Reinforcement Learning for Active Model Selection

Reinforcement Learning for Active Model Selection Aloak Kapoor [email protected]

Russell Greiner [email protected]

Department of Computing Science University of Alberta Edmonton, AB T6J 2E8 _A+S#V/
Ÿ
%'#,.*
.+KF6D0 #,"0 ; 

#S  +F"(€1

ABSTRACT

`*
\=%'/*  G*D 0E; 

#7F6D0 #,G124*3%H
6IFJ *+8>8:;6 +=`%-
# (D%'*  2%' J
D0
#= J+,""%"M

+,F ¥-"%GD%>/#"%-2` J07

+,FJ ¤

+8RS%' J"3[D0 +,F ¥-"* 6 
%*S%- !M
E,003+,
N(%2F60#0

 +F"©""6 "3 6 "%c2' 
/
#– D%'B+8!F60#0  

#X
L#,"
 m(G
k12o8:;6 "%K+8\/FJ"/"0L' 

#

Categories and Subject Descriptors

M x M y9d z{;|}^~€V}^D‚Uƒ„U|"… ‚:‚:}s†…„A,….gˆ‡)!; 

#;‰OŠrD‹ŒŽmqhwrJ>rJw‘2’3“ u'‹”.u–•V—Œ qs˜qsŽmqhwr)™2•v'•š*uŽuv9’/u•vrq:r ”


%-
""%9
XFJ* 6 D%'0
X
1.(A12 7%'/
#,K+,
@ *G 1b 0EjmmM ,M( G"/%'%'3[D;+,
E""6 nCFJ"
#9 ""  ++ J2 J '8:+ 
G+8N%-' "#/%c8:+

Keywords

#,
 AF60#07; 

# M

+,%-%


#jmlH)n"
/5.6"%2+*9/0 "6
0 £Mcµ ">µ "+
x M

+
Ex>  "%'"
.%cR1+ &UMbiHA

+.+8:%H


J+,*%?>  
#

FJR8s+,6
D07
$>iH  J"
D0 3`NM

%' J""3["%?G
0`I+8U2"+/
*+

F%'I
++,
%B+8C /
8:+ ""*"
.R; 

# ·N8C
+(J1\ 8s B

+,
%G+;
 6 b+IB  +,F"

 

  i¬%'+8

%"‡

µ 
" "%'63?+8U"+,6+,*R+8€"+/


 7+=6 U0;

/  J0R"+/
NM + )`* ,(;38"+


/  J0S
D0E6 
%B6 4,0 %"(N"
S%R0"
%'E8:6
+,


%b6 U0"0I+

j

n· +8!"+,6 %',(9%'*/ b6 U0;

+."6 %>8:+ =%–+6"+*,MEj:®*0"%' /FJ–=`\8:+ ;



87

+8b*0 "
%'3E8:6
+,
X
D0=6 U0%9
4+,6 9%'* 38s 
# %'%'6*

/+
%!FJ"+;1>M n

c+,


',

 %!
0>0"
%'R6 U0%!"+
./
6

6
./!9F6D0 #,B%R` D6%-0ajm£

:9

«

fVnM


"\9F60#,B%

`6%-0N(GS 
/
#Q J /+ 0L%+;+%'"
7‰ 6%'0/
7U8:6 6 

%

%H–67/; #, HD


‚ Ž„

D  +,FF/3P.M « FJ+

X
D0

j

+.+%'
#*"+/


lG"# ;j

0  +FDFS+=@? A

8 =B? A ,DCE26F   

  O

 ,HGJI L=@? ANM  "  P 3ER K P(Q S UT  

:9 , WVX1T 

§

M?!+.+%'"3$%' J"& 
#( 12
j Zn § j €n(G*
%bD;G="+,
%G/&,"37+

+ ?`* ,(38NB"+,
=%C
3/3=>±cjhy

$+7FJ=I;` /–6

"%'R12 >£R%GM

+.""6 %IFJ""6%'7µ k"+,* 6"%9%'"+ K8s+ –"+,






%

/ %c
=GF60#?+9>%'
#/H"+,


7

M

  J0awrJu(U
07
µ  " J"%2>  < +6%G"6^;@

7

W7

±cl\(?µ 

D%=%-' +,
#4 J '8s+ 
",(cF6 I%*%-G%'6FJ+,

/mM

P
  '"6/; (Dµ E%'6TU %?/
%'36D;+,
%12 GI63 G"+,
%



"+
%'/0 
#a+1

W7



M

$ 

#

12+,6 

eE+,
%"+6/0Q
.  ¤ +9*  +;0 ""%'+,
$' ,M

(

)

/+
%

5%* # ' 8^ ' ‚ „  ‚  „  a F

9(C 1b; 0a8:6
+,


#

(9%'2+8

(C
D0X$' 
%'3/+
X8:6
+,


\MCµ J"3[D/3.(.1cB/0"
.38s*\%-;

+8!H$p>³XF –

–

"/

#\F60#,£ h( 
0*F IG"+,"+,
7+8A±c\. J  D@ * %+;+8?–8:+ ‡ ,£ M9_I"+*  § § %'9+8c DF%-"%\"+ ' "%' J+,
0%\+E€* J+,%'%'F/ J+%-@

F,+

 + H±c=0%-' F6 /+
%bD;b
+.""6 2+/
712$£



2W-* (  5 2 5' 5

/+
%b+8!R$p>³X"+ ' "%' J+,
0+\ "+/


2.3 Standard Policies *+ 0N%'/+,
!M



%)c[D
3@ˆ+ "+
9 &V+;
+,

\/0>; F3'  37^; #,,‡ q:¡ur•r

u qs˜Žm˜B•

w˜q:Žmq:¡uBq:rŽuh”.uv

v'w "’/uš ‘CqsŽ j Exn ¤ jˆx ¤ nR˜Œ Ž •ŽŽ u •,Žmqhwr•Ž’/u'•˜ŽC©Žmq:š*u˜

”.uŽ)£

BuŽˆ•,j-e

Œ‹,“

w,’ qm *Žˆ• Vu˜9•˜Œ w DŽmq:š=•,’

_Rµ S#,+ 3

6"%97` J"0 "# j

eZŽ uvu

enBwq:r˜Z•rJ‹

&

n

x,n

j

xn'nc%

6 

#>6

y MŸiH%IK' 
%'3+,
 8:6
+,
Ÿ%' J""3[D%

u

j

nc
 ^">+8 9j

nM

3.1 The Optimal Policy

   WN  % n ! y  n , "{– $# L , –
k n n %#&/  ; W ( ' c 7 Single Coin Lookahead (SCL). e,M

*j

j

"+=@

5 6+,
Qxn–+8GK J+,XD;

6
D0  G
$+, N J+/N‡ j

n

`

j

nd

j

±c"#


#*bR"
D0%-%G
K127£

n

j

ng



j .n

fI
D0 J '8s+ *
#

Z

$Z


Z‚s…!… | A{;… "… |  "… D{QA{

nZ

D‚ A… )„A,|} J„





µ 

;6 "%

e






&

!}4|"}:„A†]| A…

±cl

lH?jm%'en

±c60#,(J$
%G
0Eµ 
D0 07pB"< ^;+,
%



±c6D0 #,(D$
µ ;%"( c+
[J0 "
>P
. 
  1 0 %"( 
D0=# ,0 6D3*; 

#9R J+,=+





*
/*"HR` J"0K "# M

0.25

nZ nZ Z

%'/+,
!M?lG" J"0K" %'+ 0"%2+8!\$pR³Ÿ
7FJB%'/–6/"0N(

0.50

0.75

1.0

Lambda

Z

D‚< A…

\‚s8=
>A@?BADC¬D„FEGIH

+ =+6 IlBo
1%I""6/;0a8:+ =±cl\(€µ €(Z
D0=[%'+;12
$/
_)F/9x.M

8^ "
D0 9DB8:+ 9C

+,F/*%B"+
%'/0 "0N(!"3@  R±cl

+ \µ  

+ 06"0$\%'/"%-R` J"0$ "# MHP


12/0 \ 
#9+8C J+,
.%G
$> D; * H%' D",(/
"6D0 /
#*+*FJ;>µ +,
 •r K+8Z\

+,F"*%"M?®a

7

Djm,M #MC"+
[D0"
"B
. +,F%' %'"G`3 12Ktu'•ŽmŒ vu˜–; –
/600
Et"u•ŽmŒ v'u\”v'wŒ DM n

+ R+,6

,



+ R`* ,( )#,6 7e9%'+12%B\ %'63%R+8?+ !+8CE%-;,M "+,6^0L"+* 6 4+ B J+,

%'+,*G%'""2%'+8A%-"%c/
G%*B*+6
.c+8!*G3

&,"%A "
8:+ "*"
.A; 

#H#"
.!+2"+* Z' 
/
#MAP
TU"( H+ ³

8s+ I6/+,
O
¯@

+.+
%R*+,
#=+,F ¥-"%"M

%"M ³) D %)/" "%-? #6*"
.G•”V•q:r˜Ž)6%'
#BlHK8s+ ?/
SI#"
 €F60#,0S; 

#7  +F@



'!rDuvŽˆ•q:rŽ

:

«

 

+;` +
 #,+ M

%=+46%'$" 8s6GF%-' +,
%*+S' 
%-8:+ 

:Z

J„N|{}

nZ


A|} D„7

l9M$+.+,
.MJiG%'""+,
NMDP
GŠ(Jxf,f .M

1 &

7

d g>pIMi9M c+,
!( ZM

D 
m(
04MDM,+ 0
!MDiH "< 1 %98:+ I –"+**"
.%"MlG6%'%'" 
#M

4w‹.uvr

"* J+ @0 TU "
"B/" 

#=1278:6
+,


#"
 +,6%%'6  J+ 'MQ®a$%'+aD
&ap>
oN/+'
0

%'+HD
& %U?iHFJ 'bP
#,"
63

n

,x.M

d3e !;g1M 9MD_%'3%'& /%H
0±HM –MlH+.M iG

3 %'%H+8

c «

(Ae

d3e g\l9MµUMDµ 6 '+,
$
D07i9M

12/!  +;*+ 0+8

FJ' >8:;6 "%>8s+ \8:6
+,
   +` /;+,
!(U1c= ""+,**
D0

Rµ

—i—— n

$•rJ‹+9•Žˆ•+q:rq:r ” Cwrt"uvurJu(!e

d3e g–µUMlH6%'%'"A
D0$³)M B+ < # M.GvŽmq )cqm•,’UŠrŽu’:’ q/”.urJu/0

+,F/]+8JF60#0I; 

# M?µ J""3[3.(V
I2F%'
"b+8

US y7

L*""
.

` J *"
.%"M bŒ’s’/uŽmq:rSw-tRŽ u,Gš*uvqm•r-4•Ž uš*•Žmqm•’



_%' "%'63%

; ?*+%-)" 8:612"
\"+,
%'^0  
#H   +V"%!8s+ !C#,"
 

±?+ 6 + %\12%'X+$
&

;"%"M

d3e g\›–M lH+FF/
%"MJµ +,*>%' J"%2+8ZR%'5.6
/A0 "%'#,
+8

%'* /> J+//%B; \FR+*"+1 2 "# 21278m H"%'%

c

k

>q:˜w¡uv



6 –` @

J /*
%"(A+,
4

Acknowledgments

cMD³Z +; "
@

0 3TU "
.–8s6 $%'%98:+ I8:6
+
Q 

+;` +
!M

&



/ #,$  +,F"*%

8s+ "*"
.H; 

#=+0 "%'/A R#6D; 
."0DG±?l   
#[ %-K"+/
L
kE%'M

12

_ 6%"(G±cl

12&V%'6FJ+,

/0 ""%'+,
a12
"