Quintessenz Journals

0 downloads 0 Views 385KB Size Report
Objective: To determine the effectiveness of aloe vera gel in the treatment of oral lichen planus when ... 1 cm; 3, white striae with atrophic area more than 1 cm; 4, ...
Q U I N T E S S E N C E I N T E R N AT I O N A L

Randomized trial of aloe vera gel vs triamcinolone acetonide ointment in the treatment of oral lichen planus 3FEEZ-BWBOZB3FEEZ .%413FEEZ4VEIBLBSB3FEEZ .%42/ 5BUBQVEJ3BNFTI .%435IBLVSJ3BKFTI4JOHI .%44/ -JOHBN"NBSB4XBQOB .%41/JNNB7JKBZB-BYNJ .%41

Objective:5PEFUFSNJOFUIFFGGFDUJWFOFTTPGBMPFWFSBHFMJOUIFUSFBUNFOUPGPSBM MJDIFOQMBOVTXIFODPNQBSFEXJUIUSJBNDJOPMPOFBDFUPOJEFMethod and Materials:" SBOEPNJ[FE EPVCMFCMJOE DMJOJDBMUSJBMXBTEFTJHOFE5IFTUVEZTBNQMFDPOTUJUVUFE QBUJFOUT NBMFTBOEGFNBMFT XIPXFSFSBOEPNMZEJWJEFEJOUPUXPFRVBMHSPVQT (SPVQ"QBUJFOUTSFDFJWFEBMPFWFSBHFM XIJMFHSPVQ#QBUJFOUTSFDFJWFEUSJBNDJOPMPOF BDFUPOJEFResults:'PSUZQBUJFOUTXFSFJODMVEFEJOUIFTUVEZ.PTUPGUIFTBNQMF QSFTFOUFEXJUIFSPTJWF O BOEBUSPQIJD O WBSJBOUTPGPSBMMJDIFOQMBOVT 8IFODMJOJDBMTJHOTBOETZNQUPNTXFSFPCTFSWFEBGUFSXFFLTPGUIFSBQZ JUXBT EFUFSNJOFEUIBUBMPFWFSBHFMXBTNPSFFGGFDUJWFUIBOUSJBNDJOPMPOFBDFUPOJEFJOUIF USFBUNFOUPGPSBMMJDIFOQMBOVTConclusion:"MPFWFSBHFMDBOCFDPOTJEFSFEBTBGF BMUFSOBUJWFUSFBUNFOUGPSPSBMMJDIFOQMBOVT(Quintessence Int 2012;43:793–800)

Key words:BMPFWFSBHFM CVSOJOHTFOTBUJPO IFBMJOH PSBMMJDIFOQMBOVT  USJBNDJOPMPOFBDFUPOJEF

-JDIFOQMBOVTJTBSFMBUJWFMZDPNNPODISPO-

3FUJDVMBS  QBQVMBS  BOE QMBRVF MFTJPOT TFM-

JD JOGMBNNBUPSZ NVDPDVUBOFPVT EJTPSEFS

EPN QSFTFOU XJUI BOZ TZNQUPNT 5IFZ BSF

UIBUBGGFDUTUIFTLJOBOEPSBMNVDPTB1 0SBM

VTVBMMZBTZNQUPNBUJDBOEGPVOEVQPOSPV-

MJDIFOQMBOVTJTFTUJNBUFEUPBGGFDUUP

UJOF PSBM FYBNJOBUJPO )PXFWFS  BUSPQIJD 

 PG JOEJWJEVBMT2 5IF QSFWBMFODF SBUF

FSPTJWF  BOE CVMMPVT MFTJPOT DBVTF DPN-

NBZ EJGGFS BNPOH SBDFT BOE HFPHSBQIJD

QMBJOUTPGQBJOPSCVSOJOHTFOTBUJPOT8

3

BSFBT  "MUIPVHI UIF FYBDU DBVTF PG PSBM

$VSSFOU USFBUNFOU NPEBMJUJFT GPS PSBM

MJDIFO QMBOVT JT BNCJHVPVT  FYQFSJNFOUBM

MJDIFO QMBOVT BSF BJNFE BU BMMFWJBUJOH UIF

FWJEFODFTVHHFTUTUIBUJUJTBOJOGMBNNBUPSZ

QBJOPSCVSOJOHTFOTBUJPOBOEFMJNJOBUJOHUIF

5DFMMoNFEJBUFEJNNVOFSFTQPOTF4

MFTJPOT"XJEFSBOHFPGUIFSBQFVUJDBHFOUT 

0SBM MJDIFO QMBOVT MFTJPOT BSF DMJOJDBMMZ

JODMVEJOH DPSUJDPTUFSPJET  SFUJOPJET  BOUJNZ-

DMBTTJGJFE BT SFUJDVMBS  BUSPQIJD  QBQVMBS 

DPUJDT  B[BUIJPQSJOF  DZDMPTQPSJOF  UBDSPMJ-

QMBRVFFODSVTUFE  FSPTJWF  BOE CVMMPVT5–7

NVT  QIPUPDIFNPUIFSQZ  BOE TVSHFSZ  IBWF CFFO VTFE GPS UIF USFBUNFOU PG PSBM MJDIFO QMBOVT 

1

1BUJFOUTXJUITZNQUPNBUJDPSBMMJDIFOQMB-

Postgraduate Student, Department of Oral Medicine and Radiology, Vishnu Dental College, Bhimavaram, Andhra Pradesh, India.

OVTPGUFOSFRVJSFJOUFOTJWFUIFSBQZUPBMMJFWJBUF JUTTJHOTBOETZNQUPNT/PUSFBUNFOUNPEBM-

2

Professor and Head, Department of Oral Medicine and Radiology, Vishnu Dental College, Bhimavaram, Andhra

3

4

JUZQSPWJEFTDPNQMFUFSFTPMVUJPOPGUIFMFTJPO

Pradesh, India.

UIFSFGPSF UIFNBOBHFNFOUTUSBUFHZGPDVTFT

Associate Professor, Department of Oral Medicine and

POUIFVTFPGESVHTUIBUDPVOUFSUJTTVFJOGMBN-

Radiology, Vishnu Dental College, Bhimavaram, Andhra

NBUJPO BOE UIFJS VOEFSMZJOH JNNVOPMPHJD

Pradesh, India.

NFDIBOJTNT10.BOZQMBOUTBSFVTFEJONFE-

Assistant Professor, Department of Oral Medicine and

JDJOF GPS USFBUJOH WBSJPVT EJTFBTFT  BOE BMPF

Radiology, Vishnu Dental College, Bhimavaram, Andhra Pradesh, India. Correspondence: Dr Reddy Lavanya Reddy, Vishnu Dental College, Gangipelli, Madal: Manakodur, Karimnagar, Andhra Pradesh, 505474, India. Email: [email protected]

WFSBJTPOFBNPOHUIFN*UJTBDPNQMFYQMBOU DPOUBJOJOH CJPMPHJDBMMZ BDUJWF TVCTUBODFT XJUIQSPQFSUJFTUIBUFOIBODFUIFJNNVOFTZTUFNUPDPNCBUNBOZPSBMEJTFBTFT11–13

VOLUME 43 t /6.#&39 t 0$50#&3 2012

793

Q U I N T E S S E N C E I N T E R N AT I O N A L Reddy et al

"MPF WFSB JT B DBDUVTMJLF QMBOU UIBU

DPOUBJOFST XBT EPOF CZ UIF JOWFTUJHBUPS

CFMPOHT UP UIF MJMJBDFBF GBNJMZ *U DPOUBJOT

BOEEJTDMPTFEBUUIFFOEPGUIFDMJOJDBMUSJBM

 QPUFOUJBMMZ BDUJWF DPOTUJUVFOUT  JODMVE-

 XFFLT  5XP PQFSBUPST XFSF BTTJHOFE

JOH WJUBNJOT  FO[ZNFT  NJOFSBMT  TVHBST 

UP DMJOJDBMMZ TDSFFO UIF MFTJPOT 5IFZ XFSF

MJHOJOT TBQPOJOT TBMJDZMJDBDJET BOEBNJOP

USBJOFEUPHSBEFUIFMFTJPO11GPSUIFCVSOJOH

BDJET14*UIBTBMPOHIJTUPSZPGQPQVMBSVTF 

TFOTBUJPO BWJTVBMBOBMPHTDBMF 7"4 XBT

BOEJUTUPQJDBMBQQMJDBUJPOJTHFOFSBMMZDPO-

GPMMPXFE

TJEFSFEUPCFTBGF15

(SPVQ"QBUJFOUTSFDFJWFECMVFNFEJDB-

4FWFSBMUPQJDBMBOETZTUFNJDUSFBUNFOUT

NFOU DPOUBJOFST  BOE BMM HSPVQ # QBUJFOUT

BSFBWBJMBCMFGPSPSBMMJDIFOQMBOVTQBUJFOUT 

SFDFJWFE QJOL NFEJDBNFOU DPOUBJOFST 5IF

CVUUIFSBQFVUJDSFTQPOTFTNBZEJGGFS 

QBUJFOUTXFSFJOTUSVDUFEUPBQQMZUIFNFEJ-

1SFWJPVT TUVEJFT IBWF QSPWFO UIBU JO

DBUJPO UISFF UJNFT EBJMZ *G BOZ BMMFSHJD

DPNQBSJTPO XJUI B QMBDFCP  BMPF WFSB JT

NBOJGFTUBUJPOTXFSFTFFOBGUFSGJSTUBQQMZJOH

FGGFDUJWF JO UIF USFBUNFOU PG PSBM MJDIFO

UIF QSFTDSJCFE NFEJDBNFOU  QBUJFOUT XFSF

QMBOVT  5IFSF IBT CFFO OP TUVEZ DPN-

BTLFE UP TUPQ NFEJDBUJPO BOE JNNFEJBUFMZ

QBSJOHBMPFWFSBHFMBOEUSJBNDJOPMPOFBDF-

SFQPSUUPUIFIPTQJUBM

UPOJEFJOUIFUSFBUNFOUPGPSBMMJDIFOQMBOVT

1BUJFOUT XFSF SFDBMMFE GPS QFSJPEJD

5IFSFGPSF UIFQSFTFOUTUVEZXBTEFTJHOFE

SFWJFX  BU UIF OE  UI  UI  BOE UI XFFLT

UPFWBMVBUFUIFFGGJDBDZPGUPQJDBMBMPFWFSB

$MJOJDBMMZ  UIF MPDBUJPO PG UIF MFTJPOT XBT

HFM JO UIF USFBUNFOU PG PSBM MJDIFO QMBOVT

SFDPSEFE11 OPMFTJPO NJMEXIJUFTUSJBF

DPNQBSFEXJUIUSJBNDJOPMPOFBDFUPOJEF

  XIJUF TUSJBF XJUI BUSPQIJD BSFB MFTT UIBO DN XIJUFTUSJBFXJUIBUSPQIJDBSFBNPSF UIBO  DN   XIJUF TUSJBF XJUI BO FSPTJWF BSFB MFTT UIBO  DN BOE   XIJUF TUSJBF

METHOD AND MATERIALS

XJUI BO FSPTJWF BSFB NPSF UIBO  DN PS BO VMDFSBUJWF MFTJPO "OZ CVSOJOH TFOTBUJPO XBTTDPSFECZ7"41BUJFOUTXFSFBTLFEUP

5IF QSFTFOU TUVEZ XBT EFTJHOFE XJUI UIF

TDPSFUIFJSJOUFOTJUZPGCVSOJOHTFOTBUJPOBU

NBJOPCKFDUJWFPGEFUFSNJOJOHUIFFGGFDUJWF-

FBDI WJTJU 4DPSFT SBOHFE GSPN  OP QBJO 

OFTTPGBMPFWFSBHFMJOUIFUSFBUNFOUPGPSBM

UP FYUSFNFQBJO 

MJDIFO QMBOVT XIFO DPNQBSFE XJUI USJBNDJOPMPOF BDFUPOJEF 5IF BMPF WFSB HFM XBT

5SFBUNFOUSFTQPOTFXBTHSBEFEBTDPNQMFUF XIFO UIF TDPSFT11 XFSF FJUIFS  PS  

QSFQBSFEBDDPSEJOHUPQSFWJPVTTUVEJFT 

HPPE XIFO TDPSFT EFDSFBTFE CZ ö 

5IF TUVEZ QSPUPDPM XBT BQQSPWFE CZ UIF

GSPNCBTFMJOF QPPSXIFOTDPSFTEFDSFBTFE

*OTUJUVUJPOBM&UIJDBM3FWJFX#PBSEPG7JTIOV

CZGSPNCBTFMJOF BOEBTOPSFTQPOTF

%FOUBM

XIFOUIFMFTJPOTXFSFVODIBOHFE$PNQMFUF

$PMMFHF 

#IJNBWBSBN 

"OEISB

1SBEFTI *OEJB *&3# 7%$0.3 

SFTPMVUJPO PG UIF TZNQUPNT XBT EFGJOFE BT BO BCTFODF PG CVSOJOH TFOTBUJPO 7"4

Methodology

TDPSF  (PPE QPPS PSOPSFTQPOTFPGUIF

5IF TUVEZ TBNQMF DPNQSJTFE  QBUJFOUT 

TZNQUPNBUPMPHZXBTEFGJOFEBTBEFDSFBTF

XIPXFSFSBOEPNMZEJWJEFEJOUPUXPHSPVQT

PG ö   B EFDSFBTF PG    PS OP

PG  QBUJFOUT FBDI (SPVQ " TVCKFDUT

DIBOHF SFTQFDUJWFMZ JO7"4TDPSFT

SFDFJWFE BMPF WFSB HFM UFTU HSPVQ

 BOE HSPVQ # TVCKFDUT SFDFJWFE USJBNDJOPMPOF BDFUPOJEF DPOUSPMHSPVQ  #PUI UIF PQFSBUPS BOE QBUJFOU XFSF

RESULTS

VOBXBSFPGNFEJDBNFOUVTFE5IFCMJOEJOH XBTQFSGPSNFECZDPMPSDPEJOHUIFDPOUBJOFST GSPN XIJDI UIF NFEJDBNFOU XBT EJT-

5IF EBUB XFSF BOBMZ[FE VTJOH 4144 

QFOTFE*EFOUJDBMPQBRVFTUFSJMFDPOUBJOFST

*#.  5IF .BOO8IJUOFZ U UFTU XBT

XJUI NFEJDBNFOU XFSF DPMPSDPEFE CZ BO

VTFE GPS JOUFSHSPVQ DPNQBSJTPO  BOE UIF

JOWFTUJHBUPS%JTQFOTJOHPGUIFNFEJDBNFOU

8JMDPYPO NBUDIFE QBJST UFTU CZ SBOLT XBT

BMPF WFSB PS USJBNDJOPMPOF BDFUPOJEF  JOUP

VTFE GPS JOUSBHSPVQ DPNQBSJTPO 4UBUJTUJDBM

UIF QBSUJDVMBS DPMPSDPEFE CMVF PS QJOL 

TJHOJGJDBODFXBTTFUBUP

794

VOLUME 43 t /6.#&39 t 0$50#&3 2012

Q U I N T E S S E N C E I N T E R N AT I O N A L Reddy et al

Table 1

Comparison of control and study groups with respect to clinical score at different time intervals U value

Z value

P value

 



o



œ œ

 



o



4 wk  $POUSPM  4UVEZ

œ œ

 



o



6 wk  $POUSPM  4UVEZ

œ œ

 



o



8 wk  $POUSPM  4UVEZ

œ œ

 



o



Group

Mean ± SD

Initial visit  $POUSPM  4UVEZ

œ œ

2 wk  $POUSPM  4UVEZ

Sum of ranks

P .BOO8IJUOFZ6UFTU 4% TUBOEBSEEFWJBUJPO

5IF UPUBM TBNQMF JODMVEFE  QBUJFOUT  BNPOH XIPN    XFSF NBMFT BOE

HSPVQT  BO JOTJHOJGJDBOU EJGGFSFODF XBT PCTFSWFE XJUI SFTQFDU UP DMJOJDBM TDPSFT ;  o P    BU UIF  MFWFM PG

Mean value

   XFSF GFNBMFT 0O DPNQBSJTPO PG DMJOJDBM TDPSFT JO UIF DPOUSPM BOE TUVEZ

TJHOJGJDBODF 5IJT NFBOT UIBU UIF DMJOJDBM TDPSFT BU UIF JOJUJBM WJTJU XFSF TJNJMBS JO UIF DPOUSPMBOETUVEZHSPVQT " TJHOJGJDBOU EJGGFSFODF XBT PCTFSWFE

9.00 8.00 7.00 6.00 5.00 4.00 3.00 2.00 1.00 0.00

7.00 5.20 3.80

Initial visit

CFUXFFO DPOUSPM BOE TUVEZ HSPVQT XJUI SFTQFDU UP DMJOJDBM TDPSFT BU UIF OE ;o P 

UI ;o P 

 UI ;  o  P  

 BOE UI XFFLT

2 wk

2.45

2.15

4 wk 6 wk Control group

8 wk

Fig 1 Comparison of the burning sensation in the control group at different time intervals.

;  o  P    BU B  MFWFM PG TJHOJGJDBODF 5IJT NFBOT UIBU UIF DMJOJDBM

" TJHOJGJDBOU EJGGFSFODF XBT PCTFSWFE

TDPSFT BU UIF OE  UI  UI  BOE UI XFFL

BNPOHEJGGFSFOUUJNFQFSJPETFYDFQUCFUXFFO

XFSF EJGGFSFOU JO UIF DPOUSPM BOE TUVEZ

BOEXFFLTXJUISFTQFDUUPDMJOJDBMTDPSFT

HSPVQT$MJOJDBMTDPSFTBNPOHTUVEZHSPVQ

JO UIF DPOUSPM HSPVQ 5IJT TIPXT UIBU BT UIF

XFSF MFTT XIFO DPNQBSFE UP UIF DPOUSPM

UJNF JOUFSWBM JODSFBTFT  UIF DMJOJDBM TDPSFT

HSPVQ BU UIF FOE PG OE  UI  UI  BOE UI

PG UIF MFTJPO EFDSFBTFE XJUI SFTQFDU UP UIF

XFFLT 5BCMF  5IFSF XBT OP TUBUJTUJDBM TJHOJGJDBODF

JOJUJBM WJTJU 8IFO UIF DMJOJDBM TDPSFT PG UIF MFTJPO XFSF DPNQBSFE CFUXFFO UIF DPOUSPM

P   PCTFSWFE CFUXFFO UIF TUVEZ BOE

HSPVQT BU EJGGFSFOU UJNF JOUFSWBMT  TUBUJTUJDBM

DPOUSPM HSPVQ BU UIF JOJUJBM MFTJPO BOE UIF

TJHOJGJDBODF XBT GPVOE  FYDFQU GPS UIF UI

OE  UI  UI  BOE UI XFFLT 5IJT NFBOT

BOEUIXFFLJOUFSWBMT5IJTTIPXTUIBUUIFSF

UIBU CVSOJOH TFOTBUJPO TDPSFT XFSF TJNJMBS

XBTOPUNVDIEJGGFSFODFJOUIFDMJOJDBMTDPSF

JOCPUIHSPVQTBUUIFJOJUJBMWJTJUBOEUIFOE 

CFUXFFOUIFUIBOEUIXFFLJOUFSWBMTJOUIF

UI UI BOEUIXFFLT

DPOUSPMHSPVQ 'JH 

VOLUME 43 t /6.#&39 t 0$50#&3 2012

795

Q U I N T E S S E N C E I N T E R N AT I O N A L Reddy et al

Table 2

Comparison of burning sensation scores in the control group Mean

SD

Mean difference

SD difference

% change

Z value

P value

*OJUJBMWJTJU XL

 

 











*OJUJBMWJTJU XL

 

 











*OJUJBMWJTJU XL

 

 











*OJUJBMWJTJU XL

 

 











XL XL

 

 











XL XL

 

 











XL XL

 

 











XL XL

 

 











XL XL

 

 











XL XL

 

 











P 8JMDPYPONBUDIFEQBJSTUFTUCZSBOLT 4% TUBOEBSEEFWJBUJPO

" TJHOJGJDBOU EJGGFSFODF XBT PCTFSWFE

JO UIF TUVEZ HSPVQ QSFTFOUFE XJUI TDPSFT

BNPOH EJGGFSFOU UJNF QFSJPET FYDFQU

 BOE  TIPXJOH DPNQMFUF SFTQPOTF



CFUXFFOUIFUIBOEUIXFFLXJUISFTQFDU

TVCKFDUTQSFTFOUFEXJUITDPSF TIPXJOH

UP CVSOJOH TFOTBUJPO TDPSFT JO UIF DPOUSPM

HPPESFTQPOTF

BOETVCKFDUTXJUITDPSF

HSPVQ 5BCMF 

 TIPXJOH QPPS SFTQPOTF  UP UIF UIFSBQZ

5IF DMJOJDBM TDPSFT PG UIF MFTJPOT XFSF DPNQBSFEJOUIFTUVEZHSPVQXJUISFTQFDUUP

*O UIF DPOUSPM HSPVQ   PG  QBUJFOUT QSFTFOUFE XJUI TDPSFT  BOE  DPNQMFUF

UIFJOJUJBMWJTJUBOEBUOE UI UI BOEUI

SFTQPOTF

XIFSFTVCKFDUTQSFTFOUFEXJUI

XFFLT " TUBUJTUJDBMMZ TJHOJGJDBOU EJGGFSFODF

TDPSF HPPESFTQPOTF

XIFSFBTTVCKFDU

XBTPCTFSWFE P  5IJTTIPXTUIBUBT

XJUITDPSF QPPSSFTQPOTF BOETVCKFDUT

UJNF JOUFSWBM JODSFBTFT  UIF DMJOJDBM TDPSFT

QSFTFOUFE XJUI TDPSF  OP DIBOHF PG UIF

PG UIF MFTJPO JO TUVEZ HSPVQ EFDSFBTFE

MFTJPO BUUIFFOEPGUIFUIFSBQZ 5BCMF  5IF CVSOJOH TDPSF JO UIF UPUBM TBNQMF

5BCMF  5IF CVSOJOH TFOTBUJPO PG UIF MFTJPOT

BU UIF FOE PG UIF UIFSBQZ  XFFLT  XBT

XFSFDPNQBSFEJOTUVEZHSPVQXJUISFTQFDU

PCTFSWFE JO CPUI HSPVQT *O UIF TUVEZ

UPCVSOJOHTFOTBUJPOTDPSFPGJOJUJBMMFTJPOBU

HSPVQ   QBUJFOUT QSFTFOUFE XJUI TDPSF 

UIF OE  UI  UI  BOE UI XFFLT " TUBUJTUJ-

DPNQMFUF SFNJTTJPO PG TZNQUPNBUPMPHZ 

DBMMZ TJHOJGJDBOU EJGGFSFODF XBT PCTFSWFE

BOE  QBUJFOUT TIPXFE TDPSFT ö  GSPN

P    5IJT TIPXT UIBU BT UJNF JOUFSWBM

CBTFMJOF *O UIF DPOUSPM HSPVQ  UIFSF XFSF

JODSFBTFT  UIF CVSOJOH TFOTBUJPO TDPSF PG

 QBUJFOUT XJUI TDPSF  DPNQMFUF SFNJT-

UIFMFTJPOTJOTUVEZHSPVQEFDSFBTFE 'JH 

TJPO

  QBUJFOUT XJUI TDPSF ö  GSPN

5IF DMJOJDBM TJHOT JO UIF UPUBM TBNQMF

CBTFMJOF  BOE  QBUJFOUT XJUI TDPSF  

BU UIF FOE PG UIF UIFSBQZ  XFFLT  XBT

GSPN CBTFMJOF PCTFSWFE BU FOE PG UIF UIFS-

PCTFSWFE JO CPUI HSPVQT 'JGUFFO QBUJFOUT

BQZ 5BCMF 

796

VOLUME 43 t /6.#&39 t 0$50#&3 2012

Q U I N T E S S E N C E I N T E R N AT I O N A L Reddy et al

Table 3

Comparison of clinical scores in the study group Mean

SD

Mean difference

SD difference

% change

Z value

P value

*OJUJBMWJTJU XL

 

 











*OJUJBMWJTJU XL

 

 











*OJUJBMWJTJU XL

 

 











*OJUJBMWJTJU XL

 

 











XL XL

 

 











XL XL

 

 











XL XL

 

 











XL XL

 

 











XL XL

 

 











XL XL

 

 











P 8JMDPYPONBUDIFEQBJSTUFTUCZSBOLT 4% TUBOEBSEEFWJBUJPO

Mean value

Fig 2 Comparision of burning sensation in the study group at different time intervals.

Table 4 Scores 0

9.00 8.00 7.00 6.00 5.00 4.00 3.00 2.00 1.00 0.00

6.60 3.90 2.45

Initial visit

2 wk

4 wk Study group

1.10

1.00

6 wk

8 wk

Clinical scores at 8 weeks in the study population Triamcinolone acetonide group

%

Aloe vera gel group

%

Total

3

15

9

45

12

1

6

30

6

30

12

2

8

40

3

15

11

3

1

5

2

10

3

4

2

10

0

0

2

VOLUME 43 t /6.#&39 t 0$50#&3 2012

797

Q U I N T E S S E N C E I N T E R N AT I O N A L Reddy et al

Table 5 Scores

Burning sensation at 8 weeks in the study population Triamcinolone acetonide group

%

Aloe vera gel group

%

Total

75

25

0

0

3

2

10

3

0

1

5

1

4

20

2

10

6

1

5

0

0

1

1

5

0

0

1

0

10

50

15

2

3

15

3

1

5

4

0

5 6 8

DISCUSSION

OJGJDBOU P  BTTPDJBUJPOXBTPCTFSWFE CFUXFFOUIFTUVEZBOEDPOUSPMHSPVQT5IJT NFBOT UIBU CVSOJOH TFOTBUJPO TDPSFT XFSF

-JDIFO QMBOVT JT B DISPOJD JOGMBNNBUPSZ

TJNJMBSJOCPUIHSPVQTBUBMMUJNFT#PUIUIF

EJTFBTFUIBUDPNNPOMZBGGFDUTTLJOBOEPSBM

NFEJDBNFOUTIBWFQPUFOUBOUJJOGMBNNBUPSZ

NVDPTB*UIBTBOVNCFSPGXFMMSFDPHOJ[FE

BDUJPOT

DMJOJDBM TJHOT BOE B XJEF SBOHF PG TZNQUPNT  GSPN OPOF BTZNQUPNBUJD  UP NJME

5IFCVSOJOHTFOTBUJPOPGUIFMFTJPOTXFSF DPNQBSFE JO CPUI HSPVQT XJUI SFTQFDU UP

EJTDPNGPSU UP TFWFSF EFCJMJUBUJOH JOUSBPSBM

CVSOJOH TFOTBUJPO TDPSF BU UIF JOJUJBM MFTJPO

MFTJPOT

BOEUIFOE UI UI BOEUIXFFLT"TUB-

'PSUZQBUJFOUT NBMFTBOEGFNBMFT 

UJTUJDBMMZTJHOJGJDBOUEJGGFSFODFXBTPCTFSWFE

XFSF JODMVEFE JO UIF TUVEZ .PTU PG UIF

P    JO CPUI HSPVQT VOUJM UIF UI XFFL 

TBNQMF QSFTFOUFE XJUI FSPTJWF O   

CVU UIF TUBUJTUJDBMMZ TJHOJGJDBOU EJGGFSFODF

BOEBUSPQIJD O WBSJBOUTPGPSBMMJDIFO

DPOUJOVFE JO UIF TUVEZ HSPVQ VOUJM UIF FOE

QMBOVT5IFNPTUDPNNPOTJUFPGPSBMMJDIFO

PG UIFSBQZ 5IJT TIPXT UIBU BT UIF UJNF

QMBOVT XBT UIF CVDDBM NVDPTB GPMMPXFE CZ

JOUFSWBM JODSFBTFE  UIF CVSOJOH TFOTBUJPO

UIFHJOHJWB

TDPSF PG UIF MFTJPOT EFDSFBTFE DPOUJOV-

*O UIF QSFTFOU TUVEZ  BMPF WFSB HFM XBT

PVTMZ JO QBUJFOUT XIP SFDFJWFE BMPF WFSB

NPSFFGGFDUJWFJOJNQSPWJOHDMJOJDBMTDPSF JO

HFM USFBUNFOU 5IJT NFBOT UIBU B SFEVDUJPO

TIPSUFOJOH UIF EVSBUJPO PG XPVOE IFBMJOH 

PG CVSOJOH TFOTBUJPO XBT PCTFSWFE XJUI BO

'JHTBOE DPNQBSFEXJUIUSJBNDJOPMPOF

JODSFBTF JO UIF UJNF JOUFSWBM 5IJT NJHIU CF

BDFUPOJEF5IJTGJOEJOHXBTTJNJMBSUPUIBUPG

EVF UP UIF BCJMJUZ PG BMPF WFSB UP QFOFUSBUF

)BZFT 17 XIPSFQPSUFEBDBTFPGTVDDFTTGVM

UIF UJTTVF  SFTVMUJOH JO CSJOHJOH UIF NFEJDB-

USFBUNFOU PG MJDIFO QMBOVT XJUI BMPF WFSB

NFOU UP UIF BSFB OFFEJOH JU17 5IJT IFMQT JO

$IPPOIBLBSOFUBM11SFQPSUFEUIBUBMPFWFSB

SFMJFWJOHCVSOJOHTFOTBUJPOCZJOBDUJWBUJOHPS

XBTFGGFDUJWFJOUIFUSFBUNFOUPGPSBMMJDIFO

JOUFSGFSJOH XJUI UIF BSBDIJEPOJD QBUIXBZ WJB

QMBOVT DPNQBSFE XJUI B QMBDFCP  BOE

DZDMPPYZHFOBTF 

18

4BMB[BS4ÈODIF[FUBM DPODMVEFEUIBUUPQJDBMBQQMJDBUJPOPGBMPFWFSBJNQSPWFTRVBMJUZ

8IFO DMJOJDBM TJHOT BOE CVSOJOH TFOTBUJPOTDPSFTXFSFPCTFSWFEBUUIFFOEPGUIF

PGMJGFTDPSFTJOQBUJFOUTXJUIPSBMMJDIFOQMB-

UIFSBQZ UIXFFL  TFF'JHTBOE

CFU-

OVT 5IJT JT CFDBVTF BMPF WFSB DBO JOIJCJU

UFS DMJOJDBM BOE TZNQUPNBUPMPHJD JNQSPWF-

UIF JOGMBNNBUPSZ QSPDFTT CZ JUT JOUFSGFSJOH

NFOUXBTPCTFSWFEJOUIFTBNQMFSFDFJWJOH

BDUJPO PO UIF BSDIJEPOJD BDJE QBUIXBZ WJB

BMPFWFSBHFMUIBOUSJBNDJOPMPOFBDFUPOJEF

DZDMPPYZHFOBTF 3FDFOU EBUB TVHHFTU UIBU

5IJT NJHIU CF EVF UP GBTUFS IFBMJOH PG UIF

BMPFWFSBBMTPIBTBOUJJOGMBNNBUPSZFGGFDUT

MFTJPO UIBU NBZ CF BUUSJCVUFE UP UIF QSFT-

CZUIFSFEVDUJPOPGMFVLPDZUFBEIFTJPOBOE

FODF PG BDUJWF HSPXUI GBDUPS NBOOPTF

5/'αMFWFM 

QIPTQIBUF  MJLF UIF TVCTUBODF JO BMPF

8IFOCVSOJOHTFOTBUJPOTDPSFTBUEJGGFSFOUUJNFJOUFSWBMT XFSFDPNQBSFE BOJOTJH-

798

WFSB  XIJDI FOIBODFT GJCSPCMBTUJD BDUJWJUZ SFTVMUJOHJOUJTTVFSFQBJS 

VOLUME 43 t /6.#&39 t 0$50#&3 2012

Q U I N T E S S E N C E I N T E R N AT I O N A L Reddy et al

Fig 3 Photographs of study group patient.

Fig 4

Photographs of the aloe vera patient.

VOLUME 43 t /6.#&39 t 0$50#&3 2012

799

Q U I N T E S S E N C E I N T E R N AT I O N A L Reddy et al

CONCLUSION

6. McCarthy PL, Shklar G. Diseases of the Oral Mucosa, ed 2. Philadelphia: Febiger Philadelphia, 1980:203–224. 7. Huber MA. Oral lichen planus. Quintessence Int 2004;

"MPFWFSBHFMXBTFGGFDUJWFJOSFEVDJOHCPUI

35:731–752.

DMJOJDBMTJHOTBOECVSOJOHTFOTBUJPOTPGUIF

8. Dusek JJ, Frick WG. Lichen planus: Oral manifesta-

MFTJPO XIFO DPNQBSFE XJUI USJBNDJOPMPOF

tions and suggested treatments. J Oral Maxillofac

BDFUPOJEF 5IVT  BMPF WFSB HFM JT TBGF BOE FGGFDUJWFJOUIFUSFBUNFOUPGPSBMMJDIFOQMBOVT 4JODF UIFSF XFSF GFX DMJOJDBM SFQPSUT JO UIF MJUFSBUVSF SFHBSEJOH JUT FGGFDUJWFOFTT  GVSUIFSSFTFBSDIJTSFRVJSFE

Surg 1982;40:240–244. 9. Aleinikov A, Jordan RCK, Main JHP. Topical steroid therapy in oral lichen planus: Review of a novel delivery method in 24 patients. J Can Dent Assoc 1996 62:324–327. 10. Lodi G, Scully C, Carrozzo M, Griffiths M, Sugerman PB, Thongprasom K. Current controversies in oral lichen planus: Report of an international consensus meeting. Part 2. Clinical management and malig-

ACKNOWLEDGMENTS

nant transformation. Oral Surg Oral Med Oral Pathol Oral Radiol Endod 2005;100:164–178. 11. Choonhakarn C, Busaracome P, Sripanidkulchai B,

The authors thank Professor Dr Laxman Rao, Sri Vishnu Pharmacy College, for his help and concern in the preparation of the aloe vera gel. They would also like to acknowledge the support of Drs N. Vijaya Laxmi, L. A. Swapna, C.H. Saikiran, K. Ramya, and N. Saimadavi.

Sarakarn P. The efficacy of aloe vera gel in the treatment of oral lichen planus: A randomized controlled trial. Br J Dermatol 2008;158:573–577. 12. Vogler BK, Ernst E. Aloe vera: A systemic review of its clinical effectiveness. Br J Gen Pract 1999;49:823–828. 13. Smith S, Jindal R, Singh S. Aloe vera: Boon to dentistry. Indian Dent Res Rev 2010;138–141. 14. Surjushe A, Vasani R, Saple DG. Aloe vera: A short

REFERENCES

review. Indian J Dermatol 2008;53:163–166. 15. Davis RH, Leitner MG, Russo JM, Byrne ME. Wound healing oral and topical activity of aloe vera. J Am

1. Amerikanou

CP,

Markopoulos

AK,

Belazi

M,

Ped Med Assoc 1989;79:559–562.

Karamitsos D, Papanayotou P. Prevalence of oral

16. Sampath Kumar KP, Bhowmik D, Chiranjib L, Biswajit

lichen in diabetes mellitus according to the type of

M. Aloe vera: A potential herb and its medicinal importance. J Chem Pharm Res 2010;2:21–29.

diabetes. Oral Dis 1998;4:37–40. 2. Colquhoun AN, Ferguson MM. An association

17. Hayes SM. Lichen planus—Report of successful

between oral lichen planus and a persistently dry

treatment with aloe vera. Gen Dent 1999;47:268–272.

mouth. Oral Surg Oral Med Oral Pathol Oral Radiol

18. Salazar-Sánchez N, López-Jornet P, Camacho-

Endod 2004;98:1–8.

Alonso F, Sanchez-Siles M. Efficacy of topical aloe

3. Vas dis ML, Parks ET. Prevalence of oral lichen planus

vera in patients with oral lichen planus: A random-

in patients with diabetes mellitus. Oral Surg Oral Med

ized double-blind study. J Oral Pathol Med 2010; 39:735–740.

Oral Pathol Oral Radiol Endod 1995;79:696–700. 4. Roopashree MR, Gondhalekar RV, Shashikanth MC,

19. Davis RH, Joseph JD, Donato D, Hartman GM, Haas

George J, Thippeswamy SH, Shukla A. Pathogenesis

RC. Inflammatory and Wound Healing Action of Aloe

of oral lichen planus—A review. J Oral Pathol Med

Vera. Hightstown: Mettler Instrument, 1994:77–81.

2010;39:729–734. 5. Burket S. Oral Medicine, ed 11. Hamilton: BC Decker, 2008.

800

VOLUME 43 t /6.#&39 t 0$50#&3 2012