Simulated Annealing Based Parameter Optimization ... - ScienceDirect

Download PDF
3 downloads 0 Views 372KB Size Report
Comment
H.myers, Douglas.c.montgomery, and A.Yc. christine m, Response Surface Methodology: Process and Product Optimization Using Designed Experiments.
Available online at www.sciencedirect.com

ScienceDirect Procedia Engineering 97 (2014) 864 – 870

I= %(%(' +,,('&'.-.+"' '&' &'-  && 

,>BJA6I:9CC:6A>CB>O6I>DC ;DG G>8I>DC ,I>G0:A9>CHH>B>A6GAJB>CJBAADNH + )69B6C676C 6 / 6AJH6BN7 ,6>@G>H=C6 /6 6C9 DE6I= '>G6CI=6G $6 6

0;,=?809?:180.3,94.,7924900=492 $&(%)(*#& :48-,?:=0   &,8479,/@! 7 0;,=?809?:180?,77@=24.,7924900=492#%:77020:1&0.39:7:2D#007,80/@:48-,?:=0  !

&'%' G>8I>DC,I>G0:A9>CHDC:D;I=:A6I:HIHDA>9HI6I:?D>C>CFJ:H7:>CK:ANJH:9;DG?D>C>CB>A6G 6C99>HH>B>A6GB6I:G>6A8DB7>C6I>DCH;DGHIGJ8IJG6AAN9:B6C9>C86I>DCH6C9I=:G:HJAIH6G:EGDB>H>C< -=:L:A9FJ6A>I>:HD; I=: ,0 ?D>CIH 9:E:C9 DC I=: EGD8:HH E6G6B:I:GH JH:9  AJB>CJB 6AADNH   6C9   ;>C9 6EEA>86I>DCH >C 6>G8G6;I >C9JHIG>:H6C9EDH:8=6AA:CC:9JH>CDC6A;JH>DCL:A9>CFJ:H "CI=>HHIJ9N ;G>8I>DCHI>GL:A9>C< D; 9>HH>B>A6G6AJB>CJB6AADNH   >HE:G;DGB:9 6I 9>;;:G:CIIDDAGDI6I>DCHE::9H-+,6C9L:A9>CI:9:H>I=I=G::;68IDGH6C9I=G:: A:K:AH;DG:68=;68IDG ;68:8:CIG:9 +:HEDCH:HJG;68:B:I=D9DADH JH:96B6I=:B6I>86ABD9:A;DGEG:9>8I>CA:HIG:CCCIH L6H9:K:ADE:9 -=:BD9:A>HJH:9IDHIJ9N I=::;;:8ID;I=:-+,6C90,DCI=:HIG:CCIH -=:I:CH>A:HIG:CCIH>H;DJC9ID7:6;;:8I:97N7DI=I=: -+, 6C9 0,  ,>BJA6I:9 CC:6A>CH JH:9 ID DEI>B>O: I=: -+, 6C9 0, ;DG B6M>B>O>CA: HIG:CCIH (EI>BJBK6AJ:HD; I=:-+,6C90,6G:;DJC9ID7:  GEB6C9 BB B>C G:HE:8I>K:AN -=:B6M>BJBI:CH>A:HIG:CCIH>HEG:9>8I:9ID7: &)6L=:CI=:H:E6G6B:I:GH6G:JH:9 © by Elsevier Ltd. This is an open access P2014  Published -=:JI=DGH )J7A>H=:97NAH:K>:G %I9 article under the CC BY-NC-ND license (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/3.0/). ,:A:8I>DC6C9E::G G:K>:LJC9:GG:HEDCH>7>A>IND; I=:(GO>CII::D; &&  Selection and peer-review under responsibility of the Organizing Committee of GCMM 2014

0DB:=/> G>8I>DC,I>G0:A9>CA:HIG:CB>O6I>DC,>BJA6I:9CC:6A>C<

DGG:HEDC9>C>/=+;,/8,9,-,9.-,8=4?,0/@

1877-7058 © 2014 Published by Elsevier Ltd. This is an open access article under the CC BY-NC-ND license

(http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/3.0/). Selection and peer-review under responsibility of the Organizing Committee of GCMM 2014

doi:10.1016/j.proeng.2014.12.361

R. Padmanaban et al. / Procedia Engineering 97 (2014) 864 – 870

865

 "'%#('#" G>8I>DCHI>GL:A9>CCK:CI:97N-=:0:A9>CC3 4 >HDC:D;I=:G:A6I>K:ANG:8:CI HDA>9 HI6I: L:A9>CFJ:  "C ,0 EGD8:HH 6 8NA>C9G>86A IDDA L>I= 6 H=DJA9:G  6C9 6 EGD;>A:9 E>C  >H HADLAN EAJCCID I=: 67JII>C:8:H 6C9 I=:C IG6CHA6I:9 6ADCDC6A =:6I I=6I HD;I:CH I=: HJGGDJC9>C:8: B6I:G>6A6C96AADLHI=:IDDAIDBDK:6ADCCIA>C: -=:6M>6AAD696C9I=:IG6K:GH>CDCD;I=:IDDA86JH:H I=:EA6HI>8>O:9B6I:G>6AID UDL;GDBI=:;GDCIIDI=:768@D;I=:IDDA 0=:CI=:IDDABDK:H;DGL6G9 I=:IG6CHEDGI:9 B6I:G>6A8DDAH9DLC6C98DCHDA>96I:HID;DGB 6 ?D>CI>CHDA>9 HI6I: 6II:BE:G6IJG: 7:ADL I=: B:AI>CCID;76H: B:I6AH 3 4 -=: ,0 EGD8:HH E6G6B:I:GH 8DCIGDA I=: =:6I DC  B>8GDHIGJ8IJG: :KDAJI>DC 6C9 I=: ?D>CI EGDE:GI>:H D; ;G>8I>DCHI>GL:A9>CC8AJ9: EGD8:HHE6G6B:I:GHIDDAGDI6I>DCHE::9 L:A9>C6A ;DG8: 6C9 I=: IDDA O: 6C9 EGD;>A:  "C 699>I>DC ID I=: EGD8:HH E6G6B:I:GH 6C9 IDDA 6A9DLC ;DG8: >C>I>6AI:BE:GD;I=: LDG@E>:8:  B6I:G>6AD;I=:IDDA6C9>IH =6G9C:HH  B6I:G>6A6C9I=>8@C:HHD; 768@>CCDC D; ;G>8I>DC HI>G L:A9>C86A  B>8GD HIGJ8IJG6A  ;6I>DC EGDE:GI>:H>H6EG>B6GNG:FJ>G:B:CIIDD7I6>C:;;>8>:CI 9:;:8I;G::;G>8I>DCHI>GL:A9:9?D>CIH !:6IIG:6I67A: 6AJB>CJB6AADNHMMM6C9MMM6G:H>;>86CI8A6HH:HD;6AADNHL>I==>C9 L>9: 6EEA>86I>DCH >C K6G>DJH >C9JHIG>:H 3 4  H 6 G:HJAI  ?D>C>CH 6C >BEDGI6CI C::9 >C 6 K6G>:IN D; 6EEA>86I>DCH  (88JGG:C8: D; 9:C9G>I>8 HIGJ8IJG: >C I=: ;JH>DC ODC: 6C9 I=: 688DBE6CN>CCL:A9HIG:CCDC6A;JH>DCL:A9>CC9:G:9 I=:L>9: HEG:69JH68I>DC HI>G L:A9>CC>C6AH I=6I L:G: JCL:A967A: 7N 8DCK:CI>DC6AEGD8:HH:H -=::;;:8ID;EGD8:HHE6G6B:I:GH6C9IDDA9:H>HIDGN6C9I:BE:G6IJG:9>HIG>7JI>DC B6I:G>6A;ADL B>8GDHIGJ8IJG::KDAJI>DC6C9EGDE:GI>:H9JG>CB>A6GB6I:G>6AH=6H7::C:MI:CH>K:ANHIJ9>:96C9G:EDGI:9 %:::I6A 34 G:EDGI:9>BEGDK:B:CI>CB:8=6C>86AEGDE:GI>:H>CI=:L:A9ODC:L=:C ,0 6AADNH L>I=K6G>DJH L:A9>CC8GDHIGJ8IJG: B:8=6C>86AEGDE:GIN6C9 G:H>9J6A HIG:HH D; ;G>8I>DC HI>G L:A9:9   6AJB>CJB 6AADNH  %6@H=B>C6G6N6C6C 6C9 6A6HJ7G6B6C>6C 6EEA>:9 -6 I:8=C>FJ: ID 9:I:GB>C: I=: BDHI >C;AJ:CI>6A ;68IDGH 8DCIGDAA>CA: HIG:C8I>DC HI>G L:A9:9 +  6AJB>C>JB6AADN?D>CIH 3 4 GI>;>8>6AC:JG6AC:ILDG@''BD9:AH=6K:7::C 9:K:ADE:9;DG I=:6C6ANH>H6C9H>BJA6I>DCD;I=:8DGG:A6I>DC 7:IL::C EGD8:HH E6G6B:I:GH 6C9 EGDE:GI>:H D; ;G>8I>DC HI>G L:A9:9 ?D>CIH 3 4  %6@H=B>C6G6N6C6C 6C9 6A6HJ7G6B6C>6C EG:9>8I:9 I=: I:CH>A: HIG:C8I>DC HI>G L:A9:9   6AJB>C>JB 6AADN JH>C 6C9 /JC96K>AA> BD9:A:9 ,0 EGD8:HH JH>C8 AI=B IG6>C:9 C:JG6A C:ILDG@ 6C9 JH:9 I=: H6B: ;DG DCA>C: EG:9>8I>DC D; I=: B:8=6C>86A EGDE:GI>:H D; ,0 EGD8:HH 6I 9>;;:G:CIDE:G6I>CI>DCH 34 676?6CO69::I6A 9:K:ADE:9 696EI>K:C:JGD ;JOON>C;:G:C8:HNHI:BH'", IDHIJ9NE6G6B:I:G :;;:8I 6C9 DEI>B>O:9 ,0IDG:9B:8=6C>86AEGDE:GI>:HJH>CBJA6I:96CC:6A>C< 34 #D>CIHL>I=7:II:GB:8=6C>86AEGDE:GI>:HG:HJAIL=:CDEI>BJB EGD8:HH E6G6B:I:GH6G:JH:9 %:GIDG66C9 6B76GD 34 EG:H:CI:96C6EEGD68=IDDEI>B>O:,0EGD8:HHE6G6B:I:GHCA:HIG:C;:D;   A %>6AADN -6CH:A:I6A 34 JH:986AANDEI>B>O:9C:JG6AC:ILDG@HNHI:BH ('',ID:HI>B6I:I=: DEI>B6ADE:G6I>CI>DCD;I=:;G>8I>DCHI>GL:A9>CC6AJB>CJB6AADN%  )6A6C>K:A 6C9 $DH=N &6I=:LH 34 EG:H:CI:9 6C :BE>G>86A BD9:A ;DG I=: I:CH>A: HIG:CCJB 6AADN 6C9 DEI>B>O:9 EGD8:HH E6G6B:I:GH  #6N6G6B6C :I 6A 34 JH:9-6 9:H>A: HIG:C8I>DC HI>G L:A9:9 86HI 6AJB>CJB 6AADN  6C9 G:EDGI:9 DEI>BJB L:A9>CI>DC >HH>B>A6G B6I:G>6A ;G>8I>DC HI>G L:A9>CH G:FJ>G:9 >C 6 CJB7:G D; 6EEA>86I>DCH  -=: B:8=6C>86A EGDE:GI>:H 6C9 B>8GDHIGJ8IJG: D; 9>HH>B>A6G ;G>8I>DC HI>G L:A9:9    A ?D>CIH B6>CAN9:E:C9:9DCI=:B6I:G>6AH;>M:96II=:G:IG:6I>C9: 3 4 )6G@:I6A >CK:HI>DC HE::96C9L:A9>C86AEGDE:GI>:HD;9>HH>B>A6G?D>CIH7:IL::C  (6C9  !A6AADNH ;67G>86I:9JH>C8I>DCHI>GL:A9>C8I:9I=:DEI>B6AE6G6B:I:GH 34

R. Padmanaban et al. / Procedia Engineering 97 (2014) 864 – 870

866

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



R. Padmanaban et al. / Procedia Engineering 97 (2014) 864 – 870

867

-67A:  &6IG>MD;ME:G>B:CIH6C9+:HJAIH -+, GEB

0, BB B>C

-, &)6















































 







 





, 'D

'

/

































 









 









 









 









 





 $'!+'#" "C DG9:G ID ;>C9 I=: DEI>BJB IDDA GDI6I>DC HE::9 6C9 L:A9>C:A9 I=: B6M>BJB I:CH>A: HIG:CK:;JC8I>DC>HDEI>B>O:9JH>CBJA6I:96AI=B -=:H>BJA6I:96CC:6A>CH6CDEI>B>O6I>DC I:8=C>FJ: 76H:9 DC I=: 6C6ADCI>86AAN =:6I:9 HDA>9H  @CDLC 6H 6CC:6A>CC>B>O6I>DC  DG B6M>B>O6I>DC I=: C:K: D; I=: D7?:8I>K: ;JC8I>DC >H JH:9  -=: 6AI=B L6H 8D9:9 >C &-%  !( '"" " #%'! 3 4  ,I6GIL>I=6C>C>I>6A6C96=>CI 1> >C I=: K>8>C>IN D; I=: 8JGG:CI ED>CI G6C9DBAN 6C9 ;>C9 I=: 9>;;:G:C8: >C ;JC8I>DCK6AJ:H QQ;;> ;> S;1> R ;1> ";Q;>HC:K: 688:EII=:ED>CI1> 6HI=:C:MI9:H>CI  0=:CQ;>HEDH>I>K: 688:EII=:ED>CI1> 6HI=:C:MI9:H>CIDCANL>I=6EGD767>A>IN:RQ @- -=>HB:6CHI=6I >;I=:K6AJ:D;6G6C9DBANHA6GCI1>DI=:GL>H:G:?:8II=:ED>CI 1>  0=:CI=:ED>CI1>>HG:?:8I:9 I=:CG:E:6IHI:EH6C9 -DH>BJA6I:I=:6II6>CB:CID;I=:GB6A:FJ>A>7G>JB6I :K:GNI:BE:G6IJG: 6EG:9:I:GB>C:9CJB7:GCD;C:LED>CIH1 >6G:I:HI:96I6CNHE:8>T8K6AJ:D;I=:I:BE:G6IJG: - ";5&:IGDEDA>H:FJ>A>7G>JB>HG:6A>O:9 I=:CHD7H:GK:9;GDB >CIH;67G>86I:96I6-+,D;

GEB 6G:ADL:GI=6CI=DH:;67G>86I:96I  GEB6C9

GEB -=:I:CH>A:HIG:CCIB69:6I6-+,D;    GEB L6H ;DJC9 ID 7: I=: B6M>BJB  I ADL -+,  ADL =:6I DC G:HJAIH >C >C:;;>8>:CI B>M>C6AH6C9=:C8:L:6@?D>CIH -=:D88JGG:C8:D;9:;:8IH6I=>CIH

>6I>DCD;-,L>I=-+,

-=::;;:8ID;0,K6G>6I>DCDCI=:-,D;I=:?D>CI6I9>;;:G:CI0,>HH=DLC>C >B>A6GID-+, >C8G:6H:>C 0,JEIDBB B>CG:HJAIH>C6C>C8G:6H:>CI=:-,D;I=:?D>CIH 0=:CI=:0,L6H>C8G:6H:9ID BB B>CI=: I:CH>A: HIG:CCCI L6H ;DJC9 ID 9:8G:6H:  ,>B>A6G IG:C9 L6H D7H:GK:9 6I 6AA K6AJ:H D; -+,  I =>H:MEDH:9ID;G>8I>DC6A=:6I>CB: 86JH>C8;ADLD;I=:B:I6A 6C9;DGB6I>DCD;KD>9H 34 I=6I68I6HHIG:HHG6>H:GH9JG>CC< D;I=:?D>CI6C9L:6@:C>I

>6I>DCD;-,L>I=0,

-=:8DCIDJGEADID;-,6IK6G>DJH-+,6C90,D;,L:A9:9?D>CIH>H9:E>8I:9>C >I86C 7:>C;:GG:9I=6IHIG:CCIH7:IL::C   L>AA7:=>I=>C   ID  GEB 6C9  ID  BB B>C G:HE:8I>K:AN  (EI>BJB K6AJ:H D; -+, 6C9 0, 86C 7: ;DJC9 7N 6EEAN>CB>O6I>DCI:8=C>FJ:H

R. Padmanaban et al. / Procedia Engineering 97 (2014) 864 – 870

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

6L:H   #  6C9 0 &  -=DB6H =4.?4:9 >?4= ;=:.0>> B07/> ,7@849@8 ,77:D> 0:A9>C?=@.?@=,7>>@0>49,=4.?4:9%?4=)07/0/7@849@877:D ,8G>EI6&6I:G>6A>6   E     0 -6C<  1  #  &8AJG: %  &JGG  6C9   'JC:H 0,? 9;@? ,9/ &08;0=,?@=0 4>?=4-@?4:9 49 =4.?4:9%?4=)07/492 #DJGC6AD;&6I:G>6A)GD8:HH>CC:C8:  E   =6D  2 #  1  *>  6C9 0  -6C< 0,? &=,9>10= 49 =4.?4:9 %?4= )07/492C;0=4809?,7 ,9/ !@80=4.,7 %?@/40> #DJGC6AD;&6CJ;68IJG>C:C8:6C9CC::G>C< 

 E  

869

870

34 34 34 34 34 3 4 34 34 34 34 34 34 34 34 34 3 4 34 34 34 34 34 34

R. Padmanaban et al. / Procedia Engineering 97 (2014) 864 – 870

6K>H  # +  :9 %  ,9/-::6 (:7@80   #=:;0=?40> ,9/ %070.?4:9 !:910==:@> 77:D> ,9/ %;0.4,7 #@=;:>0 ,?0=4,7> -:CI=:9 ,&!6C97DD@  ,&"CI:GC6I>DC6AA:K:A6C9 (! & % 6J88>D  :9 %  0?,7> $010=09.0 ::6  -=>G9 :9    ,& "CI:GC6I>DC6A &6I:G>6AH )6G@ (! E6?=@.?@=,749A0>?42,?4:9:11=4.?4:9>?4=B07/0/ & ,7@8494@8 8I6&6I:G>6A>6 

 E   %:: 0  2 & 2:DC 6C9,  #JC< &3048;=:A0809?:180.3,94.,7;=:;0=?40>:11=4.?4:9>?4=B07/0/  7,77:D &6I:G>6AH,8>:C8:6C9CC::G>C?=@.?@=080.3,94.,7;=:;0=?40>,9/=0>4/@,7>?=0>>0>,>,1@9.?4:9:1B07/492>;00/ 49,7@8494@8  1=4.?4:9>?4=B07/> 8I6&6I:G>6A>6 

 E    %6@H=B>C6G6N6C6C   $  6C9 /  6A6HJ7G6B6C>6C #=:.0>> ;,=,80?0=> :;?484E,?4:9 1:= 1=4.?4:9 >?4= B07/492:1$ ,7@8494@8,77:D@>492&,[email protected]?0.394DCHD;'DC;:GGDJH&:I6AH,D8>:IN D;=>C6 

  E   2 $ 2DJH>; $ & 6LH 6C9 " $6O:B #=0/4.?4:9:1=4.?4:9%?4=)07/4923,=,.?0=4>?4.'>492!0@=,7 !0?B:=6 #DG96C#DJGC6AD;&:8=6C>86A6C9"C9JHIG>6ACC::G>C< 

 E   (@JNJ8J !  $JGI 6C9 G86@A>D?4=B07/492 :1,7@849@8;7,?0> &6I:G>6AH6BE:H>C6G6N6C6C   $  6C9 /  6A6HJ7G6B6C>6C :8;,=4>:9 :1 $%  B4?3 !! 49 ;=0/4.?492 ?09>470 >?=092?3:11=4.?4:9>?4=B07/0/ ,7@8494@8,77:D5:49?> -G6CH68I>DCHD;'DC;:GGDJH&:I6AH,D8>:IN D;=>C6 

  E   &JII>C:C> , 6C9) + /JC96K>AA> :/07492:1=4.?4:9%?4=)07/492:1 '>492!0@=,7!0?B:=6>   " " AD76A E   676?6CO69:+DH=6C , :I6A ";?484E,?4:9:11=4.?4:9>?4=B07/492;=:.0>>:1 ,7@849@8,77:D?: ,.340A0 /0>4=,-70 80.3,94.,7 ;=:;0=?40> @>492 !% 8:/07> ,9/ >48@7,?0/ ,990,7492 ,72:=4?38 -=: "CI:GC6I>DC6A#DJGC6AD;9K6C8:9&6CJ;68IJG>C,9/49.=0,>01,?42@0 7410 "CI:GC6I>DC6A#DJGC6AD;&6I:G>6ADGB>C<    E 

 

 

 -6CH:A " ' :I6A ";?484E,?4:9>:11=4.?4:9>?4=B07/492:1,7@849@8,77:D-D@>4922090?4.,77D:;?484E0/ 90@=,790?B:=6 -=:"CI:GC6I>DC6A#DJGC6AD;9K6C8:9&6CJ;68IJG>C> ;,=,80?0= :1 1=4.?4:9 >?4= B07/0/     ,7@849@8 ,77:D @>492 =0>;:9>0 >@=1,.0 80?3:/:7:2D #DJGC6A D; :CIG6A ,DJI= .C>K:GH>IN    E   #6N6G6B6C & :I6A ";?484E,?4:9:1;=:.0>>;,=,80?0=>1:=1=4.?4:9>?4=B07/492:1.,>?,7@8494@8,77:D  -D&,[email protected] 0?3:/ #DJGC6AD;,8>:CI>;>8"C9JHIG>6A+:H:6G8= 

 E   %:: 0  2 & 2:DC 6C9,  #JC< &305:49?;=:;0=?40>:1/4>>4847,=1:=80/7,77:D>-D1=4.?4:9>?4= B07/492,..:=/492?:?3014C0/7:.,?4:9:18,?0=4,7> ,8G>EI6&6I:G>6A>6 

  E   )6G@ #  6C9, # $>B ";?484E,?4:9:11=4.?4:9>?4=B07/492B4?3?30A,=4:@>B07/492 ;,=,80?0=>1:=7 2,77:D> +6G:&:I6AH   E   +6NBDC9 ! &N:GH  DJC: & $0>;:9>0 %@=1,.0 0?3:/:7:2D #=:.0>>,9/#=:/@.?";?484E,?4:9'>4920>4290/C;0=4809?> G9 :9 

#D=C0>A:N,DCH   )69B6C676C + 110.?:1#=:.0>>#,=,80?0=>:9?30&09>470%?=092?3:1=4.?4:9%?4=)07/0/4>>4847,= 7@849@8:49?> #DJGC6AD;CC::G>C:C8:6C9-:8=CDADG@E6IG>8@     :A6II  6C9 & )  /:88=> ";?484E,?4:9 -D %48@7,?0/ 990,7492 ,8>:C8:  E  ,>CG:HJ , +6D 924900=492";?484E,?4:9&30:=D,9/#=,.?4.0 

 ':L#:GH:N#D=C0>A:N,DCH "C8 A6C6C [email protected]>:1?::7;49;=:1470,9/B07/492>;00/:9?301:=8,?4:9 :11=4.?4:9>?4=;=:.0>>492E:9049

,7@8494@8,77:D #DJGC6AD;&6I:G>6AH)GD8:HH>C