Review - Issues in Philosop...

6 downloads 0 Views 150KB Size Report
Nov 8, 2009 - Talk about this issue in our mental health support ... Assessment and Treatment of. Childhood Problems .... The Talking Cure. The Unsayable.
Deakin Research Online Deakin University’s institutional research repository

DDeakin Research Online Research Online This is the published version (version of record) of: Van Hooft, Stan 2002-12-23, Issues in philosophical counseling / Peter B. Raabe, Mentalhelp.net. Available from Deakin Research Online: http://hdl.handle.net/10536/DRO/DU:30015194 Reproduced with kind permission of the copyright owner. Copyright : © 2002, Stan van Hoof

Review - Issues in Philosophical Counseling - Psychotherapy Treatmen... http://www.mentalhelp.net/poc/view_doc.php?id=1479&type=book&cn=91

1 of 4

find therapists | jobs | feeds

Home

Community

Topics

News

Blog

Browse

Find

About advertisement

PSYCHOTHERAPY

Issues in Philosophical Counseling

by Peter B. Raabe Praeger Publishers, 2002 Review by Stan van Hooft, Ph.D. on Dec 23rd 2002 Of the relatively few books on philosophical counseling currently available, Peter Raabe has written one of the best: namely, Philosophical Counseling: Theory and Practice (reviewed in Metapsychology October 2001). The present volume is a follow-up addressed to practicing or would-be philosophical counselors which combines a number of previously published essays and delivered talks with new chapters. It offers practical advice and encouragement and useful discussions of a number of quandaries that might arise in such a practice. There are chapters that seek to define philosophical counseling, to distinguish it from academic philosophy, and to describe such counseling as worldly, experimental, and engaged philosophy. There is advice relating to how women and men differ as clients and as counselors. There is a critique of the inappropriate use of medication for those suffering from non-physical ailments. There are wise discussions of ageing, religion, suicide, humor, and of why the meaning of life is so often sought. There is no step-by-step description of the counseling process (for that, one would need to consult the earlier book), but there is practical advice on how to set up a practice and how to protect oneself against the pressures it might bring. In all of these discussions (and especially in his examples of e-mail advice a practice which Raabe does not recommend) Raabe shows himself to be insightful, intelligent, and wise. While he can be a little too dismissive of academic philosophy (he should take note of Aristotle’s insistence that contemplation or

THERAPIST SEARCH

Mental Help Net Terms of Use/Privacy Policy Our Mission Contributors Jobs

Find help: Psychotherapy

Advertising on Mental Help Net

within

Contact Us

miles of

Tips On Choosing A Therapist Advanced Therapist Search

Sign up for our Mental Health Email Newsletter

COMMUNITY Talk about this issue in our mental health support community

RESOURCES advertisement

email page print page Basic Information More Information Latest News Questions and Answers Blog Entries Videos Links Book Reviews 101 Healing Stories A Primer for Beginning Psychotherapy A Therapist's Guide to Understanding Common Medical Problems Assessment and Treatment of Childhood Problems, Second Edition Bad Therapy Before Forgiving Being a Brain-Wise Therapist Biofeedback for the Brain Boundaries and Boundary Violations in Psychoanalysis Breaking Apart Buffy the Vampire Slayer and Philosophy Building on Bion Care of the Psyche

11/08/2009 12:22 PM

Review - Issues in Philosophical Counseling - Psychotherapy Treatmen... http://www.mentalhelp.net/poc/view_doc.php?id=1479&type=book&cn=91

2 of 4

the pure pursuit of truth is an enrichment of life important for the attainment of fulfillment.), he has a clear grasp of the possibilities and limitations of philosophical counseling. He acknowledges that while there will be many clients who need psychotherapy or psychiatry, there are many more that can be helped by this relatively new form of helping practice. The central assumption upon which philosophical counseling rests is that clients are autonomous agents able, with assistance where necessary, to understand their own situation and to change their own life for the better. While much psychologically based practice (illustrated in this volume by theories of dream interpretation) assumes that clients are subject to internal psychological forces over which they have no control, the philosophical counselor accords full respect to the autonomy of the client. (Of course, whether the assumptions on both sides of this debate are justified is a matter which is open to debate and this is another reason why, in my view, there continues to be an important role for academic philosophy.) While rejecting the usefulness of the psychodynamic notion of the unconscious, however, Raabe does acknowledge the need for a hermeneutic approach to what clients say and do. It is often necessary to help clients to see the hidden motivations and intentions for their actions, emotions, and dreams. The best example in the book of the rational method used by philosophical counselors is the discussion of the reasons that have been proposed for condemning homosexuality. While Raabe is a little too willing to use the label of ‘fallacy’ to refute these arguments rather than focusing on their content, his critique is devastating and would certainly provide a reassuring armory to any clients who felt themselves victimized by prejudice in this area. Raabe is also more aware than many therapists of the need to discuss the morality of what clients do or envisage doing. His discussion of suicide, for example, addresses not just the psychological issues that are involved but also its morality. Although there is not much discussion of cases in this book, one does gain the impression of a typical client as one who shares the same broad world-view as the counselor. In this way, even though Raabe’s method eschews offering advice in a directive manner, the reader does gain an impression of the counselor as an avuncular figure equipped with bon mots and rational suggestions for solving life’s problems which clients can be expected to take up because their basic outlook on life and thinking skills

Choosing an Online Therapist Clinical Handbook of Psychological Disorders Confessions of a Former Child Confidential Relationships Confidentiality and Mental Health Confiding Counseling with Choice Theory Critical Issues in Psychotherapy Crucial Choices, Crucial Changes Decoding the Ethics Code Depression in Context Do-It-Yourself Eye Movement Techniques for Emotional Healing Doing It E-Therapy Encountering the Sacred in Psychotherapy Energy Psychology Interactive Essays on Philosophical Counseling Ethics in Psychotherapy and Counseling Everyday Mind Reading Expressing Emotion Facing Human Suffering Family Therapy Favorite Counseling and Therapy Homework Assignments Flourishing Flying Colors Handbook of Counseling and Psychotherapy with Lesbian, Gay, and Bisexual Clients Healing the Soul in the Age of the Brain Heinz Kohut How to Give Her Absolute Pleasure How to Go to Therapy If Only I Had Known In Session In Therapy We Trust In Treatment: Season 1 Incorporating Spirituality in Counseling and Psychotherapy Is Long-Term Therapy Unethical? Issues in Philosophical Counseling It’s Your Hour Learning from Our Mistakes Letters to a Young Therapist Love's Executioner Man's Search for Meaning Metaphoria: Metaphor and Guided Metaphor for Psychotherapy and Healing Mindfulness and Acceptance Mindfulness-Based Cognitive Therapy for Depression Mindworks: An Introduction to NLP Mockingbird Years Momma and the Meaning of Life Motivational Interviewing: Preparing People For Change Multiculturalism and the Therapeutic Process Of Mice and Metaphors Of Two Minds On the Couch One Nation Under Therapy

11/08/2009 12:22 PM

Review - Issues in Philosophical Counseling - Psychotherapy Treatmen... http://www.mentalhelp.net/poc/view_doc.php?id=1479&type=book&cn=91

3 of 4

are already akin to that of the counselor. There is no suggestion that clients might be intractable. There is no suggestion either (though there is in the earlier book) that the client might be taught to do philosophy for themselves so as to be enabled to engage with the world in their own (possibly idiosyncratic) way. Perhaps Raabe’s impatience with academic philosophy leads him to stress the practical over the theoretical to the extent that it prevents him from seeing the importance of engaging with the world-view of the client if one is doing philosophy. (Raabe thinks that counselors should not challenge the religious beliefs of clients.) But this is a muted criticism (from an academic philosopher) of an admirable and useful book.

© 2002 Stan van Hooft

Stan van Hooft, Ph.D., Associate Professor, School of Social Inquiry - Philosophical Studies, Faculty of Arts, Deakin University, Australia advertisement

Our Inner World Overcoming Destructive Beliefs, Feelings, and Behaviors Philosophical Counseling Philosophical Midwifery Philosophical Practice Philosophy and Psychotherapy Philosophy for Counselling and Psychotherapy Philosophy Practice Plato, Not Prozac! Psychologists Defying the Crowd Psychology, Psychotherapy, Psychoanalysis, and the Politics of Human Relationships Psychotherapy Psychotherapy As Praxis Psychotherapy for Children and Adolescents Psychotherapy for Personality Disorders Rational Emotive Behavior Therapy Recovery Options Rent Two Films and Let's Talk in the Morning Saving the Modern Soul Second-order Change in Psychotherapy Self Matters Self-Determination Theory in the Clinic Sexual Orientation and Psychodynamic Psychotherapy Strangers to Ourselves Taking America Off Drugs Tales of Psychotherapy The Case Formulation Approach to Cognitive-Behavior Therapy The Crucible of Experience The Education of Mrs. Bemis The Fall Of An Icon The Gift of Therapy The Love Cure The Making of a Therapist The Mummy at the Dining Room Table The Neuroscience of Psychotherapy The New Psychoanalysis The Philosopher's Autobiography The Portable Coach The Portable Ethicist for Mental Health Professionals The Present Moment in Psychotherapy and Everyday Life The Psychodynamics of Gender and Gender Role The Psychotherapy Documentation Primer The Real World Guide to Psychotherapy Practice The Schopenhauer Cure The Talking Cure The Unsayable The Wing of Madness Theory and Practice of Brief Therapy Therapy TheraScribe 4.0 Toward a Psychology of Awakening Tracking Mental Health Outcomes

11/08/2009 12:22 PM

Review - Issues in Philosophical Counseling - Psychotherapy Treatmen... http://www.mentalhelp.net/poc/view_doc.php?id=1479&type=book&cn=91

4 of 4

Treating Attachment Disorders What the Buddha Felt What Works for Whom? Second Edition Why Psychoanalysis?

RELATED TOPICS Psychological Testing Mental Disorders Mental Health Professions Treatments & Interventions Mental Disorders Medical Disorders Wellness Life Issues Healthcare Treatments & Interventions Lifespan Development

About Us | About CenterSite | Terms & Privacy | Submit/Update Listings Copyright © CenterSite, LLC, 1995-2009

11/08/2009 12:22 PM