2010 Board meeting in conjunction with the NCEES Western Zone Meeting as ....
Boise State University mechanical engineering seniors on the Rules of.
BOARD OF PROFESSIONAL ENGINEERS AND PROFESSIONAL LAND SURVEYORS Minutes of Meeting The Board of Professional Engineers and Professional Land Surveyors held a regular meeting on June 3-4, 2010 at the Homewood Suites, Boise, Idaho, to conduct Board business. The meeting convened at 8:10 a.m. on Thursday, June 3, 2010 with the following Board members present: Gary Young, James H. Milligan, John W. Howe, David Bennion and George Wagner. Also present was David L. Curtis, Executive Director, Jim Szatkowski, Deputy Director and Jennifer Rowe, Administrative Assistant. i.
AGENDA REVIEW - Are there any new agenda items?
Mr. Szatkowski completed a Preliminary Investigation for docket FY10.27 and this information will be added to this item for discussion and review by the Board. Mr. Milligan would like to schedule a visit to the new office building in Meridian. The Board will visit the new building Thursday evening. I.
READING OF MINUTES
1.
Approval of minutes of the February 11-13, 2010 Board meeting as distributed.
Moved by Mr. Milligan, seconded by Mr. Howe to approve the minutes of the February 11-13, 2010 Board meeting as distributed. Motion passed unanimously. 2.
Approval of minutes of the March 11-13, 2010 Board meeting as distributed.
Moved by Mr. Milligan, seconded by Mr. Howe to approve the minutes of the March 1113, 2010 Board meeting as distributed. Motion passed unanimously. 3.
Approval of minutes of the May 15, 2010 Board meeting in conjunction with the NCEES Western Zone Meeting as distributed.
Moved by Mr. Milligan, seconded by Mr. Howe to approve the minutes of the May 15, 2010 Board meeting in conjunction with the NCEES Western Zone Meeting as distributed. Motion passed unanimously. II.
REVIEW AND APPROVAL OF CONSENT AGENDA
1.
The following items have been continued at previous meetings and staff is unaware of any activity relating to these matters: a. FY08.23a: Munio, Albert, unlicensed practice FY08.23b: Bessaw, John W., P.E., violations of statutes and Rules of Professional Responsibility
June 3 – 4, 2010
4324
FY08.23c: Washington Group International, violations of statutes and Rules of Professional Responsibility. An ORDER extending the time until 6 months after the end of litigation has been signed.
2.
b. FY09.25
Tikker, Robert, rules of professional responsibility. This matter is pending completion of civil litigation.
c. FY10.08
Spaulding, Scott, standard of care. This matter is pending completion of course work.
d. FY10.09
Lund, Michael, Rules of Professional Responsibility. A preliminary investigation has been authorized. On advice of Counsel, the investigation has been halted pending the outcome of an investigation by the Office of the Attorney General.
ISPE nominated George Wagner to serve on the Board.
Moved by Mr. Milligan, seconded by Mr. Bennion to note the items on the Consent Agenda with no further action. Motion passed unanimously. III.
UNFINISHED BUSINESS
1.
Review Strategic Plan Objectives. Mr. Young stated that Goal 3 Objective B will no longer be necessary effective July 1, 2010.
Moved by Mr. Milligan, seconded by Mr. Howe to approve changes to Strategic Plan by eliminating Goal 3 Objective B. Motion passed unanimously. 3.
A subcommittee of Mr. Young and Mr. Bennion will report progress on reviewing state job descriptions in terms of engineering without licensure requirements.
Mr. Young reviewed the DHR descriptions for engineering and found no discrepancies. Geologist and Geologist Engineering Assistant do not require licensing as an engineer, but require a geologist background. The Board discussed the overlap or “gray areas” of engineering and geology and work being done in the private sector versus the public sector. There are some Public Television Broadcast Engineer descriptions that do not really include professional engineering but rather maintenance and operations. Moved by Mr. Milligan, seconded by Mr. Bennion to authorize the Chair to sign a letter to Mr. Falk stating that the Board reviewed the DHR position descriptions and while the actual unlicensed practice of engineering is a broader issue and has to be dealt with on a case-by-case basis, we do not see the need to pursue the matter further. Motion passed unanimously.
June 3 – 4, 2010
4325
5.
A subcommittee of Mr. Bennion, Mr. Milligan and Mr. Szatkowski met with representatives of ITD to review whether Storm Water Prevention Plans need to be stamped. There has been no further communication with ITD on this matter.
Moved by Mr. Milligan, seconded by Mr. Howe to close this matter. Motion passed unanimously. 8.
An Item Writing Workshop was held March 8 & 9, 2010 in Moscow in advance of the ISPLS Annual Meeting. The Workshop was conducted by Jack and Steve Warner of TEST, Inc. out of Aurora, Colorado. Staff would like the Board to consider appointing a subcommittee to develop the final July 2010 version of the Idaho State-Specific PLS exam. Mr. Milligan suggested that we should require a listing of a reference to justify the correct answer and that each distracter needs a clear and documented rationale. The Board noted the suggestion and directed Mr. Howe and Mr. Young to evaluate new items and prepare new exam.
11.
David Kelly would like to obtain a license in Idaho based on comity with his Oregon license. He is licensed as a Traffic Engineer and took a State-Specific exam for licensure. Is this exam equivalent to an NCEES PE exam? Staff obtained a copy of the exam from California. Mr. Milligan reviewed the examination and reported to the Board that the examination is sufficient for approval as a Traffic Engineering examination.
Moved by Mr. Milligan, seconded by Mr. Bennion to approve the examination for licensing purposes and if we get a candidate for comity who has taken and passed it, and is otherwise qualified, we should license them as a professional engineer especially qualified in Traffic Engineering. Staff is directed to consider such applicants as nonstandard. The Board authorized the Chair to inform Mr. Kelly that if he applies for a license in Idaho his education and experience will also need to meet the requirements of Idaho Code and will be evaluated by the Board. Motion passed with Mr. Wagner voting against the motion. IV.
NEW BUSINESS
1.
Reports by Board Members and Staff of activities since the March Board meeting. Mr. Milligan attended a Civil PE exam committee meeting April 22-25, 2010 in Clemson, SC; attended the NCEES Western Zone meeting where he presented the EPE committee report; attended an Architectural Engineering Cut Score Panel May 23-25, 2010 in Kansas City, MO with a follow up telephone call on May 26, 2010. Mr. Milligan has been named Chair of EPE and was asked to be a consultant to the Exam Audit Committee as well as CBT and EPP. Mr. Curtis participated in a webinar for MBAs on ABET; made a presentation to Boise State University mechanical engineering seniors on the Rules of Professional responsibility; attended the ACEC-Idaho April and May meetings; attended the ISPLS SW Chapter meeting to provide a presentation on Board
June 3 – 4, 2010
4326
issues; attended the APEGGA Annual Meeting in Alberta, Canada; participated in a CBT Conference Call; made a presentation to University of Idaho electrical engineering sophomores on licensing; attended the NCEES Western Zone meeting, and provided a post mortem account of the University of Idaho PE Review class. Mr. Szatkowski attended a subcommittee meeting with architects and subsequent meetings with DBS, DPW AIC, the IDABO Executive Director; attended the NCEES Western Zone meeting, and made a presentation to the Utah Engineers on enforcement trends. Mr. Howe attended the Survey Board Member Forum at ACSM in Phoenix, AZ; attended the NCEES Western Zone meeting; attended the ISPLS Board of Governors meeting; attended 2 ISPLS Northern Section meetings and has been invited to be on the NCEES EPS committee. Mr. Young attended a subcommittee meeting with architects; attended the APEGGA Annual Meeting in Alberta, Canada and attended the NCEES Western Zone meeting. 2.
Staff presented an Expense Reimbursement Summary for the Executive Director from March 1, 2010 to May 31, 2010 for the Board’s review.
Moved by Mr. Milligan, seconded by Mr. Bennion to approve the expense reimbursement summary as presented. Motion passed unanimously. 3.
ISPLS would like to encourage ISPE to nominate a dual license holder for Mr. Young’s position on the Board when his term ends in 2011.
Moved by Mr. Milligan, seconded by Mr. Howe to note the request. Motion passed unanimously. 4.
Lewis-Clark State College is considering offering a Bachelor of Technology in Surveying through a link to courses at Idaho State University.
Moved by Mr. Milligan, seconded by Mr. Howe to request the full curriculum and identification of courses taught by Idaho State University and those by Lewis-Clark State College. The Chair will send a letter to LCSC letting them know that there appears to be deficiencies in relation to the 27 prescriptive credits in the Board Administrative Rules. Motion passed unanimously. 5.
If an applicant was continued for additional coursework, what is the minimum final course grade earned that is acceptable?
Moved by Mr. Bennion, seconded by Mr. Milligan to authorize the Chair to send a letter to the candidate and inform him that the Board does not consider a “D” a satisfactory June 3 – 4, 2010
4327
grade for purposes of qualifying additional education for assignment to a subsequent examination. Motion passed unanimously. 6.
Staff drafted a NEWS BULLETIN for the Board’s review.
Moved by Mr. Milligan, seconded by Mr. Howe to approve the NEWS BULLETIN as amended. Motion passed unanimously. 7.
NCEES Education Criteria has a new proposal for a NCEES Standard for education.
Moved by Mr. Milligan, seconded by Mr. Bennion to note this item as it will be reviewed in more detail at the Board Retreat in August. Motion passed unanimously. 8.
Under the current CPD rules, engineers are exempt from the effective date of the CPD requirement (May 8, 2009) to their next biennial renewal. The Board established a policy that any CPD PDH’s earned by an engineer during the renewal biennium in which the exempt period falls may be carried forward to the next renewal biennium (up to a maximum of 30 PDH’s). If an individual takes and passes the PE exam after May 8, 2008, they are exempt from the CPD requirement during the time between issuance of their license and their next regular biennial renewal. Would the Board approve carrying forward any CPD PDH’s earned by that engineer during the renewal biennium in which that exempt period falls?
Moved by Mr. Milligan, seconded by Mr. Bennion to approve carrying forward any CPD PDH’s earned by an engineer during the renewal biennium in which that exempt period falls up to a maximum of 30 PDHs. Motion passed unanimously. 9.
Is it be acceptable for an individual trying to obtain the additional 8 semester credits needed after failing the FE exam twice to count the FE Review Course in those credits, even though the course was taken previously?
Moved by Mr. Milligan, seconded by Mr. Howe to authorize the Chair to write to candidate and inform her that the FE review course is not allowed as additional education to qualify for assignment to exam, and repeat is not allowed either. Motion passed unanimously. 10.
DEQ created a brochure on how to hire an engineer.
Moved by Mr. Wagner, seconded by Mr. Milligan to authorize the Chair to send a letter to DEQ complimenting them on their brochure, and suggest that they submit a copy of it to the QBS Facilitation Committee for their comments. DEQ may even want to provide information on that group in the brochure. Motion passed unanimously.
June 3 – 4, 2010
4328
11.
Mr. Truchot will be out of the country for an extended period of time making it difficult for him to complete his CPD.
Moved by Mr. Milligan, seconded by Mr. Bennion to authorize the Chair to write to Mr. Truchot and let him know that the Board will allow earning the PDHs required to be postponed for 6 months after returning to the USA for a period of at least 6 months. Staff directed to develop amendments to Administrative Rule for future consideration by the Board. Motion passed unanimously. 12.
John Dunn, P.L.S., Latah County Surveyor asked the Board to express an opinion.
Moved by Mr. Howe, seconded by Mr. Bennion to authorize the Chair to write a letter to Mr. Dunn and inform him that a Record of Survey is not required for mere replacement of lot corner unless any of the “triggers” in the Record of Survey law exist. Motion passed unanimously. 13.
Staff presented proposed meeting dates for calendar year 2011.
Moved by Mr. Milligan, seconded by Mr. Wagner to approve calendar year 2011 meeting dates of the following: • • • • • •
February 10-12, 2011 April 7-9, 2011 June 9-11, 2011 August 4-6, 2011 board Retreat August 31, September 1-2, 2011 November 17-19, 2011
Motion passed unanimously with Mr. Bennion absent. 14.
Staff provided an update on the Board’s financial status as of April 30, 2010.
Moved by Mr. Milligan, seconded by Mr. Howe to note the information. Motion passed with Mr. Bennion absent. 15.
Mr. Curtis received an email from NCEES regarding a possible collusion occurrence on the FE exam.
Moved by Mr. Milligan, seconded by Mr. Wagner to authorize staff to work with Mr. Naylor to conduct an investigation using NCEES guidelines and direct staff to not release the exam results to the individuals under investigation. Motion passed unanimously with Mr. Bennion absent. V.
CONSIDERATION OF APPLICATIONS
TERMINATIONS June 3 – 4, 2010
4329
All individuals listed were contacted multiple times about the need for more information, none responded. Baek, Seung II (FE) Barr, Matthew John (PLS by comity with Colorado) Barrett, Lou M. (PLS by comity with Utah) Braughton, Russell D. (PLS by comity with Oregon) Brewer, Finis Howard (PLS by comity with Washington) Briggs, Randal L. (PLS by comity with Nevada) Chappell, Carl William (PE(FpE) by exam) Chidley, Douglas J. (PE(CE) by comity with Illinois) Dhungel, Ramesh (FE) Eldridge, Ryan A. (PE(Civil) by comity with New Mexico) Fontenot, Eric John (PE(CE by comity with Pennsylvania) Fox, Karl (FE) Gaithuma, David Rubia (PE(CE) by exam) Gough, Adrian Stuart (FE) Greer, Lance Paul (PLS by comity with Utah) Lott, Lewis John (PE(CE) by comity with Colorado) Miller, Gerald E. (PE(ME) by exam) Rogers, Robert (PE(ME) by comity with Oregon) Selman, Mark Ernest (PE(EnvE) by comity with Colorado) Sheldon, Shane (FE) Vangari, Sandeep (FE) Warriner, Joel A. (PE(CE) by comity with Virginia) Whited, Keith William (PE(ME) by comity with Connecticut) Williams, Kevin Arthur (PLS by comity with Montana) Willingham, William E. (PE(EE) by comity with Washington) Zhang, Song (FE) Bussard Williams, LLC Petra Engineering, LLC Moved by Mr. Milligan, seconded by Mr. Howe to terminate the applications referenced above. Motion passed unanimously with Mr. Bennion absent. Mr. Kane joined the meeting. III.
UNFINISHED BUSINESS
2.
Jim Baker, (ISPE and URS-Washington Division), submitted a question regarding the QBS law and its applications regarding pricing requests from government entities. Mr. Kane researched this matter and discussed his findings with the Board.
June 3 – 4, 2010
4330
Moved by Mr. Milligan, seconded by Mr. Wagner to direct Mr. Kane to look further into the law and rule and re-evaluate interpretation based on Board input. The Board authorizes the Chair to send a letter to Mr. Baker and inform him that we are continuing to discuss the matter and request his authorization to forward his inquiry to QBS. The Board is working with our legal counsel on the matter. Board directs staff to include an article on the QBS Facilitation Council and their role and services in the next NEWS BULLETIN. Motion passed unanimously. 4.
Mr. Howe and Mr. Young worked in conjunction with ISPLS to draft amendments to the surveying laws. Draft document of changes were distributed for comment.
Moved by Mr. Milligan, seconded by Mr. Bennion to authorize staff to develop “final” draft legislation for submittal to DFM. Motion passed unanimously. 6.
Comments were received on the Discussion Paper on Board Composition.
Moved by Mr. Wagner, seconded by Mr. Milligan to authorize Mr. Bennion to contact ACEC-Idaho and authorize Mr. Howe to contact ISPLS and report back to the Board the status of any joint committee of ACEC/ISPE/ISPLS regarding Board composition. Motion passed unanimously. 7.
Lance King requested that the Board reconsider some courses outlined in the Final Order.
Moved by Mr. Milligan, seconded by Mr. Young to enter into executive session to consider records that are exempt from disclosure as provided for by Idaho Code 672345(1)(d). Roll call vote results; Mr. Milligan, yes; Mr. Young, yes; Mr. Bennion, yes; Mr. Howe, yes and Mr. Wagner, yes. After meeting in executive session, the Chairman directed the Board to return to regular session. Moved by Mr. Howe, seconded by Mr. Milligan to reject Mr. King’s proposed TVCC Math 060 as it is not the equivalent of the ISU courses CET 110 and 120 as required in the FINAL ORDER. The Board suggests that he come forth with other alternative courses and submit them for Board consideration. Motion passed unanimously. 9.
Mr. Szatkowski updated the Board on the status of the Architects/Engineers subcommittee progress. AIC and IDABO will be meeting on June 16th in Idaho Falls and the Board subcommittee is invited to attend.
Moved by Mr. Bennion, seconded by Mr. Milligan to authorize Mr. Szatkowski and Mr. Young to attend the meeting in Idaho Falls. Motion passed unanimously. 10.
Staff scheduled a Negotiated Rule Making Meeting for 9:00 a.m. June 15, 2010 at Len B. Jordan Building Conference Room 302. The document provided contains the suggested amendments which are available for final editing by the Board.
June 3 – 4, 2010
4331
Moved by Mr. Bennion, seconded by Mr. Milligan to change 14 days to 20 days in the definition of misconduct. Motion passed with Mr. Wagner voting against the motion. VI.
CONSIDERATION OF DISCIPLINARY ACTIONS
FY08.41
Root, John. Mr. Curtis reviewed surveys submitted by Mr. Root as required in the Stipulation and Consent Order.
Moved by Mr. Young, seconded by Mr. Milligan to enter into executive session to consider records that are exempt from disclosure as provided for by Idaho Code 672345(1)(d). Roll call vote results; Mr. Milligan, yes; Mr. Young, yes; Mr. Bennion, yes; Mr. Howe, yes and Mr. Wagner, yes. After meeting in executive session, the Chairman directed the Board to return to regular session. Moved by Mr. Milligan, seconded by Mr. Howe to continue this docket. Motion passed unanimously. FY09.01
Green, Richard, violations of ROPR. Mr. Green completed the requirements of the Stipulation and Consent Agreement.
Moved by Mr. Howe, seconded by Mr. Milligan to close this docket. Motion passed unanimously. FY09.23
Spaulding, Scott, standard of care. Mr. Spaulding completed the Engineering Ethics course as required in the Stipulation and Consent Order.
Moved by Mr. Milligan, seconded by Mr. Howe to close this docket. Motion passed unanimously. FY10.11
Pearsons, Elaine C., license was suspended for failing to meet requirements of Stipulation and Consent Order.
Moved by Mr. Bennion, seconded by Mr. Howe to enter into executive session to consider records that are exempt from disclosure as provided for by Idaho Code 672345(1)(d). Roll call vote results; Mr. Bennion, yes; Mr. Howe, yes; Mr. Young, yes; Mr. Milligan, yes and Mr. Wagner, yes. After meeting in executive session, the Chairman directed the Board to return to regular session. Moved by Mr. Howe, seconded by Mr. Bennion to reinstate Ms. Pearsons’ license and close this docket. Motion passed unanimously. FY10.18
Forsgren Associates, Inc. Rules of Professional Responsibility. This matter was continued pending the outcome of civil litigation. Mr. Lund was notified of the continuance and he submitted a response to the Board’s ORDER.
June 3 – 4, 2010
4332
Moved by Mr. Howe, seconded by Mr. Milligan to enter into executive session to consider records that are exempt from disclosure as provided for by Idaho Code 672345(1)(d). Roll call vote results; Mr. Milligan, yes; Mr. Young, yes; Mr. Bennion, yes; Mr. Howe, yes and Mr. Wagner, yes. After meeting in executive session, the Chairman directed the Board to return to regular session. Moved by Mr. Milligan, seconded by Mr. Bennion to authorize the Chair to write to Mr. Lund and notify him that on advice of counsel we will not conduct the investigation until such time as the Attorney General’s investigation is completed. Motion passed unanimously. FY10.20
Busby, Byron D., unlicensed practice as a surveyor, setting pin. A preliminary investigation was completed in this matter. Mr. Kane suggested that the Board may want to refer this to the Attorney General’s office.
Moved by Mr. Bennion, seconded by Mr. Howe to enter into executive session to consider records that are exempt from disclosure as provided for by Idaho Code 672345(1)(d). Roll call vote results; Mr. Bennion, yes; Mr. Howe, yes; Mr. Young, yes; Mr. Milligan, yes and Mr. Wagner, yes. After meeting in executive session, the Chairman directed the Board to return to regular session. Moved by Mr. Milligan, seconded by Mr. Bennion to authorize Counsel to write to Mr. Busby and inform him that he may have intentionally or unintentionally practiced land surveying without being licensed to do so. If found guilty of such an act it would be a criminal misdemeanor. Threaten to send any future allegations to the Attorney General’s Office for criminal prosecution. The Chair will send a letter to complainant informing her that original property pin is still in place and she may have opportunities for redress through the civil courts. If advised by Counsel, release Preliminary Investigation following his further research on the matter. Motion passed with Mr. Howe voting against the motion. FY10.21
Formusa, Brian R., failure to sign, stamp report.
Moved by Mr. Milligan, seconded by Mr. Howe to authorize staff to conduct a Preliminary Investigation in this matter. Motion passed unanimously. FY10.22
Stearns, John M., CPD deficiency
Moved by Mr. Young, seconded by Mr. Milligan to enter into executive session to consider records that are exempt from disclosure as provided for by Idaho Code 672345(1)(d). Roll call vote results; Mr. Milligan, yes; Mr. Young, yes; Mr. Bennion, yes; Mr. Howe, yes and Mr. Wagner, yes. After meeting in executive session, the Chairman directed the Board to return to regular session.
June 3 – 4, 2010
4333
Moved by Mr. Milligan, seconded by Mr. Bennion to authorize staff to negotiate a Stipulation and Consent Order. Motion passed unanimously. FY10.23
Terragraphics Environmental Engineering, Inc. himself in this matter.
Mr. Howe recused
Moved by Mr. Milligan, seconded by Mr. Bennion to authorize staff to conduct a Preliminary Investigation in this matter. Motion passed with Mr. Howe recused. FY10.24
Trane US, unlicensed – No COA - in conjunction with FY10.25
Moved by Mr. Bennion, seconded by Mr. Howe to enter into executive session to consider records that are exempt from disclosure as provided for by Idaho Code 672345(1)(d). Roll call vote results; Mr. Bennion, yes; Mr. Howe, yes; Mr. Young, yes; Mr. Milligan, yes and Mr. Wagner, yes. After meeting in executive session, the Chairman directed the Board to return to regular session. Moved by Mr. Milligan, seconded by Mr. Wagner to authorize this matter be turned over to Attorney General’s Office for criminal prosecution. If the Attorney General is not willing to prosecute, seek appointment of private practice attorney as Special Deputy Attorney General to contract with the Attorney General, and agree to pay for services. Motion passed unanimously. FY10.25
ES2, unlicensed – failure to seal, sign and date documents.
Moved by Mr. Howe, seconded by Mr. Young to enter into executive session to consider records that are exempt from disclosure as provided for by Idaho Code 67-2345(1)(d). Roll call vote results; Mr. Milligan, yes; Mr. Howe, yes; Mr. Bennion, yes; Mr. Young, yes and Mr. Wagner, yes. After meeting in executive session, the Chairman directed the Board to return to regular session. Moved by Mr. Milligan, seconded by Mr. Howe to authorize staff to negotiate a Stipulation and Consent Order in this matter. Motion passed unanimously. FY10.26
Barrett, Robert D., renewal irregularity
Moved by Mr. Bennion, seconded by Mr. Howe to authorize the Chair to send a letter to Mr. Barrett notifying him that we have closed the matter. Motion passed unanimously. FY10.27
Stoddard, Steven Scott, Failure to file ROS
Moved by Mr. Young, seconded by Mr. Milligan to enter into executive session to consider records that are exempt from disclosure as provided for by Idaho Code 672345(1)(d). Roll call vote results; Mr. Milligan, yes; Mr. Young, yes; Mr. Bennion, yes; Mr. Howe, yes and Mr. Wagner, yes. After meeting in executive session, the Chairman directed the Board to return to regular session. June 3 – 4, 2010
4334
Moved by Mr. Milligan, seconded by Mr. Howe to direct staff to continue investigation, verify existence of Records of Survey and report findings at next Board meeting. Motion passed unanimously. V.
CONSIDERATION OF APPLICATIONS
Moved by Mr. Bennion, seconded by Mr. Howe to enter into executive session to consider records that are exempt from disclosure as provided for by Idaho Code 672345(1)(d). Roll call vote results; Mr. Bennion, yes; Mr. Howe, yes; Mr. Young, yes; Mr. Milligan, yes and Mr. Wagner, yes. After meeting in executive session, the Chairman directed the Board to return to regular session. NON-STANDARD – COMITY Moved by Mr. Milligan, seconded by Mr. Howe to approve the following applications for comity licensure: • • • • •
Rex Doyle Brown for licensure as a professional engineer especially qualified in electrical engineering on the basis of comity with his licensure in Washington. Jane Marie Costello for licensure as a professional engineer especially qualified in environmental engineering on the basis of comity with her licensure in Wisconsin. Kevin J. Haiar for the addition of structural engineering to his current Idaho licensure. Jon Menough for licensure as a professional engineer especially qualified in civil engineering on the basis of comity with his licensure in Alaska. Ken Thomason for licensure as a professional land surveyor on the basis of comity with his licensure in Washington.
Motion passed unanimously. Moved by Mr. Howe, seconded by Mr. Bennion to continue the application of Gregory A. Cates for licensure as a professional land surveyor on the basis of his licensure in Utah for additional documentation. Motion passed with Mr. Milligan voting against the motion. Moved by Mr. Milligan, seconded by Mr. Bennion to approve the application of Scott D. Fein for licensure as a professional land surveyor on the basis of the passage of the Principles and Practice of Surveying examination in Oregon. Motion passed with Mr. Howe voting against the motion. Moved by Mr. Bennion, seconded by Mr. Milligan to reconsider the previous motion. Motion passed unanimously. Moved by Mr. Howe, seconded by Mr. Bennion to approve the application of Scott D. Fein for licensure as a professional land surveyor on the basis of the passage of the Principles and Practice of Surveying examination in Oregon pending successful licensure June 3 – 4, 2010
4335
in Oregon within one year and completion of an additional 5 semester credits of surveying. Motion passed unanimously. Moved by Mr. Milligan, seconded by Mr. Bennion to deny the application of Bruce Mathieson Johnston for licensure as a professional engineer especially qualified in control systems engineering on the basis of comity with his licensure in Washington. Motion passed unanimously. Moved by Mr. Milligan, seconded by Mr. Howe to deny the application of Brian Douglas Leach for licensure as a professional engineer especially qualified in civil engineering on the basis of comity with his licensure in Washington. Motion passed unanimously. Moved by Mr. Milligan, seconded by Mr. Bennion to approve the application of Jeffery T. Moog for licensure as a professional land surveyor on the basis of his licensure in Washington. Motion passed with Mr. Howe voting against the motion. Moved by Mr. Milligan to approve the application of William John Pilkington for licensure as a professional land surveyor on the basis of the passage of the Principles and Practice of Surveying examination in Wyoming. Motion failed for lack of a second. Moved by Mr. Howe, seconded by Mr. Bennion to approve the application of William John Pilkington for licensure as a professional land surveyor on the basis of the passage of the Principles and Practice of Surveying examination in Wyoming pending successful licensure in Wyoming within one year. Motion passed unanimously. Moved by Mr. Howe, seconded by Mr. Milligan to deny the application of Scott H. Shurtliff for licensure as a professional engineer especially qualified in civil engineering on the basis of comity with his licensure in Arizona. Motion passed unanimously. Moved by Mr. Howe to continue the application of Ede J. Vessey for licensure as a professional engineer especially qualified in structural engineering on the basis of his licensure in Texas pending additional documentation. Motion died for lack of a second. Moved by Mr. Milligan, seconded by Mr. Bennion to approve the application of Ede J. Vessey for licensure as a professional engineer especially qualified in structural engineering on the basis of his licensure in Texas. Motion passed unanimously. Moved by Mr. Milligan, seconded by Mr. Bennion to deny the request from Charles Alan Wall for the addition of the discipline of structural engineering to his current Idaho license. Motion passed unanimously. Moved by Mr. Milligan, seconded by Mr. Howe to deny the application of Wayne Andrew Yevoli for licensure as a professional engineer especially qualified in mechanical engineering on the basis of comity with his licensure in Colorado. Motion passed unanimously.
June 3 – 4, 2010
4336
NON-STANDARD – EXAMINATION Moved by Mr. Bennion, seconded by Mr. Milligan to assign Craig Eldon Dees to the Principles and Practice of Engineering examination in the mechanical discipline. Motion passed unanimously. Moved by Mr. Milligan, seconded by Mr. Howe to issue Tyson Glahe’s Land Surveyor Intern certificate based on his completion of the educational requirements. Motion passed unanimously. Moved by Mr. Milligan, seconded by Mr. Howe to deny the application of Clinton R. Stone for assignment to the Principles and Practice of Surveying examination. Motion passed unanimously. The Board noted the issuance of professional engineer licenses to the following individuals since the last meeting of the Board. They are listed by name, discipline and the comity state as indicated: Robert L. Annear (Environmental) DHI Water & Environment, Inc. 319 S.W. Washington St. Ste. 614 Portland, OR 97204
Oregon
Armen Baroonian (Civil, Structural) B & B Associates, Inc. 1111 S. Arroyo Pkwy, Ste. 450 Pasadena, CA 91105
California
Tom L. Bauwens (Civil) 400 S. Granite Way Boise, ID 83712
Wisconsin
Danny D. Beal (Civil) 3050 Lostwood Dr Sandy, UT 84092
Utah
David K. Boatman (Civil) 20875 E. Country Club Loop Brightwood, OR 97011
Oregon
James Armstrong Bouche (Fire Protection) F.E. Moran Inc, Special Hazard Systems 2265 Carlson Drive Northbrook, IL 60062
Indiana
June 3 – 4, 2010
4337
Shannon K. Brattebo (Environmental) Tetra Tech, Inc. 1235 N. Post St. Ste, 101 Spokane, WA 99201
South Dakota
William Thomas Brown (Mechanical) 2938 Vista Arroyo Dr. Camarillo, CA 93012
California
Edward R. Burke (Civil) 1415 North 13th Street Boise, ID 83702
Utah
Nathan Byers (Mechanical) Sider + Byers Associates, Inc. 192 Nickerson St., Suite 300 Seattle, WA 98109
California
Daniel J. Clayton (Civil) Reynolds Smith And Hills 10748 Deerwood Park Blvd. S. Jacksonville, FL 32256
Florida
Norman Edward Cowden (Mechanical) Sentry Engineering Group, Inc. 1032 Old Peachtree Rd. #401-139 Lawrenceville, GA 30043
Alabama
Alicia I. Crump (Civil) Structural Technology Consultants 7827 Convoy Court Ste. 406 San Diego, CA 92111
California
Thomas Hoyt Denney (Mechanical) GPW & Associates, LLC 1001 New Hampshire Lawrence, KS 66044
Kansas
James Patrick Dowhaniuk (Electrical) 11715 S.W. Fairview Lane Tigard, OR 97223
Oregon
Jeffrey Douglas Drummond (Electrical) 1420 N.W. Lovejoy St. #521 Portland, OR 97209
California
June 3 – 4, 2010
4338
David W. Edwards (Civil) 875 Holly Lane Canton, GA 30115
Georgia
Brandon D. Enevold (Electrical) MW Consulting Engineers N. 222 Wall Street Ste. 200 Spokane, WA 99201
Washington
Mark Ewbank (Civil) Herrera Environmental Cons. 2200 Sixth Ave. #1100 Seattle, WA 98121-1820
Illinois
John Edward Fee (Mechanical) 32 Brentwood Road Eatontown, NJ 07724
New Jersey
Leo J. Florence Jr. (Civil) 1172 E. Gavin Cricle Draper, UT 84020
Utah
Timothy J. Fry (Civil, Structural) Lionakis 1919 19th Street Sacramento, CA 95811
California
Rembert A. Gomez (Mechanical) 11035 Ramp Creek Lane Sugar Land, TX 77498
North Carolina
Clark Bernard Goodlett (Electrical) 840 N.W. Naito Pkwy., Unit H-10 Portland, OR 97209
Oregon
Steven J. Gridley (Mechanical) H. F. Lenz Company 1407 Scalp Avenue Johnstown, PA 15904
Pennsylvania
David L. Hagen (Civil) Telesto Nevada, Inc. 5490 Longley Lane Reno, NV 89511
California
June 3 – 4, 2010
4339
Deborah L. Harkey (Electrical) 2615 Roswell Avenue Charlotte, NC 28209
North Carolina
Brent Jarred Harland (Civil) Stanley Consultants, Inc. 5820 S. Eastern Ave. Ste. 140 Las Vegas, NV 89119
Nevada
Edsel R. Harrison Jr. (Civil) Harrison Engineering 430 Walnut Avenue Klamath Falls, OR 97601
California
Robert V. Hood (Civil) P.O. Box 93 Auburn, WY 83111
Wyoming
William A. Hultman (Civil) Shannon & Wilson, Inc. 400 N. 34th St. Ste. 100 Seattle, WA 98103-8636
Washington
Andrew J. Huseman (Civil) 715 N. Ash Drive Chandler, AZ 85224
Arizona
Ronald Scott Johnson (Civil) Geosyntec Consultants 10875 Rancho Bernardo Rd. #200 San Diego, CA 92127
California
David C. Kahly (Electrical) 913 N. Goldenrod Ct., Box 2 Post Falls, ID 83854
Minnesota
Christopher Michael Klopp (Mechanical) 508 E. Penn Street Topton, PA 19562
Pennsylvania
Christopher Charles Knodel (Environmental) States West Water Resources Corp 59 Western Avenue Buffalo, WY 82834
Wyoming
June 3 – 4, 2010
4340
Jonathan I Krombein (Electrical) 219 NE 91st Street Seattle, WA 98115
Washington
Kjersten E. Kuhta (Mechanical) MW Consulting Engineers N 222 Wall Street, Ste. 200 Spokane, WA 99201-0813
Washington
Lowell J. Larson (Electrical) Reister Engineering, Inc. 1440 21 Street. Ste. 100 Rockford, IL 61108
Illinois
Rebecca D Lindeman (Civil) P.O. Box 772143 Steamboat Springs, CO 80487
Colorado
Matthew O'Neal Marshall (Mechanical) Case, Lowe, And Hart, Inc. 2484 Wshington Blvd. Ste. 510 Ogden, UT 84401
Alabama
Alice E. Maupin (Civil) 1701 Clinton St. #309 Los Angeles, CA 90026
California
Vernon Louis McAllister (Electrical) Stanley Consultants, Inc. 225 Iowa Ave. Muscatine, IA 52761
Iowa
Ryan David McGraw (Civil) Blazer Industries, Inc. P.O. Box 489 Aumsville, OR 97325-0489
Oklahoma
Roland McPherson (Civil, Structural) McPherson Design Group, P.C. 6371 Center Dr. Ste. 100 Norfolk, VA 23502
Virginia
Kevin L Merrill (Civil) 616 Wild Rose Lane San Dimas, CA 91773
California
June 3 – 4, 2010
4341
David J. Morrone (Electrical) WH Pacific, Inc. 6501 Americas Pkwy. N.E. #400 Albuquerque, NM 87110
Washington
Brian W. Ness (Civil) P.O. Box 2448 Eagle, ID 83616
Michigan
Patrick J. O'Connor (Civil) 6412 W. Kitsap Drive Spokane, WA 99208
Washington
Randall Delon Peterson (Mining/Mineral) 11602 Colchester Drive Sandy, UT 84092
Utah
David J. Peterson (Civil) Watershape Consulting, Inc. 3830 Valley Ctr. Dr. Ste. 705-316 San Diego, CA 92130-3307
California
Thomas Popelka IV (Civil) Steelplanit, LLC P.O. Box 3460 Temple, TX 76505-3460
Texas
Rachel S. Price (Civil) Reid Middleton 728 134th St., Sw #200 Everett, WA 98204
Wisconsin
Brian R. Reese (Civil) 1044 St. John's Road Drums, PA 18222
Pennsylvania
Glen E. Rieger Jr. (Civil) 3186 Allison Drive Gibsonia, PA 15044
Pennsylvania
David A Roggenkamp (Civil,Structural) Roggenkamp Structural Engineers PC 9901 N.E. 7th Ave. Ste. B233 Vancouver, WA 98685
California
June 3 – 4, 2010
4342
Joseph Edward Rottman (Civil) 8730 West Mountain View Lane Littleton, CO 80125
Colorado
Rifaat Sammy Salem (Civil) 4195 W. Sample Avenue Fresno, CA 93722
California
Ryan James Seavert (Civil) 13725 Prairie Court Becker, MN 55308
Minnesota
Danna James Snyder (Civil) 3135 Rosewood Circle Saint George, UT 84790
Utah
Tony E. Stenlund (Civil) Thomas, Dean & Hoskins, Inc. 303 E. 2nd Ave. Spokane, WA 99202
Washington
Aaron Lee Storo (Civil) Pike Energy Solutions 700 N.E. Multnomah St. Ste. 500 Portland, OR 97232
Minnesota
Andrew J. Stouppe (Civil, Structural) 20577 NE 32nd Court Sammamish, WA 90104
Connecticut
Robert Lynn Stratton (Civil) 5944 W. Grayeagle Rd. Rathdrum, ID 83858
Washington
Andrew J. Suedkamp (Geological) Ground Engineering Consultants, Inc. 41 Inverness Drive East Englewood, CO 80112
Colorado
Michael F. Sullaway (Civil) 9616 Deer Trail Drive San Diego, CA 92127
California
Aaron E. Swenson (Civil) 266 Jill Drive Rexburg, ID 83440
Utah
June 3 – 4, 2010
4343
Jenelle Elizabeth Taflin (Civil) Pacland Bellevue, Inc. 11711 S.E 8th St. Ste. 303 Bellevue, WA 98005
Washington
Nels E. Trygstad (Civil) 802 Mountain View Road Blanchard, ID 83804
Washington
Peter Tuz (Mechanical) 216 Coach Ridge Trail Matthews, NC 28105
North Carolina
Robert D. Viers (Mechanical) SCS Energy 3900 Kilroy Airport Way #100 Long Beach, CA 90806
California
Charles Alan Wall (Civil) Wallace Engineering-Structural Consultants, Inc. 200 East Brady Tulsa, OK 74103
Oklahoma
Don Wall Jr (Civil) 14832 Fontana Ct. S.E. Salem, OR 97317
Oregon
Jeffrey J. Walla (Civil) 17 White Bark Lane Kalispell, MT 59901
Montana
Richard L. Warren (Civil) S3 Engineers LLC 27 Antero Dr. Henderson, NV 89074
Utah
Benjamin Allen White (Civil) GRL Engineers, Inc. 4535 Renaissance Parkway Cleveland, OH 44128
Ohio
Richard William Wiley (Electrical) 3913 Monterey Place Lawrence, KS 66049
Kansas
June 3 – 4, 2010
4344
Comity licenses were granted to the following Professional Land Surveyors with the state as indicated: Craig William Forbes 5117 N.E. 56th Ave. Vancouver, WA 98661
Arizona
Parneli J. Perkins Vertical Surveying, Inc. 65855 61st. Street Bend, OR 97701
Oregon
Leroy W Farley 2139 S. 280th E. Avenue Catoosa, OK 74015-5109
Oklahoma
Jeffrey Clark Stromberg 5064 West 3440 South West Valley City, UT 84120
Utah
Based on passage of the Fundamentals of Engineering examination, a certificate was issued to the following: Thomas J. Anderson: 1305 Denver Ave. Boise, ID 83706 Lauren Leslie Brooks: 29003 23rd Ave. S, Federal Way, WA 98003 James Garrison: 3301 N. 800 E. Castleford, ID 83321 Khan Hammond: 1930 W. Mulhuland Ct., Kuna, ID 83634 Joshua Gary Johnson: 11308 W. Fitzwilliam Loop, Nampa, ID 83651 Sarah Klevmoen: 1303 Chrisway Dr. Apt. G406, Boise, ID 83706 Jason Klose: 10112 Glen Ellyn Ct., Boise, ID 83704 Noe J. Loera: 8475 W. Rifleman Street, Boise, ID 83704 Danielle Marie Perez: 485 E. 25th Street, Idaho Falls ID 83404 John M. Ricardi: 816 South 19th St, Pocatello, ID 83201 Timothy Wade Ross: 1900 Parkwood St., Idaho Falls, ID 83401 Benjamen F. Seely: 3253 N. Wing Road, Star, ID 83669 Brad A. Vawter: 2095 E. Gloucester St., Boise, ID 83706 Brad Williams: 1118 Maple St, Nampa, ID 83686 Aaron Wozniak: 3800 Rose Hill Street, Boise, ID 83705 Based on passage of the Fundamentals of Surveying examination, a certificate was issued to the following: Patrick A. Baumgartner: 1020 McKinley Manor Apt. 16, Pocatello, ID 83201 Andrew Martin Farias: 863 E. Carter, Boise, ID 83706 Jason Michael Von Lindern: 3829 15th Street, Lewiston, ID 83501
June 3 – 4, 2010
4345
The following business entities were issued a Certificate of Authorization: Business Entities offering Professional Engineering Services Only Air Conditioning Company, Inc. Attn: Hugh Palmer 6265 San Fernando Glendale, CA 91201 Apex Engineering Services, Inc. 1201 S. 6th Street W. #102 Missoula, MT 59801 BMA Environmental PLLC 210 E Pine Street Shelley, ID 83274 Dashiell Corporation 12301 Kurland Dr. Ste. 400 Houston, TX 77034 EE Associates, LLC 157 W. Hayden Ave. Ste. 203 Hayden, ID 83835 Encon Design, LLC 1660 Lincoln St. Ste. 1800 Denver, CO 80264 Exterior Research & Design LLC dba Trinity ERD 80 Yesler Way Ste. 200 Seattle, WA 98104 GRL Engineers, Inc. 4535 Renaissance Pkwy. Cleveland, OH 44128 Ground Engineering Consultants, Inc. 41 Iverness Drive East Englewood, CO 80112 H.F. Lenz Company 1407 Scalp Avenue Johnstown, PA 15904
June 3 – 4, 2010
4346
Harrison Engineering, LLC 430 Walnut Avenue Klamath Falls, OR 97601 Hiline Homes LLC 11306 62nd Avenue East Puyallup, WA 98373 Hughes Engineering, P.C. 1117 S. Camas Street Nampa, ID 83686 JBR Environmental Cons., Inc. 8160 S Highland Dr Sandy, UT 84093 Kraemer Consulting Engineers, PLLC 2050 W. Whispering Wind Drive, Suite 158 Phoenix, AZ 85085 M Consultants, LLC dba M-Engineering 750 Brooksedge Blvd. Westerville, OH 43081 Michael J. Baker, PLLC 5595 N. Quail Summit Pl. Boise, ID 83703 Pacific Engineering Technologies, Inc. 1300 Dexter Ave. N. Ste. 100 Seattle, WA 98109 RB Engineering, Inc. P.O. Box 923 Chehalis, WA 98532 Reister Engineering, Inc. 1440 21st Street Ste. 100 Rockford, IL 61108 RS & H Idaho, P.C. 10748 Deerwood Park Blvd S. Jacksonville, FL 32256
June 3 – 4, 2010
4347
Sentry Engineering Group, Inc 1032 Old Peachtree Rd. #401-139 Lawrenceville, GA 30043 Shea, Carr & Jewell, Inc. 2102 Carriage Dr. S.W. Bldg. H Olympia, WA 98502 SK Geotechnical Corporation P.O. Box 16123 Missoula, MT 59808 SLR International Corp. 22122 20th Ave. S.E., H-150 Bothell, WA 98021 Spectrum Engineering, Inc. 19395 W. Capitol Drive Brookfield, WI 53045 SPX Heat Transfer, Inc. 95 Highland Ave. Ste. 210 Bethlehem, PA 18017 Summit Land Surveying 366 Washington Ave. Pocatello, ID 83201 Telesto Nevada Inc. 5490 Longley Lane Reno, NV 89511 Torgersen Engineering, Inc. 379 Pahvant Drive Richfield, UT 84701 Watershape Consulting, Inc. 3830 Valley Ctr. Dr. Ste. 705-316 San Diego, CA 92130-3307 Western States Fire Protection 13896 Fir St. Ste. B Oregon City, OR 97045
June 3 – 4, 2010
4348
