Page 1 240 DAVID J. CHEHHLNGTON AND OWEN CHF.JHRINGTON ...

2 downloads 0 Views 24MB Size Report
4) indicated significant budgetary control main effects on task 2 :o;corrs for General Satisfaction (71 ::::; .02), Personal Competence (p ::::; .01), and. Supervisor ...
240

DAVID J. CHEHHLNGTON AND OWEN CHF.JHRINGTON

T All LE 3 Analyses of V ariance: The Nwnber Estimated, the Number 1Vlade and th e Foreca sting Error -- --------- -- --·----- ·-Source

Estimated

Jj

/r'- Rat io

- --- - - -- --

- - - - - - ·- ---

Prob

Made

l'-Ratio

--

Forecast ing erro r

Prob

--- -- -- ·F-Ratio

Prob ____.,,.__ ___ _____

Tusk (T) 10.76 .00 1 6.99 . Ol 41.61 Periocl (P) :13.28 .0001 73 . 70 .0001 26. 55 Itcinforccmcnt contingency (TIC) 2 I. 88 5. 89 .005 2. 37 n• Bud1ictary control (BC) :1 72.1 1 .Oinfor-cem ent. rontingency ( 8 C) B udgetary eo n t rol (TIC ) RC ~< DC Error

Task l

df

Personal competence

Task 2

--- p- -

T ask I

p

MS

F

3.42

.05

4 .64

4 . 2!l

.Ol

.42

1.14 .22

ns

3.52

[\."

:! . 2-1

3.25 2 08

.02 .05

. .58 .89 .94

MS

F

2

3. 11

3 G 218

1. 03 .20 .!JO

1. 08

MS

>

T ask 2

p

MS

.-14

llS

3.83

4.59

.01

.G2

ns

.94

ns

3.25 l. G9 .83

3 91 2.04

.01 .05

F

F

p

>ti ':l

~

"" > ..., ~ ~

~

~

z

'=I

Supr- n· i ~ o r

~ o urc c

dj

compcte n 4 .5

_,,,",,o

p--~.:;.::~

0-· -·-~ ;~-~ / ,,,,.. -· -y

I.I~

~

6.0

~5.5f­

,'2

"'

Pseudo - portici po l ion

c

.'? 5.0 -

]

D-·--0

,~_,,,.. • •

-

I

I

~ ,,,,,

--~

/-~~~-~------' '

C"_,, -

4 .5 ,____.tf _._·____,1_ _ _ _-'1_ __, Ou!pu l Bud get Ou I put Only Or iented Bu d ge t

"'u

~ 5.0 QJ

a.

t:

(._'3 4. 0 0



·5 ~ 3.0 -

,v

if

-

a.

1 Ji 4.0 ~-~ ---·~1 ----~1-~

Ou tpu t Only

I

.,..._...,.Lenient

B,;clqct Or iented

Oufpuf El uc1 CJe l

:J

(f)

I

I

I

Output On ly

Bu dge t Ori ent ed

Output Oudgc t

Fie:. ~. --· l11Le r act. i o 11 r ~ ffec:t s :; 111< >11 g thr l'ollr all.itlld e nw:cs urC's fr"m

t a;; k '.!

Based u pon 11ic int 1·ractio1t dfrcts of the budgetary control a11cl n ·in forc c mcnt contiu gr·ncy condition s , it 11·as concluded that. only some of Uwsc conditions crea tcd s imilar cff«·ctc; on both perform an('() and sati sfacti o n . Th en· \1·c:rc two co ndit iun s ' " hich resulted in both high 1wrfo rm a11 cc :rnd high o;at isfact.ion o;co1H-;: (a) tl w outpuL-bu : , :ind ;-;t' o l t. ( 11 :!:1 :·1h1> vC'); !