III. The Hong Kong Ministerial Conference (December 13-18, 2005) . ... A. A Mission Impossible? .... (1994). 2 See WTO, M embers and Observers, available at.
XX Berkeley Journal of International Law, Vol. 25 No. 2 (Forthcoming 2006)
♠
! "#
$
! # & '
% ) ) , -
( !
'
!
!* +
* $
. (
* ! 3* ! "# * . # 3 ( * 4 ! 3 ! 5 !! ! 4#" 6 7 & " 3 8 5 * #" /! 6 * ! !
! #
7 ! 0< #
&
!
#/ !
' )0 1--2$
!
! # 3 : ;! / ! ! "# 5 ! & "! ##
% 9 9 , 11 1 1% 1= 1,
! #
!
♠
+< ##
& !
0
! !
< :0 " 0
'( #! ! #/ "
!! 0*+
< :0 !! 0 > !!
Electronic copy available at: http://ssrn.com/abstract=910515
! !!
#
XX Berkeley Journal of International Law, Vol. 25 No. 2 (Forthcoming 2006)
> ! ! " # #/ "/ " /! ! " " > " ! "# " : ! 5 > ! ! # !! : ! ! /
? ! :
8 01 /
! "
!
" #"! 0 # !
! / !# + : "
:
0
"" !!
.
/!
8 @
! /!
" ! "
? .$ "
! 0 : 0
8!0 # 0: 0 0 0 !! " ! A% % # # #" /! ! !! "
! " A ! ! ! 0 " / / !! #" 0 : ! ! A # !! ! / : ! " " ! !
2
:
0
? .A " ,,, ? . * ! + # !
A ? . * #/
*
+
4#/
# !
# ,,%$
F0 " ! / !/ ! # R + PS /! #
& , 0. &&, 10 : K J# K J# - K J# - K # ! # * #! * & ! * &! # & 09L A< 4 . < 1 , 1--%$ E 0. &! # . ! ! " $0 1 0 ! L 90 1--20 J : K JK JK #T ! < +0 .
!
!
! J
4;4*. H < D .
' #
"
!
#
!!
# 0 0 #" " # > 6 # ? ! ? . ! / " ! " ! "! ! " R " " ! #" " !
! # " ! #
#
!!
? . ! !" 8 0
! ! /!
" ! "#
* !
0:
+ 0)
" #/
)
190 1--=$ &
!
4
# + /
#
D
A
XX Berkeley Journal of International Law, Vol. 25 No. 2 (Forthcoming 2006)
B : '! ! : ! 0
# C
! #
&
" : !
" ' ( ( * /
#
" /! !!
! "
! ! #
! "#
!# # " /! " "' : #
!
" " !
!
' ? !
D
> ! : # " !/ !8 "
#
! 0 ! ! ! "#
: 0 ! " A #"! # B / ! "# ! !! ! ! ! #
0 / #!
0
: &
0
0 ! ##
!!
7" "
/# # " " /! " !
!
#/ #" # "! ! / " ! ! / 0 / #' " " !
1 D $ ! ? .$ L ,,20 D " # " ! #" ? . # 0 # % " " ! ! : ! " A #
. A!
! !
" /!
0 !! : / + ! 8 ! & 7
! "!
# !
! &- ! 0-
!
& #>
0
.(#!
/
!
! "# & " ? . : !! ! ! # ! ! !
!
"
"
:
8 '
/ ! C "
## # D /
2
#
#
/ /
/ : U -- / !!
! + " 0 :
#
=
/ & #0 , , + , #! ) , &#" /) A< . ; %19 ,))$ % ? .0 . , " 0 "3JJ::: : J ! J "K J K J ! L 0 1--=$ 2 & ? .0 # " ,! 6 0 (78 $5551 .& , ! # ! 0 "3JJ::: : J ! J : K J"##K J"##-9K # ! L 0 1--2$ B # " " + : : 0/ " /! C$ = ;" / I "" C$0 !/ !8 # + ! $ 1B " C " # 0 * !
0
0 # + /
!
!/ I
!8
! 0: '
! 0 B# 0
!"
! # 0 ! $: ,,= :
# #" :
#
!" : " # !" C$0
!# ! " "
0 # :
A: #
0 0 !!
" + ! 0 ? .
(#! " " # ! !" # 9
0 "
! 0
:
! "
0
!
B
0: ! !"
!! 8 !
# #
! ? .# !# ! ! : 0 / " # " : ! + " ! ! : !! ## ! " W ! " : 0 # ! ## # # " 0 ! ! ! " @ > ! ! C ; " + : B ? +& #C$ ? . * #/ : ! 0: " L ! 1--20 "" > # C$0 : : ! / ! 0 ! 0 ! ( * !
1
0
#
1
::: 0 1--
!+ 0
! BL ! 5 # : +C # ! 19 L ! 5 # : +0 1--% D B "" C # / / : ! ! 1) : 0 ! / ! " + BL ! " !# ! ! 0 : ! !" ! ! 1, #/ #/
,0 4 4 . .* 0 %0 -0 1--1 * 0 K0 1 ' , A B, 0 # # C- & . ,
?
4 4 . .* 11
# @
0
=90 0. # ! ( 80 /7$ , # / I+
10 1--1I#! @
" +
0 1-- 0 !
, +
" 0 D ? 40
1%
? .0 ## % " #/ 0 1-- 0 20 4 : "3JJ::: : J ! J : K J# K J# - K J# - K % " K # 1--2$I ! D" 5 ? .* ! 0 =0 ? !! ? 0 " 20 1-- 0 "3JJ::: J# !J J: K ! J/ - -, 2 # ! 12 ! D" 5 ? .* ! 0 !! . 0 " %0 1-- 0 "3JJ::: J# !J J: K ! J/ - -, % # !
#
0 L
!
"
0
!! " 3 ? L 20
0 1--=$ 4!
L
0 1--=$
0
1= 19 1) 1,
120 1--20 1--=$
? .0 0
? +&
#0
/
;
!
!
0 1--%0 ? J 0 #! # "3JJ::: !
J
& # - ! J1--2J-)J -2-)12
5
0 #! !
C / $0 2-X :! /! " ! / 0 " # # B/! / >C / $0 : ! !# /! / > / 0 >" / 0 1- #"! " ! D
? " B : :
! .
" "
! : ! # 0 #! , " " !# / #"! 1--=0 !! . '; !& !< # ! " " ! "# C1H 0 ! " ;'1" ! # /! ! ! 5 > #"! 0 8! ! D ! C # / 0 !" # ! ! # ! 8 ;.$0 8 & ! ! ! /! ! # D ! # 2 # #" ! :" " * 4D
!: "
: ! #"
" " D
1--20
/&
:
B 4
: +
# ! " # # :! ' ! ! " ! B #" ! $: #" / !/ !8 # ! " " " ! ! < + : 0 .> #0 # " " !0 ! # / D 0% !B ' ! !" # C
/
8 /
" " !A # # + C9? ! # -
:
"
# 0.
" " !A : # 0L : " ! # / = ! D / L " /! : ! ! D ## " D " " ! 0 ) # 4D # #/ ! ""
,D+
=,/
! - ! #
#
05
*4
" # ! !/
0.
-0
2 1
# - ! D (
, 0 0.
4 4 . .*
. ,0 %0 . 10 1--2 E % .> #0 ? ( (* "3JJ::: > # +J" J ! 2 ! O "
0. 20 1--20 ,9 , & * . # E ? " 0 E ? " F && F 0A . J K / - --2 # !* 0 ? ( ( && *
I 0 H *4 0 . ? +!
90 1--2 : 0
!
-0 1--20 !
L 05
*4
0 1--=$ 0. -0 1--20
=
& # 0 K E ? " 0 ) ; & + O4 : 20 1--20 1 9
.
!
K 0
+ !
6
?
,
#
#
05
# 0
XX Berkeley Journal of International Law, Vol. 25 No. 2 (Forthcoming 2006)
#
0
"
!
5 : : 5 * / B D W # 4 " # + " " # ! ! C%5 & : ! !C 4DA ! !& ! &$ % ! # # > : ! # >" ,X $0 : !! "" / ! " ! / 4DA 0 !
!!
!
,
: !
4D D " " /
+ 8 ! #/ !A /
+ >
L @ B/! + : / @ ## 0 ## A 0 ! " !! # 4D # #/ 0 ! 5 0 %1 " ! ! " " 4D / > " " 0 " 5 # 0 : @ / ! "
.
#/ ,0 1--20 # 0 D 0 4D0 8!0 # ? . # #/ : ! / /! ! !! ! % ! ! " # ( * ! !# ! C # 0 ! " #/ # ! 0: : ! # + ( # ! #"! 1--= / @ ! 0 / >" # ! + !# ! 0 %% ( C & !< # 0 ? . '; !0 ! ? . %2 #/ # B !/ C ! >"
# #/ B
( B #
# / + 0 ? . #/ 1=0 1--20 * #: : ! / ( * ' )0 1--2 %= # ! ! " # 0 > ! : +/ " ## # 0 : / !! #/
" &
,
! !
'; >
!&
!< # ? + #/
" ?
:
##
D "+ , 0 4 4 . .* 0 L ! 10 1--20 %, * ! !0 4 D F* D D# * ,! & " ! 05 *4 0 . 1 0 1--20 1 % ; & + !0 ! , * ! # -& &* 0 5 *4 0 . 1)0 1--20 % %1 ? && &* # && * # 0 ;4 ?44( :
! # : !!0 : " #/ 90 1--20 ? . # #/
# C%9 .
B
" " N " > :
! "
#
%)
#
!
"
.(. , ?
/0
! :0 : # #/ ! : ! : #"! /! + # #
! / ! # !" ? . # #/ /! / # %, ! ! " B
> # "" / B !! C: #" ! ! ! $ : !! # L ! 1--% 5 # : +0 : /> / # ! B
%9 %)
! #
! "
! / + ! ! >
" ? . # #/ +
! #/ /
: !
> ! ## C 2-
> " B $ ? . # #/
/! "
! ! / ')-X $ 2 :
#
/
# # : +
! !
$: " > ! /! / > / !! "" C * $$0 / 0 9') X
C / / #/ > $ #!
0 ? +& "3JJ::: :
#0 J !
* ! J : K J#
> 0 ? J* -2$J?J 0 ! K J# -2K J K > K
90 1--20 #E
>F %, 22
0
01 0
' !! :
#
> "
# : +
!!
/
! "
'1 #
$% "&
1
8
'
-' -
X '9-X
-'=-
2 X '92X
Y =-
9-X ')-X
XX Berkeley Journal of International Law, Vol. 25 No. 2 (Forthcoming 2006)
!! /
! 2
" 0#
#"! #
21
#" ! 0 : !B " C # D 0 : 0 / !
# / !
8 : # #" " +
2%
.
# + # " "
>"
B" ! "
C$0 B $0
!!
! C !
0
>
/. , 0
"
/
0
0
>
$ 2=
/
# ! ! /
!
/
"
C
> "
B : # :
: # : +
2)
*
2,
0 B #" #
/! # # ! 0
!" ? . # #/ 0:
#/
!# + !! :
! : #
A ! > # !
21
/
0C
0 . .1
>
! !
!
>"
.,,
!
> # ! 0C :
"
29
#
#
/ # #/ : / : !! ! : ## /
# : + 0 ! # " !! > : B #" # ! 22 ! "# " # 0 : : ! 0 ! / ! >/! ! " $0 B " !" C # #C ! "
!#
(
! : !!
! $0
/ ! > " " B"
0
# ! *
# >"
! "
' #
$% "&
1
'
-' 1J 2
9'=-X
1J 2'12
=-'9-X
Y 12
9-') X
2
? .0 - , / D) G 0 "3JJ::: : J ! J : K J# K J# -2K J/ 1--=$ E ) F 2% >0 K0 '2 22 ) 0 K 2= >0 K0 '20 '= 29 0 '% 2) 0 2, 0 ' 0 '1
9
K J/
- K
# !
L
0
XX Berkeley Journal of International Law, Vol. 25 No. 2 (Forthcoming 2006)
!
" /! # >" > !
! " > ! > #"! 0 # #/
! " ! >/! ! / /
/! ! !
#
=
:
: #
"!
: + ! / @ / 0 # ! 0 !/
:
!! "! 5 ! " # ! R # ! 0
! >/! ! # >
B
:
C
:
# #/ A ! B ! /! C 3 # ! 0 ! >/! ! " ! + " 0 * ! / " ! ! !+ 0 =% " * !+
!
:
=1
>
* #
(
! =-
#" ! /
: " '
" + !
(
!
!
!#
!
" 0 L !
=
/ : "
/
,
: "" > / D !+ " # #/ " ""! =2 : 0 " !#
>" "
# ! /! ! B !! C @ > ! !
0 !C
RB"! ! 0 "! ! ! # #/ # !
!
> " # # 0
==
-( ! . > ! #
:
"! 0 # ! ! " =-
0 0
= =%
4?
#
;4 =2 == =9
#
0 0 0 0
! ' !
" =9
!
!
# 0 !! !" " " ! ! ! " /
K >0
=1
#" $0
#
$0 0
)
=
! #
#" !
#
' '9 ) ! ,0 ' '% %' -
K0
'1
- ! 20 .
& E ,0 1--2
10
=
0
;4
?44(" # < ! "# ' ! 0 B 5 C 0 + 5 0 0 * !$" : " " ! 0 !! !# / / 0 " ! D 0 : !! #" ! >" 9= ! !! # #/ "" " " ! / B/! : : ! C99 ! 9) D # " /! # 0 !" : 9, ## " /
#
!
!
# "
0#
0
!#
>"
0 !
D
! R
/ ! !
>" / 0 0 >" ' / >" #" " 0 // 0 & : : B" " #
9
! D" > * "3JJ::: J# !J + J: K ! J 1--=$ E F 9% ? .0 ## #/ 90 1--20 ! /! "3JJ::: : J ! J : K J# 5 / 10 1--=$ E ? . 2F 92 I ? 0 # * ,/ 1--2 9= 0 K 99 ? . 10 K
! K
#
# #/ B >" #" C 0 : !! B" !! ! #CR: " 0 )"! 0 ;',-R &$0 < 0 : / " > C" $) : 0
0 0 #/ J -2 1
0 1--%0 # !
5 / 10
23 ! I* K J# -2K J# -2K 9 K # ! + ,
=
#
0 4D 4 0
##
0
0
9) 9,
0 K ? .0 ## #/ =0 1--20 %3 * & " * ! >0 ! /! "3JJ::: : J ! J : K J# K J# -2K J# -2K = K # ! 5 / 10 1--=$ ) ! D" > * ! 0 %0 =0 1--%0 "3JJ::: J# !J + J: K ! J =K #/ J -2 1 = # ! 5 / 10 1--=$ E %F )-
12
XX Berkeley Journal of International Law, Vol. 25 No. 2 (Forthcoming 2006)
:
! " ! !! "
: : !
!
""
#"
#
# 0 " ! ! ;'1# ## / >" / / 1- -0 ' @ ' ! " ! " /! # ) : 0 + : )% 0 D 4D ! # ## D +" 8 "" ! ! )2 # / 0 4D )= : # # / (
!
A
, /
B
'
C 0
E
0))
( ! "# # + !
!: # 0
0
! >" >"
!
1-
! :
#" 0
! " " !" 1- - . : !! / # " / $0
/ " "! 4D : !!
:
! " A" ;',- # B;' 3 !# !! < >" 0 " 0 " !! ! #4 " + D 0
: -C ! ! ! "# Q : # ? !
HI
-,
!
! /
=
"
!
>"
4D
)1
#
" " "
#
0 +
0 !
0 # #/ 0 4DA ! # "" 0 / ! !! : / D
!
!! 0 : !! / " !
/ L "
!
!
# !#
/
: $0 # !
)1 )
"3JJ::: 1--=$ )%
! D" J#
!J
+
> * J: K
! ! J 9K
90 1--%0 # !
5 / 10
" # ! D $0 # 0 D '4D ! ! 0 0 1-- 0 J1-- J-)J-1)9 # ! 5 / 10 1--=$ )2 0 ! : ! 0: # 4D B# / ! " C &4 # #/ 0 1--2 5 ! O 7 * !! 0 .+ - ! # ,05 *4 0 1 0 1--20 )= ! D" > * ! 0 10 %0 1--%0 "3JJ::: J# !J + J: K ! J %K #/ J -2 1 % # ! 5 / 10 1--=$ E 1F )9 ? .* ! > 0 ( 0 ' )0 1--2$0 ? + & #3 * ! ! $0 ? J* -2$J?J J 0 )0 1--20 "3JJ::: : J ! J : K J# K J# -2K J# -2K # ! 5 / 10 1--=$ )) (0? 0 K
5 # : + :::
D ? . J :J ! 0 D
0 20 #/ J -2 1 9
13
XX Berkeley Journal of International Law, Vol. 25 No. 2 (Forthcoming 2006)
/ $0 # ! $ !! # ! > " " !" >" / /
? . # #/ ! ! !# +
! /
#/ $ / : !! /
# ! / " ! -0 1--= H 0 #" / ! " $ # 0 !! # 1--=0 ' @ #"! #
" ! "
! " A
! D
* $0 # #/ !! " H 0 0 !# ! " ! -0 1--= 0 " / ! " '/ ""! * $ B"! ! !C @ ' " ! > 0 : : !! #" ! / 4D D
(
E &*
"
! !/
( " >"
* 0/
),
#< ! "
#/
/
/
0
#
,1
# ? . # #/
+
#/ "!
!! %0
'
,
> / #
"
@ "
J
# ? . !! :
:
' ,9X L "
! !
" ! B: / C # 0 # #/
!
E &
# !
" >
!
,-
:
: 1--- ;. " %--! " " @ ! ? . ! " " /! : , ( # ! ' !! B/ #' "C "" 0
K
,,
! D" "3JJ::: J# !J 1--=$ ,1 ) 0 K , ? .0 , 0 5 / 10 1--=$
+
> * J: K
! ! J 2K
"3JJ::: : # =
14
0 0 #/ J -2 1 2
+J
J: /
20 1--%0 # !
J: /
5 / 10
#! !
XX Berkeley Journal of International Law, Vol. 25 No. 2 (Forthcoming 2006)
#" 8 " # ! # ! B > !! ! 0 : : ! # + /
0
! # # #/ 0 ,% > 8 * !
A
B "' ( #
! "
#" > ! # #/ #" !! / " X ' # !
,2
#
0
! @ ,)
' 0
L "
! !
0
! ! " & " ! ! ## # / 0: # ! -? ! 5 / # D D # #" # + 0
:
!
>!
#
!
/ # >"
'
0 # + -
,%
? . 20 K ? .0 ## #/ )0 1--20 =3 * + +0A "3JJ::: : J ! J : K J# K J# -2K J# -2K ) E ? . =F ,= & ! ! 0 # = # . " !,0 1--20 , ,2
! K
Z&
# !
5 / 10 1--=$ 0?
#
&. 0
,9 ,)
D 0 "3JJ::: J # . ! 0K? ! K K* 5 / 10 1--=$ ,, ! D" "3JJ::: J# 1--=$ E
/ D ; # . !0 K< / J " J1--2J #/ J !0K K( K K4> /
!J 9F
+
> * J: K
! ! J ,X 1-
--
15
K/ K K
0 90 #/ J -2 1 ,
KD K; #! ! ,0 1--%0 # !
#
K
5 / 10
XX Berkeley Journal of International Law, Vol. 25 No. 2 (Forthcoming 2006)
#> ! : ? .: :
0
/ ! "# ! "# ! "#
"
( !0 ? . !' # / !& ! < # #" 8 -1 " /! ! # / " ! "# " + ! # ! + # B/ ! # ! #" # / !
!
# /! " # '; : B/ + +C ! "# A "" !: #" B/ C" : ! ! " ! 0 ;. ! ! .> # # -% " # C ; " ! : "! " + ! 8 -2
! 0
)12
3 5 4 $
4 $28
-..)'
4 $ "
: " 0 !! # >" /
/
! #
6
4
'
/ #"
-../' !! ! ! # !! # >" / / 1- J. "! #"! / " ! -0 1--= ! / J " / 4D$I# ! / D 0 L " $I / #/ * #/ $ " /
; !
""
4 $(
( $ &
# ! J '
'
!
$4 -..7' & !! ! ! # !! # >" / / /
0: '
6
!
/
!
# ! J
#
; : > " "
-1
? . =0 E # ! E -% .> # & ! 0 "3JJ::: > # J J : J" -2 ; " 0 * ,/ )0 1--20 "3JJ::: " J ! L -0 1--=$ -
$
K = 0 4 4 . .* 0 ,0 1--2 E # . . &+ ! J1--2J" -2 1 )K: K/ ! ! -, ! # * . ! !J"
J !
J? .K
16
!
K !K
: > " * ! /!
E
$J /
#
" !
!F
0 L 0 1--=$ , &* # 0 K
!K #"
K
K
XX Berkeley Journal of International Law, Vol. 25 No. 2 (Forthcoming 2006)
#/ >" ! J / ##
4 ( 6 4 $ 4( 4'
# ! 4! # $ " + ! J * ! /
"
" + ! $ J. # & ! ! !/ !8 " #
9
## $9
'
"" !
@
'
: >! ""!
#
" / !# 1--= J @ ' #< " B : # ! C
0
"
0 ? . # #/ !+ ! # ! ! # &4 -= : ! $ !
/!
" : ! / ! ! B# '
19'1)0 1--=0 # # / 12 0 ! ? ! 4 # 5 # ?45$ ! # '# ! # : / ! # && E 0 ;4 ?44( > ! " B C ! #/ : ! # B / 4 " # # : / # ! C %? ! " ! ! " # + ! 0 " ! ! / " " 0 " !! 2 ! "# ! 0 ! / : # =
-9
! 0 K ) 0 K -, ? .0 ) ! & . : 44 ; . 0. 0 1--20 "3JJ::: : J ! J : K J : -2K J K -2K # ! L 0 1--=$ " !* 0# ! & ? ? * ,0 5 *4 0 1 0 1--2 " 4DA " " / ! # * #/ ( * ! $ & !" : 0 ) # # 0 A< 4 < D 40 ,0 1--2 1 & / ? 0- ! * * ,. 05 *4 0 %0 1--20 %I. E & ) + , 0 H *4 0 . %0 1--2 L " ! 8O : ! 0 #! - ! ! + E + 05 *4 0 0 1--20 9 % #! - " #! - ! 05 *4 0 0 1--20 2 # ! ( * ! 0 ! " 8!0 4 " 0 0 0 #/ 0 & ! "" 0 0 7 8 ! $ ! -)
18
0
XX Berkeley Journal of International Law, Vol. 25 No. 2 (Forthcoming 2006)
5
!! 0 0 # !< # 0 :
& ;
!# 0
/ /
PS !! : / # !! / +
/ !
#! ! ! !
!0
!! " ! +/ "
+
"
)
! (
D " ! / ? . '; ! +! ! > 0 9 !! " /! ! / ' / : ! H 0 !!0 < # ! !" !! : 4 " "
(. A , "
! " !! !! # A ! ! / / ? ( (6 ? 1--2$0 8! : # ! / # : ? . "" !! " # # : " / / / ! * # $ , 6 3 ! / !# + 8! ! ! / # >" / # ! # >" / # ! * # D " 8 " >" /
/ !
/
#
0
! 0
? . " #
: !
1
!
" 0 # /
#"! !
! !! @
# ! " !
! "
L ! =
# .> # &
! 10 ! 0 "3JJ::: > #
/
$
! #
! D
"
! # " #" : ! 0!+ D 0
: @
/
8!A 1--2$0 " 4D ! / ! / #"! : !! 1-
? . A / ? .0 11 #"
/!
? .
! ! "#
# 0
! "
K
? ? * # & 7%%K0 1-0 1--20 J J : J" ! J1--2J" -2 11-K + ! 5 / 10 1--=$ E ? ? F 9 ( 0 (#( ( ! & D 0 H *4 0 120 1--2 ) < # + :! 4D ! #" / E # !0 K , D G / D"! 0 " "" !! 0 ? J 1=9J J 0 ! * 0 1--2 14 G 4>" / 0 " "" !! 0 ? J 1=2J J 0 ? J 1==J J 0 ? J 1) J J 0 ! " 1)0 1--2 1 ! 0* F * , ) #! 0A 5 *4 0 -0 1--20 11 .[5 *0 D . . 4V D4 4 3 ? H 4 4D D *D 45. * D 4 0. & H 4& 40 .[5 * 45 ; & &4 . ) 1--2$
19
!
4
XX Berkeley Journal of International Law, Vol. 25 No. 2 (Forthcoming 2006)
"
#
"
!
!
!
!
!+ 0 " !/ !8
!
!
: !
/ 5
!!0 #
" # "" ! ! " "
0
! "
#
" !
!
:
" 5 #
" D :
!
#
/
! 0
#
" ! " 0 :
: #/ # + # 0" "
5 ! " "
D /
D 4 ! "
#"! # #/ #0
>" 0 A# +
!
1
# 0 0 !
1%
0
!
/
:/ : "
!
; " !/ " 0 # / ; J? . " !0
!
" A "
+ !
/
> #"! 0 "
4
: !
!
0
" 0 > ? . # #/ A /
!
: !! / #
/ !
/ 12
! "
D #/
5
? . A
!
# +
A
!
#
!#
D
#
!
4 !
!
# ! " 0! / '"
#
"
"
"
.
>"
> 4
#
/ / /
#
! # # " ! ! ! " # ! ! #"! 0 " " ! 0 # ! " # 0 + # /
: #
1=
" " ! "
:
#
0:
!
/ (
( " !
#
! 0
/!
"
0: *5 '/
" # ! !
! !
1 1%
/ 12
# 1=
! ! !" / 8 / D 4D : ? . #"! 0 0 '1 L * ? + 0 #! 3 , &! ? # . . 0 & " & ! " ! # * 0 " ! 20 1--%$0 )', 0 2
20
"
!! ,
XX Berkeley Journal of International Law, Vol. 25 No. 2 (Forthcoming 2006)
#0 :
!
" > /
!" " !+
: # ! #
/
1--2 "
19
H 0 0 # !
# !
1)
D"
!! "
"
" B "
C
/! " ! Q #
D
-
Q # !0 1,
0
1-- 0 ! !0 : ! " D #"!
D
! ! # ! :
B
C ! : 0 # 0 L 20 ! :
!
! * )0 1--%$0 ! # 5 3 4! ! 0; # ! 0 0 $ * 1)0 1--%$0 * 1--%$0 " #/ %0 1--%$0 #! & # 0 & 0 ! #/ 0 ! 0 4 $0 # D D$ # #/ & /! # !! 0 : 0 # ! " /! " ! ! " !: " ! ! 0 " !! 5 0: 1 'D # #/ # ! 8 ! > " ! ! " ! > /
# + B
/ # / *5 0C % # #/ # /! /' ! '
!
:
0
! # ! #0C 4 # ! ! ! #0 ! / # 4 0( G ! 5 $0 ! 0 4 "! 2 ? ! "
/
! !
! $ # A #
19
!
"
D
"
:
#
: !! ! /! B5 ! 0L " 0( 4 $ #" ! 4 G D J M$0 # ! : #"
#! * &! # . ! ! ! " $0 0 ! L 90 1--20 "3JJ::: : J ! J : K JK JK #T ! 1) ( 0 .& ! # E = 4 &.< H ?. ( ; & &4 19 1--=$0 = 1, . D ! ; ! 0* # #3 Q 0 " %0 1-D 0+ &? ( (# D 0 # . 0 "3JJ::: J K # J ! !J K > #! ! 1 #! .*#. 0 4 4 . .* 0 L )0 1--20 * + 0. . #! ! & , "3JJ " @ J J-----%,=J ! 1)0 1--%$ % . 4 . / + > #"! " A ! ## ' ' " ! ! ! /! # : !! > / 0 ! ; " . 0 ! ! /! ! 3 # ! /! # ! /!
#
/ 0 !
4 # ( ,'%;
10
: 0 K / 4 A !" ! ! !! ! # / / ? .$ , # @ * / !0 ( J0 40 . 0 47 4 +
/! ! + ! !
!
0
:
! / " 1
.(. -
"
# + / #"
! // /
/
=
# ! #8 A
* ! # # !
' #" !" :
" !
" /
!
"/ : "
&
!
* + ! 0
! ! #"
"
# ! & # D >" A# 0 : # ! ! / ! 5 ! ,!
#
A
#" # # + " !
!
! " " A ! ! ! 0 %2 ; # + / ! C %= / /!
8 0# .& ,
?
#0
:
0 ! " ! "#
%9
" %)
%
# # !
! "
#" # : ! A " %% 0 #/ # B" ! C / # ! B"! !8 ! + ! " ! / ! "
A"
%1
A
> ! "
#
:
:
/
+#
0
" 0% " ! "
!
#" !
0
" * !
! /
,!
0 !
!
#
+
#
!
"
%1
>
&-
" /
" ! 0
: "
#
!
#
! # : ! # #"! # !! " >" 0 ! # , / !! !! 0 : ! ! " # %, " # / : ! & " 0L # * ! :
0
*
=)0 9 D
4 4
,!
1--2$ 0
4 4 . .*
0
9 0L !
1%0 1-%%
D+ ? 0 #" L
%2
110 1--20 %=
1 ? .
0 ? 0.-
%)
0+ %,
? 0
K !
&+
,
0 12 ? L
N< < O D
20
=' )
F
,
#"! 0 #/
0 /! 0 D > ! D !
2-
# J!
"3JJ::: : 2
; #
" :'# B #
!/ /! " ! 21
/ # ! "
>"! !
!
: 0
!" :
!
" :
@ ! ! ! > 0+ , . , ,! M N0 L 1-0 1--=$ 0 #! # D ,! &0 2= < < 47 %) 0 %,1 1--%$ E
=
? !
F 21 2
+0 # ! " , 4 ! # 0 11 ;4. %2 0 %2, 1-- $ / ! # " / ! # ! ! " / # # # " ! '# + " $IL " < 0 & ! !. , * # . . # & A, # + , 0 % 7 A< < L ) 0 %-- ,, $ / D A " ! 5 A ! $ 2% / 4 .## . J #! * &! . # && # 0 )- H " : " # "
#"
! 0 :
"! !
#
! ! ! :
> #" #" #
# " "
! 0#
#
!
/ +
(. +
"
0
/
@ !
/ /
0
!
!
+ ! : +
" !/
2)
5
*4
0
2,
1--20
2 =-
!"
"
? .A ! #
! #
! ! "
! A"
!
! 0
## #
0! ! ! #
!
" "
# ## ! /! ; # 0 ! ## 0 ! 0 : 0 " " ! " ! ! ## : ? . ! / # / + " ! " # :
!&
/ !! " " 0 ! / : !8 0 : ! /
!
2)
" #
#
0 : !
/ 0 ! + # !
! - !
# /
!
=-
!
! ? . # #/ " ! : !!
" & / 0" #
' #"
#0 / " # : ! ' #' ! /! # ! 0 0 # D
:
/ ! ##
!
/
! + ( ! #/ : 0 " ' ! "# + # ! ! $ H 0 : " " ! " ! " / + : ! # + 0 #" /! 0 : !
!
! / # !
0
0 !
H O? * # 0.- ! # , 20 1--20 9 < + + ! 0 #! * + , #! + 05 "" 4 " ## A " " ! B ! /! # 90 K I- 0 4 4 . .* 0 -0 1--20 1
26
!
E *4
C$
= 0
0 0
XX Berkeley Journal of International Law, Vol. 25 No. 2 (Forthcoming 2006)
!! 0 # ! "
!" 0 "
+
/
" /! 0 0 0 !
:
0
# #
!
? . # #/ A ! ! " # # 0: " # " = , 0 !0 ! * B ! ! C =1 / " /! 0 " ! ! ! !! !! : 0 ! ! # # # # ! ! ## 0 / ! 0 0 # ! / # " ! ! " ! ! #
? . # #/ # ! " ! 0 # 0 #' "C "" : !! ! !: ! # : 0 !/ " " 0 ! / # /! 8 " # " ! # + 0 # #/ : / ! # " # !: ! 0 # # " /! " 0 ! " /! 0 " ! > : # ( 8 ! ! ! # " 0C D " ! : ! / #: :
#
: " 0 B/ # " /!
'/
0 " /! $ 0 ! 0 =% ! #
! !/
# !
/! " !! /
/
" .
!
=
!! "'
:
!
"" 8
#
0 #
" !! : !8 ! " ! '# + / 0B ! # : =
# + " ! " ! " : " # ! 0 8 ! # # " " " ! ! # #
! ! . / 4 0 4 4 . .* 0 %0 * ' 90 1--1 / : D # / !! / ! B/ -X C # $I ! . 0 4 4 . .* 0 10 L ! ' =0 1--1 8 4DA ## ! !& ! &$ : # !! #/ # B! 2X : + C$ : ! 4D / >" >" # $I* !( 0 */ )- . = *, & 0 D ? 40 " -0 1--1 ? ! + 4 # ! : 8 A " " ! " : ! B: ! #" " # " : ! " ! C$ =1 . 4 4 D 4 04 H . 4 D 4 .5 4 . < 4< ? ,,,$ L D*< 0 & . 4 . *3 4 &.< H 4*. . 4 4 ,)2$ = 4 . ( D4;4 0 *4 4 &.< H3 ;4 H 4* ( ; ,,2$ =% (( 0+ , 0 K0 11'1 8 B C: B! ! " : " : # / : ! " 0 ! #" / !!0 "" " / !!0 + ! ! " C$
27
XX Berkeley Journal of International Law, Vol. 25 No. 2 (Forthcoming 2006)
!!' :
#
'
, - =2
:!
/ H 0
/ " /!
!
" " / "
+ !
/
! !
! "
44
4 &
==
" " ! : =9 . !"
+ "3JJ
/ =) =,
!! " "3JJ::: : $0
## #
!
/ : /
0
" " : !!
# +! 8
@
? ! " "! #0 ! ! : " " !! # ! /!
" "! A
=)
# !" ! 0 :
8 0 0
!
## ##
:
+ ! 0 :
/ / !/
0:
"
/
# : 0 " "!
"
/ ! / #
!/ !!
0 " "! 0: ! > ! ! + :! " /! ! / # / "
"
" !
/!
#
0
#
!/ " /!
0
/ 0 ! :
!
@ " /!
> ==
0 /
=2
# 1--%$
!
" ! " # " !
# !
#
" !"
# + : " " " # : ! 0 =9 # ! # !8 0 ! : + 0 ! ! # !! #/ " "! : # " " "! & / " " # # !! 0 " 0 " / / !! : / # # ! #" # #"! " " ! # !/ " " ./ / ! >" /
& 7
:
" !
#0 # 0 / ! ! " ! #
:
? ! ?
@ "
:
! /!
!
!
# "!
! !8
4 4 0 &.< 0& 4 D 4 4 553 & 4 D 4 &.< 0 .? 4 ,1,' , - 47 . .5 0 9 3+ + D ! # ) ,0 1--% !* < : $ 8 0 K 0 9-'9 8 # #"! ! " : #! /! 0 # 9 &.&& + , & ? ( (* 0 /! J K/ J K # #! ! L 8 0 K 0 9-'9 8 ! / # /! 8 # # " ! (0 # ? ! ? $0 J! 5 / 10 1--=$I # "3JJ::: J! 5 / 10 1--=$ 4
28
# /!
0 =,
D H .5 5 44 4 55 ,
2$
" /! 0* U10---
1-0 1--=$
!
0
XX Berkeley Journal of International Law, Vol. 25 No. 2 (Forthcoming 2006)
. !
# #/ # !! ! D P # "
!
!
#
/
: #
# #
#
# # ! '
# " # #
/ + : # 9#0 !! ! 0 " "! 0 #
# " # ! #0 / ! # @ +! : ! 0 : !! !! # "
? . ( * !/ !/ # # 0 # ? . # #/ A " ! ! & " : # " "R # " ! ! /! ! / / # +
!
: # ! #/ : ! ! ! # 0 # B" ! ! !C 9 H 0 :# # # / : : " / :" : ! " R ! " /! 0 : /
! /!
!
!0 #
!!
#
# !
! " /! # + #" ! 0: " ! ! !
9-
# 9
*4
/ :
!! 0
0
& >C: L L 1 0 1--2
#
0
0
!
#
0
:
# # !0 " /! / /
# 0 1--=
! !! #"
" ! . 0# /
!
K0
:
+
" 0.+
!+ !
! #
"
" :
!'
!
:
!
!+
" ! !
, G
#
29
! / B
/ F. !
/ #" D
$ 05
