how do teachers of mathematics teach? a four-way ...

Download PDF
4 downloads 0 Views 247KB Size Report
Comment
Oct 7, 2010 - To cite this article: Paul Andrews & Judy Sayers (2005): HOW DO ... systems in order to learn from them (Le Tendre et al., 2001; Clarke, 2003).
This article was downloaded by: [University of Cambridge] On: 01 February 2012, At: 00:44 Publisher: Routledge Informa Ltd Registered in England and Wales Registered Number: 1072954 Registered office: Mortimer House, 37-41 Mortimer Street, London W1T 3JH, UK

Research in Mathematics Education Publication details, including instructions for authors and subscription information: http://www.tandfonline.com/loi/rrme20

HOW DO TEACHERS OF MATHEMATICS TEACH? A FOUR-WAY INTERNATIONAL COMPARISON a

Paul Andrews & Judy Sayers a

University of Cambridge

b

University of Northampton

b

Available online: 07 Oct 2010

To cite this article: Paul Andrews & Judy Sayers (2005): HOW DO TEACHERS OF MATHEMATICS TEACH? A FOUR-WAY INTERNATIONAL COMPARISON, Research in Mathematics Education, 7:1, 139-158 To link to this article: http://dx.doi.org/10.1080/14794800008520150

PLEASE SCROLL DOWN FOR ARTICLE Full terms and conditions of use: http://www.tandfonline.com/page/terms-and-conditions This article may be used for research, teaching, and private study purposes. Any substantial or systematic reproduction, redistribution, reselling, loan, sub-licensing, systematic supply, or distribution in any form to anyone is expressly forbidden. The publisher does not give any warranty express or implied or make any representation that the contents will be complete or accurate or up to date. The accuracy of any instructions, formulae, and drug doses should be independently verified with primary sources. The publisher shall not be liable for any loss, actions, claims, proceedings, demand, or costs or damages whatsoever or howsoever caused arising directly or indirectly in connection with or arising out of the use of this material.

#

!"# $" %&'(!&)* "+ ,'%!&,'%-(* %&'(!. ' +"/)0#'1 -2%&)2'%-"2'3 (",4')-*"2

Downloaded by [University of Cambridge] at 00:44 01 February 2012

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cFH [>%3 1./ .,).1312,'4 8%)%:,* A58?%+%312, +,.,%+A> %''5-. +,.,%+A>,+. 35 1*,)3164 %)* ,G%81), A+131A%''4 3>5., ?+%A31A,. 56 %)53>,+ .4.3,8 -13> 3>, ?53,)31%' 65+ 1)A5+?5+%315) 1)35 3>,1+ 5-)H ( +,A,)3/ 3>5&:> ?55+'4 8%)%:,*/ ,G%8?', -%. 3>, 1)A5+?5+%315) 56 3>, S-%+8Q&?V ?>%., 65&)* 1) 8%)4 O&):%+1%) ',..5). 1)35 3>, =%315)%' =&8,+%A4 +,, ?%+3 ',..5)H %!& 4)"5&(% [>, R%3>,8%31A. ,*&A%315) 3+%*1315). 56 Z&+5?, CRZ[ZF ?+5d,A3 1. % Z&+5?,%) 0)15)Q6&)*,*/ .3&*4 56 3>, 3,%A>1): 56 8%3>,8%31A. 1) b',81.> ^,':1&8/ Z):'%)*/ b1)'%)*/ O&):%+4 %)* ()*%'&A1%)