Authenticity in a Reliable Protocol for Mobile Computing Nicoletta De Francesco
Marinella Petrocchi
Dipartimento di Ingegneria dell’Informazione Universita` di Pisa via Diotisalvi 2 - 56122 Pisa, Italy
Istituto di Informatica e Telematica Consiglio Nazionale delle Ricerche via Moruzzi 1 - 56124 Pisa, Italy
[email protected]
[email protected]
ABSTRACT
!#"$%&'!( )!*,+!( (% -& (. ( -/ ()+0* ) !(1 -2 -* ,34* ) (!(43 - '**,+ (% 536& 5 "78% - ++9) 2* :%"; 5'!('
2 ? @ !A
B'' 5CDE ( F%"#39 !A ' GG8 & (
8% ( H% 2 (,"D' *+I
'+ 5J2LK#MNO= % 2 *H'2NO' M' **+ (E ( P)BQ1%+3' (Q2W '>% 5J2W%" 8O 9%N X3V 5'!('
!( ( '?Y@ (%!'NO!*' (w'*+=6Dx **,+ (E/
(W%&D)!( >,3&'!2*' *'
%> ' AENO;8 (83D'!( A*HO' B 8E¿PNO' -/ >0xD8O 'À< %R-'= w'!% (NO'!52w% -2Á"7WNO= /
% (' X WB
'
( .": \ +DEV'
+' '?X@ZG*'83D% (
*|)D
'fBaO`8Î&*'
>' I%D 8%
* (
( A?^@ 4"#3&% ' !A ' G8 & (F 26%'' + 9
=/ '+ (Q2 (
+' ^V3U
''G%"DB
)!( N % (' P3D% P )B''
;?P¾Q,3 ( :DB=:UX%
+*G3DE !#%/ '! 531%+3' '% ( *'83D% (
* IV
+3%D%) (!( (Q2 "$%31!> 5 (*H%F3 - MT+3' (%4TD%= H % (> 5/ DE0)2}.!('> 5 (*H%F3 -?Á@& ( X'
=8% ( HX+ (NO
5Q2 'N 5 *uOV"7'
Z%D3 ( G%
-8% 'u3 !( -G=83D%>%/ (>. -+D' ,>8' 'u;?S )D%
M3'
( SS
*'' ' * (>4"7*Ñ B -/ !( :)2MÒx
'= Ô
' WzENON (Õ"3%/ '!e?,' ( ´
X3% ' !P (H
''+ 5J2W'N 5 / *' ?9¾JT'= º U,B
,HÖNO=
T%":3%/ '!eu;' (=3F (3
'+ 5J2W*=3 (
* 6+3' (%3 83D> F8O '?9' ( .·M> (NO &M
O83W"^+9 > (> '
E=3'>OE8 (>Z3U"7*H!NO= (C% (,"3U
'+V%/
!d?X¾Q.'= ¹M ' '?VÒU
(!(!52 u; Z×WØÙ" *Ú
(> !(X
'!(9'' N GÜ (43X"$!(! (>WÊ$"7*Ñ4
'Û F1
Vçz"G*+!5 (!(M)+=CD''' (NO 'um 53S!52.
D (> (BËG "$!!( 'K Ý Þ ÛéáDè â ç Kê×FØ'Ù 3Mç| ( YH
Y"U '
' '?,å9 (
×Õ -8 X"7pJ*+!5 5/ ' -s*%!( (Q2 ? V'
' 93V)O% -"U*'
>4Ê$"7*ëH
'DYÛ *,+!5 (!(F'' (NO HçZuG 53w!52}
' (>S ( DË
"7 !(!( 'K Ý Þ ÛíáDìâ ç Kê×FØ'Ù 3&ÛxB
()!52H) ' - .2* (%!!52ÁÁ 54 ( 4HCÂ N' ?^îI *Yï9 -8 G"$%4pQ)O% -s*%! 5Q2 ? ' '? v "7*H%!I!52
X"^3/ = ,"G3H !duP' ' 53S8!:8M'!( (NO 2 u +!( (%' U,!(
' U'ENO 2 uO3 ^)B''B "7*M (Fà ²Å ? @6D. (!
,'**,+ (% ( . ( +'!( 5/ %)!( ? ¶4ò 1' **+ '%F3+>3Á 5'!('
W!( 4%Dx*H'2 *ENO? ¶ ENO'*' GE&+ =8)!( u (139 % (q'= 2 %34''!(!&%4'N 'x'*H (w+1"V'ENO8%> "$4
*W (* ? @ 9*' -/
%> ' 6 53Á3F> %
3 8 (%?V@ % ' & %!(! ¶4ò M (}3' 5M'!!Z%D0
'Dq*'
%> ' MT.
B' 5CD ¶4ò (03' 5,''!(!d?}@ Z)BG"7*H!( (Ð'H% U (Ht# (>? r%D63Y ''+XF)BY=! (1 G"$!(! 'K r ? v *) (!(T3 - ¶4ò uG (
3 (>0}' **+ (E.wfBi=ô *'
>X,%3 'u
' 1ØEþ uD' 8 ( (>3V
'\+'+*)B "P3Y'+ ' fBi=ôP?ZÌ:%=3W> % % % +B ''' (N (>W%+ /{"/Q%8V*' -/
> ?:yXB H'' N (>M6fBa `8Î%u39>OEG'21
'D ¶4ò ' 2 "931*
(>T*+!5 ( - '?ÂÌ^83Â> %Z)B=J +DE8 'M3,"$+!(C!(!*%"G' 8% (
''+ 5J2./ = ' ? =X (NO'031
'
5 (NO4%+4"X ("$%*H% ( ÂB
()!52 =83D%>S (ÂF+q"9W !G 5M%BE ,%
D%)!(1
F3'
'T (w3.1"B %!Y NO % (' 'K +D%+3% (Ð'3 - U*H'2 2 "7 (33Z*H%!D/ '+ ( 6"#Y !L (1%8 TF>+D%8% 'H1
V%" B (' 'uX*>3 (=3;KS AË @8fbQieÏ Ç c7bdÉuZ\ + 5 (>S3%1 2 8OG'' (NO4) 26,!('> ( (*HEY3 -Z3 )B''1 (> (DEF) 2 !('> 5 (*H%:3 - B ( DË CYF_ EGHBn ce`abQi=u -8% (>3DE#Z!('> 5 *HE 3 -:'' ^+!( (EGD8O 'u d? ?^+!( '%' ^% (
%8;? @ 5 (*H%3 - 9H+3' (E 3Y'' (NOF) - X X ('1 (> (DEF"7*ý3
-8% (D% 2T3 -Y'
B
()!(M"$%V3M''!(!^ (T3 (83T32 3D%B'6M)B&!( E;? 9P\ + ( % H%"A3fDaO`8ÎM*'
>9 ( U+ (*B 8% > (NO'3%I38%3 2Fà ² ²Å u3X (> 58!
(>D%+X ( :3GJ2 (%!D*'83D (
*Ó>+D%8% 'X%+3' '%/ (S"G% (> (0T ( '> 5J2 ?M¾J. +V' um+"$% +%'!52 u 6 > 58!(!52
>T'830fBi=ô *
> *H'2F%+
("$'
()!( *+8% ( !A%N !(O F"7&*) (!(3 - 3 (83W3DNOY ( (/
(Z!( * 5V'
+'' '?:@ 5+D
*H%!(!=3Dq 50)D%D 3BË%D0*H'2q%M3DNO63H/
+' V"7VB "$%* (>F+)!( (MO=2 B8E V (T3 (V'*M/ !('
'? ò ''um+DE8 '' (>W3
3 (0"Z3H+)!( (HO2 ,E, -8%O ? µ **q
!(+ (
!(2 qîP+)!( O NY=2¾Q"78% - ++' 6Êe7î NY¾Q 8Ë&D (> 58!U' /
5CDE' 'uDÃ5r ²EÅ ?P¾J9 5'!('
P'N (*' uE3:*H> *' I" (> (8%!L' 5CDE' G'+!M'
+!5G (1V)B% !'8,"$%Y+ >U3D H Ç igJa Gb l i=fbdce`abdce_%f 3
& (!(!m)B&+
13 +>313&*H (1 5'!('
9!( B? S (3= (Y3,''"G]m_`abdce_fg$]Ic$h,c7bQij kml affLin o"7 * Ã · Å ? v ]m_`abdce_%fDg7]Pc$hc$bQi j kml affBinÊd3E"7ÍmÍ µ ËV ,
'DE/ 8%'"7*Ô3M (3.%=3 3+ (>VV 8%
* (
( 6ENOU3&ÍAÍ µ ? ò 'X+D (,%D ("8%x83D%! 6'+!x)B> wÍmÍ µ 4> N 'Á3W3 2
(%! !( (* ('68> "m3' 5 8
*
( 'u#Ã5r ´ umr· Å ? SU+
ÍmÍ µ ^X=3>< ("7*H% (H)B +I3G+)!( ( "I,+)!( (&O2 u d? ?P3Y%
' % ( )BQ (8%!B' 5CD'% ( '*' " (> (8%!B' 5CD'%' U+) 27î NY¾P'+!M'
+!5U 6Y)B !(''8 (63Z3 !(& -2 -'*ñ+U NO - > % ( ;?:@ +%8%x 2>8%3 (q*'83D% (
* F (Ô%8W > +%8%M
''+ (Q2B (' '?M¾Q3,"$!(! (>FU,
+B
3H'
'6%"++3 (Ð'S*) (!(3 - 'u: d? ?3 - 3D%
E%Y!('> 5 (*H% ?@mF - (> + (
3T)BJU''S%+3 (Ð'TD +D%+3% (Ð'q3 - 'u^U1G 51Í ¶4ò .'1!('> 5 *HE 3 -?Ì^830Í ¶4ò !(
.F* ) (!H3 - ¶4ò )+V3 B/
59 U: + KI>'= ¶4ò UU''
% (!521!('> 5 *HE 3 -?
+*3%H3W*+!5 ( -6ENO183D'! Ý (|t# (>?¯r 'FZ)BY' * * (
L?ISX + -Z3Y>' 9439 (' !( (B?Ut+ 3*uUMZ'
9%W NO % 24)!( 8%*B 5343Y'**,+ (% (4 13& 5F!( (B?U¾{"#3= ( X (R- ( ":E8' * (>M" *ý++3 (Ð'F3 - 'uDU %
+*Y 5, '+Z 43X 5'!('
X!( (B? M+
,ÍmÍ µ 53.3"7 !(!( >.
+* ( 'KX ËX"G%!(!^3 *) (!(F3 - 'u_fn É34!> 5 (*H%W3 - } 8
* (M%N 3ZÍmÍ µ B ( Ë#3Z -8% ( % 23 - U'M 8
* 5UENO^3ZÍAÍ µ %D03!}D 5%"X+)! ( » (N%4 2 .B "$%* '> +!%
(>D%+
=3'*' (SÃ ² r Å ? @ +
3HD% 'Km3GC -UD% U' ' 5 *HE3 -Z,3' %8 (DEuD3 (!3Y
' F Z'/ q 53}34%+3' '% ( }"936>O%=G'2 .3 !('> 5 *HEY3 - Z+ ' !526'
' (4'!(!A d?:Ì^N '63 +> 31U !(
93'' (
' 5J2M%"B3
':"A&=x*'
%> uOU EM ( ' - !(2. (Ï' (M%+3 (' 5Q20Êd83T!('> 5 *HE 3 -Y'W''> (Ð'33YH*'
> ( 5/ *HEY3 -=ËG8E33D%o= +%+3' (Q2 Ê$3Y) (!( 5J2 , ' 5"7263&
(>!(V% Q26 53 F,
=Ë=? 4.1 9\ Authenticating + (&* ) (!93 -Gthe %mobile N X 5 G!('> sender 5 (*H26 (4%8G
D0W*'
> ?¾QS3H=/J%+3' '% ( 03
363 - 3 GM)BY32
(%!!526!( %'F'!(
Y,3X' 8 %%? UVU û U ø|ú áDß â û K Xú W Ø Y ZM[ ü Ý þ \;]_^ UVU û û áDßâ U ø|ú Ka`!bdc @%2DË=?^t# 5 -u 39*) (!( 3 -Y 8%
* 5 X3, (> -"GH8 *!52W>'=8%.+*,)B ü þ \;]_^ W36' 8 %%ENO,36ÍmÍ µ ?^@ 5 +)!( (XO*2 `(bdc