigation CSIS Disclosure Binder May 25, 1999 Copy of Relevant Documents vetted for National Security interested released to the RCMP Public Complaints Commission APEC Litigation CSIS Disclosure Binder May 25, 1999 Copy of Relevant Documents vetted for National Security interested released to the RCMP Public Complaints Commission APEC Litigation CSIS Canada Evidence Act Sections 37, 38 Certificate Number 2 APEC Litigation CSIS Canada Evidence Act Sections 37, 38 Certificate Number 2 APEC RCMP PCC Proceedings Exhibit 25 [CSIS] APEC RCMP PCC Proceedings Exhibit 25 [CSIS] [Miscellaneous CSIS Documents and Police Transcripts] [Miscellaneous CSIS Documents and Police Transcripts] Exhibit 26 – Binder of Department of Foreign Affairs Documents originally filed as Exhibit 26 in APEC Hearing Version 1.0 Exhibit 26 – Binder of Department of Foreign Affairs Documents originally filed as Exhibit 26 in APEC Hearing Version 1.0 Exhibit 26 – Binder of Department of Foreign Affairs Documents originally filed as Exhibit 26 in APEC Hearing Version 1.0
5-18 5-19
Exhibit 26 – Binder of Department of Foreign Affairs Documents originally filed as Exhibit 26 in APEC Hearing Version 1.0 APEC RCMP PCC Proceedings: Department of Foreign Affairs and International Trade Tab 40 – Mary McNeil Notes February 1999
Box 6 6-1 6-2 6-3 6-4 6-5 6-6 6-7 6-8 6-9 6-10 6-11 6-12 6-13 6-14 6-15 6-16 6-17
APEC RCMP PCC Proceedings: Department of Foreign Affairs and International Trade Tab 40 – Mary McNeil Notes February 1999 RCMP Public Complaints Commission Exhibit 26A Certificate SS 37, 38 Canada Evidence Act DFAIT and Privy Council Office Volume II Department of Foreign Affairs and International Trade Documents – B67-B91, SS-002 Department of Foreign Affairs and International Trade Documents – B67-B91, SS-002 Department of Foreign Affairs and International Trade Documents – B67-B91, SS-002 Exhibit 26A the second binder of DFAIT documents originally filed as Exhibit 26A in the APEC Hearing Version 1.0 APEC Litigation, DFAIT, Canada Evidence Act Sections 37, 38 Certificate #2 APEC RCMP PCC Proceedings: Department of Foreign Affairs and International Trade Binder #3 February 1999. APEC RCMP PCC Proceedings: Department of Foreign Affairs and International Trade Binder #3 February 1999. APEC RCMP PCC Proceedings: Department of Foreign Affairs and International Trade Binder #3 February 1999. APEC RCMP PCC Proceedings: Department of Foreign Affairs and International Trade Binder #3 February 1999. RCMP Public Complaints Commission APEC UBC Exhibit 26 Certificate ss 37, 38 Canada Evidence Act DFAIT and PCO Volume I RCMP Public Complaints Commission APEC UBC Exhibit 26 Certificate ss 37, 38 Canada Evidence Act DFAIT and PCO Volume I RCMP Public Complaints Commission APEC UBC Exhibit 26 Certificate ss 37, 38 Canada Evidence Act DFAIT and PCO Volume I Department of Justice re: PCC (APEC 3) – 00796-137 RCMP Public Complaints Commission Exhibit 23 Complaint APEC UBC Submitted by Justice Department (Fothergill) October 16, 1998 Certificate (ss. 37,38 Canada Evidence Act) Department of National Defence – Colonel Lea Alexandre Vachon
6-18 6-19
APEC Litigation Privy Council Office and Department of the Solicitor General Canada Evidence Act, Sections 37, 38 Certificate Number 2 APEC Litigation Privy Council Office and Department of the Solicitor General Canada Evidence Act, Sections 37, 38 Certificate Number 2
Box 7 7-1 7-2 7-3 7-4 7-5 7-6 7-7 7-8 7-9 7-10 7-11 7-12 7-13 7-14 7-15 7-16 7-17 7-18 7-19 7-20
Prime Minister's Office Documents Prime Minister's Office Documents [Index of RCMP Documents, Hearing Exhibits, Videotaped Exhibits] RCMP Public Complaints Commission APEC/UBC Exhibit 23 APEC Litigation, RCMP, Canada Evidence Act, Section 37 Certificate Number 2 RCMP Public Complaints Commission Royal Canadian Mounted Police ss. 37, 38 Canada Evidence Act May 27, 1999 RCMP Public Complaints Commission Royal Canadian Mounted Police ss. 37, 38 Canada Evidence Act May 27, 1999 Incidents at UBC During APEC 1997 – RCMP Documents Volume 1 of 4, A-H Incidents at UBC During APEC 1997 – RCMP Documents Volume 1 of 4, A-H Incidents at UBC During APEC 1997 – RCMP Documents Volume 2 of 4 Incidents at UBC During APEC 1997 – RCMP Documents Volume 2 of 4 Incidents at UBC During APEC 1997 – RCMP Documents Volume 2 of 4 Incidents at UBC During APEC 1997 – RCMP Documents Volume 3 of 4, Q-Z Incidents at UBC During APEC 1997 – RCMP Documents Volume 3 of 4, Q-Z Incidents at UBC During APEC 1997 – RCMP Documents Volume 3 of 4, Q-Z Incidents at UBC During APEC 1997 – Supplementary Documents of RCMP Volume 1 of 2 Incidents at UBC During APEC 1997 – Supplementary Documents of RCMP Volume 1 of 2 Incidents at UBC During APEC 1997 – Supplementary Documents of RCMP Volume 1 of 2 Incidents at UBC During APEC 1997 – Supplementary Documents of RCMP Volume 2 of 2 Incidents at UBC During APEC 1997 – Supplementary Documents of RCMP Volume 2 of 2
Box 8 8-1
8-2
8-3 8-4 8-5 8-6 8-7 8-8 8-9 8-10 8-11 8-12 8-13
8-14 8-15 8-16 8-17 8-18 8-19 8-20
[RCMP Internal Interviews, Exhibit B-006 Prisoner Handling/Richmond Detention Cells, Exhibit C-009 Police Files or Booking Sheets, Exhibit T-002 Gate 6 Clearing] [RCMP Internal Interviews, Exhibit B-006 Prisoner Handling/Richmond Detention Cells, Exhibit C-009 Police Files or Booking Sheets, Exhibit T-002 Gate 6 Clearing] [RCMP Internal Interviews] Note: contains miscellaneous statements and interview transcripts [RCMP Internal Interviews] Note: contains Exhibit BB-005, FF-003, FF-004 [RCMP Internal Interviews] Note: contains Exhibit HH-004, RR-001 [Documents of the Respondent RCMP officers in the RCMP PCC Represented by Farris, Vaughan, Wills and Murphy Barristers and Solicitors] [Documents of the Respondent RCMP officers in the RCMP PCC Represented by Farris, Vaughan, Wills and Murphy Barristers and Solicitors] [RCMP PCC Certificates Exhibit ?, 24, 25, 26] Wayne May Supplemental Binder Number 1 Wayne May Supplemental Binder Number 1 [RCMP Documents – Wayne May] Note: includes documents labeled ex 275, ex 276, S-004 [Police/RCMP Training Documents] RCMP Public Complaints Commission Department of the Solicitor General and Privy Council Office Documents ss. 37, 38 Canada Evidence Act, 16 October, 1998 Exhibit 24 Department of the Solicitor General and Privy Council Office Documents ss. 37,38 Canada Evidence Act UBC Documents Exhibit 20 UBC Documents Exhibit 20 UBC Documents [Documents relating to APEC in institutions at UBC] [Documents relating to APEC in institutions at UBC] [Documents relating to APEC in institutions at UBC]
Box 9 9-1 9-2
[VPD PC. Hynes 1081, APEC Documents] [VPD PC. Hynes 1081, APEC Documents]
9-3 9-4 9-5 9-6 9-7 9-8 9-9 9-10 9-11 9-12 9-13 9-14 9-15 9-16 9-17 9-18 9-19 9-20 9-21 9-22 9-23 9-24 9-25 9-26 9-27
[Miscellaneous APEC Documents (VPD?)] Documents Submitted by David Malmo-Levine Designation "EF" Documents Submitted by Kevin Dwyer – Designation "FG" April 23, 1999 Documents Submitted by David Goodrich Designation "GH" "IJ" Volume 3 Craig Jones Exhibit "JK" Volume 1 Craig Jones Documents tendered by G. Macintosh Counsel for 38 Subject Members Interview with Witness Jonathan Oppenheim RCMP Complaints Commission Witness Statements Volume I (A to O) Public's Copy RCMP Complaints Commission Witness Statements Volume I (A to O) Public's Copy RCMP Complaints Commission Witness Statements Volume I (A to O) Public's Copy RCMP Complaints Commission Witness Statements Volume II (P to Z) Public's Copy RCMP Complaints Commission Witness Statements Volume II (P to Z) Public's Copy RCMP Complaints Commission Witness Statements Volume II (P to Z) Public's Copy [RCMP PCC Documents re: Witnesses] [Box Table of Contents and Lists for APEC ‘97] Schedule PCC APEC/UBC Complaints as of February 14, 1998] Documents from RCMP PCC Counsel Office dated February 7, 2000 and March 9, 1999 re: RCMP PCC] [Miscellaneous APEC Documents and Exhibits] [Miscellaneous APEC PCC Documents] [Police/Pepper Spray Documents] [Miscellaneous Evidence for RCMP Public Complaints Commission] [Miscellaneous APEC legal documents] [Miscellaneous Precedents] [Documents regarding Legal Precedents]
Box 10 10-1 10-2
Documents reviewed by Commission Counsel in July 1998 but not selected by him at that time Documents reviewed by Commission Counsel in July 1998 but not selected by him at that time
10-3 10-4 10-5 10-6
Documents reviewed by Commission Counsel in July 1998 but not selected by him at that time RCMP PCC – Transcription of Oral Rulings Made by Commissioner E. N. (Ted) Hughes, Q.C. March 5, 1999 [Miscellaneous Documents] Commission for Public Complaints against the RCMP Commission Interim Report July 31, 2001
Legal Documents For APEC PCC And Related Federal Court Legislation series 10-7 10-8 10-9 10-10 10-11 10-12 10-13 10-14 10-15 10-16 10-17 10-18
Consolidated Materials of the Attorney General of Canada – RCMP PCC Consolidated Materials of the Attorney General of Canada – RCMP PCC RCMP PCC Transcript Excerpts of the Attorney General of Canada (Application for Additional Government Witnesses) Affidavit of Sgt. D. R. Bindon Affidavit of Sgt. D. R. Bindon Federal Court – Trial Court Affidavits Russell Black and Erin Poyner Affidavit of Lena Fiorda Affidavit of Katherine MacCormick RCMP PCC Affidavit of Aymen Nader [Regarding documents not received by counsel for complainants from RCMP Affidavit of Aymen Nader Federal Court Affidavits – Jonathon Oppenheim, J. C. Michel Gauthier, Craig Elton Jones, Dale Neufeld, Hugh Stephens Respondents' Application Record (Commission's Application to Intervene)
Box 11 11-1 11-2 11-3 11-4 11-5 11-6 11-7 11-8
Application Re: Letter to Federal Government for Funding for Legal Counsel Argument Re: Messrs. Storrow, Gillett and Ms. Fisher Summary of Argument of the Attorney General of Canada (Productions of Documents) Authorities of Attorney General of Canada (Application for Summonses) Authorities of Attorney General of Canada (Production of Documents) Book of Authorities of the Attorney General of Canada (Funding of Complainant's Counsel) Book of Authorities (Applicants/Plaintiffs) Book of Authorities of the Attorney General of Canada (Intervention of Her Majesty the Queen in right of Canada)
11-9 11-10 11-11 11-12 11-13 11-14 11-15 11-16 11-17 11-18 11-19 11-20 11-21 11-22
Further Case Authorities on Application to Call Witness Brief of Authorities of the Vancouver Police Department Re: Application to Quash a Summons Brief of Evidence – Funding Assistance Memorandum of Fact and Law of the Applicants Westergard-Thorpe, Muttray et al. Motion Record Motion Record (Applicants/Plaintiffs) Motion Record Motion Record of the RCMP Public Complaints Commission in Support of Application for Intervention Motion Record of the RCMP Public Complaints Commission in Support of Application for Intervention Notice of Motion of the Attorney General of Canada (Intervention of Her Majesty the Queen in Right of Canada) Notice of Motion [To: The Register, RCMP PCC c/o Commission Counsel] Submissions of the Attorney General of Canada (Application for Summonses) Submissions of the Attorney General of Canada (Funding of Complainants' Counsel) Submissions of Subject Members of the RCMP in Reply to Application for Adjournment
RCMP PCC/Federal Trail Correspondence series Box 12 12-1 12-2 12-3 12-4 12-5 12-6 12-7 12-8 12-9 12-10 12-11 12-12 12-13
[Jonathon Oppenheim's "Resignation Letter"] [Correspondence re: APEC documents/exhibits] APEC PCC/Federal Trial Correspondence 1997 APEC PCC/Federal Trial Correspondence 01 to 07 1998 APEC PCC/Federal Trial Correspondence 08 1998 APEC PCC/Federal Trial Correspondence 09 1998 APEC PCC/Federal Trial Correspondence 10 1998 APEC PCC/Federal Trial Correspondence 11 1998 APEC PCC/Federal Trial Correspondence 11 1998 APEC PCC/Federal Trial Correspondence 12 1998 APEC PCC/Federal Trial Correspondence 01 to 03 1999 APEC PCC/Federal Trial Correspondence 04 1999 APEC PCC/Federal Trial Correspondence 05 to 08 1999
12-14 12-15 12-16 12-17 12-18
APEC PCC/Federal Trial Correspondence 05 to 08 1999 APEC PCC/Federal Trial Correspondence 09 to 12 1999 [Miscellaneous undated correspondence] [RCMP PCC Correspondence] [Miscellaneous Federal Court Documents and Correspondence]
APEC Alert and Jonathan Oppenheim Documents series 12-19 12-20 12-21 12-22 12-23 12-24 12-25 12-26 12-27 12-28 12-29 12-30 12-31
[Documents re: Motion to Subpoena Chretien] [Jonathon Oppenheim – Supplemental Documents re: PM Involvement in APEC] APEC Media Handbook APEC Alert News Advisories and Releases APEC Alert New Releases APEC Alert Miscellaneous pamphlets, flyers, and information APEC Alert Posters APEC Alert Letter to Faculty Note: includes paper and diskette copy [Newsclippings and leaflets re: Suharto and other APEC leaders] [Photos of APEC and related student action] [Miscellaneous Jonathan Oppenheim Documents] ["APEC Stuff"] [Oppenheim documents re: APEC Alert]
General APEC Documents and Correspondence series Box 13 13-1 13-2 13-3 13-4 13-5 13-6 13-7 13-8
[Documents labeled PP-002.5, PP-002.6, Incident Report 97.11.20, PP-002.7] [Miscellaneous APEC Documents and Correspondence] [Miscellaneous APEC Correspondence and Precedents] [Miscellaneous APEC Correspondence] [Miscellaneous APEC Correspondence] [Miscellaneous APEC Documents and Correspondence] The University as/in Contested Space – Ruth B. Phillips Note: paper and diskette copy [Miscellaneous APEC Documents including Procter's note which led to Andy Scott's resignation]
13-9 13-10 13-11 13-12 13-13 13-14 13-15 13-16 13-17 13-18 13-19 13-20 13-21 13-22 13-23 13-24 13-25 13-26 13-27 13-28
[Miscellaneous APEC Correspondence] [APEC information and essays] [Notebook containing some notes by ?] [Miscellaneous APEC Documents and Correspondence] [Miscellaneous PCC Exhibit Material (sent to Svend Robinson?)] [Miscellaneous APEC Documents and Correspondence including Jonathon Oppenheim's Opening Statement] Interview with Jaggi Singh by Donna Horton [Miscellaneous APEC Documents and Correspondence] [APEC Commission of Inquiry Legal Background papers] [Miscellaneous APEC Correspondence (1998)] [Some Hearing Notes and Video Notes] [Additional PCC Documents, Correspondence and News Advisories] Affidavit of Jean Chretien [Additional Documents re: Call for Additional Government Witnesses] [Correspondence and Documents re: Requests for Additional Documents/Witnesses] [Miscellaneous Documents] [Miscellaneous Documents] APEC PCC/Federal Trial Miscellaneous Correspondence 1999 APEC PCC/ Federal Trial Miscellaneous Correspondence 2000 [Miscellaneous APEC Documents and Correspondence]
Box 14 14-1 14-2 14-3 14-4 14-5 14-6 14-7 14-8 14-9 14-10 14-11 14-12 14-13
[Documents and Notes re: Chretien, Martha Piper, UBC] Certificate ss 37.38 Canada Evidence Act Department of Foreign Affairs and International Trade and Privy Council's Office RCMP PCC Media Briefing Folder Monday October 5, 1998 Submissions of the Attorney General of Canada (Application to Adduce Expert Evidence) Application for Government Witnesses Exhibit H -076 [APEC Alert Posters] [APEC Alert Posters] [Miscellaneous APEC PCC Documents and Correspondence] [Miscellaneous APEC PCC Documents and Correspondence] [Miscellaneous APEC PCC Documents and Correspondence] [Miscellaneous Jonathan Oppenheim APEC Documents and Correspondence] APEC – RCC and Stays of Proceedings
14-14 14-15 14-16
14-17
Photographs from various sources/Photos taken by Richard Lam APEC PCC Photo Exhibits/Photocopies of photocopies RCMP PCC Outline of Arguments of the complainants Jamie Doucette, Mark Brooks, Annette Muttray, Alissa Westergard-Thorpe and Dennis Potter on preliminary Applications October 5, 1998 RCMP PCC Videotape Exhibit Lists
Videotapes series 1734 1735 1736 1737 1738 1739 1740 1741 1742 1743
1744 1745
1746
APEC NOV 25-97 - #01 VHS Tape (1 hr.) APEC NOV 25-97 #02 VHS Tape (1.5 hr.) PEPPER SPRAY NOV, 25/97 THE NATIONAL #3 VHS Tape (1 hr.) APEC NOV 24-97 #04 VHS Tape (1 hr.) APEC #06 VHS Tape (2 hr.) JAGGI SINGH VIDEO # 7 VHS Tape (30 min.) APEC FOOTAGE GABE LINDER #9 VHS Tape (15 min.) CBC APEC #11 VHS Tape (1 hr.) RICHMOND RCMP DETACHMENT CELL BLOCK – DRUNK TANK #12 VHS Tape (3 min.) APEC-UBC NOV 25/97 FENCE INCIDENT & ROAD CLEARING OPERATION #13 VHS Tape (15 min.) APEC – UBC DEMONSTRATION NOVEMBER 25th, 1997 #14 VHS Tape (15 min.) APEC NEWS STORIES – CBC/BCTV/GLOBAL – TUESDAY NOV 18/1997 #15 VHS Tape (1 hr.) APEC NEWS STORIES – CBC/BCTV/GLOBAL – WEDNESDAY, NOV 19/1997 #16 VHS Tape (1 hr.)
1747
1748 1749 1750 1751
1752
1753
1754
1755
1756 1757 1758 1759 1760 1761 1762
APEC NEWS STORIES – CBC/BCTV /GLOBAL – THURSDAY, NOV 20/1997 #17 VHS Tape (1 hr.) APEC NEWS STORIES CBC/BCTV/GLOBAL – FRIDAY, NOV 21/1997 #18 VHS Tape (1 hr.) APEC NEWS STORIES CBC/BCTV/GLOBAL SATURDAY, NOV 22/1997 #19 VHS Tape (30 min.) APEC NEWS STORIES CBC/BCTV/GLOBAL SUNDAY, NOV 23 1997 #20 VHS Tape (1 hr.) APEC NEWS STORIES CBC/BCTV/GLOBAL/VTV – MONDAY, NOV 24/1997 #21 VHS Tape (2 hr.) APEC NEWS STORIES CBC/BCTV/GLOBAL/VTV – TUESDAY, NOV. 25/1997 #22 VHS Tape (2 hr.) APEC NEWS STORIES CBC/BCTV/GLOBAL/VTV – WEDNESDAY, NOV 27, 1997 # 23 VHS Tape (1 hr.) note: Correct date is Wednesday, Nov 26, 1997. APEC NEWS STORIES CBC/BCTV/GLOBAL/VTV – THURSDAY, NOV. 27/1997 #24 VHS Tape (30 min.) APEC NEWS STORIES – CBC/BCTV/GLOBAL/VTV – NOVEMBER 28-30, 1997 - # 25 VHS Tape (20 min.) UBC TAPE #1 KRAEMER 97-11-25 # 26 VHS Tape (30 min.) UBC TAPE #2 KREAMER 97-11-25 #27 VHS Tape (15 min.) APEC – UBC MCLEAP – 97-11-25 # 28 VHS Tape (1 hr.) APEC – UBC/ART CENTER CPL RIGBY – 97-11-25 #29 VHS Tape (30 min.) APEC – UBC/ PAN TAPE SGT. PHILLIPE – 97-11-25 # 30 VHS Tape (30 min.) APEC ART GALLERY/HYATT/UBC MCDLARMLD – 97-11-24/25 # 31 VHS Tape (30 min.) APEC- HELICOPTER TAPE #2 FLIR 97-11-25 #32 VHS Tape (1.5 hr.)
1763 1764 1765 1766 1767 1768 1769
1770 1771 1772 1773 1774
1775 1776 1777
1778 1779 1780
97-11-24/19:04-19:45/G24 97-11-25/16:40-19:00/COPY #1 #34 VHS Tape (1.5 hr.) UBC PROTEST/BC PLACE MOTORCADE 97-11-24/16:30-18:50 (G25) #35 VHS Tape (2 hr.) 97-11-25 (G SIMARD) (06:30-08:35/12:00-13:40) # 36 VHS Tape (1.5 hr.) 97-11-25 (1507-1634 – HRS) #37 VHS Tape (2 hr.) G28/97-11-23/16:00-17:00/21:00-01:10 A. LEATHERDALE #38 VHS Tape (1.5 hr.) G29/97-11-23/07:40 – 10:05 G. SIMARD #39 VHS Tape (1.5 hr.) DEMO @ HYATT/MOTORCADES – 97-11-23/17:05-20:50/09:45-12:05 (G30) #40 VHS Tape (1.5 hr.) APEC – UBC – PROTESTS RCMP GATE 6 #41 VHS Tape (90 min.) UBC PROTEST CBC- FRIDAY, NOV 28th, 1997 #42 VHS Tape (10 min.) POLICING APEC #43 VHS Tape (15 min.) INCIDENT FREE! SANS INCIDENT – 1997 #45 VHS Tape (30 min.) ROUGH CUT – APEC DAY, NOV, 1997 SUBMITTED BY DENISE KENNY #46 VHS Tape (30 min.) RCMP APEC VIDEO NOVEMBER 22-26/97 #47 G-044 VHS Tape (1 hr.) VARIOUS NEWS COVERAGES # 11 C.W. VHS Tape (1.5 hr.) CONVERSATION WITH HUGHSTEWART SCENES AND INTERVIEW @ SUB – FLAGPOLE INCIDENTS #14 C.W. VHS Tape (1.5 hr.) PEPPER SPRAY INCIDENTS FENCE SCENES # 15 C.W. VHS Tape (1 hr.) NOV 25/97 FENCE SCENES VARIOUS PROTEST SCENES # 16 C.W. VHS Tape (1 hr.) DAVID’S ARREST SPEECHES AT FLAGPOLE # 17 C.W. VHS Tape (1 hr.)
1781 1782 1783 1784
1785
1786 1787 1788 1789 1790 1791 1792 1793 1794 1795 1796 1797 1798 1799
DEMO @ SUB DEMO @ KOERNER # 18 C.W. VHS Tape (1 hr.) SECURITY @ FENCE PEPPER SPRAY @ FENCE, ARRESTS # 19 C.W. VHS Tape (1 hr.) UBC SUHARTO ARREST SCENE # 21 C.W. VHS Tape (1.5 hr.) CITIZEN ARREST OF SUHARTO (WHOLE EVENT) SEDGWICK LIBRARY #22 C.W. VHS Tape (30 min.) # 49 – (PCC) APEC – Various Events at UBC November 25, 1997 Taken by Mark Achbar VHS Tape (1.5 hr.) Tape 8B DP VHS Copy VHS Tape (1:36 min.) CEO SUMMIT ’97 MINI DV 4… VHS Tape (1:01 min.) TAPE #1: People’s Summit March, UBC Tent City, Free University Panel… VHS Tape (2:03 min.) TAPE # 2, # 3 VHS Copy DP VHS Tape (1:53 min.) #57 YVETTE’S TAPE VHS Tape (1:28 min.) TAPE 5 VHS COPY D.P. VHS Tape (45 min.) VHS Copy Tape 4 D.P. VHS Tape (2 hr.) APEC PROTEST VHS Tape (3:30 min.) APEC HEARING S/SGT STEWART COMPILATION OCT. 1999 VHS Tape (1.5 hr.) APEC LEGAL CHALLENGE [The National] VHS Tape (45 min.) APEC Rogers Coverage… VHS Tape (4:05 min.) DEMOCRACY ON TRIAL: Promotional Reel VHS Tape (10 min.) APEC UBC PROTEST – 2ND MINI D.V. VHS Tape (2 hr.) CBC – APEC AS TRIGGER…[CBC, CPAC Broadcast] VHS Tape (2:05 min.)
1800 1801 1802 1803 1804
1805 1806 1807 1808 1809 1810 1811
1812
1813 1814
APEC ALERT – DEMO @ UBC 25 Nov 1997 VHS Tape (1 hr.) UBC NEWS COVERAGE [Global News, CPAC Broadcast] VHS Tape (1:07 min.) APEC ABEC PRESS CONF. MON. NOV 24 [1997]… VHS Tape (2 hr.) C.W. #26 Various "actions" at UBC VHS Tape (1 hr.) RCMP #48 APEC Museum of Anthropology Cpl. Birkenshaw Indet Tape – Nov. 22/97 VHS Tape (1 hr.) BCTV – ERIC CABLE – NOV 25/97 – UBC PCC #58 – Ex. 703 VHS Tape (20 min.) RICHMOND RCMP DETACHMENT CELL BLOCK DRUNK TANK 98-10-08 VHS Tape (3 min.) APEC Tape by Maia Chowdhury VHS Tape (57 min.) APEC NEWS COVERAGE [Rogers Cable Broadcast, 25 Nov. 1997] VHS Tape (1:05 min.) APEC Nov. 24-25/97 # 5 VHS Tape (1:37 min.) APEC-NEWS/CHRETIEN… VHS Tape (2:01 min.) Anti-APEC Protest in Vancouver/ Produced by Sam Pullen and Maegan Willan VHS Tape (55 min.) TAPE #2 Women’s Panel, Free Jaggi March, Indigenous Panel, Suharto Protest VHS Tape (2 hr.) TAPE #3i Crash the Summit (Pepper Spray) VHS Tape (22 min.) #54 MARCH ACHBAR NOV 25/97 VHS Tape (90 min.)
Photographs series 135.1/1
APEC at UBC photograph– [1997] – 25.5 X 20.5cm b&w matte print – note: [photo shows public being pepper sprayed with media crews in the back], written on the back is Richard Lam 1999.
135.1/2
135.1/3
135.1/4
135.1/5
135.1/6
135.1/7
135.1/8 135.1/9
135.1/10
135.1/11
135.1/12
135.1/13
135.1/14
Street Theater at Koerner Library – Nov. 25 [1997] – 12.5 X 18cm b&w glossy print – note: [photo shows an aerial view of gathering on the north side of Koerner library]. Mock Riot Police Guarding Koerporate Library – [1997] – 13.5 X 20cm b&w glossy print – note: [photo shows gathering including media on and in front of the Walter C. Koerner Library]. Jonathan [Oppenheim] and Terry [Moleski] – [1997] – 13.5 X 20cm b&w glossy print – note: written on photo "Jonathan and Terry (photograph included for benefit of PMO)". The Infamous Fence – [1997] – 12.5 X 18cm b&w glossy print – note: [photos shows gathering clinging to fence with RCMP, Vancouver Police and media present]. Koerner Library: APEC can Kiss my… - 1997 – 25.5 X 20cm b&w glossy print – note: [photo shows bottom half of person standing on Koerner Library facing crowd in front of Irving K Barber building] photo by Paul Gubbe. APEC at UBC photograph – [1997] – 25.5 X 20cm b&w glossy print – note: [photo shows man that may have been pepper sprayed being removed from crowd] Richard Lam. Gate 6 – [1997] – 25.5 X 20.5cm b&w glossy print – note: [photo shows side view of line of RCMP and Vancouver Police facing crowd]. Arrested Students and Prof Tester – Nov. 25 [1997] – 18 X 13cm b&w glossy print – note: [photo shows individuals with zap-straps on their wrists beside RCMP and Vancouver Police beside fence with crowd on the other side of fence]. APEC at UBC photograph – [1997]– 20 X 25.5cm b&w glossy print – note: [photo shows line of individuals pressed up against RCMP and Vancouver Police with line of bicycles]. Richard Lam 1999. Arrest of Jaggi Singh and Aiyanas – Nov. 24/87 - 13 X 18cm b&w glossy print – note: [photo shows Jaggi Singh on ground with two RCMP officers leaning over him] Photo by Richard Lam. Police Line Gate 6 – Nov.25 [1997] – 18 X 13cm b&w glossy print – note: [photo shows line of RCMP and Vancouver Police at least 3 rows deep on street near sign that reads future home of St. Johns College] photo by Richard Lam. APEC at UBC photograph – [1997] – 10 X 12.5cm glossy colour print – note: [photo shows crowd with signs on lawn between Belkin Art Gallery and Buchanan Building]. APEC at UBC photograph – [1997] – 10 X 12.5cm glossy colour print – note: [photo shows crowd with media, RCMP officers and Vancouver Police near the Chan Centre].
135.1/15 A Corner of Demoville – [1997] – 10 X 15cm glossy colour print – note: [photo shows collection of pitched tents and tarps near the Student Union Building]. 135.1/16 A Corner of Demoville – [1997] – 10 X 15cm glossy colour print – note: [photo shows collection of pitched tents near the Main Library]. 135.1/17 APEC at UBC photograph – [1997] – 25.5 X 20cm b&w glossy print – note: [photo shows media and crowd pressed against RCMP and Vancouver Police against a fence] Richard Lam 1999 135.1/18 Imagine UBC – [1997] – 10 X 15cm glossy colour print – note: [photograph shows APEC at UBC posters wrapped around statue of Goddess of Democracy]. 135.1/19 Imagine UBC – [1997] - 10 X 15cm glossy colour print – note: [photograph shows APEC at UBC posters]. 135.1/20 Resistance is Beautiful – [1997] – 20 X 20.5cm b&w glossy print – note: [photograph shows crowd and posters at APEC at UBC]. 135.1/21 Post –spray – [1997] – 20 X 25.5cm b&w glossy print – note: [photo shows woman pouring water down her face with onlookers in the back]. 135.1/22 APEC at UBC photograph – [1997] – 28 X 35.5cm b&w glossy print – note: [photograph shows man in tent with sign that reads APEC IS ORGANIZED CRIME on the west side of the Museum of Anthropology].
ANNETTE MUTTRAY SUB-COLLECTION APEC RCMP PCC Exhibits series BOX 15 15.1 15.2 15.3 15.4 15.5 15.6 15.7 15.8 15.9 15.10 15.11 15.12
RCMP, DND, DFAIT, PCO/PMO, CSIS Documents Table of Contents March 12, 1999 Exhibit B-002 to B-005 Exhibit F-001 to F-004.5 Exhibit G-033 Photos Exhibit G-036.67 Exhibit H-004 to H-032 and H-040 to H-042 Exhibit H-004 to H-032 and H-040 to H-042 Exhibit H-044 to H-060 Exhibit H-044 to H-060 Exhibit H-061 to H-075.1 Exhibit H-076 to H-078 Exhibit H-080 to H-089
15.13 15.14 15.15 15.16 15.17 15.18 15.19 15.20 15.21 15.22 15.23 15.24 15.25 15.26 15.27 15.28
Exhibit I-001 to I-003.2 Exhibit I-004 Exhibit J-001 to J-005 Exhibit L-001 to M-001 Exhibit M-002 to M-004 Exhibit P-001 to S-004 Exhibit P-001 to S-004 Exhibit P-001 to S-004 Exhibit U-008 Exhibit W-001, 002, 003, 005, X-002, 004, Y-003,004, Z-003 to Z-005, 009, 011, Z014 to Z-017 Exhibit BB-001, BB-003-004 Exhibit DD-002 and EE-007 Exhibit FF-001 Exhibit HH-001 to HH-003 Exhibit KK-006 Privy Council Office Documents Exhibit KK-010 Binder #2
BOX 16 16-1 16-2 16-3 16-4 16-5 16-6 16-7 16-8 16-9 16-10 16-11
PCO Documents Exhibit KK-010 Binder # 2 PCO Documents Exhibit KK-010 Binder # 2 Exhibits SS-003 to SS-006 City of Vancouver and Vancouver Police Department Documents for APEC Hearing Volume IX City of Vancouver and Vancouver Police Department Documents for APEC Hearing Volume IX City of Vancouver and Vancouver Police Department Documents for APEC Hearing Volume IX City of Vancouver and Vancouver Police Department Documents for APEC Hearing Volume X City of Vancouver and Vancouver Police Department Documents for APEC Hearing Volume X City of Vancouver and Vancouver Police Department Documents for APEC Hearing Volume X City of Vancouver and Vancouver Police Department Documents for APEC Hearing Volume XI City of Vancouver and Vancouver Police Department Documents for APEC Hearing Volume XI
16-12 16-13 16-14 16-15 16-16
City of Vancouver and Vancouver Police Department Documents for APEC Hearing Volume XI City of Vancouver and Vancouver Police Department Documents for APEC Hearing Volume XII City of Vancouver and Vancouver Police Department Documents for APEC Hearing Volume XII City of Vancouver and Vancouver Police Department Documents for APEC Hearing Volume XII City of Vancouver and Vancouver Police Department Documents for APEC Hearing Volume XIII
BOX 17 17-1 17-2 17-3 17-4 17-5 17-6 17-7 17-8 17-9 17-10 17-11 17-12 17-13 17-14 17-15 17-16 17-17 17-18 17-19 17-20 17-21 17-22
City of Vancouver and Vancouver Police Department Documents for APEC Hearing Volume XIII City of Vancouver and Vancouver Police Department Documents for APEC Hearing Volume XIII City of Vancouver and Vancouver Police Department Documents for APEC Hearing Volume XIV City of Vancouver and Vancouver Police Department Documents for APEC Hearing Volume XV Photographs from various sources Documents Submitted by Jonathan Oppenheim Designation "CD" Documents Submitted by Jonathan Oppenheim Designation "CD" Documents Submitted by Jonathan Oppenheim Designation "CD" Civilian Witness Documents – Oppenheim – CD 02 to CD 03 Civilian Witness Documents – Oppenheim – CD 04 Civilian Witness Documents – Oppenheim – CD 04 Civilian Witness Documents – Oppenheim – CD 06 to CD 15 Civilian Witness Documents – Kevin Dwyer – "FG" Civilian Witness Documents – David Goodrich – "GH" DE – 01 A to E [Jaggi Singh Documents] DE – 01 A to E [Jaggi Singh Documents] DE – 02 C to I [Jaggi Singh Documents] DE – 02 C to I [Jaggi Singh Documents] DE – 02 C to I [Jaggi Singh Documents] DE – 03 J to K [Jaggi Singh Documents] Department of Justice Additional Documents Volume 2 September 29, 1999 Additional Documents for APEC Hearing Volume 2 – Will Says
BOX 18 18-1 18-2 18-3 18-4 18-5 18-6 18-7 18-8 18-9
Internal Witness Statements Tab 1 to Tab 48 Internal Witness Statements Tab 1 to Tab 48 Internal Witness Statements Tab 49 to Tab 90 Internal Witness Statements Tab 49 to Tab 90 Internal Witness Statements Tab 49 to Tab 90 EW – 1 Expert Witness Documents as placed in Reading Room March 10, 2000 [Additional Documents not otherwise numbered] Report of the Commission of Inquiry into the Events of March 18, 1996 at Queen's Park [additional documents for RCMP PCC APEC] [Miscellaneous indexes from documents for APEC RCMP PCC]
RCMP PCC Transcripts series 18-10 18-11 18-12 18-13 18-14 18-15 18-16 18-17
Transcripts RCMP PCC June 30, 29, 28, 27, 26, May 12, 2000 Transcripts RCMP PCC April 13 2000, March 31, 30, 29, 28, 27, 2000 Transcripts RCMP PCC March 23, 22, 21, 20, 17, 2000 Transcripts RCMP PCC March 16, 15, 14, 13, 10, 2000 Transcripts RCMP PCC March 2, 1, 2000, February 29, 25, 2000 Transcripts RCMP PCC February 24, 23, 22, 21, 2000 Transcripts RCMP PCC February 7, 4, 3, 2, 1, 2000 Transcripts RCMP PCC January 31, 21, 20, 19 2000
BOX 19 19-1 19-2 19-3 19-4 19-5 19-6 19-7
Transcripts RCMP PCC January 18, 17, 14, 13, 12, 11, 10, 2000 Transcripts RCMP PCC December 17, 16, 15, 14, 13, 1999 Transcripts RCMP PCC December 10, 9, 8, 7, 6, 1999 Transcripts RCMP PCC November 25, 18, 17, 16 1999 Transcripts RCMP PCC October 19, 18, 8, 7, 6, 1999 Transcripts RCMP PCC September 30, 27, 15, 9, 1999 Transcripts RCMP PCC September 7, 1999, August 27, 26, 25, 19, 1999
