Reinforcing sound management through trade: shea tree products in ...

Download PDF
45 downloads 530 Views 147KB Size Report
Comment
the protection of productive individual. Reinforcing sound management through trade: shea tree products in Africa. '.T. Masters, ,.A. ;idana and P.0. .ovett.


4GKPHQTEKPIUQWPFOCPCIGOGPVVJTQWIJVTCFG UJGCVTGGRTQFWEVUKP#HTKEC '6/CUVGTU,#;KFCPCCPF20.QXGVV

&GXGNQROGPVQHPQPYQQF RTQFWEVUHTQOVJGUJGCVTGG QHHGTURTQOKUGHQTDQVJNQECN CPFGZRQTVVTCFG

6

JGKPVGITKV[QHVJGPCVWTCNGPXKTQP OGPVVQDGKPJGTKVGFD[VJGPGZV IGPGTCVKQP QH #HTKECP HCTOGTU FGRGPFU XGT[ OWEJ QP VJG NKXGNKJQQF QRRQTVWPKVKGUCPFEQPUVTCKPVUVJGKTRCT GPVUHCEGVQFC[+VFGRGPFUQPUOCNNFGEK UKQPUOCFGGXGT[FC[D[NQECNTGUQWTEG WUGTUDCUGFQPEQPUKFGTCVKQPQHEQUVUCPF DGPGſVUDWVQHVGPYKVJUJQTVVGTOEQP UKFGTCVKQPUPGEGUUCTKN[HQTGOQUVKPOKPF 6JWUVJQUGEQPEGTPGFYKVJUWUVCKPCDNG OCPCIGOGPVQH#HTKECPHQTGUVUCPFYQQF NCPFUPGGFVQEQPUKFGTYC[UVQCFFXCNWG VQVJGTGPGYCDNGPQPYQQFRTQFWEVUQH HQTGUVUCPFYQQFNCPFUYJKEJOKIJVRTQ XKFGRTCEVKECNOCTMGVDCUGFKPEGPVKXGU HQTVJGUWUVCKPCDNGOCPCIGOGPVCPFEQP UGTXCVKQPQHVJGTGUQWTEGU 2GTJCRU VJG ITGCVGUV RQVGPVKCN KP VJKU TGURGEVNKGUKPVJGEQOOGTEKCNFGXGNQR OGPVQHRTQFWEVUHTQOPCVWTCNN[QEEWT TKPIURGEKGUYKVJTGCF[ KHQHVGPWPFG XGNQRGF OCTMGVXCNWG1PGUWEJURGEKGU QPN[HQWPFKPUWD5CJCTCP#HTKECKUVJG UJGCVTGG8KVGNNCTKCRCTCFQZC U[P$WV[ TQURGTOWORCTMKK$WV[TQURGTOWORCTC FQZWO YJKEJKUKPFKIGPQWUVQCDCPFQH XGIGVCVKQPGZVGPFKPIQXGTMOHTQO 5GPGICNVQ'VJKQRKCCPF7ICPFC 6JKU CTVKENG FGUETKDGU VJG PQPYQQF RTQFWEVU FGTKXGF HTQO VJG UJGC VTGG VJGNQECNCPFGZRQTVOCTMGVUHQTVJGO CPF TGEGPV GHHQTVU VQ GPJCPEG OCTMGV

QRRQTVWPKVKGUCPFKPETGCUGTGVWTPUVQVJG RTKOCT[RTQFWEGTUD[CFFKPIXCNWGRCT VKEWNCTN[VJTQWIJSWCNKV[KORTQXGOGPVU CPFKPKVKCVKXGUUWEJCUEGTVKHKECVKQPCPF HCKTVTCFGNCDGNNKPI 5*'#$766'4#0&+65/#4-'65

6JGHTWKVQHVJGUJGCVTGGTKRGPUFWTKPI VJG CPPWCN JWPIT[ UGCUQP YJGP HQQF UWRRNKGUCTGCVVJGKTNQYGUVGDDCPFCITK EWNVWTCNNCDQWTTGSWKTGOGPVUCTGCVVJGKT RGCM+VKUTKEJKPXKVCOKPUCPFOKPGTCNU CPFPQVNCEMKPIKPRTQVGKP+PUKFGVJGHTWKV KU C UGGF TKEJ KP VJG OKZVWTG QH GFKDNG QKNUCPFHCVUMPQYPCUUJGCDWVVGTŌC ETWEKCNPWVTKVKQPCNTGUQWTEGHQTOKNNKQPU QHTWTCNJQWUGJQNFU 6JG /QTQEECP VTCXGNGT +DP $CVVWVC CNTGCF[QDUGTXGFTGIKQPCNVTCFGQHUJGC DWVVGT CETQUU 9GUV #HTKEC KP VJG HQWT VGGPVJ EGPVWT[ # HGY EGPVWTKGU NCVGT VJG5EQVVKUJGZRNQTGT/WPIQ2CTMPQVGF VJG ITGCV KORQTVCPEG QH UJGC DWVVGT KP RTGUGPVFC[ /CNK CPF 5GPGICN 2CTM  JGOCFGVJGHKTUVMPQYPDQVCPK ECNFTCYKPIUQHVJGVTGGCPFCVVGORVGF VQENCUUKH[VJGURGEKGU .QPI CUUQEKCVGF YKVJ JWOCP UGVVNG OGPVUVJGUJGCVTGGOC[DGECNNGFőUGOK FQOGUVKECVGFŒ KP VJCV KVU IGTORNCUO TGHNGEVUEQPUEKQWUUGNGEVKQPQXGTOKNNGP PKCŌKGKORTQXGOGPVQHVJGURGEKGUD[ VJGRTQVGEVKQPQHRTQFWEVKXGKPFKXKFWCN

'NKQV6/CUVGTUYQTMUHQTVJG 9QTNF#ITQHQTGUVT[%GPVTG +%4#(  $COCMQ/CNK ,QUJWC#;KFCPCKUKPVJG &GRCTVOGPVQH*QTVKEWNVWTGCVVJG 7PKXGTUKV[HQT&GXGNQROGPV5VWFKGU 6COCNG)JCPC 2GVGT0.QXGVVYQTMUYKVJVJG9GUV #HTKEC6TCFG*WD#EETC)JCPC

6*'5*'#241,'%6

5JGCVTGGU 8KVGNNCTKC RCTCFQZC CTG RTGUGTXGFFWTKPI NCPFENGCTCPEGHQT HCTOKPICPFHQTORCTV QHKPFKIGPQWUHCTOKPI U[UVGOU RCTMNCPF YKVJUJGCVTGGUKP 7ICPFC

7PCU[NXC8QN



(#1%(74(#+&766+

6JGHTWKVQHVJGUJGC VTGGKUTKEJKPXKVCOKPU CPFOKPGTCNUCPF KVUUGGFKUTKEJKPVJG OKZVWTGQHGFKDNGQKNU CPFHCVUMPQYPCU UJGCDWVVGT

DWVVGTJCUDGEQOGCXCNWGFKPITGFKGPV KPVJGHKPGUVPCVWTCNEQUOGVKEU (KPVTCE %QRQTCVKQP   CPF GXGP UOCNN COQWPVU KP C HQTOWNCVKQP ECP GCTP C RTQOKPGPV FKURNC[ QP VJG NCDGN 6JG EQUOGVKECPFRJCTOCEGWVKECNKPFWUVTKGU EQPUWOG CP GUVKOCVGF  VQ  VQPPGUQHUJGCDWVVGTGCEJ[GCTCPFVJKU HKIWTGKUGZRGEVGFVQTKUGYKVJITQYKPI FGOCPFKPPGYOCTMGVU *1961#&&8#.7'!

7PCU[NXC8QN

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

6QTGKPHQTEGUQWPFOCPCIGOGPVVQUWU VCKPVJGURGEKGUKVKUKORQTVCPVVQOCZK OK\G TGVWTPU VQ VJG RTKOCT[ RTQFWEGTU ŌVJGHCTOGTUYJQOCMGVJGOCPCIGOGPV FGEKUKQPU QP YJKEJ VJG HWVWTG QH VJG VTGGCPFVJGGEQNQIKECNKPVGITKV[QHVJG NCPFUECRGFGRGPF 1PGQHVJGOQUVUVTCKIJVHQTYCTFOGCPU QHCFFKPIXCNWGVQCP[EQOOQFKV[KUVJG RTQEGUUKPIQHTCYOCVGTKCNKPVQJKIJGT XCNWG GPFRTQFWEVU Ō KP VJKU ECUG VJG GZVTCEVKQPQHUJGCDWVVGTHTQOUJGCPWVU 5JGC DWVVGT FQGU JCXG C JKIJGT XCNWG VJCP UJGC PWVU DWV VJG XCNWG FGRGPFU XGT[OWEJQPVJGOCTMGVQPYJKEJKVKU UQNFCPFKPVJGECUGQHNQECNOCTMGVU QPVJGVKOGQH[GCT UGG(KIWTG 6TCFK VKQPCNGZVTCEVKQPWUKPIMPGCFKPIOGVJ QFU[KGNFUCDQWVVQRGTEGPVDWVVGT D[FT[YGKIJVYJKNGGZRGNNGTOGVJQFU VJCVKPENWFGVJGWUGQHUQNXGPVU[KGNFWR VQRGTEGPV

/QUVQHVJGUJGCPWVU EQNNGEVGFGCEJ[GCT CTGRTQEGUUGFKPVQ UJGCDWVVGTHQTJQOG EQPUWORVKQPCPFVQ OGGVNQECNOCTMGV FGOCPF

(#1%(74(#+&766+

VTGGU QP HCTOGF NCPF DCUGF QP NQECNN[ HCXQWTGFETKVGTKCUWEJCUUYGGVPGUUQH HTWKVVQVCNJCTXGUVCDNG[KGNFVTGGJGCNVJ TGFWEGFEQORGVKVKQPYKVJCPPWCNETQRU GVE .QXGVVCPF*CSC/CTCP\CPF 9KGUOCP  6JGUJGCVTGGITQYUXGT[UNQYN[[KGNF KPIKVUHKTUVHTWKVJCTXGUVCHVGTVQ [GCTU/CVWTGVTGGUCTGRTGUGTXGFFWTKPI NCPFENGCTCPEGHQTHCTOKPICPFVJWUHQTO RCTVQHVJGKPFKIGPQWUHCTOKPIU[UVGO 6JG VTGGU DGPGHKV HTQO VJG CITQPQOKE RTCEVKEGUGORNQ[GFHQTVJGCPPWCNETQRU UWEJCUYGGFKPICPFOCPCIGOGPVQHUQKN HGTVKNKV[8QNWPVGGTUGGFNKPIUCTGOCP CIGFVQOCVWTKV[CPFVJGVTGGRQRWNCVKQP KUEQPVTQNNGFVQCXQKFQXGTUJCFKPIQHVJG CPPWCNETQRU /QUVQHVJGUJGCPWVUEQNNGEVGFGCEJ [GCTCTGRTQEGUUGFKPVQUJGCDWVVGTHQT JQOG EQPUWORVKQP CPF VQ OGGV NQECN OCTMGV FGOCPF *QYGXGT UKPEG VJG HKTUVJCNHQHVJGVYGPVKGVJEGPVWT[VJGTG JCUCNUQDGGPCPGZRQTVOCTMGVHQTUJGC PWVUCUCEJGCRTCYOCVGTKCNUQWTEGQH XGIGVCDNGHCV1XGTRGTEGPVQHUJGC PWVGZRQTVUUGTXGVJGHQQFKPFWUVT[UJGC DWVVGTKUKPFWUVTKCNN[GZVTCEVGFOCKPN[ KP'WTQRGCPFUWDUGSWGPVN[UGRCTCVGF KPVQ C XGIGVCDNG HCV HTCEVKQP UVGCTKP  UQNF HQT HQTOWNCVKQP KPVQ EQEQC DWVVGT GSWKXCNGPVUQTKORTQXGTU %$'U%$+U  CPFOCTICTKPGUCPFCPQKNHTCEVKQPWUGF CUCNQYXCNWGDCUGHQTOCTICTKPGUCPF CUCEQORQPGPVQHCPKOCNHGGFU



5JGCDWVVGTHQTJGCNVJOQTGVJCPUMKPFGGR 5JGC DWVVGT JCU DGGP WUGF HQT EGPVWTKGU

RGTJCRUOKNNGPPKC CUCUMKPVTGCVOGPVKP #HTKEC RCTVKEWNCTN[ HQT PGYDQTP KPHCPVU #NVJQWIJVJGENKPKECNFCVCQHVGPTGHGTTGFVQ D[VJGEQUOGVKEEQORCPKGUVJCVOCTMGVUJGC DWVVGTCTGJCTFVQNQECVGTGEGPVUEKGPVKſE UVWFKGUUWRRQTVKVUCNNGIGFVJGTCRGWVKEXCNWG KPVTGCVOGPVQHEGTVCKPUMKPFKUQTFGTU6JG DKQCEVKXGUWDUVCPEGUKPUJGCDWVVGTTGUKFGKP VJGWPUCRQPKſCDNGHTCEVKQPŌVJGQKNUQNWDNG EQPUVKVWGPVUVJCVYQWNFPQVTGCEVYKVJCN MCNKVQHQTOUQCRŌYJKEJKUCD[RTQFWEV QHVJG%$'%$+RTQFWEVKQPRTQEGUU6JG[ KPENWFGCPVKQZKFCPVUUWEJCUVQEQRJGTQNU

XKVCOKP '  CPF ECVGEJKPU CNUQ HQWPF KP ITGGPVGC #NCPFGTCPF#PFGTUUQP   CPF#NCPFGT  KFGPVKſGFQVJGTURGEKſE EQORQWPFU UWEJ CU VTKVGTRGPG CNEQJQNU MPQYPVQTGFWEGKPƀCOOCVKQPEKPPCOKE CEKF GUVGTU YJKEJ JCXG NKOKVGF ECRCEKV[ VQCDUQTDWNVTCXKQNGV 78 TCFKCVKQPCPF

NWRGQN YJKEJ RTGXGPVU VJG GHHGEVU QH UMKP CIKPID[KPJKDKVKPIGP\[OGUVJCVFGITCFG UMKPRTQVGKPU5JGCDWVVGTCNUQRTQVGEVUUMKP D[ UVKOWNCVKPI RTQFWEVKQP QH UVTWEVWTCN RTQVGKPUD[URGEKCNK\GFUMKPEGNNU $522JCTOCCLQKPVXGPVWTGDGVYGGPVJG &CPKUJQKNUCPFHCVUOCPWHCEVWTGT#CTJWU 1NKGHCDTKM CPF VJG DKQRJCTOCEGWVKECN EQORCP[ #UVKQP KU EWTTGPVN[ WUKPI UJGC WPUCRQPKſCDNGUVQRTQFWEGCPCPVKKPƀCO OCVQT[VTGCVOGPVHQTCTVJTKVKUCPFCVQRKECN VTGCVOGPVHQTGZEGOCCPFQVJGTUMKPEQPFK VKQPUKPENWFKPIJGTRGUNGUKQPU$522JCTOC KU CNUQ RTQFWEKPI C őPWVTCEGWVKECNŒ UJGC RTQFWEVENKPKECNN[RTQXGPVQNQYGTJWOCP EJQNGUVGTQN 6JGUG VJGTCRGWVKE WUGU QH UJGC DWVVGTŏU EQPUVKVWGPVEQORQWPFUEQWNFEQPUKFGTCDN[ GPJCPEGVJGCNTGCF[UKIPKſECPVKPVGTGUVKP UJGCDWVVGTŌUKPEGHGYRTQFWEVUPCVWTCN QTU[PVJGVKEECPDGETGFKVGFYKVJUNQYKPI

QTTGXGTUKPIVJGRTQEGUUQHCIKPI*QYGXGT VJGTGKUVJGSWGUVKQPQHJQYOWEJVJKUKPVGT GUVYKNNDGPGſVVJGRTQFWEGTU%QORCPKGU UWEJ CU -CTNUJCOP C 5YGFKUJ EQORCP[ VJCVKUCPQVJGTQHVJGOCLQTRNC[GTUKPVJG KPVGTPCVKQPCN UJGC KPFWUVT[ JCXG OQXGF VQ RTQVGEV VJGKT KPXGUVOGPV KP TGUGCTEJ CPFFGXGNQROGPVQHPGYWUGUHQTVJGWPUC RQPKſCDNGEQPVGPVQHUJGCDWVVGTVJTQWIJ RCVGPVU QP VJG RTQEGUUGU D[ YJKEJ VJGUG WUGHWNUWDUVCPEGUCTGKUQNCVGFCPFGPTKEJGF HTQOVJGKTPCVWTCNHQTO+PVGTOUQHKPVGN NGEVWCNRTQRGTV[TKIJVUKVKUJQRGFVJCVVJG QYPGTUJKR QH UJGC IGPGVKE TGUQWTEGU YKNN DGTGURGEVGFCPFNGICNN[RTQVGEVGFHQTVJG DGPGſVQHVJGRGQRNGQHVJGUJGCRTQFWEKPI PCVKQPU 2QUG[CPF&WVſGNF 

+PVGTGUVKPIN[ VJG RTKEG QH UJGC PWVU CPFUJGCDWVVGTKUCRRTQZKOCVGN[VYKEG CUJKIJKPVJGEQWPVTKGUHWTVJGUVTGOQXGF HTQO VJG GZRQTV OCTMGV 7ICPFC VJG 5WFCP %GPVTCN #HTKECP 4GRWDNKE 5GPGICN CUKVKUKPVJQUGYKVJVJGOQUV FKTGEVCEEGUUVQGZRQTVRWTEJCUG )JCPC /CNK$WTMKPC(CUQ  9KVJKP9GUV#HTKECVJGUGEQPVTCFKE VKQPU RTGUGPV QDUVCENGU VQ VJG EQJGT GPV UVTCVKHKECVKQP QH RTQFWEV RTKEGU CU CHWPEVKQPQHRTQFWEVSWCNKV[+P/CNK HQTKPUVCPEGVJGKPFWUVT[RC[UUKIPKHK ECPVN[NGUUHQTUJGCPWVUVJCPKP)JCPC

UGG6CDNG QTGXGP$WTMKPC(CUQIKXGP VJGENQUGTRTQZKOKV[QHVJQUGEQWPVTKGU VQCEEGUUKDNGRQTVU +H MI QH UJGC DWVVGT HTGG QP DQCTF

HQD UJKRCV6GOC)JCPCKUXCNWGF CVPQVOQTGVJCP75CPFMIQHUJGC PWVU CV 75 20 .QXGVV WPRWD NKUJGFTGRQTVU VJGTGKUPQVOWEJQHC

OCTIKPVQYQTMYKVJWPNGUUHWTVJGTYC[U ECPDGHQWPFQHCFFKPIXCNWGUWEJCU FGXGNQRKPICPKEJGOCTMGV QTTCPIGQH PKEJGOCTMGVU RTGFKECVGFQPRTQFWEVUQH GZEGRVKQPCNSWCNKV[QTFGXGNQRKPIQVJGT RTQFWEVUQTHQTOUQHRTQEGUUKPI#PQVJGT YC[VQCFFXCNWGQPVJGRTQFWEVKQPUKFG

YQWNFDGVQTGFWEGRTQEGUUKPIEQUVUD[ KPETGCUKPIVJGGHHKEKGPE[ CPFVJWUVJG RTQHKVCDKNKV[ QHRTQFWEVKQP

9JKNGCJKIJGTSWCNKV[DWVVGTOC[HGVEJ CJKIJGTOCTMGVRTKEGKVKUCNUQRTGHGTTGF

(#1%(74(#+&766+

%QUOGVKECPF RJCTOCEGWVKECN CRRNKECVKQPUHQTOC TGNCVKXGN[UOCNNDWV HCUVITQYKPICPF RQVGPVKCNN[JKIJ XCNWGOCTMGVPKEJG HQTUJGCPWVUCPF UJGCDWVVGT

+/2418+0)241&7%637#.+6;

7PCU[NXC8QN



7PCU[NXC8QN

 

 

 

 

 









 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

HQT JQOG EQPUWORVKQP CPF YKNN MGGR 2TKEGRGTNKVTG 7ICPFCPUJKNNKPIU NQPIGT KP UVQTCIG VJCP C RQQTSWCNKV[   RTQFWEV 2TQFWEV SWCNKV[ QH DQVJ UJGC PWVUCPFUJGCDWVVGTFGRGPFURTKOCTKN[QP   RQUVJCTXGUVRTQEGUUKPIUWEJCURCTDQKN   KPIQHUJGCPWVUCVVJGUVCTVQHVJGUGCUQP   VQRTGXGPVVJGUGGFUHTQOIGTOKPCVKPI   CPFVQFT[VJGOOQTGSWKEMN[5WPFT[ KPIQHUJGCPWVRTQXKFGUDGVVGTSWCNKV[   VJCP UOQMKPI PWVU QXGT C HKTG YJKEJ  EQPVCOKPCVGUVJGOYKVJJ[FTQECTDQPU  (TGGHCVV[CEKF ((# EQPVGPVQHHGTUC  UKORN[ECNEWNCVGFKPFGZQHSWCNKV[TGR TGUGPVKPIKPGHHGEVVJGRTQRQTVKQPNQUVVQ  FGITCFCVKQPTGſPKPIUJGCDWVVGTQHRGT  EGPV((#YKNNTGUWNVKPCNQUUQHRGTEGPV QH VJG QTKIKPCN XQNWOG QH WPRTQEGUUGF DWVVGT6JTQWIJUKORNGKORTQXGOGPVUKP RTQEGUUKPIRTCEVKEGUKVJCUDGGPRQUUKDNG     EQPUKUVGPVN[ VQ RTQFWEG UJGC DWVVGT QH 0QVG#XGTCIGGZEJCPIGTCVGHQTVJGRGTKQFUJQYP75J75 EQOOGTEKCNN[CEEGRVGFITCFGUKGYKVJ ((#QHNGUUVJCPRGTEGPV 3EASONALmUCTUATIONINPRICESOF 4GUGCTEJ JCU CNUQ GUVCDNKUJGF VJCV SHEANUTSANDSHEAOILATLOCAL MARKETSINNORTHERN5GANDA VJGV[RKECNN[WPRNGCUCPVQFQWTQH9GUV n #HTKECPUJGCDWVVGT PQVEJCTCEVGTKUVKEQH VJGGCUVGTPUWDURGEKGUPKNQVKEC TGUWNVU HTQOQPGQTOQTGQHVJGUVGRUKPRQUV 'UVKOCVGFEQUVUQHUJGCPWVUGZRQTVGFHTQO)JCPCCPF/CNK %QUVFGVCKNU )JCPC /CNK JCTXGUVRTQEGUUKPICPFVJCVOQFKH[KPI VJGUG UVGRU EQWNF TGFWEG QT RTGXGPV KV (CTOICVGRTKEGRCKFRGTVQPPGUJGCPWVU 75 75

.QXGVV  #XCKNCDNGUVGCTKPRGTVQPPGUJGCPWVU MI MI 6JGTGOC[CNUQDGUEQRGHQTKORTQXKPI 6TCPURQTVEQUVUVQPGCTGUVRQTVRGTVQPPGUJGCPWVU 75 75 SWCNKV[ VJTQWIJ KFGPVKHKECVKQP QH UJGC $QTFGTETQUUKPIEQUVURGTVQPPG  75 VTGGRQRWNCVKQPUYKVJURGEKHKEEJGOKECN 'SWKXCNGPVEQUVRGTVQPPGUJGCPWVU CVRQTVGPVTCPEG 75 75 CVVTKDWVGU EQPHGTTKPI GPJCPEGF XCNWG 6QPPGUUJGCPWVUTGSWKTGFRGTVQPPGUVGCTKP   IKXGPVJGFGITGGQHEJGOKECNCPFIGPGVKE 'SWKXCNGPVEQUVRGTVQPPGUVGCTKP CVRQTVGPVTCPEG 75 75 XCTKCVKQP DGVYGGP RQRWNCVKQPU .QXGVV CPF*CSD(QPVCKPGGVCN  #UUWORVKQPU CPFVJGGZVTGOGN[URGEKCNK\GFJKIJXCNWG 6QVCNQKNHCVEQPVGPVQHPWV   RTQFWEVUCPFOCTMGVCRRNKECVKQPUFGTKXGF #RRTQZKOCVGUVGCTKPEQPVGPVQHVQVCNQKNHCV   HTQOVJGURGEKGUŏ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ŏOCTIKPUUVQTCIGQT KPIEJGOKECNRTQHKNGUKPENWFKPICPCN[UKU RTQEGUUKPIEQUVU6JGUGCFFGFEQUVUYQWNFOCMG/CNKUVGCTKPGXGPNGUUCVVTCEVKXGCVVJGUGEQUVUCPFHCVRGTEGPVCIGU



(#1%(74(#+&766+

QHUJGCHTWKVUJGCPWVUCPFUJGCDWVVGT OGGVNQECNFGOCPFHQTJKIJXCNWGUJGC VJGGZRQTVCPFKPVGTPCVKQPCNOCTMGVUYKNN HQTQXGTKPFKXKFWCNUJGCVTGGUKPVGP DWVVGTRCTVKEWNCTN[CVVJGDGIKPPKPIQHVJG CNUQDGYKNNKPIVQFQUQ7PFGTEWTTGPV UGCUQPYJGPVJGRTQFWEVKUOQUVUECTEG OCTMGVEQPFKVKQPU%$+DW[GTUOC[UGGM EQWPVTKGUCETQUU#HTKEC QP NQECN OCTMGVU CPF VJG RTKEG KU JKIJ JKIJGTSWCNKV[ PWVU VQ TGFWEG TGHKPKPI +0%'06+8'561+/2418'

'>MURGTUQPCNEQOOWPKECVKQP  EQUVUCPFPKEJGOCTMGVUKPVJGRGTUQPCN 37#.+6; +HVJGTGKUFGOCPFHQTCJKIJGTSWCN ECTGKPFWUVT[OC[DGUWHHKEKGPVN[TGOW 4GEGPVUVWFKGUJCXGKPFKECVGFVJCVRTQ KV[RTQFWEVJKIJGTTGVWTPUVQRTQFWEGTU PGTCVKXGVQUWRRQTVCRTKEGRTGOKWOHQT FWEGTU CTG YKNNKPI VQ KPXGUV CFFKVKQPCN ECP UWRRQTV KPXGUVOGPV KP CFFKVKQPCN C DWVVGT QH QRVKOCN SWCNKV[ $WV KP VJG CVVGPVKQPKPKORTQXGFRTQFWEVSWCNKV[KH KPRWVU KPENWFKPI VKOG CPF NCDQWT CU CDUGPEGQHKPHQTOCVKQPQPYJGVJGT CPF VJG[CTGOQVKXCVGFD[KPETGCUGFTGVWTPU YGNNCUCRRTQRTKCVGGSWKROGPVUWEJCU JQYOWEJ UJGCPWVDW[GTUCTGYKNNKPI QTUQOGQVJGTVCPIKDNGDGPGſV(QTGZCO UQNCTFT[GTU #HTKECPEQPUWOGTUQPNQECN VQ RC[ HQT UJGC RTQFWEVU QH KORTQXGF RNG TWTCN YQOGP UWTXG[GF KP /CNK D[ OCTMGVURCTVKEWNCTN[KPVJG%GPVTCN#HTK SWCNKV[ KV KU FKHHKEWNV VQ RTGFKEV JQY #EVKQP HQT 'PVGTRTKUG C 7PKVGF 5VCVGU ECP 4GRWDNKE 5GPGICN VJG 5WFCP CPF RTQFWEGTUŏ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ſGFDCUGNKPG*QYGXGTVJGKPFWU VT[FGUKTKPIVQQDVCKPJKIJGTSWCNKV[UJGC PWVU CV NQY EQUV JCU DGGP OQXKPI KP TGEGPV[GCTUVQYCTFUVJGCRRNKECVKQPQHC UKPINGƀCVTCVGHQTPWVUQHOKZGFSWCNKV[ 5QOG KPFWUVT[ TGRTGUGPVCVKXGU HGNV VJCV EQPVTCEVRTGOKWOUDCUGFQPSWCNKV[YGTG PQV ſPFKPI VJGKT YC[ VQ VJG RTQFWEGTU VQRTQXKFGCPKPEGPVKXGDWVYGTGTCVJGT RQEMGVGF D[ EQOOGTEKCN KPVGTOGFKCT 5JGCDWVVGTKUVTCFKVKQPCNN[RTQEGUUGF D[KPHQTOCNITQWRUQHYQOGP KGU*QYGXGTYKVJQWVRTKEGKPEGPVKXGU

$WTMKPC(CUQ RTQFWEVSWCNKV[EQWNFVGPFVQYCTFUVJG NQYGUVEQOOQPFGPQOKPCVQT

#UQEKCNRGTURGEVKXGGPXKTQPOGPVCNFGEKUKQPUCTGIGPFGTGF

4WTCNOGPCPFYQOGPQHVGPQEEWR[EQO RNGOGPVCT[KHPQVEQPƀKEVKPITQNGUKPOCP CIGOGPVQHYQQFNCPFU9JGTGCUYQOGPCTG QHVGPEJCTIGFYKVJEQNNGEVKQPCPFRTQEGUUKPI QHPQPYQQFHQTGUVRTQFWEVUHQTJQWUGJQNF WUG OGP CTG OQTG QHVGP EQPEGTPGF YKVJ KPEQOGIGPGTCVKPICEVKXKVKGU6TCFKVKQPCNN[ RTQEGUUKPI QH UJGC DWVVGT KU QHVGP ECTTKGF QWVD[KPHQTOCNITQWRUQHYQOGPYJQRQQN VJGKTNCDQWT6JWUKPGXGT[RTQFWEGTEQWP VT[TWTCNYQOGPŏUITQWRUCPFOCTMGVKPI CUUQEKCVKQPUJCXGCPKORQTVCPVTQNGKPVJG

GZVGPUKQP QH RTQEGUUKPI KPPQXCVKQPU /GP CTGOQTGNKMGN[VQWUGUJGCVTGGTGUQWTEGU VQ RTQFWEG EJCTEQCN YJKEJ JCU UWRGTKQT SWCNKV[TGNCVKXGVQVJCVHTQOQVJGTYQQFUKP EQWPVTKGUYJGTGVJGVTGGITQYU6QGPUWTG UWUVCKPCDNGOCPCIGOGPVCPFEQPUGTXCVKQP QHVJGURGEKGUCPFVJGGEQU[UVGOKPYJKEJ KVVJTKXGUVJGGEQPQOKETGVWTPUHTQOUJGC RTQEGUUKPICPFOCTMGVKPIOWUVDGUWHſEKGPV VQUCVKUH[DQVJOGPCPFYQOGP

+5241&7%6%'46+(+%#6+10# 51.76+10!

+P TGEGPV [GCTU RTQFWEV EGTVKHKECVKQP CEEQTFKPI VQ SWCNKV[ ETKVGTKC JCU DGGP EQPUKFGTGF QPG CXGPWG D[ YJKEJ VJG XCNWG QH UJGC RTQFWEVU OC[ DG TCKUGF HQT VJG DGPGHKV QH RTKOCT[ RTQFWEGTU

9CNVGTGVCN.QXGVV 2TQ FWEVXCNWGKUCNUQGPJCPEGFD[VTCEGCDKN KV[CNQPIVJGUWRRN[EJCKPCPFD[CVVGP VKQPVQVJGGPXKTQPOGPV CUKPQTICPKE őDKQŒQTYKNFETCHVGFRTQFWEVKQP CPFVQ KUUWGUQHRTQFWEGTGSWKV[QTHCKTVTCFG

7PCU[NXC8QN



6JKUEQPEGRVKUEWTTGPVN[WPFGTFGXGNQR OGPVKPCTGIKQPCNKPKVKCVKXGHQTUWRRQTVVQ RTKOCT[RTQFWEGTUQHUJGCPWVUCPFUJGC DWVVGTVJG2TQLGVFŏ#RRWK6GEJPKSWG´ NC(KNKÂTG-CTKVÃ 2TQ-CTKVÃ  UGGYYY RTQMCTKVGQTI UWRRQTVGFD[VJG%QOOQP (WPF HQT %QOOQFKVKGU %(%  CPF VJG 0GVJGTNCPFU )QXGTPOGPV YKVJ VGEJPK ECNUWRRQTVHTQO(#1+ORNGOGPVGFD[ +%4#(2TQ-CTKVÃKUUGGMKPIVQFGXGNQRC RTQITCOOGQHRTQFWEVEGTVKſECVKQPDCUGF QPCJCTOQPK\GFUGVQHSWCNKV[RCTCOGVGTU PQTOUCPFUVCPFCTFUVQDGGUVCDNKUJGFCV VJGTGIKQPCNCPFKPVGTPCVKQPCNNGXGNU 0FKT GVCN +P1EVQDGTVJGRTQLGEV JGNFCYQTMUJQRHQTIQXGTPOGPVRTKXCVG UGEVQTCPFKPFWUVT[TGRTGUGPVCVKXGUHTQO UJGCRTQFWEKPIEQWPVTKGUCETQUUUWD 5CJCTCP#HTKECVQDWKNFTGIKQPCNEQPUGP UWUQPVGEJPKECNKUUWGUQHRTQFWEVSWCNKV[ CUCDCUKUHQTDWKNFKPICTGIKQPCNN[EQJGT GPVCPFKPVGTPCVKQPCNN[ETGFKDNGEGTVKſEC VKQPU[UVGO6JGEGTVKſECVKQPQHUJGCPWVU CPFUJGCDWVVGTYKNNDGDCUGFPQVQPN[QP JQYVJGRTQFWEVKUVTGCVGFFWTKPIJCTXGUV CPFRQUVJCTXGUVRTQEGUUKPIDWVCNUQQP QTKIKPCPFRTQXGPCPEGCPFQVJGTCURGEVU QHRTQFWEVKQPVJCVOC[CFFXCNWGUWEJ CU QTICPKE RTQFWEVKQP RTQFWEGT GSWKV[ CPFHCKTVTCFG &WTKPIVJGUHCKTVTCFGNCDGNNKPI QH UJGC RTQFWEVU YCU FGTCKNGF FWTKPI VJG'WTQRGCP7PKQPFGDCVGQPHCKTVTCFG UVCPFCTFUHQTEJQEQNCVGUKPEGVJGUJGC DWVVGT FGTKXCVKXGU %$'U%$+U  YGTG VJGPXKGYGFCUEQEQCDWVVGTEQORGVKVQTU

%JCNHKP  '(6#0'95   /QTG TGEGPVN[ (CKTVTCFG .CDGNNKPI 1TICPK\CVKQPU+PVGTPCVKQPCN (.1 JCU CICKPDGIWPVQEQPUKFGTHCKTVTCFGNCDGN NKPIUVCPFCTFUHQTUJGCRTQFWEVU1PEG GUVCDNKUJGF KV KU JQRGF VJCV RTQFWEV NCDGNNKPI EQWNF GPEQWTCIG EQPUWOGTU VQRWTEJCUGUJGCDWVVGTRTQFWEVUQDVCKPGF HTQO YQOGP YQTMKPI WPFGT HCKT VTCFG EQPFKVKQPU +V OC[ PQV DG TGCNKUVKE VQ GZRGEV VJCV UJGCPWVUCPFUJGCDWVVGTQHJKIJSWCNKV[

7PCU[NXC8QN

YKNNPGEGUUCTKN[HGVEJCIQQFOCTMGVRTKEG HQTRTQFWEGTU'ZRGTKGPEGUCETQUU#HTKEC KPFKECVGVJCVVQVCNTGVWTPUVQRTQFWEVKQP CTGITGCVGUVYJGPRTQFWEVUCPFOCTMGVU CTG FKXGTUKſGF YKVJ C TCPIG QH RTKEGU 4CKUKPIRTQFWEVSWCNKV[UVCPFCTFUŌCPF FQEWOGPVCVKQPQHQVJGTCURGEVUQHRTQFWE VKQPVJCVCFFXCNWGŌECPJGNRGUVCDNKUJ OCTMGVU HQT UJGC RTQFWEVU QH UWRGTKQT SWCNKV[DCUGFQPCVKGTGFRTKEGU[UVGOCU KUVJGECUGHQTEQHHGG(WTVJGTOQTGVJG TGCNK\CVKQPD[KPVGTPCVKQPCNDW[GTUVJCVVJG #HTKECPUJGCDWVVGTKPFWUVT[KUECRCDNGQH RTQFWEKPICEQPUKUVGPVN[CXCKNCDNGJKIJ SWCNKV[RTQFWEVKPEQOOGTEKCNN[CEEGRV CDNGSWCPVKVKGUUJQWNFGPCDNGUJGCDWVVGT VQEQORGVGDGVVGTYKVJQVJGTUQWTEGUQH UKOKNCTCPFUWDUVKVWVCDNGRTQFWEVU '08+410/'06#.+/2#%651( $'66'4/#4-'612214670+6+'5

4GEGPVECUGUVWFKGUCETQUU#HTKECKPFKECVG VJCVGPJCPEGFOCTMGVQRRQTVWPKVKGUHQT UJGCRTQFWEGTUECPCPFFQJCXGCRQUKVKXG KPƀWGPEGQPUWUVCKPCDNGOCPCIGOGPVQH UJGCVTGGUCPFVJGYQQFNCPFQTRCTMNCPF NCPFUECRGUKPYJKEJVJG[CTGHQWPF&WT KPIVJGUKZVJ[GCTQHVJG5JGC2TQLGEVHQT .QECN%QPUGTXCVKQPCPF&GXGNQROGPVKP PQTVJGTP7ICPFC UGG$QZ CPKPXGPVQT[

QHYQQF[URGEKGUD[UK\GKPTCPFQORNQVU UJQYGFCUVTQPIKPENKPCVKQPVQYCTFUEQP UGTXCVKQPQH[QWPIUJGCVTGGUQPſGNFU CPFHCNNQYNCPFVJTQWIJQWVVJGRTQLGEV CTGCKPUVCTMEQPVTCUVVQCTGCUQWVUKFGVJG \QPGQHKPVGTXGPVKQP 0MWWVWGVCN .QXGVV;KFCPCCPF/CUVGTU  %10%.75+105

)TGCVGTVTCPURCTGPE[CPFSWCNKV[CUUWT CPEGVJTQWIJQWVVJGUWRRN[EJCKPKUCRTG TGSWKUKVGKHVJGUJGCVTGGKUVQTGCEJKVUHWNN RQVGPVKCNCUCPGEQPQOKEPWVTKVKQPCNCPF GPXKTQPOGPVCNTGUQWTEGHQTTWTCNJQWUG JQNFUCETQUU#HTKECCPFHQTHWVWTGIGPGTC VKQPU+PQTFGTHQTVJGFGXGNQROGPVUKP UJGCRTQFWEVUVTCFGVQTGUWNVKPVCPIKDNG KORTQXGOGPVU KP UWUVCKPCDNG OCPCIG OGPVQHVJGUJGCTGUQWTEGCPFCUUQEKCVGF YQQFNCPFUCETQUU#HTKECTGEGPVRCTVPGT UJKRUDGVYGGPTWTCNRTQFWEGTUPCVKQPCN RQNKE[OCMGTU VJG RTKXCVG UGEVQT CPF KPVGTPCVKQPCNKPFWUVT[OWUVEQPVKPWGVQ ITQYCPFUQOGRQTVKQPQHVJGDGPGHKVU OWUVDGEJCPPGNNGFKPVQDGVVGTOCPCIG OGPVQHHQTGUVUCPFYQQFNCPFUX

5JGC2TQLGEVHQT.QECN%QPUGTXCVKQPCPF&GXGNQROGPV 6JG 5JGC 2TQLGEV HQT .QECN %QPUGTXCVKQP CPF &GXGNQROGPV YYYVJGUJGCRTQLGEV QTI DGICPKPYKVJRKNQVHWPFKPIHTQO VJG7PKVGF5VCVGU#IGPE[HQT+PVGTPCVKQPCN &GXGNQROGPV 75#+& 7PFGTVJGRTQLGEV OQTGVJCPOGODGTUQHEQOOWPKV[ DCUGFTWTCNYQOGPŏUITQWRUJCXGHQTOGF VJG 0QTVJGTP 7ICPFC 5JGC 2TQEGUUQTU #UUQEKCVKQP 0752# YJKEJEWTTGPVN[UGNNU UGXGTCN VQPPGU QH RJCTOCEGWVKECNITCFG UJGC DWVVGT VQ EQUOGVKE HQTOWNCVQTU CPF RTKXCVG EQORCPKGU KP VJG 7PKVGF 5VCVGU 'WTQRGCPF,CRCP

9KVJ UKORNG RTQEGUUKPI GSWKROGPV CPF KPKVKCNVTCKPKPIHTQOVJG5JGC2TQLGEVCPF 0752# TWTCN YQOGP KP PGKIJDQWTKPI UQWVJGTP5WFCPJCXGGUVCDNKUJGFVJGKTQYP RTQEGUUKPIEGPVTGUYJKEJEWTTGPVN[UGTXG 0CKTQDK-GP[CYKVJCJKIJSWCNKV[EQUOGVKE RTQFWEVŌCPGYJKIJXCNWGOCTMGVQWVNGV HQTVJGCXCKNCDNGUWTRNWUCHVGTVJGRTKOCT[ PWVTKVKQPCN PGGFU QH VJGKT EQOOWPKVKGU CTGOGV



$KDNKQITCRJ[ #NCPFGT,5JGCDWVVGTŌCOWNVKHWPE VKQPCN KPITGFKGPV HQT HQQF CPF EQUOGVKEU .KRKF6GEJPQNQI[  Ō #NCPFGT,#PFGTUUQP#%6JG UJGCDWVVGTHCOKN[ŌVJGEQORNGVGGOQNNKGPV TCPIGHQTUMKPECTGHQTOWNCVKQPU%QUOGVKEU CPF 6QKNGVTKGU /CPWHCEVWTG 9QTNFYKFG  Ō #XCKNCDNG CV YYYEVOY EQO-#4.5*#/05RFH %JCNſP$5JGC$WVVGT4GRWDNKEUVCVG RQYGT INQDCN OCTMGVU CPF VJG OCMKPI QH CP KPFKIGPQWU EQOOQFKV[ 0GY ;QTM 75#4QWVNGFIG 'WTQRGCP(TGG6TCFG#UUQEKCVKQP '(6#  0GVYQTM QH 'WTQRGCP 9QTNFUJQRU

0'95 #ENQPGKUDGKPIRTQRQUGF $TWUUGNU$GNIKWO1:(#/ (KPVTCE %QTRQTCVKQP  /CTMGV CPF VGEJPKECN UWTXG[ UJGC PWVU 2TGRCTGF HQT 7PKVGF 5VCVGU #IGPE[ QH +PVGTPCVKQPCN &GXGNQROGPV 75#+&  4WTCN CPF #ITKEWNVWTCN +PEQOGU YKVJ C 5WUVCKPCDNG 'PXKTQPOGPV 4#+5' KPKVKCVKXG (QNF0#OCVVGTQHIQQFVCUVG!3WCNKV[ CPF VJG EQPUVTWEVKQP QH UVCPFCTFU HQT EJQEQNCVGKPVJG'WTQRGCP7PKQP%CJKGTU Fŏ'EQPQOKGGV5QEKQNQIKG4WTCNGU Ō (QPVCKPG % .QXGVV 20 5CPQW * /CNG[,$QWXGV,/)GPGVKE FKXGTUKV[ QH VJG UJGC VTGG 8KVGNNCTKC RCTCFQZC%()CGTVP FGVGEVGFD[4#2& CPF EJNQTQRNCUV OKETQUCVGNNKVG OCTMGTU *GTGFKV[  Ō .QXGVV 20  6JG KORCEV QH EGTVKſEC VKQPQPVJGUWUVCKPCDNGWUGQHUJGCDWVVGT

8KVGNNCTKC RCTCFQZC  KP )JCPC 7PRWD NKUJGFRCRGT4QOG(#1 .QXGVV 20  *CS 0 C 'XKFGPEG HQT CPVJTQRKE UGNGEVKQP QH VJG UJGCPWV VTGG 8KVGNNCTKC RCTCFQZC  #ITQHQTGUVT[ 5[UVGOUŌ .QXGVV 20  *CS 0 D &KXGTUKV[

QH VJG UJGCPWV VTGG 8KVGNNCTKC RCTCFQZC )CGTVP%( KP)JCPC)GPGVKE4GUQWTEGU CPF%TQR'XQNWVKQP  Ō .QXGVV 20 ;KFCPC ,#  /CUVGTU '6  6CPIKDNG DGPGſVU GPEQWTCIG UWUVCKPCDNG CITQHQTGUVT[ RCTMNCPFU OCPCIGOGPV QH VJG UJGC VTGG 8KVGNNCTKC RCTCFQZCKPUWD5CJCTCP#HTKECŏUHQTGUVU (QTGUVU6TGGUCPF.KXGNKJQQFU +PRTGUU  /CTCP\59KGUOCP