Other publication series from the World Agroforestry Centre ..... reported here because much of the crop is sold in local markets rather than exported. ... 2006), while approximately 30% of land planted to oil palm in Malaysia is reported to be under the ... production between 1998 and 2003 was on holdings of less than 40 ha ...
Climate change vulnerability of agroforestry Henry Neufeldt, Ian K. Dawson, Eike Luedeling, Oluyede C. Ajayi, Tracy Beedy, Aster Gebrekirstos, Ramni H. Jamnadass, Konstantin König, Gudeta W. Sileshi, Elisabeth Simelton, Carmen Sotelo Montes, John C. Weber
! !
"#$%&'(!)*&+,(!-.#+(/&0$#$'1!23!&,/232/(4'/1! ! !
!"#$%&'"()"*+,-&./#&01&2/345#-&678"&9("+"*7#:-&;*(%"+"&/%7-&?$/@%&A""+%-&=4,"$& B"C$"87$4,54-&D/E#7&!1&F/E#/+/44-&05#4,/#,7#&0G#7:-&B(+",/&H1&I7*"4J7-&6*74/C",J&I7E"*,5#-& (ET4&7#& @5EE5+7,%&T$7@"4&"Q7+"#,&7#&$"@"#,&%"/$41&
&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&& 3
S/*E4&m&4(@J&/4&57*&T/*E&/#+&,J"&5,J"$&T/*E4&$")"$$"+&,5&7#&,J74&T/T"$&m&/$"&C%&+")7#7,75#,&n,$("h&,$""4-&C(,&/4&T"$"##7/*&4T"@7"4&+"$7Q"+& )$5E&)5$"4,4&/$"&@*/44"+&/4&,$""4&)5$&,J"&T($T54"4&5)&,J"&@($$"#,&+74@(4475#1&
&
V&
& B&'&!E(/(!(D'/&)'(A!3/2%!'*(!5/&A(=565!A&'&0&4(!23!;6:=565!F3&24'&'G3&2G2/,HIG!B&'&!32/!%&+,2(4J!%&+,24'((+4!&+A!,.&-&!&/(!/(@2/'(A! '2,('*(/G!K&#.(4!$+)#.A(!/(L(D@2/'4!F$G(GJ!$%@2/'!$+'2!2+(!+&'$2+!32##2E(A!01!(D@2/'!'2!&+2'*(/IG!=2%(!)2%%2A$'$(4J!4.)*!&4!)233((J!)2)2&! &+A!)2)2+.'J!&/(!(D@2/'(A!$+!%2/(!'*&+!2+(!32/%M!32/!(&)*!)/2@J!2+#1!'*(!%24'!$%@2/'&+'!32/%!01!(D@2/'!-&#.(!$4!,$-(+!*(/(G!
;$,./(!>M&B*5C/*&"XT5$,&Q/*("4&5)&/&$/#:"&5)&,$""&@5EE5+7,%&@$5T4&)5$&,J"&%"/$4&PllO&,5&NOOl&]@5EC7#"+&)7:($"4& )5$&/**&#/,75#4&T$5Q7+7#:&+/,/^1&&
& .#&.#+5#"47/-&/$5(#+&UOo&5)&T/*E&57*&T$5+(@,75#&J/4&C""#&$"T5$,"+&,5&@5E"&)$5E&4E/**J5*+"$4&].S;]P!"\!$+!%&/$'$%(!)#$%&'(4!23! "@,"+&,J"&*78"*%&7ET/@,&5)&@*7E/,"&@J/#:"&5#&,J"&"@,"+&,J/,&T"4,&T$"44($"&37**&7#@$"/4"&4(C4,/#,7/**%&7#&6,J75T7/-&L:/#+/-& 0"#%/-&A($(#+7&/#+&D3/#+/1&.#&45E"&:$537#:&$":75#4-&,J"&#(EC"$&5)&T5447C*"&:"#"$/,75#4&5)&,J"&"@,"+&,5&+5(C*"1&?J74&4,(+%&E7$$5$4&$"4(*,4&C%&9("+"*7#:&!"#$%1&]NOPPC^-&3J5& T$5>"@,"+&4,$5#:&7#@$"/4"4&7#&,J"&#(EC"$&5)&:"#"$/,75#4&,J/,&@5(*+&T5,"#,7/**%&C"&@5ET*","+&C%&T"4,4&5)& 3/*#(,&7#&"@,75#4&5)&@*7E/,"&@J/#:"&"))"@,4&5#&@5ET5#"#,4&5)&/:$5)5$"4,$%&4%4,"E4-& 3"&/$",&/3/$"&5)&T$5@"44dC/4"+&/,,"ET,4&,5&E5+"*&,$""dC/4"+&@$5TT7#:&4%4,"E41&r",&45E"&7ET/@,& T$5>"@,75#&4,(+7"4&J/Q"&(4"+&4T"@7"4&+74,$7C(,75#&E5+"**7#:&]/*45&8#53#&/4&"@5*5:7@/*@J"&E5+"**7#:^& ,5&"4,7E/,"&)(,($"&4(7,/C*"&$/#:"4&)5$&4%4,"E41&R5$&T/$8*/#+&/:$5)5$"4,$%&4%4,"E4&7#&,J"&H"4,&=)$7@/#& I/J"*-&9("+"*7#:&/#+&'"()"*+,&]$"Q74"+&Q"$475#&(#+"$&$"Q7"3^&(4"+&,J"&K/X7E(E&6#,$5T%&/TT$5/@J&,5& T$5>"@,&)(,($"&4(7,/C*"&$/#:"4&/#+&T5,"#,7/*&@/$C5#&4,5@84-&C/4"+&5#&POP&*5@/,75#4&5C,/7#"+&)$5E& T(C*74J"+&4,(+7"41&?J"4"&*5@/,75#4&3"$"&(4"+&,5&@J/$/@,"$7e"&,J"&"@5*5:7@/*@J"&5)&T/$8*/#+&4%4,"E4& C/4"+&5#&@*7E/,7@&T/$/E","$41&?J"&4T/,7/*&"X,"#,&5)&,J74@J"&3/4&,J"#&T$5>"@,"+&)5$&P_&)(,($"&@*7E/,"& 4@"#/$7541&;Q"$*/%7#:&T$5>"@,75#4&37,J&/&+/,/4",&5#&*/#+&(4"&7#&,J"&$":75#&T$5+(@"+&"4,7E/,"4&5)&,J"& /:$7@(*,($/*&/$"/&,J/,&74&4(7,/C*"&)5$&T/$8*/#+&/:$5)5$"4,$%1&.#&/**&@*7E/,"&4@"#/$754-&4(7,/C7*7,%&)5$& T/$8*/#+4&+"@*7#"+&]R7:1&V^1&L47#:&/&K/X6#,&4(7,/C7*7,%&4@5$"&5)&O1N&/4&/&@(,d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b(7,"& @5#@"7Q/C*"&,J/,&T/$8*/#+4&@5(*+&"X74,&7#&E/#%&*5@/,75#4&3J"$"&,J"%&/$"&@($$"#,*%,&T$"4"#,1&r",&7,& 4""E4&*78"*%&,J/,&)/$E"$4&37**&E/7#,/7#&T/$8*/#+&/:$5)5$"4,4&7#&/$"/4&7+"#,7)7"+&/4&@*7E/,7@/**%&4(7,/C*"&7#& ,J74&4,(+%&$/,J"$&,J/#&7#&/$"/4&,J/,&3"$"&@*/447)7"+&(#4(7,/C*"1&HJ7*"&,J"&/@,(/*&#(EC"$4&:7Q"#&7#&,J"& 4,(+%&/$"&,J(4&$"*/,7Q"*%&@$(+"&/#+&7ET$"@74"&"4,7E/,"4-&7,&74&#"Q"$,J"*"44&"XT"@,"+&,J/,&@*7E/,7@& 4(7,/C7*7,%&)5$&T/$8*/#+4&37**&+"@*7#"&5Q"$&,J"&NP4,&@"#,($%1& &
&
PO&
& N$,*!U&D9+'!4)2/(4!4$,+$31!*$,*!4.$'&0$#$'1G!=)2/(4!23!PGC!2/!&02-(!E(/(!$+'(/@/('(A!'2!$%@#1!4.$'&0$#$'1J!/(+A(/$+,![[Y!23!=&*(#$&+!)/2@#&+A4! 4.$'&0#(!32/!@&/S#&+A4!$+!'*(!0&4(#$+(!4)(+&/$2G!;2/!&##!3.'./(!4)(+&/$24J!4.$'&0#(!&/(&4!A()#$+(A!'2!0('E((+!V!&+A![^Y!23!'2'&#!)/2@#&+A!&/(&G!
;$,./(!_?!I(7,/C7*7,%&5)&I/J"*7/#&@$5T*/#+&)5$&T/$8*/#+&/:$5)5$"4,$%-&+"$7Q"+&C%&"@5*5:7@/*@J"&E5+"**7#:&37,J&,J"& K/X7E(E&6#,$5T%&]K/X6#,^&E",J5+!!
& ?J"4"&$"4(*,4&@5#,$/4,&37,J&E5+"**7#:&5)&)(,($"&4T/,7/*&+74,$7C(,75#&5)&:$/44*/#+-&4/Q/##/&/#+&+"@7+(5(4& /#+&"Q"$:$""#&)5$"4,&7#&H"4,&=)$7@/&37,J&B"#"$/*7e"+&=++7,7Q"&K5+"*4&]B=K4^&(47#:&@*7E/,"&+/,/&)$5E& PZ&B"#"$/*&"@,"+&4J7),4&7#&Q":",/,75#&e5#"41&?J"&f":",/,75#&/#+&IG!;.##!#(,(+A4!A(4)/$0$+,!&##! -(,('&'$2+!'1@(4!)&+!0(!32.+A!$+!8$##(4a!!"#$%G!FCP>>IG!
;$,./(!^?!I7#@"&"/@J&Q":",/,75#&,%T"&]4J53#&7#&+7))"$"#,&@5*5($4^&74&/@@5ET/#7"+&C%&/#&"X,"#47Q"&*74,&5)&x(4")(*& ,$""&4T"@7"4y-&,J"&f6/-(-:'(#$./'1$+$&/#+&=$%$+'"!(#$!)8:"'$1$&3"$"&"4,/C*74J"+& /,&5#"&$"*/,7Q"*%&+$%&47,"&7#&'7:"$M&4""+4&)5$&,J"&,$7/*4&3"$"&@5**"@,"+&7#&'7:"$&]C5,J&4T"@7"4^&/#+&7#& A($87#/&R/45&]S1&$./'1$+$&5#*%^1&D"4(*,4&7#+7@/,"&,J/,&T$5Q"#/#@"4&5)&C5,J&4T"@7"4&5$7:7#/,7#:&)$5E&+$7"$& *5@/,75#4&J/+&47:#7)7@/#,*%&C",,"$&/C5Q"d:$5(#+&:$53,J&@5ET/$"+&,5&T$5Q"#/#@"4&5$7:7#/,7#:&)$5E& E5$"&J(E7+&*5@/,75#4&]H"C"$&!"#$%;&NOO_j&H"C"$&/#+&I5,"*5&K5#,"4&NOPO^1&.#&/++7,75#-&4($Q7Q/*&/#+& 355+&+"#47,%&5)&S1&$./'1$+$&3/4&47:#7)7@/#,*%&:$"/,"$&)5$&T$5Q"#/#@"4&5$7:7#/,7#:&)$5E&,J"&+$7"$& *5@/,75#4&]H"C"$&!"#$%1&NOO_j&I5,"*5&K5#,"4&/#+&H"C"$&NOOl^1&.#&@5#,$/4,-&@/*5$7)7@&Q/*("&5)&,J"&355+-& 3J7@J&"XT$"44"4&,J"&"#"$:%&@5#,"#,&)5$&(4"&/4&)("*-&3/4&:$"/,"$&)5$&T$5Q"#/#@"4&5)&C5,J&4T"@7"4& 5$7:7#/,7#:&7#&E5$"&J(E7+&*5@/,75#4&]I5,"*5&K5#,"4&!"#$%;&NOPP^1&A/4"+&5#&,J"4"&$"4(*,4&/#+&@5#47+"$7#:& T$5>"@,"+&@*7E/,"&@J/#:"-&$"4"/$@J"$4&$"@5EE"#+"+&,J/,&7,&35(*+&C"&T$(+"#,&,5&]/^&@5**"@,&4""+&5)& ,J"4"&4T"@7"4&]/#+&5,J"$&4T"@7"4^&7#&+$7"$&*5@/,75#4&)5$&)(,($"&T*/#,7#:&7#&,J"&$":75#-&/#+&]C^&E(*,7d *5@/,75#&T$5Q"#/#@"WT$5:"#%&,$7/*4&5)&5,J"$&4T"@7"4&4J5(*+&C"&"4,/C*74J"+&/#+&(4"+&)5$&/+/T,/,75#& T*/##7#:&7#&,J"&$":75#1&?J"4"&$"@5EE"#+/,75#4&3"$"&/+5T,"+&C%&/#&.R=2d)(#+"+&+"Q"*5TE"#,&T$5>"@,& ,J/,&35$84&37,J&$($/*&@5EE(#7,7"4&7#&A($87#/&R/45-&K/*7&/#+&'7:"$1& &
#&1"&+1&-&/"1%,5!-+*()"!"$3%&'%(2*&'&*+#$*3%$&%1!"/($+%1.(-2+% =:$5)5$"4,$%&4%4,"E4&E/%&$/#:"&)$5E&Q"$%&5T"#&T/$8*/#+&,%T"&/44"EC*/:"4&5)&,$""4&37,J&*7Q"4,5@8&5$& +$%*/#+&/:$7@(*,($"&,5&+"#4"&7E7,/,75#4&5)&,$5T7@/*&$/7#)5$"4,4&4(@J&/4&,$""&:/$+"#41&2","$E7#7#:& 45@75"@5#5E7@&Q(*#"$/C7*7,%&5)&/:$5)5$"4,$%&4%4,"E4&74&,J"$")5$"&@5ET5(#+"+&C%&,J"&+7Q"$47,%&5)&,J"& 4%4,"E&/4&3"**&/4&+7))7@(*,%&7#&+74,7#:(74J7#:&C",3""#&@*7E/,7@&"))"@,4&/#+&5,J"$&+"Q"*5TE"#,&$"*/,"+& )/@,5$4&,J/,&E/%&/))"@,&$"45($@"dT55$&)/$E"$41&.#&/++7,75#-&,J"$"&74&/&4,$5#:&,"ET5$/*&Q/$7/,75#&5)& 45@75"@5#5E7@&Q(*#"$/C7*7,%&C"@/(4"&%5(#:&/:$5)5$"4,$%&4%4,"E4&,"#+&,5&T$5+(@"&*7,,*"&/#+&E/%&J/Q"& J7:J"$&@54,4&,J/#&$",($#4&3J7*"&E/,($"&/:$5)5$"4,$%&4%4,"E4&37**&:"#"$/**%&T$5+(@"&T547,7Q"& "X,"$#/*7,7"4&7#&,"$E4&5)&7#@5E"-&)55+&4"@($7,%&/#+&"@54%4,"E&4"$Q7@"41& ?J74&@5ET*"X7,%&74&$"4T5#47C*"&)5$&,J"&4E/**&#(EC"$&5)&$"*"Q/#,&4,(+7"4&,J/,&@/#&@*"/$*%&4J53&J53& /:$5)5$"4,$%&4%4,"E4&@5#,$7C(,"&,5&E/#/:7#:&@*7E/,"&$7481&?$""4&5#&)/$E4&E/%&E7,7:/,"&+7$"@,&@*7E/,"& 7ET/@,4&4(@J&/4&T$5Q7+7#:&"$5475#&@5#,$5*&]K/&!"#$%1&NOOlj&K(,":7&!"#$%1&NOO_^&5$&$"+(@7#:&,J"&*544&5)& :$/7#&T$5+(@,75#&7#&+$5(:J,&%"/$4&]I7*"4J7&!"#$%1&NOPP^1&A(,&E54,&5)&,J"&"))"@,4&/$"&7#+7$"@,&7#&,J"&4"#4"& ,J/,&/:$5)5$"4,$%&,"#+4&,5&7ET$5Q"&*7Q"*7J55+4&/#+&3"**C"7#:&/#+&,J"$"C%&$"+(@"4&Q(*#"$/C7*7,%&,5& @*7E/,"&7ET/@,4&/4&E(@J&/4&+"Q"*5TE"#,&$"*/,"+&)/@,5$4&]'"(T/#"&/#+&?J/T/-&NOOPj&K7,JG)"$&/#+& H/7C"*-&NOOVj&B/$$7,%&!"#$%1&NOPO^1&R5$&"X/ET*"-&4E/**J5*+"$&)/$E"$4&7#&3"4,"$#&0"#%/&T*/#,&,$""4& E/7#*%&/4&/&*7Q7#:&n4/Q7#:4&/@@5(#,h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
PY&
B$/()'!(33()'4! I57*&"$5475#&74&/&4"$75(4&T$5C*"E&7#&@(*,7Q/,"+&/$"/4&5)&,J"&@"#,$/*&J7:J*/#+4&5)&0"#%/&/4&,J"$"&74&4,$5#:& #":/,7Q"&@5$$"*/,"+&,5&E/7e"&T$5+(@,75#&T/$/E","$41&K(,":7&!"#$%1&]NOO_^&"4,7E/,"+&J53&@$5T&%7"*+4& E7:J,&C"&/))"@,"+&C%&7#,$5+(@7#:&+7))"$"#,&"$5475#&@5#,$5*&E"/4($"4&7#,5&,J"&@5#Q"#,75#/*&E/7e"& E5#5@$5TT7#:&4%4,"E1&?J"7$&$"4(*,4&4J53"+&,J/,&#/T7"$&:$/44&]>!++'(!"*6#:*/:*/!*6^&/*5#"&J/+&,J"& J7:J"4,&"$5475#&E7,7:/,7#:&"))"@,4&C(,&,J/,&,J74&3/4&/@@5ET/#7"+&C%&/&*544&7#&E/7e"&T$5+(@,75#1& !53"Q"$-&/&@5EC7#/,75#&5)&#/T7"$&:$/44&37,J&*":(E7#5(4&4J$(C4&]?!*1!+$#"/'15$+7/$&5$&,$%%'$+7/$# 1$%-"58/(*(^&*"+&,5&/&$"+(@,75#&5)&"$5475#&/#+&/#&"#J/#@"E"#,&5)&E/7e"&T$5+(@,75#&/#+&457*&)"$,7*7,%-& T/$,7@(*/$*%&7#&,J"&4"@5#+&%"/$&5)&"4,/C*74JE"#,&5)&,J"&J"+:"4&]?/C*"&V^1&.+"#,7)%7#:&,J"&E(*,7T*"& 7#,"$/@,7#:&"))"@,4&74&,J"$")5$"&#"@"44/$%&,5&"Q/*(/,"&,J"&Q(*#"$/C7*7,%&,5&/:$5)5$"4,$%&4%4,"E4&,5& @*7E/,"&7ET/@,41&;#&,J"&*/#+4@/T"&4@/*"&K/&!"#$%1&]NOOl^&4J53"+&,J/,&*/#+d(4"&@J/#:"&,53/$+4&:$"/,"$& ,$""&+"#47,%&$"+(@"+&4($)/@"&)*534&+($7#:&,J"&E5#455#&7#&45(,Jd3"4,&XWVJ!%&$c(!$+'(/)/2@@(A!E$'*!#(.)(+&!*&A!1$(#A4!&'!#(&4'!VPY!,/(&'(/!'*&+!3(/'$#$c(A!%&$c(!A./$+,!'*(!,/(&'(4'!%2$4'./(! A(3$)$'G!
;$,./(![?!DL6&/#+&%7"*+&4,/C7*7,%&7#&.C/+/#-&'7:"$7/!! &
PZ&
&
Z+A$/()'!(33()'4! HJ7*"&,J"&/C5Q"&E"#,75#"+&E"@J/#74E4&E7,7:/,"&@*7E/,"&7ET/@,4&7#&/:$5)5$"4,$%&4%4,"E4&+7$"@,*%-& E54,&"))"@,4&5)&/:$5)5$"4,$%&/$"&"XT"@,"+&,5&C"&7#+7$"@,&7#&,J"&4"#4"&,J/,&/:$5)5$"4,$%&7#@$"/4"4& )/$E"$4h&)55+&4"@($7,%-&*7Q"*7J55+4&/#+&7#@5E"&/#+&,J"$"C%&$"+(@"4&@*7E/,"&Q(*#"$/C7*7,%&/#+&$/74"4&,J"& /+/T,7Q"&@/T/@7,7"41&?J"$"&/$"&)"3&b(/#,7,/,7Q"&$"4(*,4&45&)/$&/#+&)"3&T$5Q7+"&4T"@7)7@&"Q7+"#@"&5#& $"+(@"+&@*7E/,"&Q(*#"$/C7*7,%&C"%5#+&/&:"#"$/*&7#@$"/4"&7#&7ET$5Q"+&*7Q"*7J55+4&/#+&7#@5E"1& '5#",J"*"44-&)5$&$"45($@"dT55$&)/$E"$4-&C"7#:&/C*"&,5&E/#/:"&,J"7$&+/7*%&@J/**"#:"4&C",,"$&37,J& /:$5)5$"4,$%&74&/&@*"/$&7#+7@/,5$&5)&$"+(@"+&@*7E/,"&$7481& =&4,(+%&C%&=>/%7&!"#$%;&]NOOY^&"Q/*(/,"+&,J"&)7#/#@7/*&7ET/@,&5)&/:$5)5$"4,$%&)/**534&7#&)/$E"$4h&)7"*+4& #"/$&P!
&
&
Pl&
?J5$*/845#&/#+&'"()"*+,&]4(CE7,,"+^&/*45&4J53"+&,J/,&"#4($7#:&)55+&4"@($7,%Y&/TT"/$"+&,5&C"& #"@"44/$%&C")5$"&)/$E"$4&3"$"&37**7#:&5$&/C*"&,5&7#Q"4,&7#&*5#:"$d,"$E&T$5@"44"4&)5$&7ET$5Q7#:&5,J"$& @5ET5#"#,4&5)&,J"7$&3"**C"7#:1&?J74&3/4&"Q7+"#,&3J"#&@5ET/$7#:&,J"&E5$"&)55+&4"@($"&K7++*"&'%/#+5& 37,J&,J"&*"44&)55+&4"@($"&953"$&'%/#+5&/$"/41&953"$&'%/#+5&)/$E"$4&$/$"*%&)5@(4"+&5#&:5/*4,& +7$"@,*%&$"*/,"+&,5&7ET$5Q7#:&J5(4"J5*+&)55+&4(TT*%&3J"$"/4&K7++*"&'%/#+5&)/$E"$4&)$"b("#,*%& +74@(44"+&:5/*4&$"*/,"+&,5&"XT/#+7#:&*/#+&J5*+7#:4-&7ET$5Q7#:&@J7*+$"#h4&"+(@/,75#&/#+&7#Q"4,7#:&7#& *5#:d,"$E&T$5>"@,4&,5&"#4($"&)7#/#@7/*&4"@($7,%1&& ?J"4"&$"4(*,4&/$"&@5ET*"E"#,"+&C%&0$74,>/#45#&!"#$%;&]/@@"T,"+^&3J5&4J53"+&,J/,&T$5X7"4&)5$&)55+& 4"@($7,%&3"$"&4,$5#:*%&@5$$"*/,"+&37,J&)/$E"$4h&n7##5Q/,7Q"#"44h1&?J"&C/4"*7#"&4($Q"%&3/4&@/$$7"+&5(,&7#& )7Q"&POXPO8EN&47,"4&7#&6,J75T7/-&0"#%/-&L:/#+/&]N^&/#+&?/#e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d,"$E&)55+&4"@($7,%&7#$,J"$#&/#+&@"#,$/*&f7",&'/E1&'"X,&,5&J/$Q"4,&*544&,J/,&J7,&,J"&)/$E"$4& 7EE"+7/,"*%-&7#+7$"@,&"))"@,4&4(@J&/4&+/E/:"4&5#&7$$7:/,75#&7#)$/4,$(@,($"&5$&*544&5)&4""+4&)5$&T*/#,7#:& @/#&C"&Q"$%&47:#7)7@/#,1&.#&/++7,75#&,J"$"&/$"&7ET/@,4&5)&/&@J/#:7#:&@*7E/,"&5#&,J"&)/$E7#:&4%4,"E&,J/,& E/%&$"b(7$"&/+>(4,7#:&,J"&)/$E7#:&@/*"#+/$&/#+&@5(*+&/))"@,&4(C4"b("#,&@$5T41&.#&$"4T5#4"&,5&@*7E/,"& 4J5@84&T55$"$&)/$E"$4&7#&@"#,$/*&f7",&'/E&"XT*57,&)5$"4,4&)5$&7#@5E"&3J"$"/4&C",,"$d5))&)/$E"$4&7#Q"4,& 7#&4,$/,":7"4&,J/,&E/#/:"&$748-&"1:1&)"$,7*7e"$&/#+&457*&E/#/:"E"#,-&/#7E/*&J(4C/#+$%&/#+&7#Q"4,E"#,&7#& E(*,7T($T54"&,$""4&5#&)/$E41& .#&5$+"$&,5&5Q"$@5E"&45E"&5)&,J"7$&Q(*#"$/C7*7,7"4-&T55$&)/$E"$4&5),"#&$"*%&5#&45@7/*&4/)":(/$+&4%4,"E4& ]/4&5TT54"+&,5&)7#/#@7/*&4/)":(/$+4^1&8&K-&K7,*GJ#"$&D1&]NOPPC^&L#+"$4,/#+7#:&T/4,-&T$"4"#,-&/#+& )(,($"&@*7E/,"&@J/#:"4&)$5E&6/4,&,5&H"4,&=)$7@/1&]0"%#5,"&T/T"$^&=:$7@(*,($/*&.##5Q/,75#4&)5$& I(4,/7#/C*"&2"Q"*5TE"#,&V]N^M&ZZd_[1& B"C$"87$4,54&=-&K7,*GJ#"$&D-&?"8",/%&2-&H5$C"4&K1&]NOO_^&"@,&& PVP1 "@,& PVN1 "@,&7#&I7"$$/&K/+$"&A75+7Q"$47,%&
