What does that wealth of work mean for the labour market, economy and public
policy in Canada's youngest province? By Rob Antle hot commodities.
NEWFOUNDLAND & LABRADOR
SPECIAL REPORT
Hot commodities
Natural resources are driving the Newfoundland and Labrador economy, with energy projects pushing the province to more than 60 per cent of planned major project spending in the entire Atlantic region. What does that wealth of work mean for the labour market, economy and public policy in Canada’s youngest province? By Rob Antle
In 1883,
the Sisters of Mercy purchased the Littledale site in the Waterford Valley for use as a boarding school for Catholic girls. Over the ensuing decades, generation after generation of Newfoundland youth were educated in the leafy and bucolic setting just west of downtown St. John’s. Today, the site is being redeveloped for a new use, more in line with the metamorphosis that is transforming Newfoundland and Labrador’s capital city. By next spring, the former Catholic school and complex run by nuns will be home to 600-plus employees, all of them working
in the province’s booming energy and resource-related fields. Local firm GJ Cahill Limited bought the site from the Sisters of Mercy two years ago, and has since moved its own employees to the Tower Corporate Campus at Waterford Valley (as Littledale has been rechristened.) The collegiate setting is aimed at helping foster a creative and innovative corporate environment, according to GJ Cahill spokeswoman Lisa Anthony. GJ Cahill itself is an example of a company that has grown from humble beginnings into an important player in the resources sector. It started in 1953 as
an electrical contracting company, and has since grown into a major fabrication and construction outfit that has worked on all of the province’s major projects. And in the near term, those projects are expected to continue — from oil to mining to hydroelectricity. Newfoundland and Labrador’s economy is expected to remain strong in the coming years, as energyrelated initiatives drive growth. But with those good times come significant challenges — public-policy puzzles that must be solved to ensure that the province’s short-term gain does not become long-term pain. Online extras: atlanticbusinessmagazine.com | 47
The Tower Corporate Campus at Waterford Valley in St. John’s will soon be home to 600-plus employees working in the booming resources sector in Newfoundland and Labrador. Photo by Rob Antle
For the next few years, the news appears good. Newfoundland and Labrador alone accounts for more than half of the total inventory value of major projects on the books in the entire Atlantic region. The province boasts $43.6 billion in planned work, a whopping 61 per cent of the overall total. The other three Atlantic provinces trail far behind Newfoundland and Labrador in their share of the major development pie. Nova Scotia is next at 21 per cent, followed by New Brunswick at 16 per cent, and finally Prince Edward Island at two per cent. “Newfoundland and Labrador is a commodity rich province and the revival in commodity prices is helping to boost major project activity,” the Atlantic Provinces Economic Council (APEC) noted in its recent major projects inventory report. “The province has abundant quantities of oil, iron ore, nickel and copper, all of which are in demand from rapidly expanding economies such as China and India. The pace of investment activity is at record levels and rising quickly.” According to APEC, Newfoundland and Labrador’s current-year major project spending is up 49 per cent in 2011, to $6.2 billion. That follows a rise of 30 per cent in 2010. APEC says roughly half of this year’s 48 | Atlantic Business Magazine | September/October 2011
total is being spent on five large projects which have a total value of over $17 billion: the Long Harbour nickel processing facility, the White Rose and Hibernia oilfield expansion projects, the Hebron oil project and the Iron Ore Company of Canada expansion in Labrador West. APEC said it believes these projects, along with the start of activity on the Muskrat Falls hydro project and related transmission infrastructure, will keep spending at record levels over the next few years. “Newfoundland and Labrador will continue to bound ahead,” the report predicted.
continues to move full steam ahead with the second-fastest projected growth rate in Canada in 2011, behind only Alberta,” noted Craig Wright, senior vice-president and chief economist with RBC Economics. “Data in the early part of this year showed robust growth in construction, exports and employment. The natural resource industry, which has been the central factor in Newfoundland and Labrador’s economic performance in recent years, will continue to be a source of strength in 2011.” According to RBC, provincial employment grew by 2.8 per cent in the first quarter alone – the largest quarterly gain in Newfoundland and Labrador in more than a dozen years. RBC indicated that ongoing major project spending is helping fuel nonresidential investment. And high crude prices are continuing to offset declines in production. Newfoundland and Labrador hit peak oil production levels four years ago, in 2007. Meanwhile, TD Economics indicated that Newfoundland and Labrador is on track to recover from a whopping 10.2 per cent contraction in GDP during recessionravaged 2009. “The province made the first leg of its journey in 2010, with an estimated 5.4 per cent real GDP growth performance,”
“Newfoundland and Labrador will continue to bound ahead.” APEC 2011 major project inventory report
All told, APEC has identified 103 projects totalling $43.6 billion in the province, which is up 16 per cent over last year’s inventory. APEC said the main reasons for the growth are the increase in valuation of the Hebron oil project and the addition of planned mining projects in Labrador. Other forecasts are painting a similarly rosy picture for the province’s prospects in the near term. “Canada’s most eastern province
TD Economics noted in a report released this year. “Solid numbers will be recorded over our forecast period (4.7 per cent in 2011 and 2.6 per cent in 2012). If realized, this would make Newfoundland and Labrador one of the top economic growth performers in each year from 2010 (to) 2013.” But there are concerns buried underneath the avalanche of numbers. TD Economics noted that demographics in the province remain a “challenge.”
Great expectations
Resource-related initiatives are expected to drive major project spending in Newfoundland and Labrador over the coming years. Here is a select list of those projects (overall capital cost listed; projected start/end dates in brackets): North Atlantic Refining Ltd. Planned refinery turnaround and ongoing capital expenditures. Come By Chance. $130 million. (2011/2011)
North Atlantic Refining Ltd. Upgrade of existing refinery facility to remove process constraints and permit improved production and efficiency. Projected expenditures of $60 million for the 2011 year. Come By Chance. $300 million. (2010/2013)
Vale Newfoundland and Labrador Ltd. Construction of a nickel processing facility with an annual capacity of 50,000 tonnes of finished nickel. Capital expenditures of US$817 million expected in 2011. Long Harbour. US$2.821 billion. (2009/2013)
Tata Steel Minerals Canada Ltd. Reopening of former iron ore mines including the construction of a processing plant, rail and camp facilities, and a power plant. Approximately 75 per cent of the project cost will be spent in Newfoundland and Labrador with the remaining slated for Quebec. Elross Lake Area. $335 million. (2011/2012)
Cliffs Natural Resources Inc. Investment to improve the operation of Wabush Mines. $30 million to $35 million to replace existing equipment and to acquire new equipment; $20 million to improve reliability of equipment in the concentrator; and up to $30 million for environmental projects. Figure also reflects $30 million for full implementation of a manganese project. Wabush. $110 million to $115 million. (2010/2012) ExxonMobil and partners. Development of the Hebron oil field. The Hebron project, located approximately 350 kilometres offshore, is a joint venture among ExxonMobil Canada, Chevron Canada, Suncor, Statoil Canada, and Nalcor Energy-Oil and Gas. The Hebron field is estimated to contain 581 million barrels of recoverable reserves. Construction of the gravitybased structure is expected to start in 2012 and production of oil is expected to begin in 2017. Expenditures cover all capital costs over the life of the project. Offshore Newfoundland. $7 billion to $11 billion. (2008/2042)
ExxonMobil and partners. Development to enable the production of oil from the Hibernia Southern Extension Unit. Includes the drilling of production wells from the existing Hibernia GBS; the drilling of subsea water injection wells from a mobile drilling unit; and GBS topsides modifications. Offshore Newfoundland. $1.7 billion. (2009/2013) Iron Ore Company of Canada. Expansion project (Phase I and II) to increase mine production from 18 million tonnes to 23.2 million tonnes of concentrate. Labrador City. $828 million. (2010/2012) Suncor Energy Inc. and partners. Development and sustaining capital for the Terra Nova oil field. Offshore Newfoundland. $270 million. (2011/2011)
Husky Energy Inc. Development of three White Rose satellite fields. The first field, North Amethyst, commenced production in May 2010. Planned expenditures of $400 million in 2011. 2011 activities will focus on continued development drilling at North Amethyst and drilling of two pilot wells at West White Rose. Husky Energy has a 68.875 per cent share in the expansion project, Suncor has a 26.125 per cent share and Nalcor Energy-Oil and Gas has an equity ownership of five per cent. Offshore Newfoundland. $3.5 billion. (2008/NA)
Nalcor Energy/Emera Inc. Development of Phase I of the Lower Churchill hydroelectric project. Consists of development of Muskrat Falls portion of project that entails: construction of Muskrat Falls generating station with capacity of 824 megawatts; construction of two HVdc transmission lines from the Muskrat Falls generating station; construction of a LabradorIsland transmission link; and construction of a Maritime transmission link from the island of Newfoundland to Nova Scotia. Emera Inc. will contribute 20 per cent of overall costs. Various locations. $6.2 billion. (2011/2017)
Source: The Economy 2011, Department of Finance, Government of Newfoundland and Labrador. 50 | Atlantic Business Magazine | September/October 2011
“Who would have thought it, 10 years ago, that Newfoundland and Labrador would be the place where we’d have more jobs than people?” N.L. Finance Minister Tom Marshall Those include an aging population and the spending pressures that go hand-in-hand with that. And what was once unfathomable may now become reality — too few workers for too many jobs. According to Newfoundland and Labrador Finance Minister Tom Marshall, there may be between 5,000 and 7,000 unfilled positions in the province by 2015. “Who would have thought it?” Marshall noted. “Who would have thought it, 10 years ago, that Newfoundland and Labrador would be the place where we’d have more jobs than people?” This summer, the provincial government released its Labour Market Outlook 2020 report, which forecasts the province’s employment demands for the next decade, and outlines opportunities in several sectors. According to the report, 70,000 jobs are expected to open up between 2011 and 2020, with attrition accounting for nearly 90 per cent of them. Total employment is expected to grow by 2.8 per cent over the same time frame. That means about 7,700 new jobs in the economy. “Our historical challenge of too many people and not enough work is now giving way to the new reality of increased jobs and opportunities,” Labour Minister Darin King told reporters in releasing the report. Most of that growth will occur over the next four years, according to government forecasts, as major projects come on stream. Employment levels are expected to jump 8.2 per cent, before peaking in 2015. That will be followed by a decline of about 5.1 per cent from 2016 to 2020, as the construction phases of the projects ramp down. The utilities, health and trade sectors are expected to be most robust.
Successful Project Execution. Safely. Every Time. We’ve been around for a while; since 1932 in fact. DFB Group has developed a long standing history as one of Newfoundland and Labrador’s most prominent providers of marine, industrial, and oilfield products and services. From onshore and offshore services and repairs, custom manufacturing and fabrication, rigging and lifting products, and multi-discipline construction and contracting services, our company has established a reputation for safety, quality, and dependability. Our customers choose us because they know they can count on us, around
Bringing people home.
the clock, to deliver what we promise, safely, every time. In Newfoundland and Labrador, we have 100,000 ft2 of fabrication space with over 25 acres 2
of lay down area, including a 50,000 ft fabrication facility near an ice-free port with deep water access. With such a capacity unique to Newfoundland and Labrador, we look forward to continuing to play a key role in Newfoundland and Labrador’s vibrant Industrial, Offshore, and Construction sectors. We have grown a lot since 1932. That growth has occurred because of our great employees and the sound relationships we have built with our customers. Our clientele is more diverse now and the projects are often bigger, but our commitment to excellence that allows us to build those great relationships, remains the same.
DFB Group (Corporate) St. John's, NL Canada Tel: 709.726.6820 Fax: 709.579.5055
Sean Power VP Business Development Email:
[email protected] Mobile: 709.691.7718
The Bull Arm fabrication site — located on Newfoundland’s Avalon Peninsula about 150 kilometres from St. John’s — is expected to be busy with major construction work in the coming years. Photo courtesy of Nalcor Energy
52 | Atlantic Business Magazine | September/October 2011
To meet labour demands, the government is investing in a suite of programs and initiatives, from skills training to programs targeting immigrants to considering “familyfriendly” public policy options to help attract and retain young workers and their families. According to King, the government estimates that between five and seven per
cent of the province’s workforce actually travels outside Newfoundland and Labrador for work. The aim is to entice them to instead toil inside the province’s borders. “We see this as an era of great prosperity for our people, and one that everyone must make an effort to seize,” King said. Labour and business leaders have also recognized the importance of the work to come. “First and foremost, workers — including the next generation of workers — must be aware of the opportunities ahead,” Lana Payne, president of the Newfoundland and Labrador Federation of Labour, said in a news release. “But just as important, as a society we must be clear about the kind of labour market we want to build — we want a labour market that supports good jobs, that includes safe and rewarding work for the citizens of our province. We want to ensure that the workers of our province share fairly in the province’s prosperity.” Roger Flood, the chairman of the Newfoundland and Labrador Business Coalition, added that the report “presents an opportunity … to address labour needs and match labour supply with projected demand.”
Potential labour pains
are not the only prosperity-related public-policy issue facing the provincial government. Years of resources-fuelled growth have stuffed provincial coffers full of petro-bucks, allowing the government to ramp up spending by billions while still remaining in the black, and also paying down debt. But recently, Memorial University economist Wade Locke warned about the potential impact of the province’s big-spending ways. Locke told a panel discussion in St. John’s this summer that government expenditures have kept pace with booming revenues — something that is not sustainable into the future. According to Locke, falling royalty payments could see the province running annual deficits of $1.9 billion within a decade. Locke calculated that the public debt could double over that same time frame. Locke’s warnings follow similar cautionary words from the province’s former auditor general, John Noseworthy. As far back as 2008, Noseworthy said that Newfoundland and Labrador’s dependence on volatile non-renewable oil revenues left the province in a “vulnerable” financial position.
According to a report issued by Noseworthy earlier this year, total government expenses have increased by nearly $2 billion since 2006. In particular, health and education expenses jumped by just over $1 billion (or 34.7 per cent) since 2006 and now account for 55.6 per cent of total expenses. The business community is also expressing concern. “We managed to
Labrador’s Muskrat Falls (pictured) will be the site of an 824-MW hydroelectric project that is expected to generate first power by 2017. The $6.2-billion project is being aided by Nova Scotia’s Emera, which is investing $1.8 billion of that overall cost in exchange for a block of power and an interest in transmission infrastructure. Photo courtesy of Nalcor Energy
Online extras: atlanticbusinessmagazine.com | 53
Newfoundland and Labrador Finance Minister Tom Marshall says there has been an “amazing” turnaround in the fortunes of the province once viewed as “the poor cousin of Confederation.” Photo by Paul Daly
convince ourselves that life is good, and we can afford to live higher on the hog than we’ve been able to in the past,” Jo Mark Zurel said. “So we have our provincial government and our municipal governments spending like there’s no tomorrow.” But tomorrow always comes, bringing with it those challenging demographics — fewer young people in the workforce paying for an ever-increasing number of older residents who will require expensive services. “We’re going to be hit from both ends,” Zurel said. “We’re going to have the revenues dropping and the costs rising.
The boom in Newfoundland and Labrador is creating tremendous business opportunities. And challenges.
The outstanding economic upswing in Newfoundland and Labrador is a welcome trend. But at Grant Thornton LLP, we’re also aware that rapid growth brings challenges. Whether you’re an entrepreneur with a startup business, a corporation expanding into NL from elsewhere in Canada, or an existing company grappling with overwhelming demands—we can help you manage the unique issues that arise from rapid growth. Give us a call. We like challenges.
st.John’s 187 Kenmount Road NL, A1B 3P9 T +1 709 722 5960
www.GrantThornton.ca
Audit • Tax • Advisory
Grant Thornton LLP. A Canadian Member of Grant Thornton International Ltd 54 | Atlantic Business Magazine | September/October 2011
And that’s a scary prospect.” Zurel — a former senior vice-president and CFO with CHC Helicopter Corporation who now serves as chairman of the St. John’s Board of Trade and president/owner of the investment company Stonebridge Capital Inc. — said the province needs to diversify the economy to build the foundation now that will support those programs it values later. Zurel said he has sympathy for politicians who find it difficult to say no when they have the short-term resources to say yes. “I understand they’re in a tough spot,” he acknowledged. But that does not make action any less necessary. “When revenues are rising, you have the ability to make choices that don’t hurt anybody. But when revenues start to drop, and you have to start cutting, that’s when everybody really feels the pain.” Zurel said he does not want to look back years down the road and conclude that this generation squandered opportunities for the next one. And he issued a caution about hydro projects being viewed as a great economic panacea for the province. Muskrat Falls — while potentially good — is mostly about replacing generating capacity, and will be paid for by Newfoundland residents through their power rates. “I think we’ve got to keep that one in perspective,” Zurel noted.
The province’s finance minister,
meanwhile, defends much of the increase in program spending. Tom Marshall says the government had to play catch-up on neglected and crumbling infrastructure, and pumped billions into public-works spending to keep the economy steady during the recession. Still, Marshall acknowledged the big increases have to stop. The growth rate is down to two per cent this year, compared to a staggering recent annual spike of 9.8 per cent in program spending. “Now it’s the time to get back to fiscal prudence, and to continue to start to chip away at the debt.” Complicating matters for Marshall is the inherent volatility of resource revenues. One in every three dollars the Newfoundland and Labrador government receives comes via oil royalties. Those royalties are contingent on three key factors: production levels (which are declining); the price of oil (which is unpredictable, but again approaching the stratosphere); and the strength of the dollar (the loonie’s resurgence has taken a
We see the possibilities. For Suncor Energy, growth brings opportunity and a set of new challenges. The biggest one of all: balancing increased development with the need to live up to our social and environmental responsibilities, both as an individual company and collectively as part of Canada’s oil sands industry. We believe the key is collaboration. A great example is the Oil Sands Leadership Initiative where Suncor works closely with four companies to improve environmental, social and economic performance in the oil sands industry. With a shared commitment to excellence and innovation, we can work together to build a more sustainable energy future.
36
in amount of fresh water % decline Suncor has withdrawn from the Athabasca River since 2004*
Vincent Saubestre, executive director, Oil Sands Leadership Initiative
50
1.2
decrease in GHG emission $ %intensity at Suncor’s oil sands operation from 1990 levels*
billion
actual and planned investments in Suncor’s new tailings technology
performance partnerships possibilities
Find out more about Suncor’s track record and how we are planning to responsibly develop North America’s energy supply. www.suncor.com/sustainability
*As at December 31, 2010. ™ Trademark of Suncor Energy Inc.
Mechanical Engineering
Project Management
Site Remediation
Think
Atlantic Canada
Sustainabilit y
Planning and Permitting
Environmental Management Geotechnical and
Materials Engineering
Think
“When revenues are rising, you have the ability to make choices that don’t hurt anybody. But when revenues start to drop, and you have to start cutting, that’s when everybody really feels the pain.”
St. John’s Board of Trade chairman Jo Mark Zurel
Feasibility Studies
AD-DA-MRC-2011JUL25-P1V1
Our Atlantic Canada professionals provide creative and integrated solutions for our clients and communities. With more than 850 dedicated employees across Atlantic Canada, we apply a One Team approach, integrating stakeholders and disciplines to develop environmentally, socially, and economically sustainable solutions.
One Team. Integrated Solutions.
TILLER
TILLER ENGINEERING INC.
Specializing in structural engineering, analysis, design, inspection and mapping. Our fully qualified technical staff are trained to perform aerial inspections safely and with extreme attention to detail. Licensed across Atlantic Canada. Contact
Richard W. Tiller (M.Eng., P.Eng.) President Toll Free:
1.877.907.6700
Telephone: 709.579.6700
Email:
[email protected] St. John’s, NL Canada, A1E 5X7
www.rwtiller.com
56 | Atlantic Business Magazine | September/October 2011
Electrical Engineering
Site Development Electrical, Instrumentation and Controls Engineering
Energy Modeling and LEED ® Facilitation M u ni c ip a l P l a n nin g
Civil Engineering Construction Management
Structural Engineering Commissioning Process Engineering
Strategic Visioning
Machine Design Surveying and Geomatics
BUILDINGS, TOWERS AND OFFSHORE OIL AND GAS FACILITIES • STRUCTURAL ENGINEERING • INSPECTIONS • PROJECT MANAGEMENT
bite out of profits). “It’s extremely difficult to budget,” Marshall said. And the one-time nature of the province’s oil and mineral wealth means the government has a window of opportunity to get its house in order, Marshall said. “The fundamental issue is that we know it’s going to be gone. We suck (the oil) out of the ground, we suck the minerals out of the ground. It’s going to be gone. And it would be a travesty to turn the place over to future generations, and say, ‘By the way, the oil is all gone, the minerals are gone, and our debt is still high.’” The government plans to parlay those non-renewable resource revenues into renewable energy streams. It has pinned its hopes on the $6.2-billion Muskrat Falls hydro project in Labrador, and the subsequent potential development of nearby Gull Island, which is nearly triple the size of Muskrat. Marshall does not see any contradiction in pledging to pay down the debt while taking on billions more in liabilities to build hydro capacity. “(There’s) good debt and bad debt,” he said. “Bad debt is when you borrow to go to Florida. Bad debt is when you bought an asset that went down in value instead of going up in value. Good debt is when you bought an asset that kicked off cash, that paid off the interest and principal of your debt, and grew. And that’s what hydro does. Hydro assets will generate the revenue, pay off the debt, provide us with more money that will allow us to lower hydro costs even further, or to build hospitals, or to do other projects — whatever the government of the day decides. And that’s the difference; that’s a true investment.” According to APEC, it’s just one of the projects that will see billions spent on major developments in the province over the coming years. “We’re doing great — Newfoundland and Labrador, the poor cousin of Confederation,” Marshall said. “It’s amazing.” | ABM
