Survey ISHS Working Group Growing Media Jean-Charles MICHEL, Chair WG
https://docs.google.com/forms/d/e/1FAIpQLSeJLT34FPE0yUMLKQonALkm_FeBBH8AfzVr9TW-vvYvodWmRA/viewform#responses
Survey not already filled? Please send me an e-mail and I will forward you the link above!
[email protected]
Objectives - Survey
to propose and define some priority area of works of the ISHS WG Growing Media, according to your and our common needs in terms of improving and sharing knowledge
and
growing media.
developing
projects
focused
on
Who responded? 0 AUSTRALIA BRASIL BELGIUM CANADA CHINA COSTA RICA CYPRUS EGYPT ESTONIA FINLAND FRANCE GERMANY GREECE IRAN IRELAND ISRAEL ITALY KOREA NEW ZEALAND NIGERIA NORWAY PORTUGAL SAUDI ARABIA SRI LANKA SLOVENIA SPAIN TURKEY THAILAND THE NETHERLANDS USA UK
2
4
6
8
10
12
14
2 2
44% 56%
1 5 1 1 1 1 1 1
87 responses Public sector
74 M, 13 F
Private sector
4 10 1
0%
2
25%
50%
5 1
ISHS
5 1 1
5% 8%
3 1 1 1 1 1
9% IPS
78%
ASHS
2 1 1
Scientist 5 13 8
91%
Technical Director Consultant Other
16%
7%
75%
100%
Teaching What audiences are targeted? (60 responses) Do you teach (or occasionally participate in) specific training courses about Growing Media? (87 responses)
How many hours in total do you teach specific courses/conferences about Growing Media? (60 responses)
Master, PhD students
31%
69%
NO
23%
Bachelor, Licence students (or equivalent level)
67%
Technicians and/or engineers of private companies / universities, etc.
65%
Growers YES
52%
49% 28%
68% < 4 hours 4-20 hours > 20 hours
Would you be interested by an e-learning program about Growing Media? (87 responses)
e-learning
5%
9%
Are you aware of e-learning programs about Growing Media? (87 responses)
Would you be willing to participate in the creation of elearning programs focused on Growing Media? (87 responses)
86%
13%
23%
YES NO Don't know
40% 28%
87%
9%
For which public? (81 responses)
Master, PhD students YES NO
Bachelor, Licence students (or equivalent level)
57% 52%
Technicians and/or engineers of private companies
58%
Technicians and/or engineers working in an university, research institute, etc.
56%
Growers
79%
YES NO Why not? I'm not sure YES, but I have too little time for that
Abbey, Lord Alharbi, Abdulaziz Ameloot, Nele Anderson, Neil Bankole, Emmanuel Baumgarten, Andreas Bekhradi, Farzaneh Beneragama, Chalinda Bethke, Charles
Böhme, Michael Bragg, Neil Boztepe, Özlem Carniel, Martin Cufer, Tomaz Dittakit, Parichat Gallego, Pedro Pablo Grade, Stefanie Giuffrida, Francesco
Hosseinifarhi, Mehdi Hückstädt, Arne Irish, Annette Jackson, Brian Liedl, Barbara Massetani, Francesca Michel, Jean-Charles Naasz, Rémi Newman, Steven
Ní Chualán, Dearbháil Ojo, David Owen, James Shokalu, Adekemi Suazo, Gerardo Temming, Winfried Verhagen, Hans Voogt, Wim
Would you be interested by the publication of a book focused on Growing Media? (87 responses)
Book 15%
Do you know any reference book about Growing Media? (87 responses)
Would you be willing to participate in the writing of a collective book focused on Growing Media? (87 responses)
85%
YES
36%
18%
NO
41% 19%
64% For which public? (73 responses)
YES NO
2 main Reference books
0
10
20
M. Raviv & J. H. Lieth, 2008. Soilless Culture - Theory and Practice. A.C.Bunt, 1988. Media and Mixes for Container Grown Plants.
16
22%
Master, PhD students
56%
Bachelor, Licence students (or equivalent level)
56%
Technicians and/or engineers of private companies Technicians and/or engineers working in an university, research institute, etc.
74% 68%
10 Growers
81%
YES NO Why not? I'm not sure YES, but I have too little time for that Abbey, Lord Alharbi, Abdulaziz AmbergerOchsenbauer, Susanne Ameloot, Nele Anderson, Neil Bankole, Emmanuel Baumgarten, Andreas Bekhradi, Farzaneh Beneragama, Chalinda
Bethke, Charles Blok, Chris Böhme, Michael Boztepe, Özlem Bragg, Neil Del Grosso, Marco Valerio
Dittakit, Parichat Gaffney, Michael Gallego, Pedro Pablo
Giuffrida, Francesco Grade, Stefanie Hosseinifarhi, Mehdi Irish, Annette Jackson, Brian Liedl, Barbara Michel, Jean-Charles Naasz, Rémi Newman, Steven Ní Chualán, Dearbháil
Ojo, David Owen, James Prasad, Munoo Raviv, Michael Suazo, Gerardo Savvas, Dimitrios Shokalu, Adekemi Zheng, Youbin
Publication-sharing platform Platform for exchange of information Are you aware of any publication-sharing platform on the web? (87 responses)
41% 59%
Did you already sign up to any publicationsharing platform? (87 responses)
Adlam J. McSpadden B. Alharbi A. Micheli M. Altland J. Mohamed Ali F. AmbergerNewman S. Ochsenbauer S. Ní Chualán D. Ameloot N. Nichols M. Anderson N. Ojo D. Balas J. Pagès J.M. Bankole E. Prasad M. Beneragama C. Raviv M. Bethke C. Reis M. Botden N. Robin S. Boztepe Ö. Roccuzzo G. Bragg N. Roudier J. Carlile B. Schmilewski G. Carniel M. Schroeder F.G. Cufer T. Sharifi M. Del Grosso M.V. Taveira J. Dittakit P. Torres A. Donners M. Verheul M. Dos Santos P. C. Voogt W. Folgado R. Wegener U. Foresi L. Wei M. YES, ResearchGate.net Gaffney M. NO Gallego P.P. Grade S. YES, other Greenwood D. Hosseinifarhi M. Irish A. Jackson B. Jeong B.R. Kehoe E. If Not, could you sign up to any publicationLea-Cox J. sharing platform? (40 responses) Liedl B.
10%
44%
NO
Alharbi, Abdulaziz Altland, James Bekhradi, Farzaneh Carlile, Bill Carniel, Martin Cavins, Todd Donners, Maurice Doyle, Owen Huttunen, Jukka Kehoe, Eamonn Kumar, Silke Miquel, Marc Mohamed Ali, Fouad Pagès, Josep M. Raviv, Michael Roudier, Jean
40%
ResearchGate.net Hortigate.de Mendeley www.academia.edu
94% 6% 4% 4% 51 responses
14% 7%
46%
18% YES
Would you be interested in a platform for exchange of information, specifically focused on Growing Media (& Soilless Culture)? (87 responses)
42%
Anderson, Neil Baumgarten, Andreas Beneragama, Chalinda Bethke, Charles Blok, Chris Bragg, Neil Del Grosso, Marco Valerio Hückstädt, Arne Irish, Annette Jeong, Byoung Ryong Naranjo, César Robin, Szmidt Schmilewski, Gerald Taveira, Jose Temming, Winfried Torres, Andres Wei, Min Zheng, Youbin
YES (17) Why not? (16) NO
79% only 31/87 already signed up to the Linked-in Group “Growing media for horticulture”
YES NO Why not?
What kinds of information do you need and/or could you share? (87 responses)
Job position offers PhD, Post-doctoral, MSc or other internship position offers Updated list of publications about Growing Media National/International Scientific Events National/International Trade shows/Exhibitions Finding partners for R&D projects
57% 51% 53% 99% 97% 89%
International projects Did you already participate to such International projects? (85 responses)
Would you be willing to work on International R&D projects about Growing Media (& Soilless Culture)? (87 responses)
What could be your main participation in that project? (87 responses) 0% 25% 50% 75% 100%
Scientific activities in laboratory (physics, biology, chemistry, etc.)
53%
21%
25%
Growing tests in greenhouses and/or outside
4%
Materials supply (growing media, additives, sensors, etc.)
75%
75%
Socio-economic study: current state, benefits of the project YES
YES NO Why not?
NO
Main topics mentioned:
Developing operational tools for end-users
72% 40% 17% 49%
nutrient management (9) GM alternatives for safer environment (9) additives [mycorrhizae, biostimulants, bio wetting agent, bacteria, etc.] (7) physical properties – water-relations – irrigation - wettability (6) aqua & hydroponics (5) root growth & development (4) organic fertilizers (3) composts & properties (3) recycling (2) materials [wood, bark, biochar, coir, use of wastes as GM] (2) etc.
Very important
Importance level of topics mentioned
Important Moderately important Slightly important
(87 responses)
72,4%
Not important
80,5%
73,6%
58,8%
50%
40%
30%
51% 20%
46%
44%
40%
34% 30%
27% 10%
22%
21%
21%
19%
16%
14% 7%
0%
0%
2%
3%
2%
1%
0% E-LEARNING PROGRAMS
WRITING OF A COLLECTIVE BOOK
SPECIFIC PLATFORM FOR SHARING INFORMATION
FORMULATION OF PROPOSAL INT'L R&D PROJECT
Proposals - Tasks – Deliverables For those who did not already respond, please fill the questionnaire In ascending order of importance level BOOK 2nd version of Raviv & Lieth? New other book, specifically focused on GM? (materials, properties, processing, uses, LCA, etc.)
Chairs / team leaders for this topic? (3-5 persons) Objectives: How? Contents? Editor? Authors? Support? etc.
E-LEARNING
Chairs / team leaders for this topic? (3-5 persons) Objectives: How? Contents? Editor? Authors? Support? etc.
Boztepe, Özlem Abbey, Lord Bragg, Neil Alharbi, Abdulaziz Amberger-Ochsenbauer, Susanne Del Grosso, Marco Valerio Dittakit, Parichat Ameloot, Nele Gaffney, Michael Anderson, Neil Bankole, Emmanuel Gallego, Pedro Pablo Giuffrida, Francesco Baumgarten, Andreas Bekhradi, Farzaneh Grade, Stefanie Hosseinifarhi, Mehdi Beneragama, Chalinda Irish, Annette Bethke, Charles Blok, Chris Jackson, Brian Böhme, Michael Liedl, Barbara
Michel, Jean-Charles Naasz, Rémi Newman, Steven Ní Chualán, Dearbháil Ojo, David Owen, James Prasad, Munoo Raviv, Michael Suazo, Gerardo Savvas, Dimitrios Shokalu, Adekemi Zheng, Youbin
Abbey, Lord Alharbi, Abdulaziz Ameloot, Nele Anderson, Neil Bankole, Emmanuel Baumgarten, Andreas Bekhradi, Farzaneh Beneragama, Chalinda Bethke, Charles Böhme, Michael Bragg, Neil Boztepe, Özlem
Michel, Jean-Charles Naasz, Rémi Newman, Steven Ní Chualán, Dearbháil Ojo, David Owen, James Shokalu, Adekemi Suazo, Gerardo Temming, Winfried Verhagen, Hans Voogt, Wim
Carniel, Martin Cufer, Tomaz Dittakit, Parichat Gallego, Pedro Pablo Grade, Stefanie Giuffrida, Francesco Hosseinifarhi, Mehdi Hückstädt, Arne Irish, Annette Jackson, Brian Liedl, Barbara Massetani, Francesca
Linked-in group Adlam J. Alharbi A. Altland J. AmbergerOchsenbauer S. Ameloot N. Anderson N. Balas J. Bankole E. Beneragama C. Bethke C. Botden N. Boztepe Ö. Bragg N. Carlile B. Carniel M. Cufer T. Del Grosso M.V. Dittakit P. Donners M. Dos Santos P. C. Folgado R. Foresi L. Gaffney M. Gallego P.P. Grade S. Greenwood D. Hosseinifarhi M. Irish A. Jackson B. Jeong B.R. Kehoe E. Lea-Cox J. Liedl B. McSpadden B. Micheli M. Mohamed Ali F.
Newman S. Ní Chualán D. Nichols M. Ojo D. Pagès J.M. Prasad M. Raviv M. Reis M. Robin S. Roccuzzo G. Roudier J. Schmilewski G. Schroeder F.G. Sharifi M. Taveira J. Torres A. Verheul M. Voogt W. Wegener U. Wei M. + all attendees not cited above
Proposals - Tasks – Deliverables
researchgate.net
PLATFORMS Sign-up to http://www.researchgate.net for publication-sharing platform Sign up to https://www.linkedin.com/groups/8568066 for information and discussions: You want to inform (in some words) about your last publication? You are looking for / finding PhD, post-doctoral, MSc, etc. positions? You want to propose a new job position? You need to discuss any topic about GM? You are looking for information? partners? You want to inform about local, national, international events (about GM)? … It could/should include information coming from other societies like IPS, etc.
For all of these cases, please share information directly to the Linked-in group https://www.linkedin.com/groups/8568066 or send me it by e-mail
[email protected]
Alharbi, A. Anderson, N. Altland, J. Baumgarten, A. Bekhradi, F. Beneragama, C. Bethke, C. Blok, C. Bragg, N. Carlile, B. Carniel, M. Cavins, T. Del Grosso, M.V. Donners, M. Doyle, O. Hückstädt, A. Huttunen, J. Irish, A. Jeong, B.R. Kehoe, E. Kumar, S. Miquel, M. Mohamed Ali, F. Naranjo, C. Pagès, J.M. Raviv, M. Robin, S. Roudier, J. Schmilewski, G. Taveira, J. Temming, W. Torres, A. Wei, M. Zheng, Y. + all attendees not cited above
Proposals - Tasks – Deliverables FORMULATION
OF
PROPOSALS
FOR INTERNATIONAL
R&D PROJECTS
Topics mentioned A) nutrient management (9) B) GM alternatives for safer environment (9) C) additives [mycorrhizae, biostimulants, bio wetting agent, bacteria, etc.] (7) D) physical properties – water-relations – irrigation - wettability (6) E) aqua & hydroponics (5) F) root growth & development (4) G) organic fertilizers (3) H) composts & properties (3) I) recycling (2) J) materials [wood, bark, biochar, coir, use of wastes as GM] (2)
clearly identify the growing system(s) to study:
Materials - & their own properties (B x H x J) Nutrient management (A x G)
Additives (C)
Water management (D) Plant/Root growth (F)
Considering the WG Growing Media s.s.: Soilless culture (no soil, no soil improvers) “Plant in limited volumes for root development (pots, containers, etc. ≈ potted plants)” vs Aqua/Hydroponic systems vs Compost as Soil Improver
Proposal(s): towards more sustainable growing systems Materials and their own properties B x H x J, +/- additives (C) Water management (D) and/or Nutrient management (A x G) Effects on plant/root growth (F), etc.
Chairs / team leaders? (3-5 persons - per project?, per WG?) First objectives: identify main issues and define R&D questions, identify partners (& level of involvement).
Thanks for your attention …
… and let
us go together!
Jean-Charles MICHEL, Chair WG
Remember! Please fill the questionnaire (if not already did). Send me an e-mail and I will forward you the link.
[email protected] https://docs.google.com/forms/d/e/1FAIpQLSeJLT34FPE0yUMLKQonALkm_FeBBH8AfzVr9TW-vvYvodWmRA/viewform#responses
