South China Morning Post

Xi Jinping, the champion of Marxism, may find unlikely comrades in critics of Western capitalism | South China Morning Post

South China Morning Post South China Morning Post

CHINA HK INTERNATIONAL ASIA WORLD COMMENT BUSINESS PROPERTY EDITION: MON TECH JUL 4, LIFE 2016 CULTURE SPORT POST MAG STYLE .TV JOBS EVENTS EDUCATION COURSES

0

INSIGHT & OPINION HOME

CHINA

SHARE STYLE

HK

ASIA 0

WORLD COMMENT NOW READING Email

Print

BUSINESS

REGISTER / LOGIN

PROPERTY

TECH

LIFE

CULTURE

SPORT

POST MAG

Xi Jinping, the champion of Marxism, may find unlikely comrades in critics of Western capitalism ALL

.TV

Comment / Insight & Opinion / ›

China's Communist Party

Xi Jinping, the champion of Marxism, may find unlikely comrades in critics http://www.scmp.com/comment/insight-opinion/article/1985172/xi-jinping-champion-marxism-may-find-unlikely-comrades[4/7/2016 5:23:38 PM]

We recommend for you


of Western capitalism

NEWS

Tom Plate says while Xi’s reassertion of ideology may be a bid to legitimise the Communist Party, his rejection of the Western status quo chimes with a growing number of voices pointing to capitalism’s failures PUBLISHED : Monday, 04 July, 2016, 4:48pm UPDATED : Monday, 04 July, 2016, 4:55pm

COMMENTS:

0

Flights resume after massive delay in Shanghai strands thousands at… 29 Jun 2016

NEWS

Girls in short skirts burned with corrosive liquid in series of… 04 Jul 2016

Tom Plate

NEWS

For bankers, the smell of real estate profit in Vancouver is being…

SHARE

22 Jun 2016

NEWS

Deadly industrial building blaze claims life of second Hong Kong… 24 Jun 2016

COMMENT

0

Print

Email

True transparency is hardly the calling card of many governments, and, certainly, the People’s Republic of China wins no awards for openness.

http://www.scmp.com/comment/insight-opinion/article/1985172/xi-jinping-champion-marxism-may-find-unlikely-comrades[4/7/2016 5:23:38 PM]

How private finance can bridge Asia’s infrastructure gap


RELATED TOPICS China's Communist Party Xi Jinping

More on this story

POLICIES & POLITICS

The method in Xi Jinping’s Marxism: What’s behind the president’s push for the economic theory? 30 Nov 2015

Related Articles

POLICIES & POLITICS

All news stories must be verified, China’s internet censor decrees as it tightens grip on online media 4 Jul 2016

But about the central ideology behind the Communist Party, President Xi Jinping (習近平) could not be more transparent. The party is all about Marxism, he averred recently – and not some Scandinavian milquetoast graduate-school Marxism – but a serious Marxism, in Xi’s view the only known government system for addressing structural inequality.

Bedrock of China’s Communist Party must be clean government and righteous cadres, says Xi Jinping Xi, who is also party general secretary, laid down the party line anew on the occasion of its 95th anniversary celebration, in the Great Hall of the People on Tiananmen Square. Only Marxism, he insisted, could have provided a scientific guide for the development of China, the party and the people – melding his complex nation into one of reasonable unity. The president admitted that this Marxism had to be suffused with Chinese ways to work, but that the party would be nowhere had Marxism not been its primary operating system. To be sure, Xi’s reassertion of ideology was calculated to counter any flirtation in the party with pure neoliberal market economics, not to mention Western-style democratic governance. Just check out this revivalist line: “The whole party should remember – what we are building is socialism with Chinese characteristics, not some other –ism.” Xi’s address, televised nationally, was no discourse in economic theory, but an emphatic effort at legitimising the party’s continuance in power on the march towards the nation’s “great rejuvenation”.

04 Jul 2016

PROPERTY

Property prices soar in recently gentrified Tai Kok Tsui in Kowloon… 10 Jun 2016

PROPERTY

China loosens policy on commercial buildings to reduce oversupply… 04 Jul 2016

COMMENT

How Hong Kong’s professional services sector can provide the glue for… 28 Jun 2016

PROPERTY

Parents buying property for young children to secure a future… 07 Jun 2016

COMMENT

Letters to the Editor, June 29, 2016 29 Jun 2016

Recommended by



“Marxism must be the basic fundamental, guiding principle, or the party would lose its soul and direction,” Xi said. POLICIES & POLITICS

MOST POPULAR VIEWED

Bedrock of China’s Communist Party must be clean government and righteous cadres, says Xi Jinping 2 Jul 2016

POLICIES & POLITICS

The long, arduous process to joining China’s Communist Party

1

Chinese airlines are consistently late for this one surprising reason

2

You Singapore bureaucrats, wake up and smell the coffee

3

How a fear of inflation is driving bitcoin’s popularity in China

4

Eurexit is the real danger now

5

Li Ka-shing was well meaning but rather unhelpful in his corporate tax idea

1 Jul 2016

Academics must remake Marxism for 21st century, says China’s President Xi Jinping

Xi failed to mention it, however, but outside China, arguably, no Marxism in continuous practice has ever proven exemplary as a method of managing a nation’s economy. For China to have added those many touches of “Chinese characteristics” is not proof of the validity of pure Marxist orthodoxy but rather of the innate genius of Han improvisation.

Outside China, no Marxism in continuous practice has ever proven exemplary as a method of managing

What’s more, sceptics and critics will be quick to note that, without the inherent Marxist need for control, the party might have lost power entirely. They will view Xi’s declaration as no more than an effort to rally ideological belief. For, as China’s growth rates slow (though


SHARED

COMMENTED

PROMOTIONS


still among the world’s highest), the view is that, without some secular religion for justification, Han society might come to seem no more than one big Chinese casino in which some gamblers lose, some gamblers win – but the party’s house management never loses.

a nation’s economy

Even so, while Xi’s primary target for the revivalist speech was the party elite (speaking of inequality!), the message might well offer a touch of appeal to a broader, non-Communist audience. Even in the most intelligent and best-performing Asian economies (say, Singapore and Hong Kong), the gap between rich and poor is widening, seemingly beyond immediate amelioration. Xi’s pitch echoes growing global doubts about the equity utility of neoliberal capitalist economics, which, though a proven wealth-producer, seems incapable of yielding broad-based fairness.

The growing wealth of the 1 per cent is a problem we cannot afford http://www.scmp.com/comment/insight-opinion/article/1985172/xi-jinping-champion-marxism-may-find-unlikely-comrades[4/7/2016 5:23:38 PM]

Order your FREE copy of AT YOUR SERVICE 2016


And so in the West, where capitalism has dominated, a neo-Marxist or postmodern Marxism now gets a second long look. If the richest 1 per cent hold more wealth than ever before, and the other 99 per cent are struggling as never before, and the physical globe overall looks to need a massive urgent injection of ecological protectionism, consideration of alternative approaches to running economies and setting priorities will be necessary. In American academic and foundation circles, for example, one detects the slow surfacing of a “postmodern Marxism” that does not foolishly propose to stamp out wealthcreating market forces (clearly a cure worse than the disease) but insists on a humanitarian neosocialism that requires a governance system which stifles corruption and obscene profit-taking, and curbs the power of wealthy elites to shape social and economic policy so as to line their offshore pockets while pocketing preferred politicians. Professor Philip Clayton, a California colleague who teaches at the well-respected Claremont School of Theology, has put it this way: “Most people find it counter-intuitive that a system motivated exclusively by greed and cutthroat competition would bring the greatest benefits to the greatest number of people. We now see that there is a good reason people find this claim counterintuitive: it is false. Abuses are only overcome when governments, multinational agencies, labour groups, consumer advocates and a well-organised system of checks and balances all serve as watchdogs over market competition.” And let us get this out of the way: Clayton – with a PhD from Yale University and a background that includes teaching at Williams College, Harvard and Cambridge – is no kook.



Uncontrolled capitalism is bringing the world to ruin, and nobody is fixing it In Europe, many agree with such views as that of Jacques Derrida, the late French philosopher – that the “triumph” of capitalism in the West has only served to “highlight its own failures, as human suffering continues and environmental catastrophe appears inevitable”. At the least, the relentless ecological crisis and frightening rich-poor divide require us to open our minds to alternatives ways – or at least profound modifications – of current canons of governance and economic management. This does not mean, as the saying goes, that one throws the baby out with the bathwater: capitalism, after all, does create wealth. But at what corollary costs? And for whom? The well-known Methodist theologian and Marxist theorist Joerg Rieger is fond of praising US billionaire Warren Buffett for saying that “there is such a thing as class warfare and that his class is winning it”. You don’t have to be a Marxist – with or without Chinese characteristics – to seriously question the continued validity of status quo liberal-democratic governance. Xi is hardly the only one in the world who appears to find this transparently obvious. http://www.scmp.com/comment/insight-opinion/article/1985172/xi-jinping-champion-marxism-may-find-unlikely-comrades[4/7/2016 5:23:38 PM]


Columnist and professor Tom Plate is distinguished scholar of Asian and Pacific Studies at Loyola Marymount University and author of the series Giants of Asia

SCMP RECOMMENDS (LAST 24HRS)

LIFESTYLE

Geneva is the centre of sophistication and wonder when it comes to timepieces

SCMP

Plan a sweet spring party to celebrate the start of warmer weather 03 May, 2016

17 Jun, 2016

NEWS

California Fitness members in limbo after sudden closure of new Hung Hom outlet 04 Jul, 2016

Taking care in cleaning is sound investment practice – on health and economic grounds 18 Apr, 2016

Immersive technology breakthrough at CES in Las Vegas allows masses “to experience the impossible” 18 Mar, 2016

LIFESTYLE

Drawing inspiration from Mother Earth 29 Mar, 2016

Let wireless multi-room speakers draw you into the music 30 May, 2016

Keeping the home in the best shape is made easier by online tools that can designate cleaning duties
