£37.00 (hbk). University of Minnesota Press, 2005. 197 pp. ISBN 0816627215, £14.00 (pbk),. Book review: Elsbeth Probyn, Blush: Faces of Shame. Minneapolis:.
European Journal of Cultural Studies http://ecs.sagepub.com/
Book review: Elsbeth Probyn, Blush: Faces of Shame. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press, 2005. 197 pp. ISBN 0816627215, £14.00 (pbk), £37.00 (hbk) Marita Husso European Journal of Cultural Studies 2008 11: 377 DOI: 10.1177/1367549408091851 The online version of this article can be found at: http://ecs.sagepub.com/content/11/3/377.citation
Published by: http://www.sagepublications.com
Additional services and information for European Journal of Cultural Studies can be found at: Email Alerts: http://ecs.sagepub.com/cgi/alerts Subscriptions: http://ecs.sagepub.com/subscriptions Reprints: http://www.sagepub.com/journalsReprints.nav Permissions: http://www.sagepub.com/journalsPermissions.nav
>> Version of Record - Jul 22, 2008 What is This?
Downloaded from ecs.sagepub.com at Jyvaskylan Yliopisto on May 9, 2014
D T Q N O D @ M I N T Q M @ K N EA N N J Q D U H D V R
#OPYRIGHT¥3!'%0UBLICATIONS ,OS!NGELES ,ONDON .EW$ELHI AND3INGAPORE 6OL n $/) WWWSAGEPUBLICATIONSCOM
"OOKREVIEWS %LSBETH0ROBYN "LUSH&ACESOF3HAME-INNEAPOLIS5NIVERSITYOF-INNESOTA 0RESS PP)3". aPBK aHBK !DMITTINGSHAMEISOFTENACOMPLEXPROCESS)NMOSTSOCIETIESSHAMEIS NOTOPENLYTALKEDABOUT ANDMOSTPEOPLEPREFERNOTTODRAWATTENTIONTO IT)NSPITEOFRECENTSCHOLARLYINTERESTINSHAME THEBODYANDEMOTIONS MUCHOFTHERESEARCHREMAINSABSTRACTANDIMPERSONAL%LSBETH0ROBYNS BOOK"LUSH&ACESOF3HAMEISANEXCEPTIONTHEBOOKEMPHASIZESTHE IMPORTANCEOFEXAMININGSPECIFICAFFECTSHAPPENINGTOPARTICULARBODIES INPARTICULARPLACES 0ROBYNBEGINSHERBOOKWITHTHEARGUMENTTHATONLYSOMETHINGOR SOMEONETHATINTERESTSYOUCANPRODUCEAFLUSHOFSHAME$RAWINGONTHE WORKOFPSYCHOLOGIST3ILVAN4OMKINS THELINKBETWEENSHAMEANDINTEREST ISTHECOMMONGROUNDTHATLINKSTHEDIFFERENTVARIANTSOFSHAMEEXPLORED IN0ROBYNSBOOK)NTERESTINVOLVESADESIREFORCONNECTION COMMUNICATION TOUCH LINESOFENGAGEMENTANDRECIPROCITY3HAMEILLUMINATESOURINTENSE DESIRETOBECONNECTEDWITHOTHERS ANDTHEKNOWLEDGETHATWESOMETIMES FAILINOURATTEMPTTOMAINTAINTHOSECONNECTIONS #OMBININGCULTURALTHEORY SOCIOLOGY PSYCHOLOGYANDPERSONALNAR RATIVES 0ROBYNSTUDIESSHAMEASANAFFECTANDEXPLORESITSEFFECTS4HEBOOK INVESTIGATESSEVERALAREASOFSHAMEBODYANDSHAMETHESHAMEOFBEING OUTOFPLACEPOLITICSOFSHAMEANDSHAMINGSHAMEOFPASTANDSHAMEOF GENERATIONSANDSHAMEANDWRITING0ROBYNPURSUESASOCIOLOGICALAND CULTURALEXPLANATIONOFSHAMEWITHINTHEBODYANDITSHABITUS BUTDOES NOTGIVEUPTHEPHYSIOLOGICALLEVELOFSHAMEP 3HEWRITESABOUTTHE SHAMEOFBEINGOUTOFPLACE ANDNARRATESAMOMENTOFSHAMETHATSHE FELTWHENSHEFIRSTEXPERIENCEDTHEAWESOMEPOWEROF5LURUIN#ENTRAL !USTRALIA4HISVARIANTOFSHAME THEFEELINGOFBEINGLIKEAFISHOUTOF WATER ISSOMETHINGTHEBODYREGISTERSINSOCIALANDCULTURALCONTEXTSIN WHICHITDOESNOTBELONG0ROBYNDRAWSON"OURDIEUSCONCEPTOFHABITUS HIGHLIGHTINGTHEWAYSINWHICHWEEMBODYHISTORY ANDHOWOURBODIES CONTINUALLYSPEAKOFTHEIRPASTSINEVERYDAYACTIONSSUCHASGESTURES MANNERSANDWAYSOFBEING(ABITUSDELIMITSHOWANDINWHICHSPACES WECANMOVE7HENABODYKNOWSITDOESNOTBELONGWITHINACERTAIN PLACE IN"OURDIEUSTERMS THEREISASCHISMBETWEENTHEHABITUSANDTHE ANNJQDUHDVR Downloaded from ecs.sagepub.com at Jyvaskylan Yliopisto on May 9, 2014
D T Q N O D @ M I N T Q M @ K N E B T KS T Q @ K R S T C H D R
FIELD4HISISWHERESHAMEOFTENERUPTS4HROUGHFEELINGSHAME THEBODY INAUGURATESANALTERNATIVEWAYOFBEINGINTHEWORLD3HAME ASTHEBODYS REFLECTIONONITSELF MAYREORDERTHECOMPOSITIONOFTHEHABITUS WHICHIN TURNMAYALLOWQUITEDIFFERENTCHOICESP "LUSHISANEXCITINGINVITATIONTOJOINTHEAUTHORINEXPLORATION RATHER THANADISSERTATION0ROBYNARGUESPERSUASIVELYTHATONEOFTHEMOSTFRUS TRATINGASPECTSOFREADINGSTUDIESONEMOTIONANDAFFECTISTHEIRTENDENCY TOSPEAKINGENERALTERMS)NCONTRAST AFTERREADING"LUSHITSEEMSSELF EVIDENTTHATAFFECTSHAVESPECIFICEFFECTSANDITMAKESNOSENSETOAPPROACH AFFECTSOUTSIDETHISUNDERSTANDING3HAMEWORKSOVERTHEBODY BUTITALSO REWORKSHOWWEUNDERSTANDTHEBODYANDITSRELATIONTOOTHERBODIESOR TOTHESOCIAL4HISMATTERSATTHELEVELOFTHEORY ANDINTERMSOFWHATWE WANTWRITINGTODOP 4HEMOSTIMPORTANTCONTRIBUTIONOFTHISBOOKISTOUNDERLINEHOW ESSENTIALITISTOTHINKOFWHATSHAMEDOESTOBODIESANDWHATCONNECTED BODIESDOTOTHEORGANIZATIONOFTHESOCIAL4OBEMORECONCRETE 0ROBYN ASKS WHATISTHEEFFECTOFSHAMEONINDIVIDUALANDCOLLECTIVEACTION POWER RELATIONSANDHUMANCAPABILITIES )NPARTICULAR SHAMEPRODUCESINTEREST THAT OVERWHELMS THE POSSIBILITY OF REMAINING IN IGNORANCE P 3HAMEPRODUCESINDIVIDUALASWELLASCOLLECTIVEEFFECTSANDDEMANDS ACKNOWLEDGEMENT )T RAISES QUESTIONS OF GREAT AND ENDURING INTEREST CONCERNINGWHATITMEANSTOBEHUMAN)NADDITION SHAMEMAKESUS FEELMOREFRAGILEINOURSELVES4HISACKNOWLEDGEMENTOFFRAGILITYMAY SERVEASABASISFROMWHICHTOEVALUATEONESEXISTENCEANDOPENUPVIEWS OFEMANCIPATION)N"OURDIEUSTERMS THISKINDOFRUPTUREANDLOSSOF ASSURANCEWHENONEISTHRUSTINTOANOTHERFIELDMAYBEGINTHEPROCESSES OFCHANGEP 3OCIALCHANGEISONEOF0ROBYNSMAJORTHEMESINTHEBOOK BUTSHEALSO CALLSFORTHEORETICALANDEPISTEMOLOGICALCHANGESANDCHALLENGES7ITH HERANALYSISOFSHAME 0ROBYNOPENSOUTTHEPOSSIBILITYTHATFINALLY SOCIAL ANDCULTURALTHEORIESMAYBEGINTODEALWITHTHERELATIONSBETWEENTHE PHYSICALANDTHESOCIAL2EGARDINGTHEBODYASINVOLVEDWITHITSPHYSIC ALITYISAVERYWELCOMERETHINKINGOFBODYANDMATERIALITY2ECENTLY MANY RESEARCHERSWORKINGONQUESTIONSOFEMBODIMENTHAVEEXPRESSEDTHEIR FRUSTRATIONWITHANALYSESTHATSEEGENDER THEBODYANDPOWERASWELLAS ANYOTHERPHENOMENA REPRESENTEDANDINTERPRETEDASMERELYDISCURSIVE )TWOULDBEFRUITFULTOSET0ROBYNSIDEASOFSHAMEINAMOREEXPLICIT DIALOGUEWITHTHEANALYSISOFHOWSHAMEISGENDEREDANDCULTURALLYAND SOCIALLYPRODUCED"LUSHPROVIDESANEXCELLENTFOUNDATIONFORTHISCRUCIAL PROJECT -ARITA(USSO 5NIVERSITYOF*YVËSKYLË &INLAND
Downloaded from ecs.sagepub.com at Jyvaskylan Yliopisto on May 9, 2014
